Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents whose kids are in the same clothes for years

420 replies

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

OP posts:
Mindyourfunkybusiness · 13/01/2024 13:52

Haha this is wild.
I made friends with some amazing women who were worse off financially than I am.

They showed me charity shops, lidl etc. I shared with them the goodies I had from fortnums, nice cuts of fish, amazing fruit from markets.

We both shared our time, lifestyles, tips, bakes, veg from allotment/garden. We hung out so it'd be a bit rude of me to not get involved in their life or not buy secondhand when in the shops with her idk that's wild. Don't charity shops need the foot traffic anyway?

SamPoodle123 · 13/01/2024 13:51

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:59

@GoodOldEmmaNess Whereas they have designer clothes, highlights, beauty treatments, expensive lunches etc?

I agree with this, I have seen it. Some mums prefer to spend only on themselves and some prefer to spend on their dc or have the perfect balance.

LastRites · 13/01/2024 13:50

I rarely buy my kids new clothes. They like sports labels so I get them second hand! Pretty much everything they wear is second hand and my younger boy wears his older brother’s hand me downs a lot. I don’t see the point spending lots on clothes that will be ruined within 5 minutes of leaving the house! Not spending loads on their clothes means I’m relaxed about them getting dirty or holes in - which surely is better for my kids than me telling them to be careful.

I do buy myself expensive clothes but I also wear second hand. I won’t grow out of my new trainers in 3 months though or spill bolognaise all over my brand new t shirt! We have far better things to spend all our money on than clothes for our kids; as long as they’re weather appropriate and happy with what they’re wearing, I’m happy!!

Hardbackwriter · 13/01/2024 13:49

(thought I'd still try and get any kid of mine, especially if they already risk bullying, to look as much like other kids as possible) but if NT children want to look crap and risk people thinking they're a trampy weirdo

Pretty much every word of this is the opposite of what I want to teach my children

Hayliebells · 13/01/2024 13:49

porridgeisbae · 13/01/2024 13:28

And also, are you privy to the children's own preferences, sensory issues etc? Some children like to keep wearing old clothes and dislike anything new. They feel safer and more comfortable in familiar clothes.

I get that sensory issues can be a different thing (thought I'd still try and get any kid of mine, especially if they already risk bullying, to look as much like other kids as possible) but if NT children want to look crap and risk people thinking they're a trampy weirdo, like with every decision, it's the parents that should decide for the child's welfare. They're children, their judgement isn't the same as a grown up.

Edited

But nobody in the middle class parents circle thinks their child is a trampy weirdo. Not the kids friends and not the adults, and they don't spend a second worrying about what those outside their social circle think. When the kids ARE old enough to care, the expensive new clothes magically appear.

Fionaville · 13/01/2024 13:46

When people insist upon themselves, it becomes annoying.
So, the parents who 'only' dress their kids in designer, over priced clothes and make sure to tell you it or don't let their kids get messy because of it.

The other end of the scale of parents who insist on having their children in old, washed out clothes, when they can clearly afford new themselves.

My kids have a mix of expensive and cheaper clothes. I'm not precious about them running wild and getting muddy (apart from a few certain outfits) I always make sure that they look nice and cared for. I really enjoy buying their clothes and like to see that they are well/appropriately dressed. It's odd to me when other parents don't care, but we're all different.

ASGIRC · 13/01/2024 13:45

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:59

@GoodOldEmmaNess Whereas they have designer clothes, highlights, beauty treatments, expensive lunches etc?

Do you want them to get designer clothes for the kids, that they will outgrow in 6 months?

Your argument makes no sense. It is sensible to not spend too much on kids clothing, because realistically, its not gonna last long.

Im not sure if you are advocating highlights for the kids... or suggesting that if they dont buy designer clothes for their kids, then they also shouldnt be eating at good restaurants...

YABVU

momonpurpose · 13/01/2024 13:42

Crunchymum · 13/01/2024 12:23

Not wealthy but I always keep the nicer dresses to use as tunics when my DD grows out of something. I don't do it with everything but my girls have had such beautiful pieces over the years (and have had such little wear out of them) that it seems a shame to not be able to use them.

I have an older DD who has had dresses that became tunics that got passed down to DD2 as a dress and then a tunic and then passed on the my niece. Some of these have been hand me downs to begin with but may have only ever been worn a handful of times by each child.

Edited

Me too. My best friends mother made my daughter a beautiful Mexican folk dress for her first birthday. She wore it as a long dress a mid dress then a tunic till she was 8 lol. It kills me she can't wear it anymore.

TicTac80 · 13/01/2024 13:37

Single mum here (and nurse working FT). My parents (born in the 30's and 40's) were wealthy but we always passed clothing on to cousins or younger siblings - and stuff handed to us from older siblings/cousins. My parents didn't like waste, and their parents were the same. My mum made and mended a lot of clothes for us too (often would use fabric from pre-loved things), but she was a very talented seamstress. "New outfits" from shops, were a rarity: we might get these as a present at Christmas or Easter. We were always clean and neatly turned out for school or special events...but we could play in the mud/climb trees etc without getting in trouble for trashing "smart clothes". My parents didn't care for designer clothing, massive houses, expensive restaurants or flash cars: education (ours and that of others - they helped many people back home who wouldn't have been able to get a solid education) was their thing, and hobbies/cultural things too. School shoes (which would double up as "smart shoes") and underwear we got brand new. We also got new things if hand me downs were outgrown.

Now I'm a parent, I do similar. I don't have anywhere near the income my parents (now sadly RIP) had, but me/relatives/friends pass things on/share things, look in charity shops or eBay (rather than buying new) etc. For ourselves as well as our kids. Just because something is secondhand, it doesn't make it bad, ill-fitting or tatty, you can get some lovely things. I don't let my kids run around in torn/worn out/poorly fitting shoes and clothes. I put aside money (or save money up) to afford school trips for the kids and educational things. We don't go overseas for holidays, but will do lots of camping trips in UK. I will pay for us to go to the theatre/opera/gigs when tickets aren't expensive. My eldest has a cheap gym membership, my youngest has swimming lessons. When the kids get to the same size as me for shoes or clothes, I buy more expensive ones (then I can have them once the kids outgrow them!). Example: When DC1 was younger, I got him some Birkenstock sandals (he wanted some): I bought the real deal as he was the same size as me. When he outgrew them, I had them. When DC1 was little, I bought him a lovely winter coat that went to my friend's kids when he outgrew it....and then passed back to my youngest, and now passed to another friend's youngest. Five different kids have got good use out of it over the years, and it's in perfect condition still. We do the same with toys and books. I used to cut the kids' hair myself when they were younger. Now my eldest will go to a barber as he prefers the styles they do but my youngest likes me to trim her hair. I get my hair cut as I can't do it myself and the kids are too scared to try trimming it!! I don't get my nails done, I don't wear makeup often. I don't have beauty treatments or posh lunches. I rarely buy or drink alcohol and I don't smoke. Eating out is a rarity, as I'm lucky enough to be able to cook/make things at home. Food shopping will vary: I don't buy all my groceries in Lidl or Aldi, and I definitely don't buy it all in Waitrose or M+S!! It will vary according to what I find better quality and isn't going to break the bank!

Neither my parents, nor my friends, nor I, are trying to pretend we're poor. We're all very lucky to be able to afford a roof over our heads, heating, food. We're just trying to reduce spending, reduce waste and help each other out. Kids grow so fast, so if we were to all buy new things ( even if cheap), then that would still cost quite a bit.

StockpotSoup · 13/01/2024 13:35

Are you the same poster who started a thread because she was “worried” about her friend eating M&S food but giving her children Asda basics fish fingers and so on. It was so mean, so unfair… frankly, the whole thing was batshit.

Kids don’t give a damn about whether their food comes from M&S or Asda - and most of the time, they don’t care that they’ve had the same clothes for a while. Maybe it will be different once they become teenagers, but for now, it isn’t going to be an issue.

If you want to feel sorry for children, wail about unfairness and so on, worry about kids who have nothing; kids who are genuinely mistreated. “Waaahhh, my romper suit isn’t from Gucci!” isn’t really going to get Social Services in a panic.

Clumsykitten · 13/01/2024 13:30

I’m slightly worried about all the references to “clean”… by the time we have got anywhere it’s 50:50 whether the clothes are already filthy.

porridgeisbae · 13/01/2024 13:28

And also, are you privy to the children's own preferences, sensory issues etc? Some children like to keep wearing old clothes and dislike anything new. They feel safer and more comfortable in familiar clothes.

I get that sensory issues can be a different thing (thought I'd still try and get any kid of mine, especially if they already risk bullying, to look as much like other kids as possible) but if NT children want to look crap and risk people thinking they're a trampy weirdo, like with every decision, it's the parents that should decide for the child's welfare. They're children, their judgement isn't the same as a grown up.

porridgeisbae · 13/01/2024 13:25

I don’t have angst about bullying though & it’s not something that ever crosses my mind when making decisions for my dc.

@decisionssmecisions It'd be virtually my first priority. Bullying is so damaging to people's mental health. The effects can be for life.

Goinggreymammy · 13/01/2024 13:22

Why does it matter to you? If you think the children are being neglected contact social services. If not, mind your own business.
Unless you are privy to the families short and long term financial situation, you have no idea about their disposable income. They may also have different priorities to you, which us totally fine, unless children are neglected. And also, are you privy to the children's own preferences, sensory issues etc? Some children like to keep wearing old clothes and dislike anything new. They feel safer and more comfortable in familiar clothes.
I have average income. One of my children went through a phase of wearing clothes that were too small for her. Despite my concerns (has anyone read We need to talk about Kevin) I leith it go. She had a cupboard of clothes at home but always close these same tight ones etc. She has thankfully grown put of it now. (No punt intended).

TedWilson · 13/01/2024 13:22

People probably think this about me.
I but my kids beautiful clothes and they wear the tattiest oldest thing and refuse to let me throw it away. My 9 year old is exceptionally thin and can still fit in age 5 things so just keeps wearing the same thing. I have to lie and say it fell apart sometimes.

Hayliebells · 13/01/2024 13:20

As long as the kids are in clean clothes appropriate for the weather conditions, who cares? But I think I agree, this one of those weird British class things. The upper middle/upper classes don't need their kids to look smart. They don't care what other people think about themselves or their kids because they don't need to. They're not worried about anyone thinking less of them, or looking "poor". They can spend £1.5k on coat for themselves that will last years and years, but understandably think it's madness to do the same for a child who will soon grow out of it. They may work and socialise in circles where smart dress and appearance for adults is the norm, but kids aren't expected to be smart. And kids don't often care about being smart, they're just happy being comfortable, so there's zero pressure to dress kids smartly. They could write a reverse post along the lines of "All the mums at my kids school dress their children in new clothes, make sure hair is styled everyday etc, but why do they bother? And they have less money than us, so why are they buying their kids whole new wardrobes every few months? Won't second hand and hand-me-downs do, it's fine enough for our kids?" Without realising that they have lead a privileged existence where there's zero social or cultural reason for them to try and avoid looking poor.

BobnLen · 13/01/2024 13:20

This thread is certainly showing that people think that old clothes are a sign of being well off, so much competition of who can cram their DC into the oldest clothes, not buy any clothes themselves apart from routling in the charity shops and mentioning expensive hobbies and a large house at every opportunity

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 13:18

At most private schools/schools in expensive catchments the 2nd hand uniform stall is super popular. Cliche but true.

AdoraBell · 13/01/2024 13:17

YABU if the children are happy it doesn’t matter about the clothes being made old.

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 13:17

No, but it definitely will help/can't hurt if you don't look different in that particular way. The more someone seems different in any way, the more they risk being bullied. If you are different in multiple ways, you'll probably get bullied more than someone who's only different in one way. And why risk subjecting kids to that more, anyway?

How many times though, what is considered different depends a lot on your peers. The OP says all of the wealthy families do the same so the dc in the faded clothes aren’t going to be different in the first place.
As I already said I think bullying is quite complex because you often see a dc being bullied for one thing that makes another dc seen in a positive light. I don’t have angst about bullying though & it’s not something that ever crosses my mind when making decisions for my dc.

wronginalltherightways · 13/01/2024 13:13

Jl2014 · 13/01/2024 12:46

It’s for children to learn the value of things in high income households. Help them be less entitled when surrounded by so many nice things like the good restaurants and luxury holidays. A lot of people work hard for high incomes and children need to learn it doesn’t just land on a plate for them. I really don’t see what’s difficult to understand.

This isn't the reason, it really isn't.

wronginalltherightways · 13/01/2024 13:11

ShoePalaver · 13/01/2024 09:02

Wanting young kids to look smart is a class marker. Personally I'd rather children were comfortable and able to get clothes dirty through play. I don't see an issue with old clothes unless it's a smart occasion. It's always poor areas where tiny girls are in white dresses and boys are in label sports gear, probably the money would be better spent on other things but there's a strong pressure not to look poor. I don't think the children of extremely rich parents will feel that pressure

Second hand is good for the environment and there's plenty of it.

Lidl and Aldi well each to their own.

Exactly.

People in poorer areas are more worried about what schools/other people will think if their children aren't wearing 'nice' clothes. They don't want to appear like they're neglecting their children and many worry about social services becoming involved.

Middle and upper class people don't worry about these things.

noworklifebalance · 13/01/2024 13:10

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

You are partly describing me - kids clothes from Sainsbury’s, dresses become tops, trousers worn at the knees become cut-offs.
Used lots of second hand/passed on things throughout their childhood- clothes, newborn/toddler paraphernalia, toys (given to them as birthday/Xmas gifts), second hand books etc.

I suppose the main difference is that they were always clean, comfortable to wear and in good condition. Cut-offs were worn to play in the garden/park and generally mess around in comfort.
My DCs are beanpoles so clothes became short before they ever became tight.
Toys, books they similarly outgrow and we pass on or keep if sentimental. The value is in how much they enjoy them, not what we have spent.
We tend to give the outgrown clothes in good condition to charity or pass them on to friends. Never sold them on.

School uniform is majority second hand and the second hand sale is very very popular in our affluent school.

I also happily wear supermarket clothes, only own a few designer pieces, which were gifts.
However, I see nothing wrong in adults buying expense clothes for themselves- probably better than fast fashion and these items can last well. Children will outgrow clothes so, in my mind, it’s a waste to buy expensive or brand new, esp as they will know no different.

DCs are now teens and have no interest in designer fashion or latest trends. They seem very comfortable in themselves - hope that lasts.

Lovetheweather · 13/01/2024 13:08

Jl2014 · Today 12:46
what a load of utter twattery!! Plus for the record plenty folk on low incomes work extremely hard too. Just because you are on a high income, dosent mean you work any harder than Jo blogs who works in a warehouse. Mn is awful sometimes

BeeHappy12 · 13/01/2024 13:04

mindutopia · 13/01/2024 09:09

I would say this is me, though no spending on fancy restaurants and champagne. 🤣 My kids wear their clothes until they absolutely fall apart. My 5 year old only recently stopped wearing a size 2year old jumper. It fit, so we shoved it on! We have a whole set of clothes with holes that we wear around the house or in the mud or cleaning animals or at the beach, because no sense putting on nice new clothes to get covered in mud or animal poo.

We have a big house and lots of probably quite expensive hobbies. We travel and do lots of fun things. We don’t not buy new clothes because we can’t afford them. We just don’t value them. Same as how I’d never spend money on lash extensions or expensive makeup or a Range Rover. But I would spend it on a new bike or a city break or a day out. Dh and I only buy new clothes for ourselves about once a year and only to replace what has fallen apart. The difference is that Dh and I have to be remotely presentable for work. Other than school uniform, kids should be comfortable and happy.

Edited

This is my family. I alternate my kids clothes with my next door neighbour and they wear until it's falling apart.

We prioritise hobbies and travel advice all else and DH and myself rarely buy ourselves clothes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread