Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance reduction

257 replies

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 11/01/2024 23:34

I earn 3x as much as my DH. This isn’t an issue at all but we’re wondering what to do when it comes to child maintenance.

DH was paying his ex girlfriend a very generous amount (at this stage no CMS involved and turns out he was paying 3x more than CMS would’ve calculated)

When his ex found out me and DH were pregnant she unilaterally reduced contact to half of what it was and went through CMS thinking she would get more money. I don’t think she realised our lifestyle was because of my salary; not DH’s.

Anyway, things have always been toxic with her and DH served a court order on her when she reduced contact which saw myself and DH gain overnight contact. Not as much as we would’ve liked but it was better than what we had.

His ex has now broken the court order by saying the children do not want to visit us, stay with us etc therefore we are barely seeing them. DH doesn’t want to force them to come but we miss them.

DH has reduced his salary and CMS would decrease by 25% at the end of the month. Is it unreasonable to reduce it to the CMS suggested level?

OP posts:
ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 12/01/2024 08:54

The only way the children would think that their dad doesn't care for them anymore is if their mother told them that.
"Sorry, daddy doesn't pay me as much now"
"Daddy has a new child now, doesn't need you"
"Daddy doesn't want to see you, he hasn't taken me to court this week"
If she wanted the best for her children she would not be causing all this strife and alienating them from their father and sibling.
I could never cause my children such pain.

Beezknees · 12/01/2024 08:54

Alternat · 12/01/2024 08:47

Also - have you considered that his other children might genuinely be saying that they don’t want to see their father because they see him put his new family above them? While it would be wrong for their mother to say that sort of thing to them directly, given the decision you have made, it absolutely is true now, even if it might not have been when she said it. I feel so very sorry for those children.

Yep. I decided for various reasons when I was 12 that I didn't want to see my dad any more. Nothing to do with my mum, I actually had issues with her as well. It was down to his behaviour but of course he refused to see his own faults and blamed my mum for it.

MumblesParty · 12/01/2024 08:51

OP - Whether or not it’s technically correct to reduce maintenance, can you not see how much worse it’ll make things? He already has a toxic ex who is apparently telling the kids things that make them not want to see him. If he reduces the payments then she’ll tell the kids “see, not only does your Dad love his new baby more than he loves you, now he doesn’t even want to give me money for you. That’s how much he doesn’t care”.

As a child of a father who “stepped back”, i can tell you that the best thing your DH can do is work on seeing his kids. If they don’t want over night stays, then have them for the day. If they don’t want to come to your house, your DH should take them on fun days out.

He should be ramping up efforts at being a good father, not looking at ways of saving some money. Trust me, there is a brief window of opportunity to be a good parent and develop a strong connection with your kids. Once it’s gone, it’s gone.

Parentofeanda · 12/01/2024 08:51

i know someone whos been in this exact situation. He reduced CMS as he found out his ex had been spending it all on herself ( holidays, nails,makeup hair etc) and leaving the kids without when they needed things and then asking for more. He then saved up in his own pot for them the additional amount he had saved. When they got to 18 he gave it to them.

LittleOwl153 · 12/01/2024 08:50

I would reduce the maintenance to CMS level as that is what HE can provide. (He is then paying through the officiap channel the amount lefally required And I would not wish to be setting any precidents of anything else.)

However I would then go back to the court and log the breach of the court order as I feel that if he does not do this now his relationship with his kids will be lost forever.

As you Collectively, can clearly afford the difference in maintenance I would set this difference aside as a fund for the children - for the court costs, for some counselling to combat the parent alienation (get that noted in court too) and then for a clothes/uni/car/house fund for the dc. That way the children are benefiting from their dad's lifestyle changes too.

Alternat · 12/01/2024 08:47

Also - have you considered that his other children might genuinely be saying that they don’t want to see their father because they see him put his new family above them? While it would be wrong for their mother to say that sort of thing to them directly, given the decision you have made, it absolutely is true now, even if it might not have been when she said it. I feel so very sorry for those children.

Rumourhasit1 · 12/01/2024 08:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

I think it's beneficial for him to have the day with the youngest of course however if he / they can afford to continue with the current maintenance payment they should.

If his salary was lower then childcare costs would it be fair to cut down his days even further or even completely and then change maintenance to suit? It would be beneficial for the baby but would be paying little to no maintenance to his other children.

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 08:45

I know she doesn't seem to want him to have contact, but his other option is to reduce the maintenance but offer to have the kids more to reduce her costs that way. Has he tried this?
You haven't said how much contact he actually has court ordered.

hedgehoglurker · 12/01/2024 08:45

What is the court ordered contact? If less than 50%, why? Do you live near the children and their school?

Why hasn't your husband sought to have the children live with him, if the mother is acting to their detriment?

I think the CMS is a separate issue, and as long as the children are with their mother, he morally shouldn't reduce the payments, as his salary decreasing doesn't even benefit those older children with extra time.

Appleblum · 12/01/2024 08:45

I wouldn't reduce the maintenance. CMS is the bare minimum and as a parent he should have considered whether he could afford to reduce his hours and still adequately support his 3 children (yes he has 3, not just your 1). If the answer is no, then he shouldn't have dropped his hours at all.

Alternat · 12/01/2024 08:40

Contact and payments are 2 different things here. Go to court to enforce the contact order if needs be.

But reducing payments will hurt his other children. You have only looked at the income issue from the point of view of your family unit. Just because you as a family unit can afford for him to lower his income, that shouldn’t come at the expense (no pun intended) of his other kids’ needs. Their expenses haven’t reduced and he has a duty to them.

Personally, I don’t respect men who shirk their responsibilities to any of their children. Their needs should absolutely have been part of any decision making in relation to your DH’s hours. And if it’s a matter of you needing to work more for a higher salary, then you should consider topping his payments up because what you have decided benefits your family unit to the detriment of his other children. I fully understand that this is not a legal necessity, but it’s an issue of morality and responsibility.

amylou8 · 12/01/2024 08:39

I'm all for flexibility, but if mum is being an arse then I'd play it completely by the book. Court ordered contact and CMS maintenance. Nothing more, nothing less. If he has extra then put it into savings for the kids when they're adults.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:35

Riverstep · 12/01/2024 08:31

The ex sounds toxic. She reduced contact by half because you were pregnant and has now breached a court order. She is not thinking of her children in this scenario. Yes he should rescue his maintenance based on him working one less day per week. He’s their father, not just a money tree and wants to be more involved than the ex is allowing him to be. He should head back to court and women unilaterally deciding to reduce contact should be viewed more negatively than they tend to be. It’s amazing what people get away with for being female.

From the point of view of a woman I can see the ex’s POV. her boyfriend moved on and married a younger woman, was the man she wanted him to be for me but not her, became a massive family man, landed well financially etc etc so I can understand some bitterness.

from the point of view of a mother though…I don’t understand it at all because I couldn’t do anything this detrimental to my DC.

OP posts:
Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Thank you. My husband is a real hard worker and a day off a week means he can spend time with our DC which I think is so lovely and he is really really looking forward to it to have that time for the two of them. I suppose it’s like what I had on maternity leave and it was the best feeling and time in the world. In an ideal world he could maintain this level of support for all his children but it’s just not feasible, especially with such low contact with his other two children which we honestly have tried so so hard to increase.

OP posts:
Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:31

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:29

He needs to take his EX back to court though about rights over custody.

any decent dad would do that but he clearly isn't bothered and more concerned with engineering a situation where he can reduce maintenance.

We have been to court over and over and over again. There’s only so much you can take.

OP posts:
Riverstep · 12/01/2024 08:31

The ex sounds toxic. She reduced contact by half because you were pregnant and has now breached a court order. She is not thinking of her children in this scenario. Yes he should rescue his maintenance based on him working one less day per week. He’s their father, not just a money tree and wants to be more involved than the ex is allowing him to be. He should head back to court and women unilaterally deciding to reduce contact should be viewed more negatively than they tend to be. It’s amazing what people get away with for being female.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:30

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:26

Oh you bitter little person. He was in a toxic relationship

oh, I suppose it's ok then to throw the kids under the bus (because they will ultimately go without). Your moral compass is off!!!

The kids have never been thrown under the bus. They have never ever gone without. Myself and DH have been fighting for years to get to where we are now and it’s still pathetic. We buy all their stuff for both home and our house. They had a bedroom in our home before they even were staying so they felt like this was their home too. I can honestly say my husband and I have tried every avenue. My child will get more as a consequence of my salary being larger than my DH and his ex’s combined but I’m not holding back on my DC either. Unfortunately, that’s life.

OP posts:
Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:29

He needs to take his EX back to court though about rights over custody.

any decent dad would do that but he clearly isn't bothered and more concerned with engineering a situation where he can reduce maintenance.

Rumourhasit1 · 12/01/2024 08:26

It seems morally wrong that by him dropping a work day that your family unit will ultimately financially be better off but then will financially negatively impact his other children.

If he can continue to pay maintenance what it currently is then surely that is the best for all his children?

He needs to take his EX back to court though about rights over custody.

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:26

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:22

Oh you bitter little person. He was in a toxic relationship. His ex isn’t a bad person, nor is he, they just didn’t work and it’s unfortunate that 2 children were brought into that environment because the relationship and break up have affected them. As a daughter who’s parents should’ve broken up I understand staying together can actually be as detrimental for the children.

my husband is a happier man, a kinder man, a more calm man since we’ve gotten together. Thats not me being naive or taking his word for that, it’s what his family and friends have told me; they’re delighted to see him finally happy and content and in love and safe and enjoying his life. Men get such a bad rap sometimes. But I’ll ignore your sarcasm and agree - he was the best catch of my life, and I hope I, his.

Oh you bitter little person. He was in a toxic relationship

oh, I suppose it's ok then to throw the kids under the bus (because they will ultimately go without). Your moral compass is off!!!

dothehokeycokey · 12/01/2024 08:24

There are two separate issues going on here op

The first one being I would go back to court as the mum has broken the order

The second issue of maintenance is that if his wages have decreased then surely cms will decrease the payment themselves,and seeing as that's the route the ex decided to take that's how I would continue to proceed.

YireosDodeAver · 12/01/2024 08:23

The CMS figure is far too low, but ywnbu to reduce it a bit. 3x the CMS minimum probably excessive, double is probably about right.

Istheregoldattheendoftherainbow · 12/01/2024 08:22

Fedupandconfused0815 · 12/01/2024 08:18

Dh cannot afford it because he reduced his hours. He simply shouldn't reduce his hours of he cannot keep his payments otherwise. It's simple. I would like to reduce my hours too but I cannot afford it. Same principle applies there.

He clearly is one of the dads who got himself a shiny new family and the kids from the previous relationship don't matter. Congrats, great catch, OP!

Edited

Oh you bitter little person. He was in a toxic relationship. His ex isn’t a bad person, nor is he, they just didn’t work and it’s unfortunate that 2 children were brought into that environment because the relationship and break up have affected them. As a daughter who’s parents should’ve broken up I understand staying together can actually be as detrimental for the children.

my husband is a happier man, a kinder man, a more calm man since we’ve gotten together. Thats not me being naive or taking his word for that, it’s what his family and friends have told me; they’re delighted to see him finally happy and content and in love and safe and enjoying his life. Men get such a bad rap sometimes. But I’ll ignore your sarcasm and agree - he was the best catch of my life, and I hope I, his.

OP posts:
FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 12/01/2024 08:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

My ex had a big drop in salary. He took on a lower paid, more local job with better hours. He stopped paying maintenance and asked to change to 50/50. I am much better off as I can work full time as opposed to a flexible, family friendly, school hours min wage job.

I think it’s fair to pay less maintenance if you take more care of the children and pay for stuff on your time. Clothes , activities etc.