Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stay fat?

135 replies

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 12:24

I have struggled with my weight all my life. I managed to lose 3 stone about 20 years ago and kept it off, losing it again after 2 babies.

I was never happy with my body and always on a diet. Most family days out and holidays are marked by me trying to not put on weight. When we recently renovated our house my DH found notebook after notebook full of restrictive meal plans and calories.

I was put on medication after losing my lovely dad at the end of 2022 and have been so much happier. They are amazing and have treated the anxiety and depression I have had since my teens.

However, they have made me put in 2 stone going from a size 12 to a 14/16. I just don’t hate myself enough to say no! I cook healthy meals every night but won’t say no to the odd treat. I have been eating a lot of takeaway as I had no kitchen for 9 months which probably made the situation worse and isn’t happening anymore so that might make a difference! I turned 40 this year and have certainly felt it!

Also my DH can’t keep his hands off me now. He says he loves my body and bigger boobs and is like a besotted teenager again!

I feel so embarrassed about the weight gain but do I work on accepting it, purge my wardrobe of too small clothes and accept happy, fat me. Find a new style and rebuild myself (I feel like the old me does with my dad) or restrict enough to lose the weight and fit into all my lovely clothes?

so AIBU to stay fat?

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 13/01/2024 08:34

I've just read your update, I'm really sorry that you're upset by the feedback. I think you expected us to celebrate your freedom from diets, and encourage you to embrace your new weight. But many of us are older and are/have experienced menopause. It can really pile on the weight, and make you feel ill. The healthier you approach it, the better. Your 3 stone gain can easily double, if you don't reign it in now. Believe me I know because I went through a similar journey myself. Restricting calories and fasting windows really do work long term, as they're not diets, you can eat what you want, but less of it. Make yourself as healthy as can be, and you'll have no problems later on. I wish you all the very best.

thegreenlight · 13/01/2024 08:13

Gosh - my self esteem has taken a beating now! I was feeling better about myself and taking things slowly but the unpleasant comments on here make me want to restrict and starve! Learnt my lesson - never talk about weight on AIBU!

For all the people who keep telling me I will die early I will repost this research which everyone ignored earlier:

Population studies give varying estimates for the BMI range linked with the lowest rates of death, with most suggesting the optimum weight is in the 25 to 30 band, for all ages. The strongest evidence that a higher BMI is preferable comes from studies of older adults.

I’m not upset because I didn’t get the answer I wanted, I’m upset by how much people are willing to ride rough-shod over other’s feelings to make their point.

Feeling pretty crappy about myself now but all advice taken on board.

OP posts:
disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 21:37

@Devilshands I've said the same - dress size is meaningless. But people on this thread are saying "I'm only a size 14, I can't possibly be an unhealthy weight" when, of course, they can be, because dress size is nonsense.

Anonymouseposter · 12/01/2024 21:32

Size 14/16 is very different on someone of 5’1 and someone of 5’10. I think OP is being sensible to focus on healthy eating and more movement rather than the cycle of strict dieting and then reverting to bingeing. It should lead to better health and happiness in the long run. Anecdotally my Mum and Auntie were both overweight but not obese ( would guess BMI of 28/29) They both lived into their mid 90s and were healthy until the last couple of years. Being slightly overweight isn’t going to inevitably lead to premature death.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 12/01/2024 21:29

thegreenlight · 12/01/2024 13:53

For all those telling me I am going to get heart disease and die prematurely you might want to read this:

In fact, population studies give varying estimates for the BMI range linked with the lowest rates of death, with most suggesting the optimum weight is in the 25 to 30 band, for all ages. The strongest evidence that a higher BMI is preferable comes from studies of older adults.

Thankyou to those being balanced and kind. I am finding it easy to maintain this weight compared to the constant starvation and skipping meals to stay 10.7.

also, loving myself enough to say no had me eating special K for breakfast when away with my boys instead of the lovely full
english on offer. Never eating treats without crippling self hatred.

I am going to try to mend my relationship with food. I will start yoga and swimming to move more and will concentrate on eating healthy foods - trying to aim for 1600 a day.

i will try to accept myself and take this journey slowly.

This is a good decision. Focus on healthy food - protein, vegetables, whole grains, dairy .

Exercise you enjoy .

Step away from this thread !

SoftPillowAllNight · 12/01/2024 21:18

OP - I've had a very similar journey recently. I'm the same height as you and yo-yoed between the same sizes forever!

As I approached 45 and peri hit, I realised I no longer had a choice to stay a higher weight. I started getting blood pressure spikes and a lot of fatigue. So I decided to focus not on BMI but height-to-waist ratio. Calorie deficit was needed but I started a very regular regimen of exercise while also increasing the protein focus in my meals. I did not calorie count but ate more sensibly. Over a year I lost 3 stone and got to the right ratio. It was still high BMI but just over 25 so I didn't worry about it. But - I felt really strong and fit and energetic while not having any rule books on what I'm supposed to eat/not.

It's not as much about dress size as it is about your age and stage in life. If you are healthy and fit you are better prepared for peri. Once that hits it's even harder to get in shape.

Hope this helps.

Bibbidybobbidyroo · 12/01/2024 21:11

the best thing you can do is work on why you think being fat is bad. It’s not ugly, or unattractive, or a moral failing, and accepting your body is a brilliant thing.
i would focus on doing some exercise or activity that you love, that makes you feel brilliant after, and focus on always pairing a snack with something nutritious so if you want to eat a packet of crisps also eat a yoghurt or sone fruit etc.
diets do not work. There’s no magic cure.

BishopLenBrennan · 12/01/2024 20:55

Sorry… that Response to@VyeBrator

BishopLenBrennan · 12/01/2024 20:54

And … I’m sure you’re an intelligent woman so you’ll realise what I said counters the oft-quoted narrative that most men prefer skinny women hence the multitude of girls and young women suffering mental health issues because they try to emulate the emaciated models frequenting the catwalk in recent times-I’m sure you don’t want to encourage that do you? Better to have and celebrate a healthy weight beit somewhat curvey?

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 20:34

As I caveated earlier - most size 14s/16 are overweight. You may or may not be. You may be sporty and still overweight (speaking as someone who used to go down this route - ate what I wanted and but because I exercised vigorously eg the Edinburgh marathon in a sub 4 hour, still a stone overweight - thought it didn’t count. It did. Had visceral fat measured and pulled head out of sand and realised that whilst cardiovascularly fit and able I was still overweight. And no, wasn’t muscle.. ). I do understand what strong means. I’ve spent the last 5 years decreasing my body fat to a decent level, sorting out fat around my organs, I now weight train 3/4 times a week and run half marathons (not full any more - too much of a time commitment) etc etc. but this is all off point.

MOST size 14s are over optional weight. This is scoffed at because the general population is skewed away from what is optiomal. If you are surrounded by people that are size 14/16/18 - you think this is the norm. It really isn’t. And lying to yourself that the excess weight in some way won’t impact you. As I’ve stressed - if you choose to ignore this and not make any changes, fine. But the health impacts will be down to your own actions. OP is nearly obese at 40. She’s increasing her risk of heart problems, stroke, cancer etc. She can accept this and carry on regardless or do something about it. It does no one any favours being “kind”; her size is too fat and she should weigh less to be healthy. What she does with that info is entirely her own business. She’s a grown woman.

AndThatWasNY · 12/01/2024 20:29

BrutusMcDogface · 12/01/2024 13:40

Yabu for saying that a size 14/16 is “fat”.

I'm a size 14 and I am most definitely fat. I have rolls on my stomach that most certainly isn't muscle!

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 20:16

disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 20:15

@Devilshands it's pretty clear that you are an outlier. And dress size is meaningless as you have just shown in your post as you wear three different sizes from three different shops.

Which is why people need to stop with this 'size 14 is fat' bullshit. Which has been my point through all my posts. Dress size means jack shit.

disappearingfish · 12/01/2024 20:15

@Devilshands it's pretty clear that you are an outlier. And dress size is meaningless as you have just shown in your post as you wear three different sizes from three different shops.

Floofydawg · 12/01/2024 20:14

Amen @Devilshands

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 20:08

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 18:40

@Devilshands - SaladBrigade?? No one is ripping anyone to shreds. Sorry if the truth is a difficult pill to swallow. Size 16 may be average but the average/‘normal’ weight is overweight. By shrugging your shoulders, dismissing BMI as a crock, claiming you are fine etc etc it really is just a case of denial. The link between being overweight and health issues is clear. Whether you choose to accept those risks is wholly up to you - you have agency in this is life. Doesn’t change the fact that high weight, visceral fat means dying earlier or average. Now do with that what you will b

I mean...I'm a size 14 on average, 16 in H&M (cos their sizes come up small as hell) and a 12 in Hobbs and I do Iron Man (the marathon is a killer tbh). And when I swam competitively, I was a similar size. So I'm probably a bit fitter than most of the people here in the UK and have been through most of my life.

I am far from overweight. And far from unhealthy. I am strong. I am sorry if that makes you uncomfortable. Women can be strong and athletic and not be sticks.

Just because some of the women on mumsnet like to starve themselves and sustain on 1,200 calories a day, or less, and partake in competitive eating doesn't make that normal.

You can be a size 14 and a size 16 and be completely healthy. Just because you don't want to believe that, doesn't mean it's not true.

Sausagesinthesky · 12/01/2024 18:40

@Devilshands - SaladBrigade?? No one is ripping anyone to shreds. Sorry if the truth is a difficult pill to swallow. Size 16 may be average but the average/‘normal’ weight is overweight. By shrugging your shoulders, dismissing BMI as a crock, claiming you are fine etc etc it really is just a case of denial. The link between being overweight and health issues is clear. Whether you choose to accept those risks is wholly up to you - you have agency in this is life. Doesn’t change the fact that high weight, visceral fat means dying earlier or average. Now do with that what you will b

Cherry35 · 12/01/2024 18:31

I would focus on eating healthier. If you let go at this weight, you will gain again due to the medicine and probably binging.

Could your GP swap you the medicine?

I get preventatives for migraines and some make you gain weight; however, there are other options to swap. Could you do the same safely?

I used keto to lose weight and now only do low carb eating go maintain. I'm not constantly dieting, just mindful of what I'm eating.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/01/2024 18:07

Op’s BMI is 29.6 so top end overweight category at age 40. It’s very easy to go into obese category which does potentially carry health issues especially as we age.
Personally I found it much easier to shift weight at 43 than my current age of 48. Perimenopause also causes weight gain on middle so if waist is already in risk category it’s better to address sooner rather than later.
It creeps up on you. At 40 friends are probably all ok even those overweight. On a 50th birthday weekend away it was obvious the impacts - couldn’t walk far, popping pills for back pain, some diabetic etc.

Makeupalley · 12/01/2024 17:46

If it were me I would focus on health rather than weight. You're clearly happy and that's fab! Maybe try hello fresh or similar to kick start some home cooking. Make some healthy swaps and maybe factor in a bit of walking. Then you can feel you can have the treats as you are having some balance - and losing weight is a bonus. I too have a history of disordered eating and used to write all my food down and occasionally make myself sick. So I do understand the pressure in your head to be slimmer. Tbh mine isn't gone, but I am trying to refocus to health as I get older, not just the number on the scales

5128gap · 12/01/2024 17:40

If you need a size 16 for your waist, then this will be considered a risk to health. However health is holistic. It sounds like maintaining a lower weight caused you stress, anxiety and interfered with your pleasure in life, which is not good for wellbeing and mental health. If you cant find a way to have a healthy weight and a healthy mind you need to choose the least worst option.

FrownedUpon · 12/01/2024 17:30

peakygold · 12/01/2024 16:15

So size 16 is fat now, is it? 😕

Yes, when wasn’t it fat?

FrownedUpon · 12/01/2024 17:28

Prelapsarianhag · 12/01/2024 13:52

Size 16 is the average for British women.

Yes, it’s also very unhealthy & not something to aim for or be happy with.

Poppybob · 12/01/2024 17:18

Do what makes you feel happy and healthy.....the older you get the harder it is to lose weight..I would concentrate on being healthy and not worry about your husband who should love you no matter your dress size. I do agree that men do like curvier women 🤣 as a thin/short woman who gets absolutely zero attention or compliments..(and had nasty comments) I've had lots of struggles with my body (which is in healthy bmi range) so honestly it's about how happy you are.

TempleOfBloom · 12/01/2024 17:11

OP: “I just don’t hate myself enough to say no! “

Whatever your weight snd whatever your goal, THIS is the sentence in your OP that stood out for me.

I have been in the same journey as you, size wise, but maintained (mostly) after losing 3 stone. And the only way I can do it is by eating healthily because I value myself. I see healthier eating as a positive habit, to nurture my body and enable it to work for me. Healthier eating is never (for me) about a punitive diet, restricting myself to misery, beating myself up or hating my body. It is about finding healthy foods I enjoy, and enjoying them in reasonable portions.

Can you frame healthier eating as celebrating yourself, as a positive thing?

I wonder about your DH’s response: might he also be responding to the new you lacking anxiety and depression? Nothing as sexy as a bit of a spark, relaxation or joi de vivre!

Out with the ‘diets’, in with savouring healthier foods.

Weight aside, we all function better in the long run on less sugar and fewer ultra processed foods.

Devilshands · 12/01/2024 17:03

VirtualRealitee · 12/01/2024 16:03

NO-ONE has said a size 14 is 'automatically fat'.

Rebecca is not an ex swimmer. She's an ex professional swimmer, who still swims.

The OP has said she's fat and she's very nearly into the obese range of BMI.

There will be other size 14s who are not.

I mean...you quoted my post where two people had said that size 14 was overweight and fat.

Ex-swimmer and professional swimmer is the same thing. I was an elite swimming who competed internationally. I refer to myself as an 'ex swimmer'

My point still stands.

Size 14 isn't necessarily fat and I think it's quite sad that the mumsnet massive salad brigade feel the need to rip perfectly normal women to shreds just to get their kicks online.