Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents whose kids are in the same clothes for years

420 replies

Januaryisthepits · 13/01/2024 08:54

I have a few mum friends who are wealthy (large homes with pools, private schools etc)
These mums dress their kids in clothes that they wait until are practically falling apart before they get new ones…dresses that then become tops with leggings, coats that are extremely snug etc. I realise it’s the smart thing to do and not wasteful etc, but I notice these parents v rarely spending any money on their childrens clothes and looking smart, whereas they will on themselves and spend money on experiences, often involving good restaurants and champagne.
In comparison, my mum friends with average income spend money on their kids clothes, making sure they fit, aren’t too old and shabby etc. My wealthier friends always seem to be proud of these cut backs they’re making, but it seems unfair on the kids, often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items.
They also seem so proud to shop at Aldi/Lidl as though it’s an expression of something
Does anyone know what I mean?

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 13/01/2024 10:41

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 13/01/2024 09:18

People probably consider us to be quite wealthy as we live in a larger-than-average house and our kids go to private school.

We also however give a lot of money to charity so, after that, our disposal income is less than others who earn significantly less. We sacrifice all other luxuries (minimal meals out, clothes, holidays etc) in order to prioritise schooling and charitable giving

Do people judge my kids for wearing cheap clothes? I have no idea.

I just don't believe that I'm afraid. I believe it about the private school but not about giving so much to charity and not having any treats yourself. I've never heard of anyone who doesn't go on holiday and give money to charity instead

Bumpitybumper · 13/01/2024 10:40

It's all social status signalling.

The poorest are often desperate to pretend that they are not poor so will invest in brands and dedicate a larger percentage of their resources towards making sure their children are well cared for and aren't going without.

The middle class will invest in different brands like Joules, Boden etc and make sure their children wear them to death. You'll hear phrases like 'we buy quality rather than quantity' and 'I choose clothes my children are comfortable in' but in reality this leads to another group of kids all wearing similar clothes that act like a social signal that the child is of a certain class.

There is a sub class within the middle class where it's important to show that you don't place too much emphasis on appearance and couldn't care less about brands etc. These kids generally have messy hair and mismatched and ill fitting clothes. This is another social signal emitted to show that you are actually above the other groups that care about how their children look and wouldn't be concerned with such ridiculousness. They are literally trying to signal they are too posh and rich to care.

All the groups are ultimately playing to a stereotype and social signalling but not many people seem to realise that this is what is happening. It's a very interesting phenomenon!

SusieSussex · 13/01/2024 10:39

Bigearringsbigsmile · 13/01/2024 10:37

And this!!
Passing on ski clothes!🤣

This has to be a parody thread surely?

😀

Fundays12 · 13/01/2024 10:39

I actually disagree with this although I use clothes till the kids outgrow (if there not torn or stained etc) and will happily buy on vinted the fact the parents only have the best clothes, hair does, nights out etc is what makes this wrong. It sounds like the parents are prioritising themselves at the expense of there kids and that is wrong. We are not wealthy but he kids are always clean, dressed in clothes that fit well and are unstained. We both do without to ensure this happens. It's basic parenting to ensure kids have clothes that fit and are suitable.

I will happily buy good quality second hand toys and don't see an issue with anyone doing this because the toy industry is so wasteful.

Bigearringsbigsmile · 13/01/2024 10:37

Fairymother · 13/01/2024 10:23

Im that mother sometimes 🙈 I dont buy secondhand toys etc and my kids get the best of the best experience wise. Meaning our holidays and weekends are tailored around them, they get spoiled with excursions and so on. But their clothes are really not a priority as long as they are still comfortable and functional. For example ski outfits.. I buy very expensive brands because from experience i know they just last much longer. Usually i buy a bit too big and DS can wear it for 3 years (once a bit big, once just right and once a bit tight). DD is 8 and shes never owned her own ski clothes, because when DS outgrows its usually perfect for her. Now she would definitely pick a pink outfit if i asked her, but shes never complained so far.
Kids just dont appreciate nice things (clothes), so i dont see why they should always get nice new things. I appreciate nice things, so theres nothing wrong with buying new fancy clothes, shoes etc. for myself 🤷🏻‍♀️

And this!!
Passing on ski clothes!🤣

This has to be a parody thread surely?

MWNA · 13/01/2024 10:35

ShoePalaver · 13/01/2024 09:02

Wanting young kids to look smart is a class marker. Personally I'd rather children were comfortable and able to get clothes dirty through play. I don't see an issue with old clothes unless it's a smart occasion. It's always poor areas where tiny girls are in white dresses and boys are in label sports gear, probably the money would be better spent on other things but there's a strong pressure not to look poor. I don't think the children of extremely rich parents will feel that pressure

Second hand is good for the environment and there's plenty of it.

Lidl and Aldi well each to their own.

This 100%.

Crispsandwichrock · 13/01/2024 10:35

I have an ear worm of Pulp's Common People stuck in my head now, thanks to this thread.

Bigearringsbigsmile · 13/01/2024 10:34

I am lolling here at all the people posting that they dress their children like tramps and spend the saved money on books!!🤣

Ellie6489 · 13/01/2024 10:34

StaringAtTheWater · 13/01/2024 09:14

How do you know the mums aren't wearing second hand stuff themselves OP? Second hand doesn't equal shabby. You can buy almost new pristine items on Vinted. I bought a French connection jumper dress from a charity shop the other day - only £4 and you can't tell it's second hand. Kids second hand stuff probably does gets tatty quicker because (if they are like my boys) they fling themselves around doing knee skids, etc!

Also does it occur to you that kids in too small items might just be insisting on wearing them?! I've only just managed to persuade my youngest out of size 9 trainers he was very attached to, even though I could see they were too small, but he is a very stubborn character and I have to pick my battles!

My DC (12) will wear the same ratty trainers day in and day out even though he has others to choose from. He doesn't care about the tears or holes because he loves them and says they are comfortable. He asked for a pair of Jordans, wore them two times and never again. He won't give up the ratty ones. I've thrown them in the bin but he somehow found them again before I got rid of them for good.

Same with clothes, he must play really hard at school because he constantly has knee skids or tears/stains on everything and will still wear them. He says he doesn't want to get rid of them. I often have to ask him to change before going out.

WithACatLikeTread · 13/01/2024 10:33

JustMarriedBecca · 13/01/2024 10:28

Interesting post. We are second hand, buy to last people. We are wealthy and have high income. We have lots of nice holidays and enjoy eating out and giving the kids different experiences (they hate pizza express).
My sister and brother in law are the opposite. Lower income. But obsessed with branding for her kids. It's all North Face this and expensive Nike trainers that. No time for it.

They see it as a sign of prestige. I'd rather the kids play multiple instruments and travel the world. I've no doubt she gets it in the sales (I know she doesn't use vinted because I've seen the parcels from brands arrive and piled by the door).

Each to their own.

How old are your kids?

Copasetic · 13/01/2024 10:30

@Minibreak2023 sorry, yes that is what I meant. Within this large family was a family with children slightly younger than us, who my mum used to pass our clothes on to. In the South of England this family are well known.

JustMarriedBecca · 13/01/2024 10:28

Interesting post. We are second hand, buy to last people. We are wealthy and have high income. We have lots of nice holidays and enjoy eating out and giving the kids different experiences (they hate pizza express).
My sister and brother in law are the opposite. Lower income. But obsessed with branding for her kids. It's all North Face this and expensive Nike trainers that. No time for it.

They see it as a sign of prestige. I'd rather the kids play multiple instruments and travel the world. I've no doubt she gets it in the sales (I know she doesn't use vinted because I've seen the parcels from brands arrive and piled by the door).

Each to their own.

isthisit100 · 13/01/2024 10:26

ttcat37 · 13/01/2024 10:24

“often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items”

Wow. Today I learned that I’m not allowed to buy secondhand things in case someone less well off needs to buy it instead…!

Didn't you know there's a world wide shortage of second hand books and clothes, because rich housewives are buying up all stock?

(ignore the huge piles left outside charity shops )

HighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 13/01/2024 10:24

Tight coat is a bit rubbish but the rest is ok. The kids can play, mess around, get dirty without anyone worrying about decent clothes getting ruined.
The dryer often shrinks clothes a bit and some parents allow their dc to choose what they wear. Part of their growth and development.

ttcat37 · 13/01/2024 10:24

“often buying second hand toys and books too, again, great, but nothing second hand themselves and also a bit unfair to the mums with less, who genuinely need the second hand items”

Wow. Today I learned that I’m not allowed to buy secondhand things in case someone less well off needs to buy it instead…!

Fairymother · 13/01/2024 10:23

Im that mother sometimes 🙈 I dont buy secondhand toys etc and my kids get the best of the best experience wise. Meaning our holidays and weekends are tailored around them, they get spoiled with excursions and so on. But their clothes are really not a priority as long as they are still comfortable and functional. For example ski outfits.. I buy very expensive brands because from experience i know they just last much longer. Usually i buy a bit too big and DS can wear it for 3 years (once a bit big, once just right and once a bit tight). DD is 8 and shes never owned her own ski clothes, because when DS outgrows its usually perfect for her. Now she would definitely pick a pink outfit if i asked her, but shes never complained so far.
Kids just dont appreciate nice things (clothes), so i dont see why they should always get nice new things. I appreciate nice things, so theres nothing wrong with buying new fancy clothes, shoes etc. for myself 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheWayTheLightFalls · 13/01/2024 10:21

I think so. In the wealthy MC neighbourhood I live in kids are in mismatched hand me downs as a standard look, living in £1.5m houses and showing all the signs of not being hard up. Down the road it’s smart trainers and branded clothes but not always enough food to eat (I’m speaking from professional experience, not guessing).

isthisit100 · 13/01/2024 10:20

WithACatLikeTread · 13/01/2024 10:09

Tacky make up isn't a preserve of the poor. I would probably rather hang around with them than with you though.

OK.....

Season 4 Wow GIF by The Office
vdbfamily · 13/01/2024 10:20

Sorry...should have checked my predictive text!! child's coat !

LaMarschallin · 13/01/2024 10:19

Waterybrook

This is British though. I know upper class Germans, French, Italians, Spanish and Portugese families who would always dress their children in new, smart clothes and not let them be tatty.

But there's a lot of clothing that will lie between "new, smart clothes" and something that's "tatty".
My DCs loved dressing up in smart, new clothes sometimes; at others, they were happy in comfortable, clean, fit-for-purpose clothes that weren't either new or smart but weren't what I'd call tatty.
Much like adults, I suppose.

vdbfamily · 13/01/2024 10:19

I know exactly what you mean but I don't have an issue with it. I was raised to be thrifty but everyone thought we were very wealthy because we're lives in a big house but in reality my parents did not have a large disposable income. I actually think the opposite scenario is even stranger. I have some friends with very little disposable income who view buying servings hand toys and clothes with absolute horror so stretch themselves unnecessary to spend £40 on a child cost when they could get a decent one on eBay for £5-10.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 13/01/2024 10:18

New clothes and a dinner at an expensive restaurant usually aren’t treats for most kids. If your kids are happy to wear old clothes then as long as they’re clean, warm and comfortable why would you buy them new designer ones? It’s not a treat if the kids don’t want them.

Presumably the kids are treated in other ways such a new toys or books or kid friendly days out and holidays etc?

If the parents are spending money on themselves and literally nothing on the kids and the kids are unhappy then that’s an issue, but if the parents have their kids in old clothes because the kids don’t care about clothes but spend money on other kinds of treats then it’s no issue! What you spend money on in terms of money for the kids and money for the parents doesn’t need to be like-for-like, the parents aren’t buying their kids designer clothes despite buying them for themselves but presumably also aren’t buying themselves a new toy or book or game etc every time they buy one for the child.

Mayhemmumma · 13/01/2024 10:18

I see this as a bit as a middle class trend, boys and girls with long tousled hair in need of a good brush, mismatched colourful clothes - slightly wrong sizing, playing out in the mud, in a 'look at how we are creating a whimsical, good old fashioned childhood' (that looks good on instagram)

newrubylane · 13/01/2024 10:17

Just something else I've not seen mentioned - fit can be very subjective. My little boy frequently wears trousers that look a bit too short for him really - because that's the only way trousers will stay up, as his waist is tiny. He doesn't care, he's comfortable and clean and his very visible socks always match. I live for the summer when he can be in shorts all the time! We're reasonably well off but I buy mainly bog standard clothes from Next or M&S for them and they wear them for as long as they can. I try to put them in the better stuff when we're out and about, particularly somewhere smarter. But out in the garden or the park, who cares 🤷