Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Professional photographer at a funeral

129 replies

Anonomum14 · 12/01/2024 17:31

I just recently heard that someone hired a professional photographer for their husbands funeral (30yr old - sudden/unexpected) large turnout.
I'm not judging their decision, I have just never ever heard of this. Would you consider this? Is this what people do now? Is it a trend? Personally I don't think I would, just wondering what others think about it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Copen · 13/01/2024 17:03

It's usual in some cultures. My parents are from a Nordic country that routinely takes funeral photographs. They are generally of the coffin being carried, wreaths being laid, speeches at the wake, maybe groups at the wake. Not any of distressed mourners - but it's not a country that is prone to open displays of emotion anyway.

Eastie77Returns · 13/01/2024 08:42

EmmaEmerald · 12/01/2024 21:20

@Eastie77Returns how did you feel about that?

Uncomfortable really. Watching mourners putting up with cameras shoved in their faces was not nice. I don’t like to draw attention to myself whereas DSis absolutely loves to be the centre of it and a lot of her ‘grief’ felt performative and for the benefit of the film crew.

I posted on here in Style & Beauty before the funeral in a panic because family members all had to wear a specific colour of clothing (not black) and I couldn’t find anything suitable for myself and DC. A kind group of Mnetters helped me track down everything I needed. But Dsis then made us wear garish matching accessories so that “it looks good for the cameras”🙄

Changedmymind99 · 13/01/2024 08:21

I walked by a funeral where the chief mourners were taking selfies with the coffin outside the church.

I found it a little disturbing. So a photographer is another level to that.

Zfactorstar · 13/01/2024 08:20

Posting the photos on social media with no filter or worning maybe a bit much, but none of us have any right to tell another person how to grieve. Those photos may bring comfort to the grieving. To each their own.

Finlesswonder · 13/01/2024 08:05

The Victorians saw it as perfectly tasteful to commission photographs of the actual deceased person’s corpse

I think the difference is the victoriana were honouring the dead with their pictures. But footage of the funeral presumably doesn't include photos of the dead person, considering todays sensibilities. So funeral photography today wouldn't really be about the dead person at all. It would be about the grieving person putting themselves at the centre of a kind of "experience"

NeverStopTwinkling · 13/01/2024 07:58

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:07

@tenbob No the first part. People posing for photographs at the wake. I don't care how long you've not seen someone, it's a sodding funeral. Show some respect

But it's just photos. Of loved ones. I find your attitude beyond odd.

Honestly, I hope my wake is a happy event where the people I love come together and enjoy being with one another. I hope they recognise how special their time here is and take joy from that. If they want a photo to remember it, that's wonderful.

porridgecake · 13/01/2024 02:37

I attended a funeral during covid where a video was taken because almost no family could attend due to travel restrictions. It was done very sensitively and discreetly and was very much appreciated by dozens of people who would very much wanted to have been there. What families decide to do in these circumstances is really nobody else's business.

Sunmoonandstarsforever · 13/01/2024 02:06

My immediate thought on reading the title was - WTF and I don’t normally swear. Just awful if I had seen anyone taking photos at any of my loved ones funerals I would have lost it. It’s such a heartbreaking event, raw grief, and private

TheIroningMaiden · 13/01/2024 01:31

I worked as a military photographer many years ago and one of the jobs we sometimes had to cover was funerals for service members. It was something that was offered to the family.
I only ever had to cover the one service in my entire time and it consisted of photos of the church, the coffin being carried in, the folk who said a few words about their loved one, some overall shots inside the church, the priest, the gardens outside and the many flowers/tributes that were laid out.
I initially felt out of place and awkward at the start of the service but the family wanted it so I just kept a respectable distance and tried to be discreet.
The idea behind it is that for most of the family, the day of the funeral is a blur and they're numb with grief, so we were able to create an album for them to be able to look back on (whenever they were ready to) so that they could see the flowers and the people there and hopefully that aided them in their journey through bereavement.

Bunniemalone · 13/01/2024 00:38

My grandpa's funeral was filmed, in the 70s. But that was by the flying squad... So for much different reasons. But we do still have it, my Dad asked the police for a copy & they obliged, someone in the family had it put onto dvd.

2024afreshhope · 12/01/2024 22:27

We, like many(?), have a video of a parent’s funeral who died during covid.

It’s a recording of the funeral that few could attend in person.

Single camera point, no family group shots, no poses.

Not sure if anyone’s watched it since.

But having a photographer well post covid - a bit odd. We won’t be doing it for my Mum when she kicks the bucket!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/01/2024 22:15

One side of DH’s family always have someone taking some photos at wakes.
They’re a huge family - IL is one of 15 - and funerals are the only occasion they are all together as there’s too many for weddings and parties.

At his Aunt’s funeral his grandmother, who was 99 at the time, had a photo taken with her 11 remaining children. 6 of whom she hadn’t seen since pre covid because they’re abroad.

I think if it happened at a funeral on my side it would seem weird and odd, but because it’s always been done on that side (his Granny has a photo taken at her granny’s wake so it’s a very old habit/tradition on their side) it doesn’t seem it at funerals they have

Tatumm · 12/01/2024 22:13

It’s not something I would personally choose but we have to be guided by the needs of those closest to the deceased.

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:07

@tenbob No the first part. People posing for photographs at the wake. I don't care how long you've not seen someone, it's a sodding funeral. Show some respect

tenbob · 12/01/2024 22:06

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:03

That's awful, how disgusting

What’s disgusting? Parents wanting to get a nice video of their baby?

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:06

MissTrip82 · 12/01/2024 20:09

What a mean thread.

Disingenuously disguising disapproval and encouraging others to come on and criticise a grieving woman for being ‘distasteful’. Dismissing one woman’s desire to preserve the memory of those who came together in love for her loved one as maybe a ‘thing’ now as if she’s an insta idiot.

Very unpleasant indeed. I hope she doesn’t see it. ‘

People are entitled to discuss the concept of this. We do not live in a communist society, we have free will and have a discussion about what each of us thinks is right or wrong

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:03

Paw2024 · 12/01/2024 20:05

Not at the funeral but we took photos at the wake after my mums funeral
My dad realised there are relatives that we haven't got photos of since they were babies, and a few people asked to have some photos taken together
So me and my auntie, my cousin, me and my dad. Nobody who didn't want photos and it wasn't in the funeral itself

One of the most beautiful videos I've seen was from a guy who was hired to do birth photography/video, the baby was born and not going to survive and they asked him still to do the video. It's incredibly filmed

That's awful, how disgusting

BetrayedAuntie · 12/01/2024 22:02

@Katiepoes That is macabre and quite odd behaviour. I'd be very concerned about her mental wellbeing

gabsdot45 · 12/01/2024 21:36

This is quite common in the US. I've seen photos on Facebook of funerals. Some are very beautiful and tasteful and as a PP mentioned, sometimes it's a good time to get family photos.
Some I've seen were a bit uncomfortable E.g. photo of the widow and young children posing, smiling, by dad's coffin.

TraitorRoundTable · 12/01/2024 21:22

We received a dvd of my parents funeral and it was live streamed in lockdown, my other parent watches it frequently and gets comfort from it. 30 years old and left a young widow, there by the grace and all that.

LlynTegid · 12/01/2024 21:21

I would never consider this. The only filming I would wish for is for the church to livestream the service, for those who could not get there.

EmmaEmerald · 12/01/2024 21:20

@Eastie77Returns how did you feel about that?

2Old2Tango · 12/01/2024 21:00

I'd find it a bit odd tbh. What were they photographing? It's a bit intrusive to take pictures of people grieving. If it's a crematorium then you can request a recording of the service if you want to listen to it again afterwards. Can't imagine having pictures of a coffin and/or grieving friends and relatives in the photo album.

RandomButtons · 12/01/2024 20:57

It’s been a thing for decades. Not a modern trend. It’s just not very common.

Savedpassword · 12/01/2024 20:56

There’s an Irish funeral director who seems to specialise in very heavily edited videos of the entire funeral and regularly posts them on their FB page. I’d wouldn’t be something I’d chose for myself but I wouldn’t judge anybody who does. In the UK we have a very strange approach to death and dying. I wonder if forcing people to be more exposed to funerals will break down some of the barriers we have to accepting it more.