Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To reflect that ‘some chase ex for their salary not child contribution

212 replies

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:40

using ‘ ExDh’ as example as most common situation

Wondering genuinely …

If I was to work out how much extra having a child live in my house ( accounting for the cost of having an extra room for them )
would likely not come to around £500/ £700 a month, what I generally hear is paid in CMS.

Reflecting on the ‘ french private school’ related trending post…

I have seen many people chase and chase for exDH salary….when In reality there is no way that they are spending £700 a month on having a child ( the exDH £500 and £200 contribution of the other parent- due to the fact that the child costs is supposed to be shared , (accounting for them having child more frequently )

I wonder further about this, particularly when people live in a mortgaged property that is going up in price, yet the parent that has paid towards that housing will never have a claim on it …

When I stop and think the cost of my child’s room
their food
clothes
activities
holidays
savings
I just can’t see how it totals £500-700 every 30 days?

when you separate you may loose the ‘ bonus’ of another’s potentially greater salary… continually trying to access it, beyond what is realistic , seems unfair
AIBU

OP posts:
Newmumatlast · 11/01/2024 19:39

I think the child should benefit from as close to the lifestyle they would've had were their parents together as possible but accounting for 2 households to now pay for. I am the higher earner. I wouldnt want to be having lovely leisure activities and my kids not because I refuse to supplement my ex. So if I think like that why shouldn't a dad

IncompleteSenten · 11/01/2024 19:39

From the times

"The average amount of money spent on raising a child from birth to 18 in the UK in 2023 – including housing and childcare costs – is £223,256, according to investment platform Moneyfarm. That's a rise of 10% on 2022 and works out at about £12,400 a year, or £1,030 a month."

So half of that is £515 a month.

Allywill · 11/01/2024 19:37

When my 2 were at secondary school it was around 130 a month for bus fare and school lunches alone (£5 a day for lunch/snacks and £3 bus)- each. that’s £260 a month (working on a 40 week school year) just for that. i would very easily get to £500 a month if i added in everything else. if they were younger and i was paying for nursery/wrap round care/holiday clubs it would be more. CSA calculation say nrps should pay 16% of gross income for 2 children - apart from the fact that many don’t pay at all _ how little do you think they should pay?

ChanelNo19EDT · 11/01/2024 19:35

Foxblue · 11/01/2024 19:02

The more critical question is, why isn't any regular (week in, week out) paid-for childcare taken out of the calculation entirely and split 50/50 separately.
My friend gets £200 a month for her son, ex has him every other weekend overnight, it costs her £800 a month to put him in nursery because guess what, she works full time. Ex won't pay because there's nothing saying he has to. It should be treated separately! He should be forced to pay half - but nope. Never understood why childcare isn't calculated separately (although of course, this would come with its own set of problems...)

Oh yes, absolutely @Foxblue

Yeh, presuming the father is the higher earner, which is what this particular thread is about I think, a mother cannot bring her x to court to take the children half the week if he doesn't want to take them. That's not a thing. Father's can't be made to take responsibility. (I guess that's for the best. But it is not an advantage for a single mother getting back in to the workplace/developing earning potential.)

A mother can't take her x to court to compel father to pay for half the childcare for the days he has refused to take responsibility for the children either.

And if fathers are paying the minimum but poor guys new girlfriends feel that's too much, don't worry, just up your pension contribution. YOu'll be much better off in your old age than the mother of your children, I'll put a wager on that one.

Windywuss · 11/01/2024 19:35

I'd say it's rare for an ex to be paying so much that it's equivalent to the mortgage on the Res p's home. Why would the increased capital on the home have anything to do with the ex? He has a home too. Courts usually split things cleanly in the UK and by no means does the RP end up with a home funded by exh unless both a very wealthy and she has a shit hot lawyer.

Bloody hell, my ex was such a twat that it cost me 20k to divorce him and I was awarded 20 k towards a new home for me and my child having lost my home because he forced me out and I could not afford a barrister like him and didn't get legal aid though I should have done because he was abusive. If my parents hadn't been able to help, I would have been utterly ruined. As it is, I will never fully recover financially.

God I hate patriarchy and family courts and women excusing shit men not paying for their kids willingly as if the new woman is entitled to his bloody wealth, when usually wife 1 has facilitated his career I'm the first place.

Sorry... grumpy today but feels good to have a small rant. As you were. Grin

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 19:35

Yabvu

Most people get nowhere near £700 for starters.

I spend over £250 on petrol alone for school runs, appts, clubs etc

Then there is food - disabled kids with specific dietary needs don't get extra maintenance but the food bill can be through the roof. Many need the heating on more/electical equipment. That's before mortgage, clothes, clubs, school stuff, uniforms

I get under £5 a day to cover all of this. Plus a ruined career and no hope of a proper pension.

Child maintenance is an absolute pittance and the system simply enables deadbeat fathers.

Canyousewcushions · 11/01/2024 19:34

I spend £80 a week on music lessons and over £50 a week on classes for another hobby, plus swimming and a uniformed organisation too. So well over £500 a month in term time. During the holidays its costs me a minimum of £300 per week for camps so I can work, so activities costs actually go up.

That's clearly separate from all the essentials like uniform, clothes, school trips, food, equipment for hobbies, breakfast/after school club etc which all add up. Never mind the odd day out chucked in for good measure too.

Granted, the hobby costs above are for more than one child, but it's really not difficult to spend £500pm on them once one expensive hobby like a musical instrument is added in.

It's stuff the kids love, it's good for them, they are hobbies that have wider benefits for educational attainment as well as confidence.

I'm very aware if how lucky m kids are in being to access this much extra curricular stuff- it's stuff I'd never have been able to do when I was growing up. But fundamentally, if parents have higher incomes, it's really easy to spend it on things the kids want to do, and if you have multiple children, things really can add up fast.

Singlepringle1980 · 11/01/2024 19:33

Exactly. I don’t think any single parents will be “making a profit” from child maintenance which is what the OP is inferring.

Christmasnutcracker · 11/01/2024 19:32

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:19

Yes… this is where my confusion lies

I easily spend this on two children every month excluding mortgage/food. Obviously it’s discretionary spending but it is still spent on the children rather than ourselves.

Both children are still in primary.

DH and I have no social lives so the children can participate in activities they enjoy.

Flufferblub · 11/01/2024 19:31

My ex pays zero

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 19:30

Singlepringle1980 · 11/01/2024 19:29

Following your logic you should also factor in the cost of time caring for the child or children left with the resident parent. At current childcare prices that would be thousands of pounds a month.

Exactly. Include that in the calculation of "half" and it'll be a rare non resident parent who comes close to contributing enough.

Terfosaurus · 11/01/2024 19:30

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:51

It’s clearly an emotive topic.
I wouldn’t be happy that anyone hasn’t had a contribution or half towards raising a child.
I fear this is thread going off the original question/ set of circumstances.

There wasn't an original set of circumstances and question though.

You (basically) said you didn't know why people claimed it cost that much because your DC don't.

As everyone is in a different situation we can only reply with our experience. My DC definitely cost me more than £500 per month. And that's without hobbies, clubs, savings or holidays. I can't afford them because ex doesn't pay any maintenance. Maybe if he did I could have more than the basics.

I only know of one person who managed to keep the martial mortgaged home upon divorce. The only reason she could is because she basically bought her ex out. He ended up with cash in the bank. She took on the mortgage by herself.

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:29

Thank you for all your replies.
sorry for those of you that haven’t had what you are legally entitled to, that is rough.
I set out to understand if people
still want more than half of what I experience as enough to raise a child I feel I have my answer so will leave the post now .

OP posts:
Singlepringle1980 · 11/01/2024 19:29

Following your logic you should also factor in the cost of time caring for the child or children left with the resident parent. At current childcare prices that would be thousands of pounds a month.

Peteryourhorseishere · 11/01/2024 19:28

You sound like my ex husband. He wanted to see my utility bills and receipts for ds food, leisure activities and clothes.

Even his solicitor told him he was an idiot and that was ridiculous.

AnneElliott · 11/01/2024 19:27

Surely the big cost you're missing is childcare op? That's the killer before they child is school age.

Why should the father be completely free to earn and work as much as they want during the week with the mum paying all the childcare or taking a minimum wage job for the flexibility?

Men shouldn't be able to walk out on their responsibilities and the CM should continue to accrue even if they're not in work. I'd take it out of their state pension entitlement if they can't or won't have the cash before that.

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 19:26

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:23

Sorry to disappoint you but no…. I’m afraid your the predictable one to try and ‘ rumble ‘ me …
I’m someone who I recognise from this post budgets well and know that when you separate ‘ what’s yours is mine’…. Is no longer…
interesting how no one has commented on the increasing equity in the house that the Ex wouldn't have claim to but is paying for ( the roof over the head)

I’ve learnt a lot from this post….

I've no direct experience but it's rare the courts will simply sign the family home over to the mother (to continue the sexes from your OP). It will be taken into the general pot and either the mother buys the father out, or the father retains a share, or the house is sold and the proceeds are split. Or, and very possible in the case of a high earning father and SAHM, the house and pension will be offset against each other leaning the mother has the house and the father the pension.

(Open to correction from more knowledgeable posters.)

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:25

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 19:23

It's not about what expenses are made every single month.

It's what does it cost to give the child a standard of living commensurate with their parents' income, divided by 12.

But then …
divided by two.
it seems that many responders say that what their Ex pays doesn’t cover everything …
It shouldn’t

OP posts:
VeterinaryCareAssistant · 11/01/2024 19:24

Thelootllama · 11/01/2024 18:36

Are you seriously saying OP that if your ex partner was a millionaire and you were on NMW, you would be happy with them contributing a couple of hundred quid a month to the raising of their children? Why should the children have to suffer a decline in their standard of living?

If the ex was a millionaire then the kids could maintain the lifestyle by living with him.

PinkArt · 11/01/2024 19:24

OP what were you hoping to get from this thread?

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 19:23

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:19

Yes… this is where my confusion lies

It's not about what expenses are made every single month.

It's what does it cost to give the child a standard of living commensurate with their parents' income, divided by 12.

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:23

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 19:17

However did you guess Grin

Sorry to disappoint you but no…. I’m afraid your the predictable one to try and ‘ rumble ‘ me …
I’m someone who I recognise from this post budgets well and know that when you separate ‘ what’s yours is mine’…. Is no longer…
interesting how no one has commented on the increasing equity in the house that the Ex wouldn't have claim to but is paying for ( the roof over the head)

I’ve learnt a lot from this post….

OP posts:
Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:19

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 11/01/2024 19:16

But you don't buy all those things for children every month except maybe the phone contract.

Yes… this is where my confusion lies

OP posts:
bobomomo · 11/01/2024 19:18

@therealcookiemonster

You spend £500 on food for 1??? I spend about £400 on 3-4 adults and I don't budget

sprigatito · 11/01/2024 19:18

The reasonable expectation is that the child has the quality of life and standard of living the parents can afford to provide, based on their income. So if a father is a billionaire, it's reasonable to expect that he pays more towards the child he fathered, as he would in an intact family where the child was a dependent member of the household. Not a pittance so the child can survive.

What's remarkable isn't this expectation, it's the fact that it has to be made compulsory via CMS because so many fathers and their subsequent partners begrudge it and wouldn't pay if they weren't forced to.