Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance reduction

257 replies

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 11/01/2024 23:34

I earn 3x as much as my DH. This isn’t an issue at all but we’re wondering what to do when it comes to child maintenance.

DH was paying his ex girlfriend a very generous amount (at this stage no CMS involved and turns out he was paying 3x more than CMS would’ve calculated)

When his ex found out me and DH were pregnant she unilaterally reduced contact to half of what it was and went through CMS thinking she would get more money. I don’t think she realised our lifestyle was because of my salary; not DH’s.

Anyway, things have always been toxic with her and DH served a court order on her when she reduced contact which saw myself and DH gain overnight contact. Not as much as we would’ve liked but it was better than what we had.

His ex has now broken the court order by saying the children do not want to visit us, stay with us etc therefore we are barely seeing them. DH doesn’t want to force them to come but we miss them.

DH has reduced his salary and CMS would decrease by 25% at the end of the month. Is it unreasonable to reduce it to the CMS suggested level?

OP posts:
Marblessolveeverything · 12/01/2024 08:21

@Soontobe60 and that's great where I am and across a lot of countries that isn't an option due to demand and administration overload in accessing funding.

Spirallingdownwards · 12/01/2024 08:20

Marblessolveeverything · 12/01/2024 08:00

Again @Chocolatebuttonns that is not what I said and there really is no need for the language!

Nurseries here offer morning or afternoon or full-time here. There is because funding is linked to these. Deviation causes extra paper work.

Your area is the anomaly. Indeed most people whilst they do need to have full day, full afternoon or full morning sessions can't access a proper full time place. Indeed we had to split childcare over two settings nursery/childminder 3 days/2 days because full time spaces weren't available. ALways makes me smile/shake my head when someone assumes their normal is THE normal.

OP , if DP previously paid 3 x as much child maintenance I can only assume that even on 80% pay he can afford the amount he is currently paying. Whilst it may be the case that you feel well if ex wants CMS rate (ie when she thought it would benefit her) she can have it now when it doesn't I might leave it a while before he reduces it and sorts out the contact issues first before reconsidering whether that's what he wants to do.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 12/01/2024 08:20

I think it is 100% reasonable to drop the payment to the CMs amount. Mainly because she approached the CMS. Either party can go at any time and get a review. Her greed has backfired but that is not your problem. AT ALL.

this happened to us sort of, we don’t have any kids together but my DH ex went to CMS with pound signs in her eyes after we moved into our house. She was gutted to learn he only ever paid the right amount anyway and all the money was mine!

I do hope you can get access to the children though, I despise mothers who use their children as weapons against their ex. It’s pathetic.

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 08:20

I would suggest he pays maintenance as it would have been calculated before he dropped the day. If he was paying over before, he doesn't need to carry on doing that, but he shouldn't be reducing his hours expecting his ex to bear the brunt of it because you will earn enough to ensure it doesn't affect your family.
How much contact does he have with the kids? I think you should focus on making them feel as comfortable as you can while they are with you and building up so they want to stay. It's on your dh to do this though, and to make the effort to show your step kids that he wants them there and is invested in them. They will see it either way as they get older, and will make their choices on contact based on what they know and how they feel.

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 08:19

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:18

Dh cannot afford it because he reduced his hours. He simply shouldn't reduce his hours of he cannot keep his payments otherwise. It's simple. I would like to reduce my hours too but I cannot afford it. Same principle applies there.

He clearly is one of the dads who got himself a shiny new family and the kids from the previous relationship don't matter. Congrats, great catch, OP!

Edited

Rude

HalloumiGeller · 12/01/2024 08:18

I genuinely don't understand women who do this tbh. Why would you deliberately want to stop a decent dad being involved with his kids? It's just awful! I split with my kids dad 4.5 years ago and it was ME who pushed him to up his contact! The kids wanted more time with him, and I in all honesty thought he should be sharing more of the daily load. People who use their kids as pawns are vile IMO, and they're most definitely not putting their kids first. It sounds to me like she's done this in the hope of getting more maintenance! I'd reduce the maintenance according to what CMS advise.

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:18

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 07:44

Putting it this way: could WE afford to keep the payments up? Certainly. Could DH on his own salary? Definitely not. This is the dilemma.

Dh cannot afford it because he reduced his hours. He simply shouldn't reduce his hours of he cannot keep his payments otherwise. It's simple. I would like to reduce my hours too but I cannot afford it. Same principle applies there.

He clearly is one of the dads who got himself a shiny new family and the kids from the previous relationship don't matter. Congrats, great catch, OP!

Stressfordays · 12/01/2024 08:15

He needs to go back to court and enforce the court order. Sorry but he's not 'forcing' the DC to see him at that age, he is ensuring he can build a bond with them.

I would drop the maintenance too, if she is blocking the contact (as someone on the other side, I always believe there are 2 sides to every story) then it may persuade her to let him see them more. I would however, offer to buy clothes, shoes etc. for the DC while you've got them.

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 08:12

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:12

So I have an junior ISA set up for our DC. Again, DH can’t afford and never could nor will probably ever be able to afford to do this for DSC.

That's fine. They have different parents. Don't be suckered into doing this for his kids, they have two parents of their own.

itsgettingweird · 12/01/2024 08:12

I suspect she reduced contact in an attempt to increase CMS.

But what I'd do here is continue to pay what you were paying even though he's reduced his hours because he's reduced them to facilitate you working and reduce childcare costs and that's not his previous children's problem and I don't believe new children should reduce the lifestyle of previous ones.

Alongside that I'd be going back to court.

If you keep playing tit for tat this won't be resolved.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:12

barkymcbark · 12/01/2024 08:09

I think whatever you do will be seen as an attack from what you've said about the ex. My advice would be that it's your dh issue to resolve. If he can only afford to pay inline with the CMS then that's what he does. If he can adore atmdditional then he can pay more or buy things like school uniforms etc. Another option is to pay the CMS amount but put an additional amount into a savings account for the dc to have access to when they are at an age you think they would benefit from.

Access and maintenance are two separate things, children are not a pay per view item and regardless of if he sees the dc or not, he should still pay. The legal amount is the CMS

So I have an junior ISA set up for our DC. Again, DH can’t afford and never could nor will probably ever be able to afford to do this for DSC.

OP posts:
lunarleap · 12/01/2024 08:11

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 07:44

Putting it this way: could WE afford to keep the payments up? Certainly. Could DH on his own salary? Definitely not. This is the dilemma.

Then you don't.

They have the parents they have

Soontobe60 · 12/01/2024 08:11

Marblessolveeverything · 12/01/2024 00:25

@Chocolatebuttonns that is not what I said.

Money is a necessity, the childrens outlay hasn't reduced as I've said they have increased.

All parents I am sure would love the opportunity to financial freedom to have the choice. Again after all current financial commitments to his children are made. The same in a non split family.

And whilst in an ideal world the father having an extra day to cover childcare that hasn't been mentioned.
Most childcare providers i am aware of require a space booked for the full week so no saving is made.

I work with many parents - almost all of them have part time childcare in nurseries. My grandchildren attend nursery 2 days a week / breakfast and after school club 3 days a week.
The vast majority of childcare providers cater for part time places.

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 08:11

barkymcbark · 12/01/2024 08:09

I think whatever you do will be seen as an attack from what you've said about the ex. My advice would be that it's your dh issue to resolve. If he can only afford to pay inline with the CMS then that's what he does. If he can adore atmdditional then he can pay more or buy things like school uniforms etc. Another option is to pay the CMS amount but put an additional amount into a savings account for the dc to have access to when they are at an age you think they would benefit from.

Access and maintenance are two separate things, children are not a pay per view item and regardless of if he sees the dc or not, he should still pay. The legal amount is the CMS

I think the savings account is a good idea

lunarleap · 12/01/2024 08:10

It's absolutely reasonable to go to CMS and ask them to recalculate. She is the one who insisted it went to CMS in the first place so that's what she wants.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:10

Soontobe60 · 12/01/2024 08:07

I’ve voted YABU primarily because it’s nothing to do with you. If your DH wants to pay above the CMS rate for his children then it’s up to him. I’m assuming you knew he had children when you met him?
It does sound a bit of a cop out that he’s not pursuing overnight contact with his DC though. How old are they?

I’m not saying he can or can’t. He’s his own man who prefers that we make our decisions together so just wind your neck in a little there. How is it a cop out when he served the court papers to get overnight contact? What’s he meant to do? Barge upto her house and demand the kids come with us? That’ll cause even more damage to the kids emotionally and mentally, especially if their mother resists which has happened before and we don’t want to scar the children even more.

OP posts:
barkymcbark · 12/01/2024 08:09

I think whatever you do will be seen as an attack from what you've said about the ex. My advice would be that it's your dh issue to resolve. If he can only afford to pay inline with the CMS then that's what he does. If he can adore atmdditional then he can pay more or buy things like school uniforms etc. Another option is to pay the CMS amount but put an additional amount into a savings account for the dc to have access to when they are at an age you think they would benefit from.

Access and maintenance are two separate things, children are not a pay per view item and regardless of if he sees the dc or not, he should still pay. The legal amount is the CMS

Soontobe60 · 12/01/2024 08:07

I’ve voted YABU primarily because it’s nothing to do with you. If your DH wants to pay above the CMS rate for his children then it’s up to him. I’m assuming you knew he had children when you met him?
It does sound a bit of a cop out that he’s not pursuing overnight contact with his DC though. How old are they?

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

This! DH and I have said this we could pay her 100% of our salaries and she still wouldnt be happy. I know my DC has a better lifestyle than DSC and from a financial point of view is more secure etc but we made sure we didn’t have a baby until we were in that position and I don’t think we should feel guilty for making that choice. It wasn’t at the expense of the DSC but I know there’s disparity.

OP posts:
Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Nottodaty · 12/01/2024 08:03

My husband knows that his Dad went to court and tried to get access sorted - more than the Sunday 11-3 that’s his Mum would allow. My husband will now never plan anything for 11 o’clock as the anxiety and memory’s of his Mum bitterness at that time through his childhood.

This is 40+ years ago. My husband knows that his Dad tried and his Mum did her best to block the relationship.

Take it back to court , financially I do think he shouldn’t drop the CMS. Your husband has 3 children to provide for his choice to drop a day for one shouldn’t really unfairly knock on the other two.

Adults sometimes need to remember their actions hurt the children and the long term actions affect their children into adulthood.

Marblessolveeverything · 12/01/2024 08:00

Again @Chocolatebuttonns that is not what I said and there really is no need for the language!

Nurseries here offer morning or afternoon or full-time here. There is because funding is linked to these. Deviation causes extra paper work.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 07:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.