Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childcare when both high earners

217 replies

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 04:36

My partner today gave me shit because I haven’t got our son vaccinated against chicken pox. I suggested that it’s not impossible for him to take the day off and organise it either to which he replied he didn’t know how or where?
Neither did I until I researched it!
turns out im “better at that sort of thing”
I suggested ok, fuck it, I’ll quit my £170k a year job and then happy to cover all childcare requirements. AIBU to suggest all childcare should be 50/50 if earnings are the same?

OP posts:
SavBlancTonight · 12/01/2024 07:52

This thread had been derailed by the salary issue. Ultimately OP, no matter what the salary differential is, you are completely reasonable to be annoyed that you are the default parent and that, to make.matters worse, he expects to havr final decision making without any of the actual work.

Dh and I have had similar arguments in the past where he would choose to absent himself from the pre decision making, research phase, but then would be annoyed because he wants x or y without any idea of how practical that is. He is much better now, bit it took a few arguments before he a) stepped up and b) realised he couldn't zoom in at the end and tell me what should happen.

joyfulnessss · 12/01/2024 07:50

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:20

@User5512 if my partner was to earn 4 times my salary yes I would probably take on more of the life admin that required an impact on working hours as obviously it would be less detrimental to our lifestyle if the lower earner was to lose their job

Then the conversation should be about whether the lower paid one should go part time. Not just dump more and more on them because they earn less.

ElaineMBenes · 12/01/2024 07:50

However, your partner is out of order by expecting you to pick up all the child related things.

joyfulnessss · 12/01/2024 07:49

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:17

@User5512 bloody hell, you probably do earn significantly more than me because you chat the same shit my managers do.
I don’t define myself by my salary, im sorry you’ve got so caught up on that particular detail and don’t seem to be able to move on.
Why are you now comparing a role with wfh to one on site?

Because you stated the one who earns less/more. You didn't specify hours or work location. It was a ridiculous statement. A nurse earns far less than a CFO of an investment bank but the CFO is in a much better position to make calls and book things without losing their job.

If both people are working full time and both people want this, then the one who would take on more responsibility for home life assuming they can't do it equally, is the one whose role allows them to. Lot based on earnings alone.

Your suggestion is the lower paid one should take on MORE hours of work (domestic work) than the other one to make up for the lower income. So you mean the lower paid one owes the higher paid one. This is a very unhealthy dynamic.

Cyclingagain · 12/01/2024 07:48

Higher paid jobs have some correlation with more stress and responsibility

This is not necessarily true at all. Research in the civil service showed that higher managers were LESS stressed than their staff. The higher managers were outraged at this, but there we go.

Other research has showed that the more autonomous people feel (are) in their jobs, the less stressed and more satisfied they are.

The lower down the hierarchy you are, the less autonomy and control you usually have, hence more stress. The higher up, usually more autonomy.

Obviously, this is a general rule of thumb, but the principle stands. Being a lower earner should not be assumed to be less stress at all.

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:47

In fact I could argue that the higher paid you are average more flexibility you have. A checkout worker can't use any of their work hours to do or organise things. A CEO can.

Yep. This is why I have more scope for home life stuff than DP. He has to be physically on site to do his job between certain times. I don't, I can WFH/ any site and flex my hours too. That flexibility comes partly because of my higher salary. So I take on more at home when it's needed.

ElaineMBenes · 12/01/2024 07:47

If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments

No. It's more nuanced than that. It depends on the nature of the job and particular commitments. DH earns more than me but has far more flexibility generally as I'm an academic with teaching commitments. Therefore if I'm teaching then he needs to take the time off.

Charlie2121 · 12/01/2024 07:47

DH and I both earn 6 figure salaries. We would never want a nanny as I’d feel
that would encroach into our private family space neither of us would want.

As for tasks relating to DC who is currently 2 well I guess we informally split them the best we can.

It helps if you are good or learn to be good at different things.

I do the online shopping order whereas DH spends a lot more time researching potential schools for example.

I sort out all DC’s clothing whereas DH takes him swimming every week.

We do of course do many things together but definitely make an effort to split fairly those that we don’t.

The chickenpox vaccine was a new one to us as well. We booked it in at our local Boots store and it was minimal effort to get sorted. Your DC will need 2 doses so perhaps agree to go and do 1 each.

Cosyblankets · 12/01/2024 07:46

How is the salary relevant? You both work ft so what difference does it make?

lorien9 · 12/01/2024 07:46

'If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments'

Not sure why this statement is getting so much criticism. In almost all jobs there is a margin of discretionary time and mental energy. Certainly if a couple's joint ambition is to simply maximise earnings, it makes sense to give the higher earner that margin. Much easier to get your pay from 170 to 350 than from 0 to 170.

joyfulnessss · 12/01/2024 07:43

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 05:42

@User5512 well I don’t manage people, delegate or negotiate in my role.
is it such a small issue when more and more comes your way as “the woman”
I don’t think anyone on a lower salary should suck it up. However I would think if one partner earns significantly more than the other it would make sense for the lower earner to have to take on a bit more if you’re working together as a team

There are only a certain number of hours in a day. No matter how much each partner earns they should split childcare if both work full time. In fact I could argue that the higher paid you are average more flexibility you have. A checkout worker can't use any of their work hours to do or organise things. A CEO can.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:43

Ddifficultday · 12/01/2024 07:40

She earns the same.... Read the OP

where in the op does it say they earn the same? 😐

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:41

Ddifficultday · 12/01/2024 07:40

She earns the same.... Read the OP

90% of her follow posts are about earning disparity between couples!

Ddifficultday · 12/01/2024 07:40

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:00

poor child won’t get chicken pox but stuck with these two, and a mother that i suspect constantly throws at their father how superior she is because she earns 4x what he does

She earns the same.... Read the OP

user1492757084 · 12/01/2024 07:35

You sound hostile, Ops.
You both should be able to make plans of how to delegate important child care tasks.
Are you better at remembering which shots are due? If you are you should inform DH - don't leave him ignorant.

Allocate him some appointments, show him where the information is gathered and decide to leave the health details about your child in a mutually accessable place.

The person with the most time would be ideally placed to take DC to medical appointments.
Your earnings matter not, though with both of you seemingly resentful about taking time off work to care for DC and with your household income being high, hiring a nanny could be beneficial to DC.

tryingeverydayagain · 12/01/2024 07:33

Sodndashitall · 12/01/2024 07:31

I don't know what childcare arrangements you have but when my kids were young we had an amazing nanny/housekeeper as we were both high earners. My nanny would book stuff, take kids to routine appointments, make food, do laundry etc. It was a real godsend and enable both of us to maintain busy jobs and not spend all weekend doing life admin
I agree though that DP should pull his weight on all this stuff !

And this is why I suggested a nanny.

Tbh if we had a joint household income of 340k, I'd be hiring a nanny to help with stuff. Maybe not medical appointments, I'd rather do those myself obviously. But for household stuff, I absolutely would!

Alas. With a relatively poor joint income of 100k, we struggle on without a nanny........ 😬

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:33

110APiccadilly · 12/01/2024 07:27

I would say it makes sense for the one with the most leave to take time off for these. Which might well be the higher earner. If equal amounts of leave, take it in turns.

(Our agreement is that DH does health visitor appointments and I do other medical appointments, which probably ends up more or less 50-50 and means we always know who's handling what.)

how often do you have HV visits? i had one after my babies and then no more.

Sodndashitall · 12/01/2024 07:31

I don't know what childcare arrangements you have but when my kids were young we had an amazing nanny/housekeeper as we were both high earners. My nanny would book stuff, take kids to routine appointments, make food, do laundry etc. It was a real godsend and enable both of us to maintain busy jobs and not spend all weekend doing life admin
I agree though that DP should pull his weight on all this stuff !

heybearx · 12/01/2024 07:28

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 06:18

If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments

I think it should be shared, as it shows a lack of respect for the other person and their career if not. It’s also important for your relationship with each other and your child to both do things like appointments, school workshops etc where possible.

Ime, many higher paying jobs come with much more flexibility than lower paid ones anyway, depending on the job.

Agreed! It's not about who earns the most! What a disrespectful attitude

NoKateMoss · 12/01/2024 07:27

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:13

@backinthebox so because I didn’t mention equal hours you assumed unequal hours? It’s a pretty bold yet useless move

You have backtracked. You clearly said it should be equal because pay was equal. It is difficult to sympathise with you about your husband's sexist attitude when honestly your attitude is sexist too.

And honestly, your poor kid. It sounds like divorced parents always saying "it's your turn! No, it's your turn!" Just someone step up and take your child for the fecking vaccine. Go for a cake afterwards and enjoy these short years.

110APiccadilly · 12/01/2024 07:27

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 06:07

If one partner is earning 30k and the other earning 200k, I would think that it would make sense for the lower earner to take time off for family appointments

I would say it makes sense for the one with the most leave to take time off for these. Which might well be the higher earner. If equal amounts of leave, take it in turns.

(Our agreement is that DH does health visitor appointments and I do other medical appointments, which probably ends up more or less 50-50 and means we always know who's handling what.)

Beedleneedle · 12/01/2024 07:21

@1AngelicFruitCake yes it has crossed my mind is it all worth it. Probably not

OP posts:
110APiccadilly · 12/01/2024 07:19

InAFightWithGod · 12/01/2024 05:31

It’s not about salary, it about hours worked. If you both work 40 hour weeks, you should share everything else equally. If one of you works less hours, they do more childcare, house stuff etc.

‘Youre better at.....’ is fine for some things if he does things he is ‘better at’, but when it comes to things to do with a child that you are both parents of, you both need to be equally capable, willing and interested. Your son is a person, not a task.

This is a very good point. I actually earn slightly more than DH. I do more childcare as he works more hours. And MN may be horrified by this but I do, and have always done, all night time wakings, because DH drives a lot as part of his job. I WFH at a computer. Only one of us is able to end up dead because we're tired at work.

Plumtop11 · 12/01/2024 07:18

User5512 · 12/01/2024 05:36

And OP, in your opinion, should others with lesser salary just suck it up and do everything? It’s about the hours worked - isn’t it? Some skills pay less, but everyone has the same number of hours in a day.

I can see what you're saying but I think what the OP is saying so that their responsibilities at work are very similar. My husband is a high earner in a very big job and his work load and hours are insane! It's not your standard full time role and really dominates our lives and schedule.

It must be very challenging juggling two people in roles like that.

1AngelicFruitCake · 12/01/2024 07:18

What’s quite comforting is that despite a family earning more than £300,000 combined, there can be this underlying resentment and petty back and forth over what’s fair.

We earn £55,000 (so £250,000 less than you do!) as a family but we work well together, have defined roles and things run well. I earn more but I don’t see my husbands contribution as less, my job is more enjoyable with better ‘extras’. It’s about what works as a family.