Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Professional photographer at a funeral

129 replies

Anonomum14 · 12/01/2024 17:31

I just recently heard that someone hired a professional photographer for their husbands funeral (30yr old - sudden/unexpected) large turnout.
I'm not judging their decision, I have just never ever heard of this. Would you consider this? Is this what people do now? Is it a trend? Personally I don't think I would, just wondering what others think about it.

OP posts:
NeverStopTwinkling · 12/01/2024 19:35

I think it's a nice idea to be honest. I can just imagine how it might pass in a complete blur and later you would like to look back and see who was there or share some of the moments with people who couldn't be there.

My family are RC and mass/funerals/weddings etc are all live streamed now, no one bats an eyelid. It's seen as completely normal.

I wouldn't put smiling funeral selfies on Facebook but I've never seen any either.

LumpyandBumps · 12/01/2024 19:35

My husband died unexpectedly in summer and as he was a very popular man his funeral was quite large.
Before he died I would have been aghast at the thought of videoing the service as I thought I would never want to watch.
In fact we did have it live streamed due to good friends and elderly people living too far away to travel. We mentioned this in the service booklet and anyone who did not wish to be filmed could have opted out, although no one did.
The link went as far as USA and New Zealand.
It was filmed from the back of the room and very discreet. The eulogies were filmed, including those of our very young adult children, after checking that the speakers were ok with it. The mourners were only shown from the rear when leaving the crematorium.
I thought I would never watch the video, but actually did so about a week later. I was astounded to see many people who I had no idea attended. Not everyone came to the Wake or joined the long queue to speak to me, so had it not been for the video I might never have known all of the people who came to pay their respects.
It really is a case of each to their own. I am content with my choice. I would have made arrangements to avoid filming anyone who didn’t wish to be filmed, or been fine with them not attending, but at the end of the day I had to do what and I and my children thought was right for us.

MatildaTheCat · 12/01/2024 19:31

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/01/2024 18:54

I know people do it for those who can't attend but couldn't they focus on the professionals involved in the service only?

I thought the same, EmmaEmerald - perhaps also the cortege, footage of any family/friend doing the eulogy if they okay with this and maybe even a quick pan across the whole group

But focusing on those having a quiet moment next to the coffin or just standing there thoughtfully? Each to their own and all that, but personally I'd find this very distasteful, especially if the mourner hasn't agreed

I can see it’s not for everyone but it was actually an exceptionally moving funeral and had the added strangeness of Covid distancing. The camera was so discreet we weren’t aware of it.

The final video was well edited so anyone in distress was not shown and it looked really professional. In fact the funeral director asked permission to use it as a training piece for training celebrants and their staff.

Not for everyone but some posters are projecting their views very harshly. For us it helped to heal the fact that Dad died alone after 7 weeks in isolation in the early days of the pandemic. We were in bits.

Fionaville · 12/01/2024 19:30

I find this trend of people taking photos of funerals distasteful. I would be hurt to see photos of people smiling on social media, at my loved ones funeral. Have we stopped calling funeral goers mourners? I also think it's a day when you shouldn't have to be concerned about your photo being taken.

declutteringmymind · 12/01/2024 19:29

All the funerals/cremations that have happen have been live streamed recently. We live far away so have actually been able to attend/ say goodbye/show support where we might not have done. So they've definitely been more accessible.

I went to a funeral in the US which was filmed entirely, including the open casket. I was horrified. Apparently in that particular culture it has become the norm. The deceased's child was still young so perhaps recorded for that purpose but I wouldn't have done so. I guess you don't have to look at it ever again but it's there should the child want to see.

I guess we all deal with things differently. Each to their own.

Meowandthen · 12/01/2024 19:26

It was mentioned on a TV programme I watched a few years ago and I was really surprised. It find it distasteful.

Not everything in life needs to be photographed. And it really doesn’t need to be plastered across social media either.

Live streaming a service is different. That just shows the backs of head and any speakers and is helpful if you cannot make it to a service.

Notthatcatagain · 12/01/2024 19:23

My cousins funeral was streamed during lockdown and I was so glad as we weren't allowed to go. At a friend's funeral they had a camera crew filming for her mum who was too frail to travel.

Mrgrinch · 12/01/2024 19:21

I think it's disgraceful. Much like people who post pictures on social media of/at funerals. Do they have no respect at all?

And don't get me started on the worst of the worst- people who take pictures holding the hand of the recently deceased and post it online. An instant block from me. I don't go on social media to see dead bodies and find it beyond horrific.

DragonflyLady · 12/01/2024 19:19

I’m in a FB group where the majority of members are in the West Indies and they share funeral photographs.

ManateeFair · 12/01/2024 19:18

lI wouldn’t do it myself, but I would never dismiss anyone else’s choices about their next of kin’s funeral as ‘disgusting’ and I certainly wouldn’t think it meant they weren’t taking the funeral seriously. To me, the only ‘distasteful’ thing would be sneering or judging a grieving family for doing a funeral in whatever way that’s best for them.

I also think the culture around funerals varies hugely across different demographics, nationalities and religious denominations, and that what is distasteful to one is perfectly normal to others.

The Victorians saw it as perfectly tasteful to commission photographs of the actual deceased person’s corpse. I’ve seen Victorian death portraits of dead children laid out on a couch with their living siblings standing around them. So this isn’t a new thing.

I would also add that having a photographer doesn’t necessarily mean they’re zooming in on people and taking pictures of them crying and ‘at their most vulnerable’.

BombaySamphire · 12/01/2024 19:16

SerafinasGoose · 12/01/2024 18:59

I don't know.

It has certainly never been for me, and I'd find it intrusive and further distressing were someone to point a camera at me whilst in a grieving, emotional state. My mother's funeral, and that of a close friend's child, were so traumatic to me that they passed in a blur and I barely remember them. Neither are days I would ever want to revisit.

But the last people I ever want to sit in judgement on are those who are grieving. We all have to do this in our own way.

Edited

But it involves the whole congregation, who don’t get a veto…

MamaMia69 · 12/01/2024 19:14

I wouldn't, I think it's a bit strange for a funeral!

Northernsouloldies · 12/01/2024 19:06

Not to mention the professional grievers, look how upset I am compared to others. Just no.

Growlybear83 · 12/01/2024 19:04

I think it's a horrible idea and as others have said, I would take great exception at someone photographing me at a funeral when I was grieving.

I was really shocked when my Mum and I went to Australia for my brothers funeral 11 years ago to find out afterwards that the whole service had been videoed 😟 I thought it was horribly gruesome. I can't believe that anyone would actually sit down and watch the video of their loved one's funeral. Needless to say my Mum declined the copy of the DVD she was offered.

SerafinasGoose · 12/01/2024 18:59

I don't know.

It has certainly never been for me, and I'd find it intrusive and further distressing were someone to point a camera at me whilst in a grieving, emotional state. My mother's funeral, and that of a close friend's child, were so traumatic to me that they passed in a blur and I barely remember them. Neither are days I would ever want to revisit.

But the last people I ever want to sit in judgement on are those who are grieving. We all have to do this in our own way.

SuperFurryCat · 12/01/2024 18:58

I don’t like the thought of that at all.
a I find it bad enough when journalists take photos and put them in the newspaper of celebrities funerals and other high profile deaths.
It feels very distasteful. I don’t understand why someone would want photos of their friends and family upset. I also think it would effect how people were grieving if they felt uncomfortable being photographed. And if the photos aren’t meant to be sad and are group wedding style smiling photos then that is particularly disgusting. I can’t imagine someone wanting to look back on photos of a loved ones funeral, it’s hardly something to show the Grandkids. I have a sinking feeling though if this became a ‘thing’ it would be yet another horrible thing that will end up on their social media pages with the tagline of ‘fly high’ or something else equally meaningless, but attention-seeking.

honeyandfizz · 12/01/2024 18:57

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 18:39

HmmConfused

Why the weird faces?!!

New2024 · 12/01/2024 18:56

I’ve spoken at 3 funerals that had a videocast. One was on a private YouTube channel, the other 2 provided by Wesley Media. The Wesley Media ones stay live for a week, but can also be downloaded. With very elderly relatives it enables them to attend virtually with some help from younger family. In all these cases the venues were equipped to record the services inside the chapel. I’ve not come across a photographer in any other sense.

honeyandfizz · 12/01/2024 18:56

My DDad died last year and at his funeral myself, my two teens, my Mum and 2 brothers all got up on stage and gave our eulogies. Mum and Dad had been to the same Pentecostal Church for over 30 years and the church was full, people sining and clapping and the whole atmosphere was so uplifting and moving on such a sad day. We have all thought we wish we had it recorded so we could relive it - sounds utterly bizarre but it was the church was full of such love and emotion I wish I could see it once more.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/01/2024 18:54

I know people do it for those who can't attend but couldn't they focus on the professionals involved in the service only?

I thought the same, EmmaEmerald - perhaps also the cortege, footage of any family/friend doing the eulogy if they okay with this and maybe even a quick pan across the whole group

But focusing on those having a quiet moment next to the coffin or just standing there thoughtfully? Each to their own and all that, but personally I'd find this very distasteful, especially if the mourner hasn't agreed

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 18:50

AngelinaFibres · 12/01/2024 18:13

There was a tv documentary about funeral photography a few years ago. The widow featured said that there were lots of images of special moments between people that she would never have seen if the photographer hadn't captured them. Several people stopped by the coffin as they left the crematorium and placed their hands gently on it to say a final goodbye. She had exited first and would have had no idea. The photographer was very discreet and had a quiet motor on her camera. She didn't get groups of people together in the way you would have at wedding. She captured moments as she saw them . I was as sceptical as many people on here. I came away thinking what a lovely thing it was.

Sorry I still see it as disgusting. Those people are paying respect to someone whom they cared about. That’s a personal moment and they deserve that moment without being featured on a photo without their consent. If I use myself as an example, when my Dad died I was a crying, swollen mess with make up pouring down my face. I put my hand on his coffin and said goodbye to him in my head. If I discovered that someone had taken my photo in that moment I'd be apoplectic

Beargrumps22 · 12/01/2024 18:45

not of the mourners but afterward it was nice to re-see the flowers in photographs, at the time it all passes so quickly. I have noticed that recently the custom of people who attend the funeral being taken on a list does not seem to be done anymore. it used to be one of the funeral firm and after the blur of faces it is nice to sit again later and see who attended

Doggymummar · 12/01/2024 18:42

My friend was murdered by her husband, age 25 and they had a photographer there. It was very tasteful and really helped the family to see how loved she was, there were several 100 people there and a lot of press and TV. As it's a younger person who has died perhaps they want to make it a party rather than a sad occasion?we had pool and karaoke at her favourite bar for the wake.

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 18:39

MatildaTheCat · 12/01/2024 17:35

We had a beautiful film made of my Dads funeral which was very special ( beautiful location for burial) but it was mainly because it was during Covid so many people were unable to attend including some of his children.

HmmConfused

SaltyGod · 12/01/2024 18:38

I wouldn’t judge someone who was grieving a tremendous loss and this helped them.

My experience with an untimely unexpected death is that it passes in a blur, and that the widow was hugely comforted by the number of people who came. It gave her solace to know people cared enough to come, that he was respected and loved by many people that she wouldn’t have expected to attend.

Perhaps a photographer is there to help those grieving go over the day, see how much their loved one meant to others, to pinpoint something that otherwise would be unimaginable to them give the suddenness, something that they want to understand in the future when they are more capable of processing.