Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wrong to dislike my boyfriends female lodger?

108 replies

Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 19:19

So I'll explain the whole story so you get a clear picture around my situation...

Im a 30 yr old female, I've been with my boyfriend (35yrsold) for over 2 years now, he has his own place, and I have mine. We have talked about moving in together in the very near future, but just not yet.

A few months back my boyfriend told me he was considering getting a lodger to rent his spare room out too, to bring in extra cash and help pay his bills etc. Although I wasn't exactly happy about his idea, (as I do spend alot of my time at his), I knew it was something he wanted to do and I couldn't sway his decision.

A few weeks after our initial conversation on the renting his spare room out... he tells me he has interviewed a female lodger and she is interested in renting his room. She is 32, (very similar in age to me). I am very shocked at his decision to pick a female (I assumed it was going to be a male lodger living with him), and she is also almost identical in age and profession to me. I tell him I am not particularly happy about it being a female lodger. He then says he will look to see if anyone else is interested in the room, and if not he will rent it to her.

Fast forward another 3/4 weeks and he is being very shady about me coming round to his house, he is always offering to come round to mine instead and if I ask to come over to his he is making up excuses. I suspected something was a little off, and asked him when the new lodger was moving in. He then says she moved in a week ago!!!!! He had not mentioned to me at all that she was moving in. I completely lost it, got very upset and sad and felt like I had been lied to and deceived on about this situation.

Now she is living there, the atmosphere in the house for me is very uncomfortable. I feel unsettled and just odd being there when I know she's in the house.. (in the bedroom next door to us). There's only 1 bathroom in the house so she obviously uses that too. She's always in and hardly ever goes out, other than to work her 8am to 4pm job. All she does is either sit in her bedroom and uses the kitchen for short periods to cook. My boyfriend now makes a conscious effort to be quiet in the evenings (which he never did before), and even whispers when we get into bed so he's more quiet and doesn't disturb her. I find her extremely odd, almost awkward around me...

Although I honestly don't think he would cheat on me with her, I just find the whole idea and situation of him living with a female lodger very uncomfortable.

Am I over reacting about this all? Or do I have rights to how I feel? Advice greatly needed! As I don't know if I'm over thinking it all

OP posts:
thinslicedham · 12/01/2024 20:08

I can see why you're not happy with him having a woman in his home, but I also see why he might prefer a woman lodger. He may feel she's more likely to treat the place well, not make a huge mess, etc.

As for her attitude, she may just be shy, and she can probably tell you're uncomfortable with her, which will make her feel awkward, too.

YANBU to be annoyed with him for lying about when she was moving in and (possibly) not taking your objections seriously, but it's not the lodger's fault. She hasn't done anything wrong, just because she's a woman about your age who likes to stay in her paid-for room when she's not working.

theduchessofspork · 12/01/2024 20:08

mrsclaus1984 · 12/01/2024 19:44

Very unpopular opinion alert

if you are seriously, considering a future with this man, I’d be concerned about the following… Firstly, a man in his mid 30s, who needs a second income from a lodger to help him through the basics in life, such as paying the bills.

Secondly, the fact that he has not taken your feelings into consideration, and hid the lodger’s presence from you initially, is also a huge red flag.

It’s more of a very out of date opinion alert.

Mortgages and bills are very expensive and it’s normal to have a lodger, either to just pay off your mortgage faster or just to get by. This was true even before the cost of living crisis (if news of that has reached you PP).

OP your relationship comes across as somewhat weird - more like two people in their early 20s who haven’t learned how to communicate and don’t know each other well, not two people in their early 30s who’ve been going out for two years.

Arguably you are being weirder than him - objecting to a female lodger (for shame!) and disliking a person you don’t know because of a slightly awkward living situation, vs him childishly avoiding introducing you to her because he knew it would provoke a row.

Anyway, what I would do is try living together but don’t go selling your flat, because this one may not be the right one for you. I think you need to address your trust issues, he needs to assert himself, and you both need to communicate better.

mrsclaus1984 · 12/01/2024 20:07

With respect OP, you have contradicted yourself, you said in your initial post that it was to help him out with bills. So which one is it? I’m sorry, this is a huge red flag and I wouldn’t be pleased about this situation at all.

Ledwood85 · 12/01/2024 20:07

So you bought a property on your own, recently, despite being in a relationship where you would have surely considered the possibility of moving in together and one of the properties would have to go?

I mean this in the kindest way, but it seems like you're sending out the message that you're not seeing a future with him and he's using this lodger nonsense as his rebuttal.

candlelog · 12/01/2024 20:05

I think the whole thing is weird. He doesn't need the money but gets a young female lodger anyway. You've been going out 2 years and talked about moving in. Either he's messing you about or his lodger. How long does he think he'll have a lodger for?

I just don't think he's that committed to you, sorry.

Vitriolinsanity · 12/01/2024 20:04

X post. Apologies. Why can't he rent his?

WristCandy · 12/01/2024 20:03

It's your boyfriend that is the issue, not the lodger herself. His behaviour is shady and odd, and now dismissive of you. He's shown you who he is, don't deflect from that by focusing on some random woman.

Vitriolinsanity · 12/01/2024 20:03

Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 19:56

Because I have my own mortgage currently and its not as simple as just moving in with him. I would have to sell my home

Or one of you could rent your home,

Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 20:02

ExtremelyJoyous · 12/01/2024 19:59

Yeah I would be annoyed with that actually.

Is there a reason that you’ve stalled on moving in together? Is it a joint decision to hold off or just one of you?

There's alot of differentiating circumstances around moving in together. It means I would have to sell my property I recently bought as I can't rent it out in my mortgage agreement

OP posts:
Daz57 · 12/01/2024 20:01

Did you consider both moving into one house and letting the other for a while?

AgentJohnson · 12/01/2024 20:01

Why do you think it’s any of your business? I understand why he didn’t tell you because you would have again try to reignite a discussion that had already been litigated. It’s his home, he has the final say.

As for this woman being strange, what is strange about her spending most of her time in her new home? She has more of a right to be there than you do.

I’d be very interested in how your relationship progresses given this major difference in values. You are entitled to your opinion, your problem is that your opinion is out of step with your bf’s. If you continue to try and litigate a decision that isn’t yours to make, then I see trouble ahead.

I personally would have great difficulty with a partner who thought that they had an equal say in how I ran my home.

ExtremelyJoyous · 12/01/2024 19:59

Yeah I would be annoyed with that actually.

Is there a reason that you’ve stalled on moving in together? Is it a joint decision to hold off or just one of you?

Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 19:59

SpursFan2 · 12/01/2024 19:30

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all OP - I think your feelings are completely valid on this. Is there any way you can talk to your boyfriend about how you feel?

We have talked about it alot. He is not willing to ask her to move out, even tho I feel very uncomfortable

OP posts:
Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 19:56

Because I have my own mortgage currently and its not as simple as just moving in with him. I would have to sell my home

OP posts:
Olinguita · 12/01/2024 19:55

mrsclaus1984 · 12/01/2024 19:44

Very unpopular opinion alert

if you are seriously, considering a future with this man, I’d be concerned about the following… Firstly, a man in his mid 30s, who needs a second income from a lodger to help him through the basics in life, such as paying the bills.

Secondly, the fact that he has not taken your feelings into consideration, and hid the lodger’s presence from you initially, is also a huge red flag.

I agree with this. Plus if you guys are serious about each other after two years, why not expedite moving in together?

Ablepickle1234 · 12/01/2024 19:55

He does have a very well paid job and doesn't need the lodger to get by each month. He decided to do it so he can save extra money each month and also have extra spare money to spend on doing nice things etc

OP posts:
TornApartByLisa · 12/01/2024 19:53

When he says he was considering a lodger, why didn't you just move in? Surely if you've been together 2 years you know whether you want a future together or not.

Vitriolinsanity · 12/01/2024 19:49

mrsclaus1984 · 12/01/2024 19:44

Very unpopular opinion alert

if you are seriously, considering a future with this man, I’d be concerned about the following… Firstly, a man in his mid 30s, who needs a second income from a lodger to help him through the basics in life, such as paying the bills.

Secondly, the fact that he has not taken your feelings into consideration, and hid the lodger’s presence from you initially, is also a huge red flag.

But you have no ideas what his rent/mortgage are. My own has increased eye watering amounts in the last year. Id consider a lodger to alleviate the burden of other factors permitted. It doesn't reflect on my financial capabilities as much as it's pragmatic.

Missingmyusername · 12/01/2024 19:48

Ledwood85 · 12/01/2024 19:46

What I took away from this is that we have a couple in their early-to-mid-30s who still don't want to live together after two years of being in a relationship.

The lodger is a sidebar issue that may or may not be stemming from a lack of commitment for one or both of you.

^I agree with this.

Doodar · 12/01/2024 19:48

Can he come to yours more often?
Would make more sense you both moving in together.

Ledwood85 · 12/01/2024 19:46

What I took away from this is that we have a couple in their early-to-mid-30s who still don't want to live together after two years of being in a relationship.

The lodger is a sidebar issue that may or may not be stemming from a lack of commitment for one or both of you.

KarenNotAKaren · 12/01/2024 19:46

You need to sort out your trust issues before you get more serious. This poor woman is probably feeling the coldness from you in her own home. Her worst crime is staying in? Come on OP get a grip.

Honeyroar · 12/01/2024 19:46

I think you’re over reacting a bit. I think that was probably why he didn’t tell you she was moving in. I don’t think she sounds anything to worry about, she’s mostly sitting in her room. She sounds like the perfect lodger!

Vitriolinsanity · 12/01/2024 19:46

I think he's the one that's made it uncomfortable by not telling you she's moved in until after the fact.

On the other hand, his behaviour in keeping the noise down is really just respectful of a room mate whomever they may be.

You do have choices, insofar as you can stay at your place, which he seems to prefer anyway.

The similarities to you are down to you to conflate or ignore. Personally, I'd ignore. You know very little about her. As amazing as you think your fella is really doesn't equate to her wanting to jump him.

This isn't her problem, it's a you and him problem.

mrsclaus1984 · 12/01/2024 19:44

Very unpopular opinion alert

if you are seriously, considering a future with this man, I’d be concerned about the following… Firstly, a man in his mid 30s, who needs a second income from a lodger to help him through the basics in life, such as paying the bills.

Secondly, the fact that he has not taken your feelings into consideration, and hid the lodger’s presence from you initially, is also a huge red flag.