Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stay fat?

135 replies

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 12:24

I have struggled with my weight all my life. I managed to lose 3 stone about 20 years ago and kept it off, losing it again after 2 babies.

I was never happy with my body and always on a diet. Most family days out and holidays are marked by me trying to not put on weight. When we recently renovated our house my DH found notebook after notebook full of restrictive meal plans and calories.

I was put on medication after losing my lovely dad at the end of 2022 and have been so much happier. They are amazing and have treated the anxiety and depression I have had since my teens.

However, they have made me put in 2 stone going from a size 12 to a 14/16. I just don’t hate myself enough to say no! I cook healthy meals every night but won’t say no to the odd treat. I have been eating a lot of takeaway as I had no kitchen for 9 months which probably made the situation worse and isn’t happening anymore so that might make a difference! I turned 40 this year and have certainly felt it!

Also my DH can’t keep his hands off me now. He says he loves my body and bigger boobs and is like a besotted teenager again!

I feel so embarrassed about the weight gain but do I work on accepting it, purge my wardrobe of too small clothes and accept happy, fat me. Find a new style and rebuild myself (I feel like the old me does with my dad) or restrict enough to lose the weight and fit into all my lovely clothes?

so AIBU to stay fat?

OP posts:
Devilshands · 12/01/2024 14:28

Rebecca Adlington is about a size 14 these days. I don't think anyone could accuse her of being fat or unfit - which is what some of these comments appear to be saying (that a size 14 is automatically fat).

Part of the problem these days is that size 10 -12 is healthy and, apparently, big is beautiful (i.e. size 20+). But anything between is morbidly obese and you're gonna die and an excavator is going to have to lower your body into your grave (but only if you're a size 12 - 16!!!).

Quite frankly, unless you're a significant burden on the NHS and/or your health is rapidly declining, I don't think there is a real issue. If you were so fat you could barely walk five paces without getting out of breath, I'd think differently.

So, YABU for declaring yourself fat at a size 14 - because size 14 doesn't automatically mean fat.

YABNU to stay at that size (assuming you're not on deaths door and are capable of walking more than five paces)

Beautiful3 · 12/01/2024 14:28

I have a similar situation. I find my fitness pal app brilliant, I eat what every want but stay under my calories. Fasting really helps. You can chose a window of time that you'll eat during. It sounds weird, but it really helps. I eat between 12-7pm. I find that I lose so much weight doing this (still calorie count) than calorie counting alone. I really wouldn't let it go, because I did similar. I ended up gaining a stone each year. I ended up 3 stone overweight and I developed pains in my knees, from the excess weight. It made me feel ill. So I would say to you, to get back to it.

Jom222 · 12/01/2024 14:25

If you eat a healthy diet full of fresh veg and fruit and as much home cooking as you can manage and you're happy with your current body size don't worry too much about the number on the scale.

Do you exercise? Eat wholesome foods in normal portions? If so carry on. I'm an obese woman who has stopped binging by concentrating on an overall healthy diet and have slowly naturally lost weight just by doing the above.

YANBU

VyeBrator · 12/01/2024 14:25

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 14:18

I think DH loves my bigger boobs and bum! He is very body confident and at 6ft2 and solid 16 stone of muscle I don’t think he’s projecting! It’s really sad that people don’t believe that my husband can find my body attractive and must have an anterior motive. I really am quite pretty and look younger with weight on me, not ‘horsey and gaunt’, so that might be why? He says he likes ‘thick thighs and pretty eyes’ and I don’t think he is alone.

i might have been happy lying in bed counting my ribs but he wasn’t!

No-one's saying he doesn't find you attractive.

The point is your HEALTH is what's important, not what your bloke thinks of your tits and arse 🙄

He should be happy his wife wants to take care of herself and hopefully be around longer for him and the DC, not 'protesting' because you want to lose weight.

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 14:18

I think DH loves my bigger boobs and bum! He is very body confident and at 6ft2 and solid 16 stone of muscle I don’t think he’s projecting! It’s really sad that people don’t believe that my husband can find my body attractive and must have an anterior motive. I really am quite pretty and look younger with weight on me, not ‘horsey and gaunt’, so that might be why? He says he likes ‘thick thighs and pretty eyes’ and I don’t think he is alone.

i might have been happy lying in bed counting my ribs but he wasn’t!

OP posts:
Whataretheodds · 12/01/2024 14:16

I think you should focus on health factors:
Nourishing foods, a balanced diet limiting UPF.
Regular exercise, combining strength stamina and flexibility.

No crash diets, no restrictive mentality, focused on positive activities rather than self-denial. You need to stabilise your mind and body and get out of the binge/purge mentality.

Thisistyresome · 12/01/2024 14:15

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 13:53

For all those telling me I am going to get heart disease and die prematurely you might want to read this:

In fact, population studies give varying estimates for the BMI range linked with the lowest rates of death, with most suggesting the optimum weight is in the 25 to 30 band, for all ages. The strongest evidence that a higher BMI is preferable comes from studies of older adults.

Thankyou to those being balanced and kind. I am finding it easy to maintain this weight compared to the constant starvation and skipping meals to stay 10.7.

also, loving myself enough to say no had me eating special K for breakfast when away with my boys instead of the lovely full
english on offer. Never eating treats without crippling self hatred.

I am going to try to mend my relationship with food. I will start yoga and swimming to move more and will concentrate on eating healthy foods - trying to aim for 1600 a day.

i will try to accept myself and take this journey slowly.

Bear in mind swimming can be good or it can be dull. Also yogo is something, but have you considered something a but more fun?

Pygtrail · 12/01/2024 14:13

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 14:10

I did stay 11 stone ish for 20 years and lost the weight after each baby (I gained 4 stone in pregnancy!) I don’t feel as fit and I know I need to lose weight (despite DH’s protestations!) but I will resolve not to hate myself during the process and look for a quick fix. I’ve only ever crash dieted and can’t see slow and steady working but I think it’s best for me and my mental health.

It will give your DH time to adjust too 😂

BishopLenBrennan · 12/01/2024 14:12

In fact my own dear wife is on the curvy side which is partly what attracted me to her in the first place. I can’t keep my hands off her either but sadly not always reciprocated 🤣🤣🤣

crackofdoom · 12/01/2024 14:12

WhataFoolishFool

I'm going to guess the OP isn't the type who "can't be bothered with lunch". If she was, she probably wouldn't be overweight.

And I'm guessing that you're the type who can't imagine what it's like to be hungry and thinking about food all the time.

I don't think enough is discussed about appetite. Let's face it, a lot of the reason some drugs make you fatter is because they make you hungrier. See also menopause. There's a massive difference between only eating 1200 calories a day because you "can't be bothered" to eat any more, and only eating 1200 calories as a superhuman act of willpower when you're still starving hungry.

VyeBrator · 12/01/2024 14:12

Your DH sounds like he wants to keep you overweight.

Why is that? Does he struggle with his own body image?

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 14:10

I did stay 11 stone ish for 20 years and lost the weight after each baby (I gained 4 stone in pregnancy!) I don’t feel as fit and I know I need to lose weight (despite DH’s protestations!) but I will resolve not to hate myself during the process and look for a quick fix. I’ve only ever crash dieted and can’t see slow and steady working but I think it’s best for me and my mental health.

OP posts:
Fullrecoveryispossible · 12/01/2024 14:10

Read the fuck it diet. It will change your life. Stop restricting. Life is too short to be obsessing over a clothing size. Let your body go to where it naturally wants and you will fall into a natural routine of eating.

VyeBrator · 12/01/2024 14:10

BishopLenBrennan · 12/01/2024 14:05

A lot of blokes I know prefer (how can I put this?) curvier women!

And?

Should we all risk cardiovascular disease, diabetes and joint problems because some men prefer overweight women??

Pygtrail · 12/01/2024 14:07

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 13:53

For all those telling me I am going to get heart disease and die prematurely you might want to read this:

In fact, population studies give varying estimates for the BMI range linked with the lowest rates of death, with most suggesting the optimum weight is in the 25 to 30 band, for all ages. The strongest evidence that a higher BMI is preferable comes from studies of older adults.

Thankyou to those being balanced and kind. I am finding it easy to maintain this weight compared to the constant starvation and skipping meals to stay 10.7.

also, loving myself enough to say no had me eating special K for breakfast when away with my boys instead of the lovely full
english on offer. Never eating treats without crippling self hatred.

I am going to try to mend my relationship with food. I will start yoga and swimming to move more and will concentrate on eating healthy foods - trying to aim for 1600 a day.

i will try to accept myself and take this journey slowly.

I don’t like loads of grease and processed meat in the mornings. If I am away I always choose the poached egg with smoked salmon/haddock (if they have fish). If not the poached egg and mushrooms on toast.

Don’t just stick to special k if you are on holiday tweak the cooked breakfast to a more healthier version. My DH always gets the full English then moans after it he even had fried bread last time it was enough for me to secretly contemplate divorcing him fried bread 🤮

My DH is overweight but not obese like me. My adult son always has the fish like me he’s never been overweight.

Sounds like you have a great life don’t let obsessing about your weight impact it just tweak and choose healthier when you can.

Stubbedtoes · 12/01/2024 14:07

I'm a similar size and have also decided no more calorie counting and restricting. I have been dieting off and on since a teenager - when I wasn't even overweight - and I'm late 40s now. No more.

I've nailed the exercise bit over the last decade. I've been enjoying exercise and made it a good, consistent habit. Food is my downfall now. However, I'm going to concentrate on eating healthier food and ADDING healthy food in. The only restriction I'm going to do is processed food. More veg, more nuts. Fermented foods. More water. Less alcohol.

If dieting and calorie/food restriction worked we wouldn't have so many overweight people and I wouldn't be overweight either. It's as simple as that.

disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 14:06

PersephonePomegranate23 · 12/01/2024 13:53

It's not as stark a choice as restrictive eating vs fat though, is it? What about a mid ground approach? Healthy 80% of the time, treats 20%.

Do what makes you happiest.

As an aside, I know size 14/16 is average, but that doesn't mean people aren't overweight!

Edited

Indeed. On average people are overweight, so if you are average then it's probably not good news!

People are also notoriously bad at maintaining a calorie deficit with treats / "cheat days", they normally wipe out any savings they've made the rest of the week. Better off getting into a long term mindset where a sugary UPF confection or an oily, carby, salty takeaway isn't a "treat", in the same way as a cigarette isn't a "treat".

BishopLenBrennan · 12/01/2024 14:05

A lot of blokes I know prefer (how can I put this?) curvier women!

NotSayingImBatman · 12/01/2024 14:05

You're cooking healthy meals every night but refusing to say no to the odd treat. That sounds like a very healthy approach to food and, honestly, Mumsnet is the worst place to come for healthy eating advice. There's a real epidemic of competitive undereating slimness across all the boards and has been since I joined in 2011. If you're healthy and eating mostly healthily, crack on. You're above average in height, so a 14/16 on you is probably the same as a 10/12 on someone 3-4 inches shorter.

crackofdoom · 12/01/2024 14:04

At her height and weight, the OP is within half a stone of straying into the obese category. This is not a comfortable or healthy place to be (speaking as someone who's been there)

VirtualRealitee · 12/01/2024 14:02

Prelapsarianhag · 12/01/2024 13:52

Size 16 is the average for British women.

And over 63% of British adults are overweight or obese, so I'm not sure what your point is? 🤔

VyeBrator · 12/01/2024 13:59

BrutusMcDogface · 12/01/2024 13:40

Yabu for saying that a size 14/16 is “fat”.

Will you PLEASE STOP with this sort of shit?

You're trying to make an OP feel bad when she is the one who is fat and struggling with her weight. It's not about YOU so get over yourself! Angry

You do you and leave others alone!

crackofdoom · 12/01/2024 13:59

I'm your age and your height OP.

For a lot of my adult life I was about your weight (and I was a solid 16 on it, couldn't fit into a 14 at 13 stone 7!). And I was really quite unhealthy. I didn't look good either- I have a long face, and with a double chin I looked like Stephen Fry 😬.

You really feel the difference of those extra couple of stone- I really wish I'd made the effort to maintain a healthy weight earlier in life.

I'll concede that it's not easy though, especially not at this age- I'm a size 12, but the weight is creeping up- 10 weeks of painstaking weight loss from a low carb diet was wiped out by 2 weeks of indulgence at Christmas 😪.

I'm hoping that exercise, combined with IF, is going to be the answer to getting fit and healthy and just remaining in the healthy weight category without fretting too much over pounds lost or gained. I've just started running, so fingers crossed 🤞

WhatAFoolishFool · 12/01/2024 13:58

Absolutely embrace your happiness HOWEVER being fat isn’t healthy. Absolutely don’t go on some restrictive diet but absolutely DO continue to cook yourself healthy meals and have the occasional treat - but what’s occasional? Once a week or once an hour? I probably have a treat a few times a week, but I don’t diet, I never ever go hungry, I prepare all of my own meals from scratch and have lost over a stone naturally (I was a healthy weight to begin with). So there is no reason why you can’t lose the excess weight without dieting.

for example today I have had scrambled egg and beans on toast for breakfast (real butter!), a flat white in a cafe, and then I couldn’t be bothered with lunch so I had a banana and a glass of full fat milk. Dinner will be a homemade lasagne (as in I make all of the sauce myself, but not the pasta!) which I will have with a side salad. Only other drinks are water.

my BMI is around 21 and as I say I got to this naturally.

PersephonePomegranate23 · 12/01/2024 13:53

It's not as stark a choice as restrictive eating vs fat though, is it? What about a mid ground approach? Healthy 80% of the time, treats 20%.

Do what makes you happiest.

As an aside, I know size 14/16 is average, but that doesn't mean people aren't overweight!

Swipe left for the next trending thread