Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt by how DSS is towards DS?

106 replies

BonusDC · 11/01/2024 20:04

DSS is 11 and neurotypical. My bio DS is 6 and has autism.

Almost all of the time, whenever DS tries to engage his brother about anything, DSS just blanks him and it hurts me.

Today DSC were here and DS asked him how was his day at school, he looked right at him but didnt answer. I wish it was an isolated thing but it isn't. It happens every time they're together.

Occasionally DH will intervene and say "DSS, DS is talking to you" and DSS will begrudgingly answer him after he blanked him the first few times DS said his name.

DS has tried to use gaming as a 'way in' as DSS is a big gamer and loves roblox etc. If he asks DSS questions about roblox or wants to show him his character he couldn't be less interested and doesn't even pretend to humour him. If my other DSS wants to chat to DSS12 about roblox or gaming he happily engages.

There is no messy history. DH wasn't in an established relationship with DSC' mother so there's no broken home or toxicity. DSS' has a happy home life with his DM, SF and other siblings (the youngest one belonging to her now DH)

DSS used to enjoy DS' company when DS was small and cute but he has no time for him at all any more and sees him as an inconvenience.

DS and DH share a birthday (it's tomorrow) and DSS made a handmade card for DH but not for DS. He knows it's DS birthday tomorrow and remembers clearly that it's the same day as DH but not so much as a "happy birthday for tomorrow" from him when he went home.. yet he spoke with excitement about it being his youngest sisters 1st birthday next Monday.

I know siblings can be annoying and he's entitled to feel however he feels, but surely he should still treat DS with respect?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BlackFriYay · 12/01/2024 18:33

Sapphire387 · 12/01/2024 10:23

People always jump all over the blended family / stepchild thing on here. And every bad behaviour always has to be caused by some deep trauma, apparently.

It might be that, but... It sounds to me like your DSS might just be being a bit of a rude 11yo.

If your husband isn't going to be supportive of you, and continually suggests you show favouritism, it's probably best to take a step back from the parenting role with DSS. That means DH needs to step up and pull him up on his rudeness. All he has to say is 'alright thanks' when asked how his day was.

Yup I think this is pretty much it.

Sapphire387 · 12/01/2024 10:23

People always jump all over the blended family / stepchild thing on here. And every bad behaviour always has to be caused by some deep trauma, apparently.

It might be that, but... It sounds to me like your DSS might just be being a bit of a rude 11yo.

If your husband isn't going to be supportive of you, and continually suggests you show favouritism, it's probably best to take a step back from the parenting role with DSS. That means DH needs to step up and pull him up on his rudeness. All he has to say is 'alright thanks' when asked how his day was.

BonusDC · 12/01/2024 10:02

SequoiaTree · 12/01/2024 09:55

He sounds sweet and mature to ask how dss's day went. Certainly has better social skills than the dss!

He really is such a sweet little boy with an amazing mind 🙂 I'm very proud of him.

OP posts:
SequoiaTree · 12/01/2024 09:55

He sounds sweet and mature to ask how dss's day went. Certainly has better social skills than the dss!

BonusDC · 12/01/2024 08:48

About whether DS' autism is severe, it's a difficult question to answer really. He has a spiky profile.

He was non verbal until 4+ so I guess you could say he was severely affected, but he's made some incredible progress over the last 2 years since he started at a specialist school. He has now outgrown them, so to speak, and is working at a much higher level than his peers there (he's in the top 10% I'm told) so he will be transitioning to mainstream as they feel he is "high functioning"

I've spoke about him on MN before (not in relation to DSS though) so some might recognise him from my description.

His behaviour was incredibly challenging before he learned to speak and he was a very frustrated little boy. Lots of meltdowns and tears, but DSS was absolutely fine with him at that point, even though it would have been perfectly understandable if he wanted to avoid him a bit at that age - but he didn't.

He loved playing with him and was so patient and understanding if he had a meltdown or needed some time out.

I don't know why things have changed as DS is much better company now, enjoys games like DSS, you can have a conversation with him and he's alot more receptive to other people.

If it is resentment then it must be some repressed resentment from the early years as DS is a fab little brother now, if I do say so myself.

I agree DSS needs to be given the opportunity to be completely honest about how he feels so we can help him work through it.

OP posts:
GKD · 12/01/2024 08:34

Some ppl really hate kids, DSS isn’t a little shit he is a child behaving in an undesirable way and needs to be assisted out of it.

I think DH explaining to DSS that it isn’t on is best (and it probably won’t be a single explanation as kids forget esp when not permanently there), you could even do a family meeting about how we treat each other without explicitly calling DSS out.

I have sympathy for DS, it isn’t on but bullying DSS out of it won’t help, he is a child too, and DSS needs help to recognise that DS has feelings too and this isn’t on.

My DC is sometimes ignored by a relative in this manner - I always give a pleasant ‘x is speaking to you can you respond please’, and every so often state how rude and unkind it is to ignore someone.

Re split families, at age 11 I really struggled with my family structure just because it’s always been that way doesn’t mean that DSS won’t have new understanding/conflicted feeling as he grows.

Theres a danger in putting adult understanding on kids and forgetting that their perception changes as they mature.

ThePenguinIsDrunk · 12/01/2024 08:05

It's not unreasonable to expect DSS to be polite and just acknowledge his brother, even if just to say 'no, i don't want to do xyz' . You are though UR to be 'hurt', a bit upset yes but hurt? No. This isn't behaviour towards you.

PurpleBugz · 12/01/2024 07:38

I'd flip it around if you don't feel comfortable addressing it with dss. So say to ds "ds leave dss alone for now when he ignores you like that he's being rude and mean to you you don't want people treating you that way let go [distraction]"

Speaking as an autistic adult I would have really appreciated being taught what mean and bullying looked like so I put the time and effort trying to make friends into the right people and didn't get taken advantage of because I couldn't tell

Kittylala · 12/01/2024 07:19

Call him out on it and tell him to stop being a little shit. No way would I have gotten away with this with my parents.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 12/01/2024 06:17

DH should be pulling him up on it every time, nothing big or emotive, just pointing out DS is speaking and its rude to ignore someone. This is what I do when my 8 year old ignores his 7 year old brother in this way. DSS needs to answer politely, but then if he's saying he wants to be left alone DS should be distracted to do something else. Him ignoring his little brother doesnt necessary mean he doesn't love him. My 8 year old regularly does this to his little brother as he finds him annoying, but he does love him.

MayThe4th · 12/01/2024 05:31

OP there is a potential elephant in the room - your DS’ autism.

As he was diagnosed at 2.5 I’m guessing that he must be fairly severely autistic. Is he in mainstream school? Specialist education? How does his autism generally affect the dynamic of the family?

Because for DSS he only sees his father for two days a week, and whether we like to admit it or not, a disability can have an impact on the rest of the children. There are plenty of threads on here from siblings of disabled children talking about the difficulties of having a disabled sibling and the impact that had on their childhood, and as much as DS’ autism is something which can’t be helped, the impact on other children also needs to be considered.
Your DSS may have an understanding of autism, but is he expected to come second to it as well as to only be a part time member of the family?
IMO a conversation is necessary to establish exactly what the issues are here. But it needs to be a frank conversation, where DSS is permitted to be totally honest about his feelings. Because until he is permitted to be honest, everything is just guesswork. And giving him permission to be honest includes being able to voice his feelings over his sibling, even if that’s not something you’re potentially going to want to hear. But only after you/ve heard it can the issues be addressed or reassurances given.

bloodyeffinnora · 12/01/2024 04:40

Caerulea · 11/01/2024 22:09

I'm not for the 'It's just an age' thing, smacks a little of 'boys will be boys'.

Dss is being rude & cruel & there's no excuse like being ND, he's choosing to act this way, it's a deliberate act which he knows it's hurting his brother. Your DH needs to intervene if he won't allow you, and have a proper talk with DSS about his behaviour.

From DS pov, his (half) brother is coming into his home, his safe space, being incredibly mean to him & no one is standing up for him. At 11 he knows exactly what he's doing.

definitely agree with this. I feel so sorry for your little boy being completely ignored when directly asking a question of his older brother. This is bullying by the older brother. Please protect your son.

Cornishclio · 12/01/2024 03:19

Your DH sounds like a bad father if he is letting his older DS ignore his younger DS without pulling him up on his nastiness whether your DS is ASD or not. If he won't address it then you should regardless of how your DH feels. A reminder that being kind is nice is all that is needed.

confuseeedd · 12/01/2024 03:11

JMSA · 11/01/2024 20:21

Almost all of the time, whenever DS tries to engage his brother about anything, DSS just blanks him and it hurts me.

They're not brothers though. I'm sorry ... it's harsh but true Sad
They're two boys put together because their respective parents are in a relationship.

Since when did sharing one parent not make you brothers/sisters??

DSS needs pulling on his behaviour, it isn't nice and he needs teaching how to be kinder.

Of course siblings fight and often can't be arsed with each other, but they should have a basic level of respect and love for one another. Responding to conversation and wishing them a happy birthday isn't a lot to expect.

ChimneyPot · 12/01/2024 03:10

OP I think you are quite dismissive of any potential issues your DSC might have by saying there is no messy history, no broken family.

I don’t know if both DSC have the same mother as you say your DH didn’t have an established relationship with DSS12’s mother or if there are 3 families rather than two involved here.
Either way your DSS either has one full and at least 2 half siblings in 2 different families, or 3 half siblings from 3 different families.
It is a lot for an 11 year old to deal with. Lots of different complicated family dynamics.

Yes , if you want a good relationship between the boys, remind him not to ignore your DS but try to be more open and understanding about what he might be dealing with.

Meadowfinch · 12/01/2024 02:57

I have a db with about the same age gap. He ignored my at that age, I ignored my younger sister, who I regarded as a complete pain at that age. Not friendly, I know, but fairly normal.

You've tried explaining to him, he needs to cut younger ds some slack, but he is still only 11. He will probably grow out of it.

Geppili · 12/01/2024 02:42

He resents him.

caringcarer · 12/01/2024 01:32

I don't think it is an age gap thing because my elder DS is 8 years older than his younger brother but always has been lovely with him. They are both adults now and still quite close despite living 150 miles apart. They visit each other for a weekend here and there and message and will play games together sometimes. I think your DSS is being a bit mean to your DS.

caringcarer · 12/01/2024 01:29

OrangeSlices998 · 11/01/2024 20:24

Unless I’m mistaken, the OP’s son and her DSS share a Dad? So they are brothers if I’ve understood that correctly.

They are half brothers. Different mothers.

Pemba · 11/01/2024 23:58

I have a great nephew, he has two younger half siblings, one from his mum, one from his dad. He is absolutely lovely with both of them, so kind and caring. He's nine.

It's pretty weird that your eleven year old SS has started behaving this way towards his half brother, when he didn't before. It's rude and unkind and eleven is plenty old enough to understand this and to develop a bit of empathy and manners.His dad should be guiding him in this, or what sort of teenager and man will he become?

Chocolatebuttonns · 11/01/2024 23:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

InAPickle12345 · 11/01/2024 23:40

neilyoungismyhero · 11/01/2024 23:38

Personally having experience of a similar situation I think step son is a nasty little shit and your husband is enabling his nasty behaviour.

Wow... I'd be really interested what experience you've had that has led you to call an 11 year old child a 'nasty little shit'?

neilyoungismyhero · 11/01/2024 23:38

Personally having experience of a similar situation I think step son is a nasty little shit and your husband is enabling his nasty behaviour.

SemperIdem · 11/01/2024 23:28

BonusDC · 11/01/2024 23:17

He has a reasonable understanding of autism and how it presents. DS was diagnosed age 2.5 and we've been very open with DSS about it all and how his autism affects XYZ, etc.

DSS also has experience of other children with autism in his school, though I realise every child with ASD is different.

Totally get that but he is still only 11. His reasonable understanding won’t be the same as an adults.

I have a sibling, 8 years younger than me. Adored them when they were tiny but generally wasn’t keen/found them annoying when they were between the ages of 5-14.

I was quite rightly challenged by our parents (including step parent) every time I behaved poorly towards them.

We’ve been very close since they were about 15, both very much adults now and are closer than most closer in age adult siblings.

It is absolutely right that your step son’s rudeness towards his little brother is challenged in the right way and he’s guided to behave more kindly.

Chocolatebuttonns · 11/01/2024 23:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread