Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stepmother inheritance - who's right?

139 replies

jamiefromcanada · 11/01/2024 22:23

My father was a widow at a young age, 30, he has two children from his first marriage. He remarried after a few years to a widowed homemaker who had one child from her previous marriage. After a few years they had a child of their own.

Fast forward, my father died at seventy years old and my step-mother lived another fifteen years, until eighty five years old. During their marriage they lived on my fathers income, which he earned handsomely. We all grew up together as one big close happy family, just like the Brady Bunch. shared birthdays, weddings, and parties together.

After my step-mothers death, my half-brother and step-brother never shared the contents of the will with us or not even let us see it. I know that when my step-mother was alive she said many times to many people including myself that all her children were equal to her. After all was said and done, my brothers gave us only 10% of the entire estate. My half-brother took 50% and my step-brother took, 30%.

What's right in this situation? Both morally and legally. I know how I feel, a bit disappointed. My father and stepmother died thinking we were all one big happy family... I want to get other peoples opinions on this. Thanks

OP posts:
SlipperyLizard · 12/01/2024 06:44

jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:20

Guys, so what that im from Canada? I found similar postings on this site and decided to ask a similar question. I want to see if the general public feels the way I do, betrayed! not like I was real family! This thing has weighed heavy on my heart. What's with all the negative responses. WTH. If you have nothing of value to add don't respond. I apologize for intruding on this private UK based site.

Edited

You asked what’s right “morally and legally” without making it clear what legal system you were talking about. Loads of people have wasted their time responding about the UK , I can see why they’re annoyed that you left out a crucial fact.

GRex · 12/01/2024 06:39

jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:52

My stepmother was the only beneficiary, she lived on my fathers pension for 15 years...He died in Italy, I did not see a will, I never asked, to much in grief at the time, I assumed like in Canada, the remaining spouse automatically gets everything.

In Italy, I would have expected that your father's children should have inherited half between the 3 of you at the time of your father's death. You really need an Italian lawyer if you want to understand your rights.

sorrynotathome · 12/01/2024 06:36

Ah ok so you just want everyone to come on and say “Oh poor you; your step-bro/half-bro are immoral”? Then don’t post in AIBU.

HTH

tokesqueen · 12/01/2024 06:28

Your stepmother was the only beneficiary of your father's will and he left no provision for his biological children?! At all!?!
Wow. He was a fool, naive at best.
That would have tainted my opinion of him.

Rightsraptor · 12/01/2024 04:50

And I'd imagine a lot may hinge on what the legal definition of 'child' is in the context of an Italian will.

In the law of England and Wales, it includes adopted children, although OP says they were never actually adopted by the SM either.

Mumsnet isnt at all a 'private English space', OP. But you appreciate we tend to assume posters are in the UK unless they say otherwise and it's unclear whether you want legal advice here or comments on the morality or otherwise of your family.

I don't think we can usefully add much more.

Nonewclothes2024 · 12/01/2024 01:54

Mirabai · 11/01/2024 23:12

Italian inheritance tax law usually shares the estate equally between children

OP is not the SM's child though.

Bigcat25 · 12/01/2024 01:43

Op, it seems you were asking for emotional support whereas people were actually trying to give you legal advice that my help you.

I'm Canadian too. It's possible for kids to inherent even with a surviving spouse if that's what the person has willed. It may not be typical and would be more common in high net worth families.

DonnaBanana · 12/01/2024 01:13

I was going to say no solicitor is going to allow a will to be fraudulently handled, but then I saw they were in Italy. Good luck!

zusje · 12/01/2024 00:57

The reason people are questionning is because you're asking "What's right in this situation? Both morally and legally" and then allowing people to vote if you're being unreasonable. The OP and subsequent posts seem to suggest you are seeking legal advise on what to do, but left out important information about a. your whereabouts b. your parents's/siblings whereabouts. This changes the advise people will give you, as most people will assume you are based in the UK posting about a will that would fall under UK law. Then you add that you weren't willing to pursue actually seeing the will and aren't willing to pursue this legally as you may incure costs.

Ultimately no one can tell you who is right as we don't know the contents of the wills and your parents' wishes and the laws regarding inheritance in Italy. I get why you might be upset about the division of goods and you may well have a point, but I would also add with you living in another continent how much of the day to day care of both parents as they became elderly (doctor/hospital visits, financial help etc) fell on the shoulders of the brothers living close by and morally wouldn't they then be entitled to a "bigger piece of the cake" so to speak considering they likely invested much more time, effort and finances in taking care of their elderly parents (again not sure if this is the case as you haven't shared timings of when parents died, where you were resident at the time etc). I live in the UK but my parents and younger sibling live in a european country on the other side of the continent. I've already told both my parents and my sibling that I don't expect anything from a will etc as a. my parents have supported me enough financially in my young adult years and b. realistically my sibling is going to have the lion's share of caring responsibilities when the time comes living in the same town as them. Seems only fair to me!

jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:52

SleepPrettyDarling · 11/01/2024 23:24

Did you benefit from your father’s will at the time, or was your stepmother the only beneficiary?
did he die intestate?
Did he die in Italy?

My stepmother was the only beneficiary, she lived on my fathers pension for 15 years...He died in Italy, I did not see a will, I never asked, to much in grief at the time, I assumed like in Canada, the remaining spouse automatically gets everything.

OP posts:
endofthelinefinally · 12/01/2024 00:40

Every country has its own laws around inheritance. You really need to seek advice from a solicitor qualified in Italian law. There are legal firms in the UK who have partners qualified in various other countries. I am sure there will be similar firms in Canada. You will have to do some searching and they will charge you, but it is probably the only way to get correct advice.

jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:32

Spomsored,

Actually I believe my stepmother to have been a good women and its my brothers that I have a problem with. I feel that they changed the will to benefit their outcome.

OP posts:
jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:29

Dancerprancer19 · Yesterday 23:58

That's awful. Even if I couldn't find the will I would do a deviation to the will and divide it equally in the circumstances you describe.
---------------------

Exactly what I was thinking they should have done, thank you

OP posts:
Spomsored · 12/01/2024 00:29

People were trying to give practical advice based on UK law around wills and inheritance. The fact that you are in Canada is unimportant but your stepmother livng (and dying) in Italy is relevant to the advice people thought you wanted.

As a PP. has said you have may feel betrayed by either your stepmother (if she left you out of her will) or by your step and half brothers (if they ignored her will/wishes). How much contact did you have with her and them since your father died?

jamiefromcanada · 12/01/2024 00:20

Guys, so what that im from Canada? I found similar postings on this site and decided to ask a similar question. I want to see if the general public feels the way I do, betrayed! not like I was real family! This thing has weighed heavy on my heart. What's with all the negative responses. WTH. If you have nothing of value to add don't respond. I apologize for intruding on this private UK based site.

OP posts:
littlemousebigcheese · 12/01/2024 00:18

Until you see the will, you'll never know but something to consider is that someone will have hurt you; either your stepmother for leaving you out, or your family for not giving you what was left to you. Finding out who hurt you might help you move on, but ultimately it's a shit situation made worse by the fact that you don't want to do anything about it.
Ask to see the will. Contact the executor, or ask your stepbrother. If they won't let you, ask why.

My limited understanding is that you can't ignore the wishes of a will so what was given to you is what was left to you by her. 🤷‍♀️

EnfysPreseli · 12/01/2024 00:13

I think you need to get hold of a copy of your father's will as well as that of your step-mother. It's not going to be helpful to ruminate like this, but do nothing. You need to find out whether their wishes were respected or not, and if not decide whether you want to challenge your brothers or can accept what's happened and let it go.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 12/01/2024 00:06

jamiefromcanada · 11/01/2024 22:49

I live in Canada, but my step-mom died in Italy, Italian citizen. What are the laws there? anyone? thx

So it is unlikely that comments from a UK-based site will be of use to you. That information is important and should be in the OP.

tachetastic · 11/01/2024 23:59

familyissues12345 · 11/01/2024 23:54

I'm confused which relation you are - you have a 35 year relationship, but your SM died recently aged 85? So did she have children in her 50's? Maybe I've misread it.

I think the 35 year relationship may have been with the step-brother's cousin. Or possibly their aunt's sister-in-law's cleaner's dog.

Though I may be wrong. This thread is very confusing.

Dancerprancer19 · 11/01/2024 23:58

That's awful. Even if I couldn't find the will I would do a deviation to the will and divide it equally in the circumstances you describe.

familyissues12345 · 11/01/2024 23:54

I'm confused which relation you are - you have a 35 year relationship, but your SM died recently aged 85? So did she have children in her 50's? Maybe I've misread it.

tachetastic · 11/01/2024 23:47

jamiefromcanada · 11/01/2024 22:23

My father was a widow at a young age, 30, he has two children from his first marriage. He remarried after a few years to a widowed homemaker who had one child from her previous marriage. After a few years they had a child of their own.

Fast forward, my father died at seventy years old and my step-mother lived another fifteen years, until eighty five years old. During their marriage they lived on my fathers income, which he earned handsomely. We all grew up together as one big close happy family, just like the Brady Bunch. shared birthdays, weddings, and parties together.

After my step-mothers death, my half-brother and step-brother never shared the contents of the will with us or not even let us see it. I know that when my step-mother was alive she said many times to many people including myself that all her children were equal to her. After all was said and done, my brothers gave us only 10% of the entire estate. My half-brother took 50% and my step-brother took, 30%.

What's right in this situation? Both morally and legally. I know how I feel, a bit disappointed. My father and stepmother died thinking we were all one big happy family... I want to get other peoples opinions on this. Thanks

It is really healthy to vent this kind of thing on Mumsnet, but you need to take legal advice. If your dad left a will then my understanding is that it is up to him to choose who he leaves the money to, but you need to confirm this and fight your corner. You absolutely need to see a legally attested version of the will.

Good luck! And don't take shit from anyone. It is really easy to be convinced not to make a fuss so as not to fall out with a family member, but if they are walking away with tens of thousands that your father intended for you then that is not right either.

Mirabai · 11/01/2024 23:37

zusje · 11/01/2024 23:31

So let me try and see if can wrap my head around this. You are a Canadian citizen, posting in a UK based forum about an italian estate/will? When it has already been settled, assets have been sold, money has been distributed and you aren't willing to even contact an italian lawyer for information/advise because it may lead to costs and flights to Italy?

YABU

Sad but true.

TheAlchemistElixa · 11/01/2024 23:33

zusje · 11/01/2024 23:31

So let me try and see if can wrap my head around this. You are a Canadian citizen, posting in a UK based forum about an italian estate/will? When it has already been settled, assets have been sold, money has been distributed and you aren't willing to even contact an italian lawyer for information/advise because it may lead to costs and flights to Italy?

YABU

Yes, this!!

what exactly are you looking for from this thread OP? What would you like us to say?

zusje · 11/01/2024 23:31

So let me try and see if can wrap my head around this. You are a Canadian citizen, posting in a UK based forum about an italian estate/will? When it has already been settled, assets have been sold, money has been distributed and you aren't willing to even contact an italian lawyer for information/advise because it may lead to costs and flights to Italy?

YABU

Swipe left for the next trending thread