Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare when both high earners

217 replies

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 04:36

My partner today gave me shit because I haven’t got our son vaccinated against chicken pox. I suggested that it’s not impossible for him to take the day off and organise it either to which he replied he didn’t know how or where?
Neither did I until I researched it!
turns out im “better at that sort of thing”
I suggested ok, fuck it, I’ll quit my £170k a year job and then happy to cover all childcare requirements. AIBU to suggest all childcare should be 50/50 if earnings are the same?

OP posts:
Newhere5 · 12/01/2024 06:50

All I’m interested in is what role at 170k doesn’t require people skills delegation or management?..

Dotchange · 12/01/2024 06:50

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 05:56

@InAFightWithGod but if you work equal hours than this is a no brainier

So, OP are you saying that if one partner earns less on the same hours, they should do more around the house?

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:49

@backinthebox ”f Parent A earns 100k for their 30 hr a week job and Parent B earns 60k for their 45 hr a week job” …..ok but you’re not comparing like with like.
parent a and parent b both earn the same, work same hours, have same flexibility.

OP posts:
Truthseeker456 · 12/01/2024 06:49

Don't know anyone where the roles are 50/50 post children. Does tend to be the mum particularly around health care and school !

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:48

For example there is no point getting my SILs to do the kids eye appointments as my brothers know more about it due to them being the glasses wearers.

😂

VenhamousSnake · 12/01/2024 06:48

Plumberdrain

There are loads. Im guessing op is a technical expert of some kind and basically paid a lot for being really fucking clever/fast to learn/produces a lot of high quality output.

NoKateMoss · 12/01/2024 06:48

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:07

If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments

No. It doesn't make sense. The lower earner still has obligations and commitments. You know that by saying this you are buying into the premise that women's jobs are less important than men's since they generally earn less. As others have repeatedly said, it's down to hours, not pay. Often high earners have more flexibility, not less.

Reugny · 12/01/2024 06:47

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 06:44

All things medical, dental appointments, organising holiday care etc men will claim they aren’t good at and don’t think to book etc. They consider it the woman’s job.

That's where you point out -- well in my SILs and my case - who has the more flexible hours/employer and who has more knowledge on a particular issue.

For example there is no point getting my SILs to do the kids eye appointments as my brothers know more about it due to them being the glasses wearers.

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 06:47

She is evidently spotting an interesting sign of how a woman in a couple might slide into that default parent role if things like this aren’t challenged. It’s worth an argument!

Yes, but instead of wanting to share things equally, she thinks she should do less because she earns more. That’s as wrong as her husband trying to get out of things child related by saying OP is better at them.

Both OP and her husband have weird thoughts on this issue.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:46

i am fascinated by this £170k role a year that involves

no delegation
no management
no negotiation

GreatGateauxsby · 12/01/2024 06:45

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 06:44

All things medical, dental appointments, organising holiday care etc men will claim they aren’t good at and don’t think to book etc. They consider it the woman’s job.

Yep. Agreed.

my DH has learned to get good but it took a few conversations.

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:45

@User5512 difficult colleagues I generally just stop working with.
My initial issue here, was with all being equal (salary, hours, wfh) was just simply a rant about being expected to do the traditional women’s work, take the time off for appointments by default etc

OP posts:
plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:45

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:20

@User5512 if my partner was to earn 4 times my salary yes I would probably take on more of the life admin that required an impact on working hours as obviously it would be less detrimental to our lifestyle if the lower earner was to lose their job

most very high earning jobs have a lot more flexibility during the day than much lower earners

VenhamousSnake · 12/01/2024 06:45

Salary does matter.

What i find tends to happen with one higher earner and one much lower, is that higher earner would rather take the (smaller) financial hit of lower earner reducing hours, than step up and put in 50% of the work. So it depends if lower earner is happy if that's the outcome.

Dh and i are two high earners. Whenever he sacks off and im doing too much of the load, i simply suggest I'll drop a day or two at work to make time for doing a bigger share of chores at home, and the family budget will lose 30-60k. DH will do his share if it means me bringing in that, i don't think he would if i earned a lot less and the loss in income from my working less was lower.

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 06:44

All things medical, dental appointments, organising holiday care etc men will claim they aren’t good at and don’t think to book etc. They consider it the woman’s job.

KinS24 · 12/01/2024 06:44

I don’t why the OP is being attacked here. She hasn’t said she would actually leave her job to make a point or that lower earners can just do everything because their job is unimportant.
Higher paid jobs have some correlation with more stress and responsibility and may need to be prioritised in a family where both parents working ft proves difficult.
She is evidently spotting an interesting sign of how a woman in a couple might slide into that default parent role if things like this aren’t challenged. It’s worth an argument!

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:43

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 05:56

@InAFightWithGod but if you work equal hours than this is a no brainier

so if two people work same hours but one person earns more… the fact that one person earns more they should take on less childcare?

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 12/01/2024 06:43

Ohnoooooooo · 12/01/2024 06:34

Just hire someone to do the life admin for you

Absolutely agree with this tbh.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:41

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 05:42

@User5512 well I don’t manage people, delegate or negotiate in my role.
is it such a small issue when more and more comes your way as “the woman”
I don’t think anyone on a lower salary should suck it up. However I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more if you’re working together as a team

However I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more if you’re working together as a team

it’s not about earning
it is about time ie you seem to think the higher earner should take on less simply. by y virtue of earning more but what if the lower earner works more hours?

dancinginthewind · 12/01/2024 06:41

You have to look at something like this in the round. As it happens, I do more of the sorting things out around the children & DH does things like plan & book holidays (the extent of my knowledge often is simply that we're going skiing) and other "projects" like that. It works for us as my job is usually more consistent in terms of hours whereas his has more peaks & troughs.
We do, though, both have full authority in our areas. If it was a vaccination issue, I would mention it to DH but he would rely on me to have researched it in the same way that I rely on him to have researched a holiday or car or similar.

User5512 · 12/01/2024 06:41

Cyclingagain · 12/01/2024 06:37

It would impact the lower earner more if you divorced though. They need their job.

Their job is as important to them in all the ways yours is to you.

Telling someone you regard their job as less important, for whatever reason, throws a pretty large bomb into your relationship.

You have not made a clever argument. You have shown you have a pretty low understanding on how relationships work.

THIS 🏆

backinthebox · 12/01/2024 06:41

However I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more if you’re working together as a team

I am also baffled as to how you think this statement makes sense or is in any way fair. What you are basically saying is that if Parent A earns 100k for their 30 hr a week job and Parent B earns 60k for their 45 hr a week job, it makes sense to you that Parent B takes on more work! Which is shit for Parent B. It’s a pretty entitled way of thinking.

If you are truly working together as a team, you sit down and work out who is going to do what. Even if that discussion means you are going to book in vaccinations and he is going to take out the bins - and once you have established who ‘owns’ which job you don’t nag, interfere or query unless the other partner seems to be struggling then you ask if they need help. But if you are working equal hours in your jobs, you should be putting equal hours into running the household and childcare responsibilities. If you are bothered by doing all the child-related jobs, offer to do all the non-child jobs such as putting the bins out, managing household finances, DIY tasks, etc.

In our household I do do all the child related tasks (yes, even on my highly paying job, the horror!) but I have no idea which electricity company we are with, don’t get involved in ensuring we are on the best mortgage deal, never put the bins out, and haven’t touched an iron in decades. DH has no idea how the kids got into school or where their uniforms come from, has never taken them to the hairdressers or dentist, and so on. What does make sense is for someone in the household to be responsible for each task and to ensure that task is done properly. It would be madness for both of you to waste energy and time on both becoming familiar with the same task.

Btw I am curious to know what area you work in where you need no apparent people skills at all. I work with just one other person in a locked box 6 miles above the ground and I need people skills more than you might ever imagine!

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/01/2024 06:40

@User5512 if my partner was to earn 4 times my salary yes I would probably take on more of the life admin that required an impact on working hours as obviously it would be less detrimental to our lifestyle if the lower earner was to lose their job

But you’ve said you’re both high earners, so that argument doesn’t really fly. Besides which the “I earn more so let’s focus on my career, cos if I lose my job…” has kept men in strong careers while women take pin money jobs because he earns more. Both people in a couple should take an equal hit on their careers and have equal opportunity to progress which means sacrifice for both.

If you’re both high earners are you really going to lose your job because you took time to get your child vaccinated?

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 06:40

If you want your child to be vaccinated, one of you sorts it. Then next time something comes up, the other takes their turn. Overall, things should be shared if you’re working equal hours.

I think you need to sort your relationship issues out. You should be working together and you’re not. He needs to stop thinking of you as the default parent but you need to realise that a high salary doesn’t mean doing less towards home snd childcare. You’ll end up with a bad relationship, with a child that only goes to the ‘default’ parent and a lot of resentment towards each other.

GreatGateauxsby · 12/01/2024 06:40

Ahhh the chicken pox vaccine….

My DH and i actually had the chicken pox fight too 😅
I booked the app for him to get the ball rolling and it then wasn’t convenient due to a client meeting so I left it with him to organise.
it was a bit of a shag and he took public transport (against my advice) which was carnage 😅but he got there in the end… fyi boots do Saturday apps for chicken pox.

My DH also used to go on about “doing things together” for our dd.
No. Just no.
we have clear swim lanes now. This works better and is a fairer way to work imo.

for example he is responsible for teeth in totality
this is everything dental ever (buying the correct stupid brushes and paste, the appointments and doing the actual brushing)
I will sub in if he is away but otherwise it’s 100% on him.

remember schitts creek GIF by CBC
Swipe left for the next trending thread