Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare when both high earners

217 replies

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 04:36

My partner today gave me shit because I haven’t got our son vaccinated against chicken pox. I suggested that it’s not impossible for him to take the day off and organise it either to which he replied he didn’t know how or where?
Neither did I until I researched it!
turns out im “better at that sort of thing”
I suggested ok, fuck it, I’ll quit my £170k a year job and then happy to cover all childcare requirements. AIBU to suggest all childcare should be 50/50 if earnings are the same?

OP posts:
plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:16

You have sent your own thread off on a complete irrelevant tangent to your situation!

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:15

Oh and I earn more than DP, but my job is more flexible precisely because I'm the higher earner. It comes with more freedom and autonomy to choose my own hours. Therefore I'd take these things on at home more than DP does purely because it's easier with the greater flexibility I have in my job.

I agree that amounts on paper are irrelevant and I don't know why that's been brought into it.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:15

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:08

@plumberdrain leave the thread then? I stated my opinion on significant salary differences and how I believe it would influence my life.

no - it’s basically been the entire thread

when in actual fact you earn the same.

presumably nanny? so why not delegate?!

Plumtop11 · 12/01/2024 07:15

I totally get where you're frustrated but have you thought about just splitting the different roles for childcare to make it clearer and easier on you both.

So if you've researched and looked at the pro's and cons of a situation and decide to book it, why does he have to spend time researching it too? He could just trust you to make informed decisions and same for him and his responsibilities for childcare. We do that as things can get overwhelming. So for instance, my husband is in charge of swimming lessons and beavers. Anything to do with either is up to him. I'm in charge if packed lunches, food shopping, medical etc.

If you're both limited on time this may make things easier.

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 07:14

OP, you’ve confused your own thread! You earn the same and he’s treating you as default parent. That’s not ok. Put a stop to it now.

But, saying that if a parent worked the same or more hours, but earned less, that they should make up for that by doing more childcare or life admin, is madness.

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:14

@lunarleap

Oh I totally agree! But so is having two parents squabbling over taking him/ her to an appointment 🤷‍♀️ So I was thinking of other options since they're a wealthy family.

I wouldn't have got into any of this back and forth tbh, I'd just take my child. But that's me.

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:13

@backinthebox so because I didn’t mention equal hours you assumed unequal hours? It’s a pretty bold yet useless move

OP posts:
Heatherbell1978 · 12/01/2024 07:12

I'm not sure what earnings have to do with this to be honest. The issue here, and it's a well trodden path, is women taking on the mental load that men just don't. I'd consider DH and I to be high-earners although not in MN terms (combined income around the same as OPs). DH takes on his fair share of child related tasks like school runs, time off sick etc but things like making appointments fall to me. I have given up on things like that if I'm honest but I refuse to do practical things that he is perfectly capable of doing. I'm currently sitting in bed drinking tea while he sorts kids for school for example. Seems to work.

Vallmo47 · 12/01/2024 07:12

I guess the reason why you’re getting so many comments is because you mentioned high earners and salary OP- I tend to agree it was unnecessary, you could have left it at “similar wages”. I also think it’s more relevant if you both work exactly the same amount of hours per week- similar earnings but whoever works a bit less takes on a little bit more childcare obviously. That’s how I’d see it. My husband and I both work, I’m in charge of morning routines and he evenings. On his days off (he has one more day off than me) I do ask him to do shopping/do washing etc if it hasn’t been done, seeing as he’s at home and I’m not. I guess you just have to come to a compromise you’re both happy with- taking turns on medical appointments/ parents evenings/ looking after sick child and things like that.
I do hate the excuse “you’re just better at it” whenever anyone says it - that’s the perfect reason for them to take over, there’s clearly a learning gap they need to learn to fill in case something was ever to happen to you.

I can understand your opinion that if one earns significantly less than the other, it makes sense for that person takes on more childcare duties BUT ONLY in the sense that it would be much more financially difficult if the higher earner lost their wages through not being available at work. In any other sense, no I’m sorry, if you need both salaries you are equals and no one should be made to feel what they do in life makes them less important. I think it’s still a much safer option to try to make it a more even share - so that it doesn’t cause marital problems.
So it’s much less about salary than it is about being equal and treating each other with respect.

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:11

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/01/2024 06:53

parent a and parent b both earn the same, work same hours, have same flexibility.

You’ve just spent 4 pages going on about higher/lower earners - at one point it was one earning 4x the other. If all things work wise are equal, the work at home gets split 50:50, but honestly I’d just get the child vaccinated.

Or.... on a joint household income of 340k, pay someone else to do it? 🤷‍♀️

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/01/2024 07:10

@Fedupandconfused0815 i can’t say for sure as it’s not a situation I’ve been in, but yes, I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other this would be my stand.

You can’t see how this stance often disadvantages women? She’s on maternity leave so childcare tasks fall to her, then she returns to work - possibly part time because she earns less and it’s not worth the childcare costs. She earns less so she picks up childcare related tasks, she doesn’t go for promotion because it would impact her being able to do school drop offs, medical appointments etc. So her career takes a hit while he continues his Very Well Paid Job. And reinforces that because she earns less she needs to do more of the childcare tasks. And now she’s “better” at it because he never does it. Ad Infinitum.

Heather37231 · 12/01/2024 07:10

Surely the issue here is less about who does what and more about the fact that when the husband realised the child had not had the chicken pox vax he “gave [OP] shit”?

Any sensible couple would have a chat long the lines of “Has DS been vaccinated? No? Oops we’d better sort that out then. Have you got time to investigate, or shall I look into it?”. No blame slinging about something where they had clearly never agreed respective responsibilities and definitely no assumption it is the wife’s job. The husband sounds like an arse.

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 07:10

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:08

If you're both mega high earners can you not pay a nanny or someone to take your child to appointments? Just a thought

Bit shit for the children

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 07:09

I think planned time off should be split 50/50 regardless

Emergancy/last minute leave should be as close to 50/50 as it can get taking into account that one person's job might be to stop other people dying or be more important for them to be in at exam season or tax year end.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 12/01/2024 07:09

Researching it is your share so acting on it is his share

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:09

@Azandme no I’ve already stated previously all things are comparable re hours and flexibility

OP posts:
tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:09

*It would impact the lower earner more if you divorced though. They need their job.

Their job is as important to them in all the ways yours is to you.

Telling someone you regard their job as less important, for whatever reason, throws a pretty large bomb into your relationship.

You have not made a clever argument. You have shown you have a pretty low understanding on how relationships work.*

👆🏻 THIS!

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:08

If you're both mega high earners can you not pay a nanny or someone to take your child to appointments? Just a thought

backinthebox · 12/01/2024 07:08

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:49

@backinthebox ”f Parent A earns 100k for their 30 hr a week job and Parent B earns 60k for their 45 hr a week job” …..ok but you’re not comparing like with like.
parent a and parent b both earn the same, work same hours, have same flexibility.

No, you can’t go on and on about the parent earning more should do less work and then come out with this statement. Earlier on you were insistent that the person who earns more should do less with no mention of hours, and I used random numbers to show the weakness in your argument. If both parents work equal numbers of hours, then both parents should put equal hours and effort into the running of the household and childcare. How you spilt those tasks is between you and your DH. However, you made no mention of equal hours initially, you talked about who earned more. I think you are confused.

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:08

@plumberdrain leave the thread then? I stated my opinion on significant salary differences and how I believe it would influence my life.

OP posts:
tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:07

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 06:26

I think OP might be on the wind up, either that or they have a fucked up thought process...that working the same hours as a partner, you get to do less at home if you happen to be better paid. It’s a terrible attitude imo.

Agreed!

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:06

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:07

If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments

Erm, why?
How disrespectful to the lower earner 😲

Azandme · 12/01/2024 07:06

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 05:42

@User5512 well I don’t manage people, delegate or negotiate in my role.
is it such a small issue when more and more comes your way as “the woman”
I don’t think anyone on a lower salary should suck it up. However I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more if you’re working together as a team

".. it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more..."

And this is why YABU.

It's not about earnings. At all. It's about time. If two people work similar hours, then the parenting load should be similarly shared.

I earn less than my DP, but I'm in a higher level role, work more hours, and have significantly more responsibility (I'm education sector, he's a software engineer) - by your argument I should pick up more of our home life and child management because he earns more than me.

He starts work at 10.30am, at home, finishes by 6.30pm, and has an hour lunch break. I leave for work between 7 and 8.30am, and finish usually by 6pm - but often 7.30pm and then drive home. And I have lunch on the fly.

He earns more, but also does more, because he also has more time.

Earnings are absolutely nothing to do with contributions at home - an hour of your time isn't worth more at home, just because it is at work 🙄.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:05

@stcrispinsday

My husband took our kids for all of their jabs. I did all of the school and nursery open days. We divide and conquer.

you got lucky!

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:04

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:03

@plumberdrain yes poor child. Both parents earn the same, I don’t see myself as superior whatsoever and in fact asking for equality

so how come you have spent most of the thread waffling about about lower earners responsibilities versus higher earner?

Swipe left for the next trending thread