Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I will carry this guilt forever

120 replies

acloudofsadness · 12/01/2024 07:38

My FIL is going to die. It's been such a shock. we can't go and be with him for various reasons.

We are just waiting for the call.

In his final few months of his life he didn't see us or our children due to his mental health my DH decided he couldn't be around him. He was a lovely but difficult man. He had severe MH issues and it impacted our lives so much. We put up with a lot over the years.

I should have done more to make amends between my FIL and DH. I just respected DHs wishes and had no contact. I regret it so so much. I probably could have done more to get them to speak and make things better.

I have feelings that I don't deserve to be alive. I don't deserve to have my beautiful babies because I kept them from their kind grandad (what right did we have to do that). I feel worthless. I must be an evil person. I have thought that I might like to die too but I don't want to leave my children without a mother. I can't look at my babies without feeling an overwhelming wave of guilt.

Please someone tell me it gets easier because the guilt is like NOTHING I've ever experienced.

OP posts:
Dibilnik · 12/01/2024 10:18

If you wanted to say your own personal goodbye to him, without involving anyone else, can you phone him up, or is that impossible?

acloudofsadness · 12/01/2024 10:16

Wow there is so much amazing advice and support here. I really can't even thank you enough. It's really made me pull myself together today.

I definitely do need a break. 3 children under 4 has not been easy and I was already exhausted before this happened. Now my DH is understandably distracted and grieving in his own way so I'm trying to do everything myself.

It certainly does feel like it could be a bit hormonal as well. The excessive crying is annoying me but it's like I've started and now I can't stop.

OP posts:
horseyhorsey17 · 12/01/2024 10:15

OP - I have medication for depression and anxiety and I was really scared to take it for a number of reasons - afraid I'd be a zombie, afraid it wouldn't work, afraid I was somehow 'failing' as a human and mother - but it's been incredible, it has made me feels SO much better and none of those fears have come to pass. I'd also had them before and they hadn't worked, but a different brand this time has been a completely different experience. Don't be scared of doing what it takes to get well, especially if you're experiencing suicidal ideation.

Duh · 12/01/2024 10:14

OP you sound frazzled, knackered and possibly unwell. I think you have lost perspective and am therefore glad you have called the GP.

If the roles were reversed you wouldn’t want your DH to feel this way, you’d be horrified he was beating himself up so much and be reassuring him that he has not let anyone down.

You can’t make the situation with DH’s father’s health better but you can focus on your own mental health to make sure you can support your DH and your children when they will need you most when the time comes.

Try to make improving your own mental health your absolute aim and objective as that is what will help your family need most.

Write this goal down every morning and before you go to bed so you don’t lose perspective again. Work with your GP and strive to be well for your family.

Ulysees · 12/01/2024 10:13

I don't think some people can grasp that ILS can be as close or even closer than our own parents.

Yes OP needs help but it doesn't diminish her love.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 12/01/2024 10:13

I understand you dont want medication therefore dont see the point in a GP appointment but they can signpost other support.

I dont want to scare you but I refused to see a GP and didnt want medication and 5 years later I am still paying the price.

Yes, you can get by without medication but it makes things worse and not better.

Mental health issues after birth are real. They arent weakness or all in your head.

I can 100% tell you that a few years of meds and some decent mental health support like talking therapy would have gotten me to a better place a lot faster.

I kept having weeks of things being good and the I'd relapse to negative thought patterns and after 5 years all I can say is I've managed the problem and identified my triggers, like a lack of sleep. After 5 years I dont endorse avoidance and wish I'd been a better advocate for myself.

Dont kid yourself that it will go away.

YouveGotAFastCar · 12/01/2024 10:08

Oh OP.

Your DH gets to make the decision about being in contact with his parents. It wasn't your place to push or pressurise him. You did the right thing supporting him.

My DH is very LC with his parents at the moment. He's seen them twice in two years, once voluntarily. He doesn't call them or message them. Part of the reason for this is how they behave towards me and his son, but I didn't make the decision for him. I do sometimes worry that when they die, he'll feel resentment towards me, but it is his decision and it wouldn't be supportive or right of me to force him to see them to alleviate potential guilt on my part.

The same is true for your situation. Your DH decided to have NC. He decided it was the best decision for you as a family. Nothing you've said suggests he's said or behaved as if he regrets that decision, or would change it now.

Your response is therefore misguided. In the nicest way, it's over the top. This isn't your guilt to hold, or your relative that is dying. Your role here is to support your DH, who is losing his Dad and had a complex relationship with him. You can't do that if you're drowning in your own feelings.

Talking to your GP is a good idea. You also might want to ground yourself by reminding yourself of where your loyalties and responsibilities are. Your DH and children; not your FIL.

NoraZ · 12/01/2024 10:05

Ulysees · 12/01/2024 10:02

How is op being unreasonable? Yes it's disproportionate but op is coping with a lot. But she loves this man. I loved pils as much as my own DM.

She is being unreasonable by taking full responsibility for the relationship between FIL and her DH upon herself. It was never her responsibility and it's unreasonable to think it was. The responsibility was theirs and theirs alone.

Ulysees · 12/01/2024 10:02

NoraZ · 12/01/2024 09:59

I think you're being very unreasonable about this. Your DH and FIL's relationship was their responsibility to work out. How is it your responsibility at all?

My DH's father died when he hadn't spoken to him for years. It's sad but it doesn't mean it wasn't the right decision. I did try to help things but, in the end, had to let go and decide that their relationship (or lack of) was their concern, not mine.

This is going to be a complicated loss for your DH and your job is to support him through that.

How is op being unreasonable? Yes it's disproportionate but op is coping with a lot. But she loves this man. I loved pils as much as my own DM.

Username123343 · 12/01/2024 10:00

CatherinedeBourgh · 12/01/2024 08:28

OK, you said you need a bit of tough love so here it goes:

Your guilt is a sign of extreme egocentrism. You think you have the power to control everything in the world and so if something goes wrong it is your fault. You need to change your mindset.

The vast majority of everything that happens, including in your immediate circle, is not your responsibility. Your responsibility is limited to doing right by your dc. Right now, you are not doing that.

By feeling guilt, you are making this all about yourself, whereas you are the last person it should be about. You need to let go your guilt, and ideally most of your grief, in order to be able to support your dc and your dh the way it actually is your job, as a parent and partner.

On a softer note, it's really hard when you have the hormones of having a newborn. I suspect that they enhance the feelings of responsibility (and guilt), as they are evolved to do, in order to protect that incredibly vulnerable human being you have just given birth to (and that you are absolutely responsible for). They are just getting misdirected in this situation, and it's going to take a huge effort to override the emotions. Don't hesitate to seek professional help if you need it.

This is brilliant.

It’s not your fault.

Ulysees · 12/01/2024 10:00

It's good you're getting help.

I agree with talking to your HV. There used to be schemes where nursery nurse students would help new mothers as part of a placement. Would something like that help take some strain? You sound like you have too much to cope with and are overwhelmed.

Your hormones are bound to be affecting your emotions. They run everything in our bodies.

NoraZ · 12/01/2024 09:59

I think you're being very unreasonable about this. Your DH and FIL's relationship was their responsibility to work out. How is it your responsibility at all?

My DH's father died when he hadn't spoken to him for years. It's sad but it doesn't mean it wasn't the right decision. I did try to help things but, in the end, had to let go and decide that their relationship (or lack of) was their concern, not mine.

This is going to be a complicated loss for your DH and your job is to support him through that.

Newchapterbeckons · 12/01/2024 09:57

Please call 116 123 if you start to feel worse/suicidal.

We are here op. Many of us where you are right now.

infor · 12/01/2024 09:55

@acloudofsadness As someone who has had their compassion abused by a dying relative, I would say that a relationship is only possible if both sides are willing and able to accommodate each other.
Our lives were put on hold for almost a decade by a scheming FIL who was lying to everyone including himself. His self-centred nature enabled him to obtain a wide range of drugs he didn't need and a lot of end of life care that wasn't needed - he had Macmillan nurses for 5 years and there was no sign of the supposed cancer when he finally died of something else.
We had made him the focus of our lives, destroyed a lot of opportunities for his GC - all in order that we hoped we wouldn't feel guilty for falling short. We went above and beyond in myriad ways and yet still felt guilty.
Why? Because compassionate people will always give and others will always take. Think of your children, if your FIL was a loving, caring person with his full faculties, would he want attention for himself or those little ones?
Cut yourself some slack, hug them and let his blood relatives deal with things.

Newchapterbeckons · 12/01/2024 09:54

It’s not your choice to make op. Your poor dh has struggled with his own father and mental illness. He has already grieved the loss of a parent years ago in many ways. This might even come as a relief to him. It’s torturous having a parent but not having one in any meaningful way.

You sound very ill. Probably PND you urgently need some support. Can you also call the HV as well? This is not about your FIL op, and my heart is going out to you. You will be okay - but urgently need to be seen. Thank you for posting - we are here so just keep posting

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/01/2024 09:53

This is really not normal. You need to see a GP.

My husband's mother died about 20 years ago now. He had been none contact for at least 5 years at this point. I tried to get him to visit her in hospital before she passed, but he wouldn't.

Other posters are right, this isn't about you. It's nothing to do with you. This was your husband's father and you're drowning in feelings of guilt?

Please call your GP. They don't care if you take all the children in with you. But you need to speak to someone.

mrmagpie · 12/01/2024 09:51

EdinGirl · 12/01/2024 08:03

This is quite a strange response and I am not saying this to be unkind.

I just want you to more realise that most people wouldn't feel guilt in this situation because you have done absolutely nothing wrong.

I was NC with my father and he died.
I was NC for good reasons and wanted to keep me and my family emotionally safe (which it sounds like your DH wanted too).

I MASSIVELY resented the people who interfered and guilted me and put pressure on me to get in contact with him. I had made the right decision for me and it's not up to anyone else to "fix things" or interfere or repair anything.

You don't have any responsibility in this situation because to be quite honest, it isn't really your business...

Take a deep breath and relax. It sounds like you really care which is lovely but I would focus now on supporting your DH in what HE wants, not what you THINK is best.
You also need to focus on YOU and what you need right now because it sounds like this situation is just bringing other issues to the surface and you need some support too💗

This.

I'm NC with both my parents and they will die while this situation continues. My three children have never met them and never will.

I don't feel any guilt about any of this, and believe myself to be a half decent parent too. Kindly what you are feeling is irrational and obviously the emotions are very heightened just now, but I genuinely feel like this might be PND in disguise.

Calmdown14 · 12/01/2024 09:51

I think if he's abroad and getting there is complicated then not being there at the end is really to be expected. Not everyone gets this chance regardless of how close the relationship is.

Given the distance he was never going to be a grandfather to your kids in the sense you are carrying guilt for, nice were you ever going to be able to be a part of his life in the way you have conjured up.

Added to that all the other issues then there really wasn't any other outcome.

Look after yourself now. Your husband needs you and you haven't caused this. You can feel guilty but it won't change anything other than to make you and your family miserable. You need help to let it go

ArabellaScott · 12/01/2024 09:50

Also - worth looking into 'complex grief'.

WandaWonder · 12/01/2024 09:48

Your husband is entitled to decide his relationship with his father, don't make this about you

horseyhorsey17 · 12/01/2024 09:47

I lost my father in 2022 and also had a very complex relationship with him - he was a difficult man with mental health issues, too. Last year was a funny old year and I found myself struggling with my own mental health too - but tbh I had a lot more going on as had also recently separated from husband. I do think your grief sounds disproportionate, especially given that he's not a close relative, and it does sound like there could be something else going on - PND perhaps. You definitely need to see a doctor and you can self-refer for counselling too, which is something you can do. Your doctor will be able to tell you more about that.

Time is a great healer and remember, this too shall pass. You won't feel like this forever.

LimePi · 12/01/2024 09:45

It’s not your responsibility and not your guilt, your reaction is irrational and over the top which means that either you are depressed or projecting some other issues onto this situation

ArabellaScott · 12/01/2024 09:45

Agree with all the other posters suggesting you get in touch with your GP or local health service. Whether or not it's PND, post childbirth our hormones can be in my experience a real rollercoaster. We need extra care and support at this time, please seek this out for yourself as a priority.

You prioritising your babies is absolutely logical.

Sending you well wishes. Be extra gentle with yourself. Flowers

RaisingAnOnlyChild · 12/01/2024 09:45

@unbelievablescenes you are not blowing his life up. He has done it himself. It is his fault not yours