Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents whose kids are in the same clothes for years

420 replies

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 13/01/2024 13:04

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:58

Bullying, like neglect, is not a simple thing

i agree hence why i don’t think having the same trainers as someone else means you definitely won’t get bullied.

No, but it definitely will help/can't hurt if you don't look different in that particular way. The more someone seems different in any way, the more they risk being bullied. If you are different in multiple ways, you'll probably get bullied more than someone who's only different in one way. And why risk subjecting kids to that more, anyway?

Autistic and dressed weird, for instance, could be more likely to be bullied than autistic and dressed like the other kids.

timenowplease · 13/01/2024 13:02

I dress my kids in rags but they have expensive hobbies is 'But we took you to stately homes!' reasoning.

All a y'all with the guilty consciences need to have a good look at yourselves.

Okaaaay · 13/01/2024 12:59

@ShoePalaver i think you’re right - never thought about the pressure not to look poor. I would be marked as ‘middle class’ and amongst my friends buying second hand is a badge of honour (though not to have things falling apart).

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:58

Bullying, like neglect, is not a simple thing

i agree hence why i don’t think having the same trainers as someone else means you definitely won’t get bullied.

IndignantIguana · 13/01/2024 12:57

Oh and I gave my 11 year old the choice between a new school uniform (or very obviously second hand) when she started school and she said she'd rather have the second hand and put the money towards hobbies. I was a bit worried because it's a school in a well off area, but all her friends seem to be the same.

IndignantIguana · 13/01/2024 12:54

We keep clothes til they are falling apart or ridiculously small too. As a previous poster said we just don't see the value in spending money on clothes, particularly for the kids who outgrow them or rip them and generally don't look after them. Our children aren't hard done by though, at one point we were spending nearly my entire pay every month on their expensive hobbies. Oh and I do have some designer clothes myself (second hand) but I have no expensive hobbies!

thecatsthecats · 13/01/2024 12:51

@cantkeepawayforever

Agreed. In my school, smokers were ostracized, for example. It was very much not cool.

I think some parents put way too much emphasis on kids learning resilience in ways that happen to fall in with parental wishes.

I was a happily outspoken weird kid - but I'd have liked to be a happily outspoken weird kid with a rucksack like everyone else's. Not a hiking rucksack because that was what my parents thought was a "proper" rucksack. Ironically it was North Face before they were fashionable.

AyeRightYeAre · 13/01/2024 12:51

@Dramasloth

AyeRightYeAre
Are we talking Oliver Twiat here? Are the children unhappy?

Is Oliver Twiat related to Oliver Twist?

Awesome spot of the autocorrect 👏

timenowplease · 13/01/2024 12:50

Jl2014 · 13/01/2024 12:46

It’s for children to learn the value of things in high income households. Help them be less entitled when surrounded by so many nice things like the good restaurants and luxury holidays. A lot of people work hard for high incomes and children need to learn it doesn’t just land on a plate for them. I really don’t see what’s difficult to understand.

That's what pocket money is for.

In your example putting the kids in shabby ill fitting clothing is some kind of ritual humiliation. What lesson do you think a kid is going to learn from that?

5128gap · 13/01/2024 12:49

Partty agree, mostly disagree. There is a certain conceit amongst some wealthy people to portray their DC as 'feral' 'wild' etc which apparently involves wearing ill fitting weather inappropriate and torn clothing. People with less money would be more likely to be concerned about being judged as poor/neglectful than wealthy ones of they did thd same so may take more care with their DCs presentation. I think reusing toys and books is the ethical choice whatever your income. And just because you've a lot of money doesn't mean you have to waste it paying more for the same thing in a more expensive supermarket.

Jl2014 · 13/01/2024 12:46

It’s for children to learn the value of things in high income households. Help them be less entitled when surrounded by so many nice things like the good restaurants and luxury holidays. A lot of people work hard for high incomes and children need to learn it doesn’t just land on a plate for them. I really don’t see what’s difficult to understand.

cantkeepawayforever · 13/01/2024 12:46

I do have an ‘o’ on my keyboard. I just miss it a lot, sorry!

cantkeepawayforever · 13/01/2024 12:42

Dressing your dc the same as everyone else is not going to stop them getting bullied but I suppose it gives some parents a security blanket.

In some peer groups, dressing the same as others is, by itself, ‘different’. In ithers, dressing differently is ‘different’.

In some peer groups, dressing ‘scruffily’ is ‘different’. In ithers, being the spotless one in mainstream clothing is ‘different’. Bullying, like neglect, is not a simple thing.

On the OP, she nay perceive a coat as being ‘too tight’ or ‘too short’ by her own norms - so for her, those are ‘different’. If decent and warm , they may be extremely ‘normal’ in that group. Like ripped jeans, or very skimpy tops in the Newcastle sleet ir whatever.

SophieinParis · 13/01/2024 12:37

we have lots of disposable income/private school etc but I’m reluctant to spend on my young dcs clothes as they don’t care what they wear! Nothing is too small obviously but I try and get away with buying the minimum possible tbh! They are happy in whatever atm but on the other hand nice clothes make a big difference to my life! So the clothes budget is mainly for me!
I sometimes ponder why you see some children looking so gorgeous and beautifully dressed when the mums look scruffy and a bit frumpy and think “your kids won’t care if they’re in a pair of leggings and a hoodie from primark! Get yourself something nice”!”

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:37

This final sentence is spot on. It doesn’t matter how much a parent might love sushi and a well fitted blazer. My v. Average 5 year old loves fries + Spider-Man + his too small dinosaur hoodie. Why on earth would someone mess with that happy 5yo bubble just to project something else to the world!

exactly

Evaka · 13/01/2024 12:35

Maybe their own smart clothes are second hand OP, and/or maybe they don't want to spoil their kids? This definitely wouldn't interest or bother me once the kids seemed to be happy, warm and fed.

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:33

Would you knowingly feed your kids poor quality food all the time whilst eating the best and freshest yourself?

no, I would say we both eat a mix but I do think dc tend to prefer the crappier stuff!

bananamangoes · 13/01/2024 12:32

Kids in designer labels is the height of chav imo

bananamangoes · 13/01/2024 12:31

I don't understand fhe point of your post?

You just fancy bitching about a friend?

timenowplease · 13/01/2024 12:29

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:21

There's been threads before on this. Likewise when kids are fed turkey twizzlers and chips and the parents are eating organic.

there’s no nuance here though. I often organic but still love my childhood favourites mint Vienetta & those mini kiev things

Yes, very true, but I'm not talking about one offs. I'm talking about consistently.

Would you knowingly feed your kids poor quality food all the time whilst eating the best and freshest yourself?

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:28

I think other kids do know what's unfashionable (amongst kids at least) -obviously, as they will all tend to wear those clothes that other kids are wearing, at least the same brands etc, because parents who are considerate of trying to avoid at much as possible their child being bullied. So kids will notice if someone is wearing something different.

you can’t extrapolate that to everywhere though. Where do you live out if interest? As a teenager for me I wanted to have clothes that were different to my peers, all the teenagers who cared about clothes did, it’s a big reason why vintage is a thing.
Dressing your dc the same as everyone else is not going to stop them getting bullied but I suppose it gives some parents a security blanket.

timenowplease · 13/01/2024 12:24

cantkeepawayforever · 13/01/2024 12:19

No, it is not if itself neglect. You have to look at the whole picture. Immaculate clothing but parked on a tablet or phone all day, never played with vs stained clean clothing and a rich family life of hobbies, conversation and activities? Which is neglect?

There are many forms of neglect.

The OP's post mentions kids in ill-fitting clothes whilst the parents splash money on themselves. Maybe some kids won't notice or care but I can assure you, as a child in a family of children who was treated like this, most kids do notice and care.

porridgeisbae · 13/01/2024 12:23

determinedtomakethiswork · 13/01/2024 12:14

Secondhand nowadays can mean it hasn't even been worn or maybe has been worn once. A long time ago secondhand clothes were literally worn out.

I think other kids do know what's unfashionable (amongst kids at least) -obviously, as they will all tend to wear those clothes that other kids are wearing, at least the same brands etc, because parents who are considerate of trying to avoid at much as possible their child being bullied. So kids will notice if someone is wearing something different.

IDK if charity shops were as good in the 80s- even now, of course clothes in charity shops are usually not as fashionable or modern.

Even charity shops- some parents might not bother. Our clothes were often off my uncle's nasty second hand market stall.

Crunchymum · 13/01/2024 12:23

Not wealthy but I always keep the nicer dresses to use as tunics when my DD grows out of something. I don't do it with everything but my girls have had such beautiful pieces over the years (and have had such little wear out of them) that it seems a shame to not be able to use them.

I have an older DD who has had dresses that became tunics that got passed down to DD2 as a dress and then a tunic and then passed on the my niece. Some of these have been hand me downs to begin with but may have only ever been worn a handful of times by each child.

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 12:21

There's been threads before on this. Likewise when kids are fed turkey twizzlers and chips and the parents are eating organic.

there’s no nuance here though. I often organic but still love my childhood favourites mint Vienetta & those mini kiev things