Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stay fat?

135 replies

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 12:24

I have struggled with my weight all my life. I managed to lose 3 stone about 20 years ago and kept it off, losing it again after 2 babies.

I was never happy with my body and always on a diet. Most family days out and holidays are marked by me trying to not put on weight. When we recently renovated our house my DH found notebook after notebook full of restrictive meal plans and calories.

I was put on medication after losing my lovely dad at the end of 2022 and have been so much happier. They are amazing and have treated the anxiety and depression I have had since my teens.

However, they have made me put in 2 stone going from a size 12 to a 14/16. I just don’t hate myself enough to say no! I cook healthy meals every night but won’t say no to the odd treat. I have been eating a lot of takeaway as I had no kitchen for 9 months which probably made the situation worse and isn’t happening anymore so that might make a difference! I turned 40 this year and have certainly felt it!

Also my DH can’t keep his hands off me now. He says he loves my body and bigger boobs and is like a besotted teenager again!

I feel so embarrassed about the weight gain but do I work on accepting it, purge my wardrobe of too small clothes and accept happy, fat me. Find a new style and rebuild myself (I feel like the old me does with my dad) or restrict enough to lose the weight and fit into all my lovely clothes?

so AIBU to stay fat?

OP posts:
Newsenmum · 12/01/2024 16:54

peakygold · 12/01/2024 16:15

So size 16 is fat now, is it? 😕

Wait what did you think was??

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 16:28

Size 16 is, with the occasional exception, overweight - yes!

disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 16:20

peakygold · 12/01/2024 16:15

So size 16 is fat now, is it? 😕

DRESS SIZE IS MEANINGLESS. Women's clothes vary SO much I don't know why it's ever even mentioned on threads like these - unless it's to obscure the real issue.

BMI is not perfect but it's a good indicator of healthy weight.

Waist circumference is not perfect but is a very good indicator of healthy weight.

Dress size is only marginally more helpful than star sign as an indicator of healthy weight. I wish people would leave it alone.

AngryBird6122 · 12/01/2024 16:19

peakygold · 12/01/2024 16:15

So size 16 is fat now, is it? 😕

Well it is, isn't it?

I'm a 14/16 and I would say I am definitely overweight!

peakygold · 12/01/2024 16:15

So size 16 is fat now, is it? 😕

VirtualRealitee · 12/01/2024 16:03

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 14:37

As an aside, I know size 14/16 is average, but that doesn't mean people aren't overweight

You're trying to make an OP feel bad when she is the one who is fat and struggling with her weight. It's not about YOU so get over yourself

Two quotes by two posters referring to those sizes as fat and saying that OP is fat, for being that size. My argument was to those posters who (as I have proven in my quotes above) have said that a size 14 is fat. OP herself has literally referred to herself as fat in the title!

Rebecca Adlington is an ex-swimmer. Even as a professional she was a size 12. Ex-athletes are well known to put on weight after they stop training at a top level - as an ex-athlete myself, I can vouch for this. Aliya Mustafina is another example. Both of them are probably still fitter than the stick insects that seem to post on mumsnet boasting about their 'massive salads.'

Edited

NO-ONE has said a size 14 is 'automatically fat'.

Rebecca is not an ex swimmer. She's an ex professional swimmer, who still swims.

The OP has said she's fat and she's very nearly into the obese range of BMI.

There will be other size 14s who are not.

cheezncrackers · 12/01/2024 15:54

YANBU to ditch restrictive eating and non-stop dieting. That's an awful way to live, as you well know.

You need to change your habits and your mindset, which takes longer, but it will create good, healthy habits you can sustain. Ditch the takeaways, find a form of exercise you enjoy, learn to love and respect your body and value your health.

You're only 40. Being overweight at 40 isn't too hard, as you're still young and I assume relatively firm and without joint pain and other niggles. But if you want to know what overweight looks like as you get older, look around next time you're out. That older person carrying too much weight will likely be huffing and puffing, may be limping, may have obviously reduced mobility - you don't want that for yourself. Your health is the most important thing you own. Value it. Treasure it. And treat your body, both now and in future, like you would a treasured vehicle. Give it the right fuel in the right amounts and it should keep running reliably for many years to come.

user1497207191 · 12/01/2024 15:47

Slow and steady is definitely the way.

I was morbidly obese but have managed to lose 7 stones. But it's taken 20 years!!

That was just moving more and eating less. I turned my back on dieting as I just yo-yo'd and ended up always gaining more than I lost afterwards, hence getting so fat in the first place.

I don't do excessive exercise, just 10k steps walking per day, with the occasional bit of weight training, cycling, swimming etc for variety. It's the consistency of doing "something" every day which works.

As for food, I just eat what I want, when I want it, but in small portions, never a "plateful" not even at Christmas. If I fancy chocolate, I'll have half a chocolate bar and save the other half for another day. When my eating was out of control, I'd have an entire six-pack of Kit Kat or crisps in one go! Now I purposely buy smaller packs/bars, and smaller ready meals, cook smaller quantities, etc. After a while, your stomach shrinks and you literally "can't" eat the same quantity of food that you used to do when your eating is out of control.

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 15:42

OP do you do any strength based exercise ? The older you get the more you need this.

also - forget BMI. It’s a very rough and ready estimation. The real markers of how much of an issue your weight is, is your visceral fat. Get this looked at

Floofydawg · 12/01/2024 15:34

I focus on fitness over weight these days (aged 54). It's very difficult to lose weight in menopause and I've also gone from a 12 to a 14/16. However I'm probably the fittest I've ever been. I go to the gym 5 times a week and my cardiovascular fitness is high. Exercise is the way forward OP. And cooking healthy food from scratch.

Zombiemum1946 · 12/01/2024 15:33

What's important is how healthy you are. As for food, the nutritional value of what's on your plate is important and removing as much processed foods as possible. As others have said age related changes strongly play a part in all of this. It's great that dh loves all of you but it's not so great if it hurts your health.

Upwiththelark76 · 12/01/2024 15:28

Your mental health sounds good OP . Don’t focus on calories and size of clothes. Focus on you and loving life and I bet the happier you become the less you need to obsess about calories and restrictive diets. Take it from there .

disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 15:23

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 14:37

As an aside, I know size 14/16 is average, but that doesn't mean people aren't overweight

You're trying to make an OP feel bad when she is the one who is fat and struggling with her weight. It's not about YOU so get over yourself

Two quotes by two posters referring to those sizes as fat and saying that OP is fat, for being that size. My argument was to those posters who (as I have proven in my quotes above) have said that a size 14 is fat. OP herself has literally referred to herself as fat in the title!

Rebecca Adlington is an ex-swimmer. Even as a professional she was a size 12. Ex-athletes are well known to put on weight after they stop training at a top level - as an ex-athlete myself, I can vouch for this. Aliya Mustafina is another example. Both of them are probably still fitter than the stick insects that seem to post on mumsnet boasting about their 'massive salads.'

Edited

The vast majority of women on Mumsnet are not ex-professional athlete. Being an elite athlete requires a specific level of training/nutrition/percentage fat that is probably not great for long term health either! It's really got nothing to do with this conversation except to illustrate that dress size is a shit indicator of health.

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 15:21

And yes, unless you are an athlete - size 14 is (with very very limited exceptions) overweight. Size 20 isn’t beautiful, it’s morbidly obese and pretty bloody irresponsible. So much self delusion.

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 15:18

Depends. What’s your visceral fat percentage? Harsh truth is being overweight (and size 14/16 absolutely is) will have health impacts either now or in the future. If you are willing to accept that and suck it up when they bite, carry on.

EdgarsTale · 12/01/2024 15:14

It’s not about what you look like, it’s about your health. You have to look after your body as you move into midlife, or you will pay the price unfortunately.

PoinsettiaLives · 12/01/2024 15:05

I think you're viewing things in terms of extremes- either you have to be obsessively calorie counting and following restrictive meal plans OR you have to eat everything you want and be fat. The healthier path would be something in between. At 13st7lb you are borderline obese you it's definitely worth taking action as while you might not have any health issues now you're definitely running a risk of issues in future. It doesn't have to be a very restrictive diet fuelled by self-hate, quite the opposite- expanding the range of things you eat by including more varieties of fruit and veg plus wholegrains, healthy fats, protein. Cut out the takeaways and other crap and find some exercise you enjoy.

Plenty of men fancy bigger women so I don't doubt for a moment that your husband fancies you. But you're not just there to turn him on, you're a person in your own right and your health needs to come before his hard on. I also think you're thinking in extremes here- it's not a choice between "gaunt" and obese, you can be somewhere in the middle.

I just don’t hate myself enough to say no

This line is very telling.

laclochette · 12/01/2024 14:52

I'd reframe it as "getting healthy". Not losing weight.

Getting healthy mentally. Address the issues behind your cyclical binge/restrict mentality. What is the emotional root of that? Can you work through it?

Getting healthy physically. Takeaways are salty, non-nutritious (and of course expensive). Hopefully you can break that habit once you can cook properly at home again. And take up regular exercise not with the goal of losing weight but of getting stronger, more flexible, boosting your serotonin.

If you're still the same weight after all this, so be it. You'll be healthier and more able to enjoy life for longer.

I read recently that the way we think about longevity is wrong. We shouldn't be framing it as "extra years on the end of life" but as "how can the last ten years of my life be as great as possible". Health plays a big role in that.

mynameiscalypso · 12/01/2024 14:46

I was a size 12/14 with a BMI in the obese category. I clearly carry my weight well but it doesn't mean that I wasn't obese/suffering from associated health complications. Dress size is not a good correlation but clearly, in my case, being a size 14 did mean I was 'fat' (unless you think that having a BMI in the obese category doesn't mean you're fat).

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 14:37

VirtualRealitee · 12/01/2024 14:30

Rebecca Adlington is about a size 14 these days. I don't think anyone could accuse her of being fat orunfit - which is what some of these comments appear to be saying (that a size 14 is automatically fat).

Rebecca is a 34 year old Olympic swimmer.

No-one (literally no-one) has said that a size 14 is 'automatically fat'.

As an aside, I know size 14/16 is average, but that doesn't mean people aren't overweight

You're trying to make an OP feel bad when she is the one who is fat and struggling with her weight. It's not about YOU so get over yourself

Two quotes by two posters referring to those sizes as fat and saying that OP is fat, for being that size. My argument was to those posters who (as I have proven in my quotes above) have said that a size 14 is fat. OP herself has literally referred to herself as fat in the title!

Rebecca Adlington is an ex-swimmer. Even as a professional she was a size 12. Ex-athletes are well known to put on weight after they stop training at a top level - as an ex-athlete myself, I can vouch for this. Aliya Mustafina is another example. Both of them are probably still fitter than the stick insects that seem to post on mumsnet boasting about their 'massive salads.'

WantOutOfRatRace · 12/01/2024 14:34

I think it's important to look at why you have the treats/takeaways and see if you can switch for something better.

As a single parent that works full time, I found that I'd end up getting takeaway if work ended up finishing late or I was traveling for work, etc. Basically when tired and stressed. So I started stocking the freezer with ready meal/quick cook options that just need sticking in the oven or microwave and packs of veg that cook in the microwave so don't need any prep. It's a small change so much more manageable than trying to convince myself to start prepping proper cook from scratch options. Similarly, I've tried to switch out treats to healthier options.

There's no point in trying to have a perfect diet if it's not achievable. Find small changes that stick. And do the same with exercise.

Emily1583 · 12/01/2024 14:33

It sounds like you and your partner are both comfortable with your body which is good, but just be cautious about the associated health problems that come with being overweight.

VirtualRealitee · 12/01/2024 14:30

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 14:28

Rebecca Adlington is about a size 14 these days. I don't think anyone could accuse her of being fat or unfit - which is what some of these comments appear to be saying (that a size 14 is automatically fat).

Part of the problem these days is that size 10 -12 is healthy and, apparently, big is beautiful (i.e. size 20+). But anything between is morbidly obese and you're gonna die and an excavator is going to have to lower your body into your grave (but only if you're a size 12 - 16!!!).

Quite frankly, unless you're a significant burden on the NHS and/or your health is rapidly declining, I don't think there is a real issue. If you were so fat you could barely walk five paces without getting out of breath, I'd think differently.

So, YABU for declaring yourself fat at a size 14 - because size 14 doesn't automatically mean fat.

YABNU to stay at that size (assuming you're not on deaths door and are capable of walking more than five paces)

Rebecca Adlington is about a size 14 these days. I don't think anyone could accuse her of being fat orunfit - which is what some of these comments appear to be saying (that a size 14 is automatically fat).

Rebecca is a 34 year old Olympic swimmer.

No-one (literally no-one) has said that a size 14 is 'automatically fat'.

Pygtrail · 12/01/2024 14:28

You’ll find a middle ground and both be content and satisfied.

You sound like you’re addressing the turmoil in yourself as-well as appreciating the desire your husband has for your current build. He will be happy if you are happy.

LaughterTitsoff · 12/01/2024 14:28

There's a big area between being fat and being 'horsey' and 'gaunt'.

Your DH's opinions on your body's attractiveness which appear to be self-serving, shouldn't come into it at all.