Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To reflect that ‘some chase ex for their salary not child contribution

212 replies

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:40

using ‘ ExDh’ as example as most common situation

Wondering genuinely …

If I was to work out how much extra having a child live in my house ( accounting for the cost of having an extra room for them )
would likely not come to around £500/ £700 a month, what I generally hear is paid in CMS.

Reflecting on the ‘ french private school’ related trending post…

I have seen many people chase and chase for exDH salary….when In reality there is no way that they are spending £700 a month on having a child ( the exDH £500 and £200 contribution of the other parent- due to the fact that the child costs is supposed to be shared , (accounting for them having child more frequently )

I wonder further about this, particularly when people live in a mortgaged property that is going up in price, yet the parent that has paid towards that housing will never have a claim on it …

When I stop and think the cost of my child’s room
their food
clothes
activities
holidays
savings
I just can’t see how it totals £500-700 every 30 days?

when you separate you may loose the ‘ bonus’ of another’s potentially greater salary… continually trying to access it, beyond what is realistic , seems unfair
AIBU

OP posts:
IhaveanewTVnow · 11/01/2024 18:28

What about the cost of me having to go part time as ExH enjoyed the single life and saw the kids for one night a fortnight. He got to go on all inclusive holidays with his GF but never took the kids on holiday. He never contributed towards driving lessons, school trips etc. The ongoing impact on my pension.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/01/2024 18:27

Doingmybest12 · 11/01/2024 18:23

I don't understand the point of your post. You want the NRP to pay the minimum to just provide for the basic needs of their child even when they have a good lifestyle themselves. Why wouldn't they want to help achieve a good life for their child ?

That's not the OP's point at all. They aren't talking about the minimum etc. They are highlighting that, in some cases, the amount paid by the NRP is actually demonstratively higher than covering half the costs of the additional days that the RP has the child. In those cases, the payment effectively acts as both child maintenance and ailmony as it's funding part of the RP's life beyond the child. The OP is talking about RP's who already receive high levels of payment from the NRP and are still pushing for more.

McMuffins · 11/01/2024 18:24

Usernamen · 11/01/2024 18:08

Regardless of whether someone goes after their ex-spouse’s salary or not, they can only do this until the shared child(ren) turns 18. So it’s short-lived and the ex-spouse can keep their high salary to themselves thereafter.

Depends on when they split. Almost 2 decades is not ‘short-lived’

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:24

I think the issue is im
comparing to what I know. Home owners who chase for more when they already receive ( as stated in my OP) approx £500.
some of the responses are going down the road of a lot less than that … and I’m sorry that’s your situation, but that’s not what I’m asking

OP posts:
Doingmybest12 · 11/01/2024 18:23

I don't understand the point of your post. You want the NRP to pay the minimum to just provide for the basic needs of their child even when they have a good lifestyle themselves. Why wouldn't they want to help achieve a good life for their child ?

BuddhaAtSea · 11/01/2024 18:21

I used to get £180/month maintenance and DD’s bus permit to school came to £80/month. Her maths tuition a month was more than the£180 her dad paid. The swimming was £40 a month, the gym £25. £100-120 for school lunches.
He lived in a one bedroom, paying £70/week (so couldn’t have her overnight). My 2 bed was £750, because I was housing her as well.
That’s without food, utilities, Spotify, Netflix, clothes, school trips, clothes, make up, pocket money, 30 min showers etc
So what was your dilemma?

00100001 · 11/01/2024 18:19

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:07

older DC per child
£300 all in,
If that.
they have the elder hand me downs.
I save monthly for an annual holiday.
they have a hobbie each and some clothes new,
some brought online.
and that’s supporting them FULL TIME
not some of the week and some weekends.

So...if you lived in a 1 bed flat alone , - youregenuinely saying that, if all of a sudden, two children were thrust upon you. That your outgoings would only increase by £600 per month?

Including the rent/mortgage for a bigger property, all the increased bills (heating, council tax, electricity), the extra food, activities, clothes, stuff etc? £300 per month?

ChanelNo19EDT · 11/01/2024 18:17

My x was of this mindset because he saw no value to my time. He gave no value to my freedom. No acknowledgement of any sacrifices I'd made. Just a blunt, crude list of expenses. No comprehension of how small my life had become. I got back in to the workplace when my youngest was 11 and it was still hard (he has SEN) My x is the same as you though, even though I've been working for years now, anything I had, a coat or a bag, he would say '''I paid for that'' Grin as though I only had the 'right' to ask for child maintenance if I was DIRT POOR.

LUCKILY THE JUDGE AGREED WITH MY REQUEST THAT THE ''SACRIFICES OF PARENTING BE MADE A BIT MORE EQUAL''

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 11/01/2024 18:15

Just for fun, OP, sit down and fill out a form E.

Sleepproblems · 11/01/2024 18:15

TERFisTHEnewTREND · 11/01/2024 17:44

YABU

The non resident parent pays just 7% of their salary to the resident parent. So if the NRP earns £1000 a month, the RP gets just £70. Could you house, clothe, feed, and entertain a child on that? I know I couldn't.

This is incorrect, closer to 20% of NRP salary if going by the child maintenance calculator

Jellycatspyjamas · 11/01/2024 18:15

If I didn’t have kids I’d live in a smaller house, so cheaper mortgage, my utilities would be less, I wouldn’t be paying for school lunches (£15/child/week), my food bills would be much less, I wouldn’t be paying for holidays in the same way, or days out, or swimming lessons, or clothes for constantly growing kids. Include Christmas, birthdays, family events etc and the costs soon mount up. That’s before I look at my loss of earnings, my children have complex support needs which means full time working is impossible - I still cover the bulk of after school and holiday childcare which comes at a financial cost to me.

As it is we share care so no maintenance is due either way but we work very hard to be fair to each other. We both decided we wanted kids, they shouldn’t be disadvantaged because we decided to separate.

Jurassictrex · 11/01/2024 18:14

The children of high earners would expect to have more than £300 per month though OP. They’ll probably be doing music lessons, multiple sports clubs etc. And why shouldn’t they!

Octavia64 · 11/01/2024 18:14

If you have a preschool child and the ExH never sees them the nursery fees will be really substantial.

And at the other end university costs are pretty high too.

Sleepproblems · 11/01/2024 18:14

This is incorrect, closer to 20% of NRP salary if going by the child maintenance calculator

SisterMichaelsHabit · 11/01/2024 18:13

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:48

hmm perhaps my post is more relevant for home owners/
mortgaged

All the women I know who have separated are in the awful position of having lost the security of owning a home with a partner and not earning anywhere near enough to pay for a mortgage because childcare is coming out of their account to enable them to work so they're the ones that get shafted for it when banks calculate affordability.

None of them have a chance of getting a house.

I don't know any separated couples where the woman got the kids and was able to buy a house (SE) and I know a few who have had to move out of area or back in with parents to be able to exist at all. Meanwhile their DHs are in million pound houses and the man's affordability isn't affected at all.

I don't know any separated couples where the DH has become the RP either which is why my post is sexed.

That's one reason why I urge anyone with kids to think twice about separating if there's another way to make it work. The reality is not £700 a month of free money for most.

decisionssmecisions · 11/01/2024 18:11

i don’t understand why a higher earner would their dc to live a lesser life. My parents divorced, our lifestyle didn’t change.

decisionssmecisions · 11/01/2024 18:10

Add in bigger house, clothes, toys, food, more water, electricity etc

ChannelLightVessel · 11/01/2024 18:10

We also had an extreme income difference: I was a SAHM and he is a hospital consultant.

decisionssmecisions · 11/01/2024 18:10

I spend £500 a month just on tutoring/clubs/wraparound care for one dc.

Glitterbaby17 · 11/01/2024 18:08

But how much less would your rent/mortgage/gas/electric/water be if you were just living alone in a one bed flat? That’s the killer where we are based.

Usernamen · 11/01/2024 18:08

Regardless of whether someone goes after their ex-spouse’s salary or not, they can only do this until the shared child(ren) turns 18. So it’s short-lived and the ex-spouse can keep their high salary to themselves thereafter.

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:07

PuttingDownRoots · 11/01/2024 17:58

What do you spend then? And what age?

older DC per child
£300 all in,
If that.
they have the elder hand me downs.
I save monthly for an annual holiday.
they have a hobbie each and some clothes new,
some brought online.
and that’s supporting them FULL TIME
not some of the week and some weekends.

OP posts:
ChannelLightVessel · 11/01/2024 18:05

I got divorced in the US, so I don’t know how far the approach is different, but one of the considerations was that a child should have the same lifestyle in both homes. This means that a high earner whose ex-spouse is the primary carer would be expected to contribute more than the minimum amount a child’s care might cost. (I also had a very good lawyer.)

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:03

Iamnotthe1 · 11/01/2024 18:01

You'll be dragged on here but there is some truth to what you're saying, depending on the level of payment.

People seem to forget that the contribution is supposed to be for half of the costs incurred for the days the RP has the child over the NRP. It's not supposed to cover the cost of raising the child entirely or even half of it.

The average cost of raising a child from birth to 18, including childcare, a portion of bills, etc. is currently worked out to be around £198k. So, in your example, £500 per month does actually cover half the cost of raising the child even if that child lives full time with the RP and never sees the NRP. The issue is when the NRP's payments are so much lower and don't cover what it should.

That’s a really Interesting and realistic response thank you.

OP posts:
Iamnotthe1 · 11/01/2024 18:01

You'll be dragged on here but there is some truth to what you're saying, depending on the level of payment.

People seem to forget that the contribution is supposed to be for half of the costs incurred for the days the RP has the child over the NRP. It's not supposed to cover the cost of raising the child entirely or even half of it.

The average cost of raising a child from birth to 18, including childcare, a portion of bills, etc. is currently worked out to be around £198k. So, in your example, £500 per month does actually cover half the cost of raising the child even if that child lives full time with the RP and never sees the NRP. The issue is when the NRP's payments are so much lower and don't cover what it should.