Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents whose kids are in the same clothes for years

420 replies

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

OP posts:
BobnLen · 13/01/2024 09:28

It alright wearing them for years if they fit but not really if they don't if you can afford to replace them

WonderingWanda · 13/01/2024 09:28

Maybe they treat their kids in other ways. My dds clothes have involved mostly hand me downs from relatives which has been ideal. They probably have looked a bit tatty at times because she is prone to insisting on wearing things she loves even when they don't fit. It's really nothing to do with me being tight. Why would I spend money on clothes when we get given them for free and my dd is happy. Also she has a fortune spent on her afterschool activities, days out, toys, bikes, holidays etc. My ds is a teen now and I'm shelling out a fortune on designer gear for him but never have done in the past. I am also saving furiously to help them through university and beyond. I work hard and if I want to get my hair done or buy am expensive jumper then I will. I also don't judge anyone for their choices with their kids, for example if they want to dress a toddler head to toe in designer gear then good on them, personally I wouldn't have because my kids trashed their clothes at that age and also grew out of them really fast.

MarathonBarbie · 13/01/2024 09:27

Feeling sorry for the kids is your own value judgement. The kids are (presumably) in comfy clothing that they’re happy in, and the parents are in clothing they're comfortable in.
Your judgement is that’s unfair because of the disparity in spending but that’s not necessarily the assessment others (including the individuals involved) are making.

SusieSussex · 13/01/2024 09:27

Something I noticed when my husband died is that before he died when we were a normal family, I didn't mind if my kids looked a bit scruffy..(Not to the extent of your friends as their clothes fit and were fine.) But after he died when we became an unfortunate family in the eyes of the school and other people, I felt like my kids couldn't be scruffy but had to be well turned out, or people would think I wasn't coping.
I think well off people don't feel scrutinised, so they can relax, whereas families considered unfortunate don't have that luxury.

OvercookedSmile · 13/01/2024 09:26

@StaringAtTheWater has a very good point about secondhand does not mean shabby. I bought a Calvin Klein dress and wore it to a wedding a few years ago, it was far from shabby.

@Dabralor you have given a perfect anecdote for my post, To him they were just clothes, he felt completely above judgement.

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:26

@MushMonster Completely agree with you, my Dds clothes are second hand from friends (some of them) She has lots of play clothes for getting dirty, I value books and experiences for *Her over new clothes, but will buy her new clothes if needed and will go without if needed

OP posts:
Passingthethyme · 13/01/2024 09:25

Seems smart to me, probably why they are wealthy 🤷🏼‍♀️ I always had hand me downs, probably until I was about 14 (I had a big family with older cousins and clothes were probably much better quality too), never did me any harm and I think it's a pity people are so wasteful now. The same people who waste money on clothes for young kids are also probably the ones who won't have the money to help them with more useful things when their children are older. I have a toddler and am shocked at the wasteful spending by other parents on unnecessary things when kids don't even know or care anyway

KnittedCardi · 13/01/2024 09:25

As we are the youngest in our two families, and our children were the last of the crop, we got so much second hand. All the baby stuff, bags and bags of clothes. I think the pram was fifth use. Some clothes that DD wore were third or fourth down. We are a reasonably wealthy family, and it's the norm for us, and others we know.

To be fair, our clothes are often very old too. I realised the other day, my beloved coat is 25 years old. Good quality lasts.

sparkellie · 13/01/2024 09:25

MasterBeth · 13/01/2024 09:22

Large mortgages and private school fees are paid for by disposal income! They're not some tax imposed on rich people!

Do you know what disposable income is?

Do you?
If you have a large mortgage and private school fees that money is allocated, in the same way utilities and council tax are. It's not disposable income. Does that help?

Cosyblankets · 13/01/2024 09:25

I don't think I've ever given kids' clothing much thought. They play out. They get mucky. They get ripped.
I had no idea how interested in other people's lives some people are! I'm amazed how judgemental you are

Singleandproud · 13/01/2024 09:25

Poorer people concern themselves more with the cleanliness of their homes and the clothes their children wear and the things they have as a status symbol and so they look like they are coping and can provide financially . Often telling the child not to get the clothes dirty/muddy/painter.

Richer people don't need to prove that to anyone, they aren't worried about SS turning up or what their neighbours think as they probably aren't living that close detached houses etc and everyone knows they have mo ey so it's not a sign of being poor. so children can wear their old clothes and not worry about getting dirty and scruffy. I imagine if they go out on outings and to the theatre etc then they wear nicer clothes.

WandaWonder · 13/01/2024 09:24

Dabralor · 13/01/2024 09:19

I do kind of get this, although I've voted yabu because I am guilty of keeping my kids' clothes for years and years.

My husband is mega posh and I'm not - when they were little I would be mortified when he dressed them on terrible, unmatching outfits.

As far as I was concerned, their clothes are a marker of me as a mum and it's how people would judge me - how well can I look after them? How healthy are they? How organised and good a mum am I? To him, they were just clothes - he felt completely above judgement. Because that's his privilege as someone who doesn't need to care.

I think you need to get out more

TrashedSofa · 13/01/2024 09:24

survivalmodemum · 13/01/2024 09:12

I tend to buy tops slightly bigger so they get longer out of them and I mend items on the whole families clothes if I can.

Teenagers likely won’t accept second hand items, or cheaper Asda/Primark pieces. Makes sense to save the pennies now!

Plus with teenagers the girls in particular are growing a lot slower than the average younger child. There's potential for more value in buying a teen something expensive, similar to an adult. Whereas a 4 year old is only ever going to get a certain amount of wear out of something, even when used thriftily and in an environmentally conscious way like the OP is horrified by.

Greengagesnfennel · 13/01/2024 09:24

lunarleap · 13/01/2024 09:16

This

This for sure. Have you never given in when your child wants to wear that favourite dress that is patently too small but because toddler clothes are loose and baggy they are still comfortable?

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:23

I’m definitely not jealous, there are reasons I wouldn’t swap my life with any of them, I do feel sorry for their kids though

OP posts:
Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:23

@AyeRightYeAre Theres nothing wrong with it at all, as I’ve said before, my friends and I all swap/pass on clothes, but by the same token, I know when it’s time that my
dc does in fact need new clothes and I will go without if need be.

OP posts:
MushMonster · 13/01/2024 09:22

I have nothing to criticise in the meantime clothes are clean, fit the weather and comfy.
Actually, old clothes are great for children's play. They can get them dirty without a second thought. And it is environmentally friendly.
Good experiences and good food are much more important than new clothes, in my book.
Once their children get to a stable size, I bet you they will start investing in good, long lasting clothing.

MasterBeth · 13/01/2024 09:22

sparkellie · 13/01/2024 09:01

Maybe the mums who seem outwardly more wealthy have less disposable income as they are paying for a bigger house/private schools. As pp said, it's priorities.
Unless you are privy to all of their financial info you can't know what choices/sacrifices they are making.

Large mortgages and private school fees are paid for by disposal income! They're not some tax imposed on rich people!

Do you know what disposable income is?

AyeRightYeAre · 13/01/2024 09:21

Read all your updates now. You really hate these women and are an inverted snob / very jealous or just odd.

Devilsmommy · 13/01/2024 09:21

Dabralor · 13/01/2024 09:19

I do kind of get this, although I've voted yabu because I am guilty of keeping my kids' clothes for years and years.

My husband is mega posh and I'm not - when they were little I would be mortified when he dressed them on terrible, unmatching outfits.

As far as I was concerned, their clothes are a marker of me as a mum and it's how people would judge me - how well can I look after them? How healthy are they? How organised and good a mum am I? To him, they were just clothes - he felt completely above judgement. Because that's his privilege as someone who doesn't need to care.

I think you're right about the judgement of your mom skills

OvercookedSmile · 13/01/2024 09:20

We are in this demographic in that we really rarely replace unless worn out and buy secondhand a lot. We are in top 10% of earners. But the difference compared to your sample is we buy secondhand for ourselves as well.

On a personal level I have never cared what others think of me and I know that DH feels the same. Studies have taken place on social class and spending patterns, many compare buying items versus buying experiences and also how people want to be perceived is the big issue.

You will also find that many people who would benefit from buying secondhand won’t. Obviously I expect many people to leap on to this thread with anecdotal evidence. I mean I have but overall it’s a well known trend from a social science perspective. I have not studied this exact phenomena but have done research in to educational outcomes dependant on social class and also taken part in research on poverty and food. People often fall in to patterns of behaviour without realising it can be predictable, though there are always outliers.

If you want a great example of how the harder up put great stock on new clothes watch Raining Stones by Ken Loach. The whole film plus a comment by the Priest nails spending patterns.

Wictc · 13/01/2024 09:19

Mine also wear clothes until they are on their last legs. Also wear secondhand and we pass them on to others too. We shop at Aldi and Waitrose. We adults wear decent clothes, we don’t like fast fashion and I have clothes that are over 20yrs old. Children’s clothes last a year at most size wise so what’s the point of spending loads on nee ones. Would prefer they can run about and get messing rather than worry they’ve ruined their ‘designer’ clothes.

Dabralor · 13/01/2024 09:19

I do kind of get this, although I've voted yabu because I am guilty of keeping my kids' clothes for years and years.

My husband is mega posh and I'm not - when they were little I would be mortified when he dressed them on terrible, unmatching outfits.

As far as I was concerned, their clothes are a marker of me as a mum and it's how people would judge me - how well can I look after them? How healthy are they? How organised and good a mum am I? To him, they were just clothes - he felt completely above judgement. Because that's his privilege as someone who doesn't need to care.

AyeRightYeAre · 13/01/2024 09:19

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:08

@Beautiful3 Theyre not particularly expensive, some passed on already from others

What is wrong with this?

Devilsmommy · 13/01/2024 09:19

@Januaryisthepits I think with the poorer people, I grew up poor before anyone says anything, because we grew up having to have second hand or nothing, when we have children we don't want them to feel the way we did iyswim. Those richer people imo are not really doing it for anything other than the praise for being so kind and thoughtful. I wonder how the kids feel about watching their parents spend£££ on themselves but buy used for them?