Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents whose kids are in the same clothes for years

420 replies

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

OP posts:
RadiatorHead · 13/01/2024 10:04

YABU. I personally think the ‘average income’ mum’s are being foolish. A kid isn’t going to remember whether they were in a new dress, they’ll remember if they went to Disneyworld/Alton Towers/Generally had fun experiences (whatever is in your budget) Life’s for living and making memories 🙄

Desecratedcoconut · 13/01/2024 10:03

You are assuming it's an economic consideration, rather than say an environmental consideration - or a cultural flex that these children are wealthy and so being scruffy doesn't denote poverty but a carefree bohemianism.

mollyfolk · 13/01/2024 10:03

Devilsmommy · 13/01/2024 09:19

@Januaryisthepits I think with the poorer people, I grew up poor before anyone says anything, because we grew up having to have second hand or nothing, when we have children we don't want them to feel the way we did iyswim. Those richer people imo are not really doing it for anything other than the praise for being so kind and thoughtful. I wonder how the kids feel about watching their parents spend£££ on themselves but buy used for them?

My kids don’t notice for now. They love getting a bag of clothes off their cousins. They always get to pick out a few new bits - and their shoes would always be new and very comfortable, waterproof and hard-wearing. They understand about being environmentally friendly as well - reuse, reduce, recycle. When we buy we try to get clothes from more ethical places. I’m sure as we get into the teenage years i will get a lot of push back.
none of this is something I would bang on about outside of my house “for praise”.

I also find it a little bit sad when I see someone admonish their child for getting their jeans dirty. Or a little girl avoiding puddle’s because they don’t want to get their shoes wet. Kids need to be comfortable & play a lot preferably outside and that is much more important than how they look.

MasterBeth · 13/01/2024 10:01

sparkellie · 13/01/2024 09:38

Apologies. Yes, that is the definition.

However, in conversation few people would say that that they had a disposable income of a certain amount without taking bills off. In most posts about money it's used to mean available spending money. This is what I was referring to, though I accept it was wrong.

I can see the point you're making but I think it hides a wider truth.

I think that classifying things like school fees, large mortgages, new car payments etc. as something different to "spending money" or "disposal income" then it's a way for the wealthier classes to minimise their privilege. School fees are a spending choice that you benefit from. A nice house is a spending choice that you benefit from.

You can sometimes see posts on here which are a variant of "£300k isn't that much to live on - not in London. Once you take off the mortgage, school fees, nanny, stabling costs and holidays, we don't end up with much money every month."

sleepismyhobby · 13/01/2024 10:01

I only buy 2nd hand for myself and ds because it's good for the environment and I'd rather buy a bundle or eBay or Vinted . With the cost of living I couldn't justify buying new . Saying that we don't wear horrible clothes that have stains etc on it

TimetoPour · 13/01/2024 10:01

I sort of get what you are saying OP.

We have friends that are financially comfortable enough to have a big house, 2 fancy cars, multiple holidays (abroad and Centre Parks etc) a year but their children are often in clothes that look worn, too small or tired. The youngest had never had a new pair of shoes until they started school, they wore the eldest child’s hand me downs instead. I don’t think there is anything wrong with hand me downs but these were most definitely ill fitting and stretched out of proportion due to the eldest having a foot condition.

I most certainly wouldn’t judge people for buying cheap/secondhand clothes for children as they out grow them so quickly. However putting them in clothes that are too small or thin and worn is a pretty sad.

Bournetilly · 13/01/2024 09:59

Completely agree with you!

Nothing wrong with second hand but children shouldn’t be in clothes that are too small, ripped or stained IMO. I guess stained is ok if they are doing messy play but personally I wouldn’t put them in stained clothes. The adults wouldn’t be wearing clothes that are too small, ripped or stained.

All of this can be brought second hand so they don’t have to spend a fortune, can also be brought new for cheap. They could shop in the sales or supermarket brands if they are against spending much money on clothes.

hotpotlover · 13/01/2024 09:59

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:06

But the difference is, they’re very happy to make sure that they have nice, new clothes and go to good restaurants..doesn’t that seem unfair.
I’m not talking about average mums putting their kids in designer items or especially smart clothes, they don’t, they do make sure their kids clothes fit, aren’t falling apart and are presentable, often going without themselves.

The difference is that I'm not growing anymore (well, at least not vertically).

So spending 200 pounds on a good quality winter coat is a good investment for me, if I wear it for many years.

Whereas my kids would outgrow such a coat in a few months.

We shop at Tesco for our kids but also buy occasionally from verbaudet or jojo maman bebe. We also used Facebook Market place and Vinted before and use hand-me-downs from family and friends.

We also buy expensive clothes a few sizes bigger, so my children can wear them for more than 1 year.

Do I feel guilty about it? No, as nursery is so expensive and our budget isn't unlimited.

Hollywolly1 · 13/01/2024 09:58

In a few years you will be back posting on how they can afford to send their children to top universities

Waterybrook · 13/01/2024 09:58

It’s a cultural thing.

Mum prioritised buying books and theatre tickets over clothes. All our clothes were second hand or hand me down. It was about what she valued and prioritised. My parents didn’t have a large income at all and I know that people would have assumed we were better off than we were.

Try not to make assumptions about other people.

Wolfpa · 13/01/2024 09:57

This feels as if you are trying to prove to yourself that you are a better parent than them even though you have less money.

stop judging and start just being concerned with your own life.

people have different priorities, when I buy something for myself I know it will be worn for years to come and so spend a little extra. When I am buying for children I know it won’t be worn for that long so don’t spend as much.

RiderofRohan · 13/01/2024 09:56

Both DH and I are higher earners but I've bought all our baby's clothes from Vinted. Why would I go and spend lots of money when she'll grow out of them in weeks? Also I can get better quality material secondhand rather than cheap Primark or Temu stuff to make sure she's comfortable.

We've also started shopping in Asda and yes we tell our friends because they could really save a bit of money if they did that too.

Geneticsbunny · 13/01/2024 09:55

You save money by buying good quality clothes as an adult. They last forever and they may well be secondhand or passed down from within the family. Just because they look expensive, doesn't mean that the person wearing them has spent loads of money on them.

Tinselunderthetv · 13/01/2024 09:54

I see this a lot in the South East, it’s like a cool way of pretending to be poor.

Baircasolly · 13/01/2024 09:52

If they really value expensive clothes it might be that they also keep their own clothes for years, and that they can't bear children wrecking similarly expensive clothes!

My kids often look a total mess. They have their favourite clothes, often a bit too small, they're comfortable, they're happy, it's very low priority for me (especially as they wear their school uniform most days anyway!)

There's much more pressure on lower income parents (and really I mean lower status, but it seems inflammatory to admit we still have a thriving class system in this country) to prove that they're "coping". Parents with socially respected jobs (and these days a lot of those professions actually pay below average - I'm a teacher, I feel this!) don't feel this same pressure.

Everydayimhuffling · 13/01/2024 09:51

Well I've learnt that disposable income doesn't mean what I've always used it and heard it to mean. Thanks @MasterBeth for that!

NoMoreBeers · 13/01/2024 09:50

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:23

I’m definitely not jealous, there are reasons I wouldn’t swap my life with any of them, I do feel sorry for their kids though

My DC couldn't care less about clothes, and grows fast. So why bother? Cheap, second hand clothes are fine. I do spend money on travel, food, experiences. No need to feel sorry for him in his tatty but comfortable clothes!

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:47

@Jioyt Yes this is exactly what I mean, thank you for understanding my post!

OP posts:
3luckystars · 13/01/2024 09:47

I know loads of people, couples, parents, all earning different amounts. Every single one of them is different, I couldn’t possibly group any of them together and find patterns like this.

How many people are you talking about?

BubziOwl · 13/01/2024 09:47

BubziOwl · 13/01/2024 09:44

I genuinely haven't ever, I don't think, bought a "new" item of clothing for my children. Everything is second hand.

My young children don't care what they look like. Therefore, neither do I. I buy them good quality second hand clothing that is comfortable and I do like to buy organic cotton clothes for them where available (now I'm just a sucker for the marketing re organic I'm sure, but there we go. I do it because some part of me feels it will be healthier for my children).

I do not give a rats arse if they're faded, look tired or past their best. I want them to be healthy, happy, and comfortable. That's literally my only concern.

I, on the other hand, do care what I look like. Not least because my success at work and in other areas depends on looking presentable. So my clothes, whilst also second hand, will be chosen with aesthetics in mind amongst other factors.

I definitely spend more time, effort, and money choosing my children's clothes than mine, but I'm sure OP would judge me otherwise.

I should clarify in case someone recognises me from a SAHM thread and pounces that I don't work anymore. What I meant by the success at work comment was more that in general, people's success depends on looking presentable (and mine did in the past), and therefore it's sort of an ingrained societal expectation to make yourself look at least halfway decent. Young children are blissfully free of the awareness of such expectations!

CaramelMac · 13/01/2024 09:46

I was one of those children in the slightly too small second hand clothes, my parents are very middle class and just didn’t think how you looked mattered because they’d always got on through knowing the right people. I went to a school in a small ex mining village where most families were working class and I really stood out as the other children were always immaculately dressed in brand new clothes, they would’ve rather died than bought clothes from a charity shop.

LemonTT · 13/01/2024 09:46

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 09:23

I’m definitely not jealous, there are reasons I wouldn’t swap my life with any of them, I do feel sorry for their kids though

These are people you call friends but you seem to have strong negative feelings for. I don’t think it’s a common or even usual thing for rich people to do. Never seen an example in my life of mum in Chanel and kid in ragged hand me downs for Lidl.

In any wealth bracket it would be concerning that a parent spends a lot on themselves but neglects basic things for their child. It’s potentially abuse. But you have not expressed those concerns. Your generalised comments seem picky and judgemental. Are you checking labels and monitoring where people shop. I have no idea where people’s clothes are from.

young children trash clothes. Their clothes get lost and exchanged. You need lots of clothes that you don’t mind getting destroyed. Adults tend to buy clothes that last for years.

Who are these people to you because they don’t sound like friends.

Mumsfishnets · 13/01/2024 09:45

I think the best point on here is that, in general, wealthy people have nothing to prove and don't care what you think. People from lower income families have traditionally cared more about keeping in appearances. Think women in the past scrubbing the front door step everyday vs upper class people walking into their hall with muddy dogs and wellies. These priorities and values get subcontiosuly passed down.

Gettingittogether · 13/01/2024 09:44

WandaWonder · 13/01/2024 09:24

I think you need to get out more

Why be like this? @Dabralor is clearly speaking from the heart - she's articulating her own insecurities which she recognises. Why feel the need to put her down like that? Just entirely unnecessary.

I think it was a very honest post.

BubziOwl · 13/01/2024 09:44

I genuinely haven't ever, I don't think, bought a "new" item of clothing for my children. Everything is second hand.

My young children don't care what they look like. Therefore, neither do I. I buy them good quality second hand clothing that is comfortable and I do like to buy organic cotton clothes for them where available (now I'm just a sucker for the marketing re organic I'm sure, but there we go. I do it because some part of me feels it will be healthier for my children).

I do not give a rats arse if they're faded, look tired or past their best. I want them to be healthy, happy, and comfortable. That's literally my only concern.

I, on the other hand, do care what I look like. Not least because my success at work and in other areas depends on looking presentable. So my clothes, whilst also second hand, will be chosen with aesthetics in mind amongst other factors.

I definitely spend more time, effort, and money choosing my children's clothes than mine, but I'm sure OP would judge me otherwise.