Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To reflect that ‘some chase ex for their salary not child contribution

212 replies

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:40

using ‘ ExDh’ as example as most common situation

Wondering genuinely …

If I was to work out how much extra having a child live in my house ( accounting for the cost of having an extra room for them )
would likely not come to around £500/ £700 a month, what I generally hear is paid in CMS.

Reflecting on the ‘ french private school’ related trending post…

I have seen many people chase and chase for exDH salary….when In reality there is no way that they are spending £700 a month on having a child ( the exDH £500 and £200 contribution of the other parent- due to the fact that the child costs is supposed to be shared , (accounting for them having child more frequently )

I wonder further about this, particularly when people live in a mortgaged property that is going up in price, yet the parent that has paid towards that housing will never have a claim on it …

When I stop and think the cost of my child’s room
their food
clothes
activities
holidays
savings
I just can’t see how it totals £500-700 every 30 days?

when you separate you may loose the ‘ bonus’ of another’s potentially greater salary… continually trying to access it, beyond what is realistic , seems unfair
AIBU

OP posts:
Chocolatebuttonns · 11/01/2024 21:49

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Arthurnewyorkcity · 11/01/2024 21:48

@Christmasnutcracker they shouldn't, hence why I said if they cost more they should absolutely have it paid for by both parents. I just gave a personal example of how id work it out in my own situation

Pungifries · 11/01/2024 21:47

I agree, it does not cost £500-£700 in costs. BUT for me, I have a much higher loss of earnings because my ex partner does not share childcare. I’ve had to change jobs to one with more “child care friendly hours”, I also can’t do the extra shifts that I used to because he won’t have our child.
costs me much much more than £500 a month plus loss in future pension

Christmasnutcracker · 11/01/2024 21:42

Arthurnewyorkcity · 11/01/2024 21:19

I somewhat agree. My child doesn't cost much at all. My water bill is perhaps 10 pound more a month, food id say 200 extra, energy is about 150 extra as I put heating for kid. Clothes I probably spend 100 every 3 months so average 35 a month so approx 400 a month extra minus child benefit is 320 then my half would be 160.
If a food bill is 400, the resident parent should pay 300, their portion and the kids 50%.
On the flip side if a child DOES cost more, then the rp should absolutely be receiving that 50% of the child's cost (not their own) but they very rarely do.

What about medical and dental expenses?
What about music/swimming/sports/special interest groups/trips to the cinema/holidays/days out/phone/trips with groups/school trips/electronic devices/equipment for activities/hairdressers/winter coat/birthday parties/party gifts/travel expenses/restaurants/favourite foods/books/tutoring/fuel to bring them to the above....the list is endless.
Children, if given opportunities if available, cost HUNDREDS. Of course you can remove all discretionary expenses but why should the child do without any of the above because their parents separated?

maddening · 11/01/2024 21:20

The rp is also more limited career wise (am not a single parent so no skin in the game) but if I was a rp then my ability to build my career would be limited as I would not be as free to work and partake in travel for work for example.

Arthurnewyorkcity · 11/01/2024 21:19

I somewhat agree. My child doesn't cost much at all. My water bill is perhaps 10 pound more a month, food id say 200 extra, energy is about 150 extra as I put heating for kid. Clothes I probably spend 100 every 3 months so average 35 a month so approx 400 a month extra minus child benefit is 320 then my half would be 160.
If a food bill is 400, the resident parent should pay 300, their portion and the kids 50%.
On the flip side if a child DOES cost more, then the rp should absolutely be receiving that 50% of the child's cost (not their own) but they very rarely do.

Bean83ts · 11/01/2024 21:18

If you have nursery fees. £500 alone could go on that!

Workworkandmoreworknow · 11/01/2024 21:13

Whoever is paying for their childcare costs are obviously making lots of money

And? Does that mean maintenance shouldn’t be paid?

barkymcbark · 11/01/2024 21:08

Without dc I could live in a 1 bed flat which would half my bills and probably save me £700 a month alone on my mortgage. I can't do that with dc, I have to have 3 bedrooms. Or at least 2 and sleep on the sofa.

But I do get your point op. I had a male friend whose ex wife was awful. She'd insist on him paying maintenance inline with CMS, but worked out on a monthly basis. He could always predict when she was looking at booking a holiday as she'd stop him seeing the kids and then up his payments inline with him never having the kids overnight. It was one of the many wonderful things she's use her dc for. Thankfully they are older now and choose to spend a lot more time with him.

toomuchfaff · 11/01/2024 21:04

SchoolQuestionnaire · 11/01/2024 17:52

I could not support my kids on only £700 per month. If I wasn’t careful and didn’t constantly plan and prep meals ahead I could spend £500 just feeding my two, they’re constantly bloody starving. That’s without activities, school trips etc. It would be spent long before the mortgage was due and there certainly wouldn’t be any holidays or savings. Yabu.

but the idea is that £700 Is the ex"s half contribution, when combined with your £700, surely you can manage 2 kids on £1400 a month?

the ex contribute but so does the resident parent...

Blueeyedmale · 11/01/2024 21:03

My ds is 14 now and I pay 300.00 per month mutual agreement between me and my ex.but I also pay for any games he wants and clothing etc.i think it can be very costly with younger children childcare etc and the cms payments probably don't reflect this enough.

Some of my friends ask me if I begrudge paying it beacuse she cheated on me and my answer is no,beacuse my ex is on benefits has 3 other children none of the dad's now have no contact with their children and pay not a penny.

The other children are not my responsibility but they must suffer with the only household income being on benefits.

Children are expensive but I strongly believe that the non residing parent should financially contribute everything they can to their children.their are many parents struggling and many many cases where they cms contributions don't reflect this.

SnowWhitesSM · 11/01/2024 20:58

Whoever is paying for their childcare costs are obviously making lots of money. I earn the average salary and still get a couple of hundred quid UC. My childcare costs were more or less paid for when I worked earning just about minimum wage and had tax credits.

I think not taking into account UC money for dc for low earners again isn't fair. If the cost is to be half than UC should be taken into account as an additional contribution towards dc and not just the lower earners contribution.

Prawncow · 11/01/2024 20:51

I can’t believe any parent would start a thread like this and not consider childcare costs.

SnowWhitesSM · 11/01/2024 20:49

I don't think the way CM is worked out is fair.

It's not fair on the rp or the nrp who still has the same housing costs and doesn't get his share covered on his days.
It's not fair on the rp paying for and doing the majority of everything.

I don't know what the answer is, dc are much more expensive than they used to be. Growing up branded trainers were a real luxury, they were a Christmas main present, we now live in a world where my ds needed airforce 1s at a £120 a pop twice a year just for school. Yes I know I could have bought him cheap trainers but they wouldn't have lasted/he has extraordinary wide feet and you want your dc to fit in.

The cost of living and the way we want to live has risen dramatically and our wages haven't caught up.

I didn't get a lot of CM. I couldn't be arsed when he pissed about with the CSA and retrained into a better career. My dc or my pension didn't miss out, but if I'd have had an extra £500 a month they would have had more abroad holidays and learnt an instrument on top of their sporting hobbies that I could just about afford.

I think it's the reality of life as a SP, your dc won't have everything material wose that their peers in married families do. That's the price you pay for freedom and (I don't mean this to sound awful) living with the decision of who you made a child with. I don't think it harms dc to not have everything they want either.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 11/01/2024 20:49

Goady post. It's not just about not starving your child and having shoes on. There's school supplies and books, clothes, prom, school trips, violin lessons, whatever sports clubs they're doing, the cost of ferrying them back and forth. Not exactly fair for a father to bring home 10k a month and for his child to not afford hobbies and school trips?

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 11/01/2024 20:48

My ex used to pay £600 in child maintenance every month. Now we do 50/50 and he pays nothing but I’m much better off as I work more, food bill is halved, he buys more clothes when they are with him, takes them for haircuts etc.

WhatanEmbarrasment · 11/01/2024 20:45

I get £7 a week for 4 children. I would be over the moon if I got £500 for 4 never mind 1! I do think some people will never be satisfied with what they get.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 11/01/2024 20:44

Never received a penny in maintenance. At one point my childcare bill was in excess of £1.2k a month. Even with them all in school, wraparound was more than £700 a month. I pay my own mortgage - the family home was lost to the mortgage company during the divorce.

Yes, children can cost a small fortune.

If you are advocating that maintenance shouldn’t be paid, for whatever reason, you are part of the reason why in many cases it isn't paid and why thousands of children are living unnecessarily in poverty.

Christmasnutcracker · 11/01/2024 20:36

And yet you appeared not to really consider any posts that didn't agree with you.

Exactly. I don’t understand the point of the thread other than for the OP to give her opinion. She certainly didn’t want any alternative opinions.

therealcookiemonster · 11/01/2024 20:27

bobomomo · 11/01/2024 19:18

@therealcookiemonster

You spend £500 on food for 1??? I spend about £400 on 3-4 adults and I don't budget

tbh all in I spend just under double that (including takeaways and I sometime use a chef service) but I have health issues so have to be very specific where and what I eat even if I cut down no way could I do it under 500....

RecycleMePlease · 11/01/2024 20:03

The child shouldn't live to the amount the poorest parent can afford (especially since the more time you are responsible for the child, the harder it is to work around childcare, therefore the less money you can earn).

The child should have a standard of living somewhere between the two - eg. if one parent can afford 20quid shoes, and the other 200 quid shoes then the child gets enough for something in the middle.

After all, you can spend as much or as little on the child as you have. This isn't about either parent, this is about the standard of living of the child.

And as others have said, even if the non-resident parent has no overnights, it's still only 12% of their gross salary. Show me any resident parent who only pays 12% of their gross salary in expenses on their child! It's a bargain for childcare costs alone.

Beastiesandthebeauty · 11/01/2024 19:56

I get 75 ew for 2 dc
I have them 365 nights a year

I actually pot out money ( school uniforms and clothing allowances I put money aside instead of it being a big ohoh)
Food.
Transport.
Extra Curricular activities.
Pocket money.

It genuinely doesn't go as far as some may think. I know my dcs dad should probably be paying almost double it but it's absolutely not worth the agro to chase it.

I will point out my dp covers most the finances and we actually put away into the dcs trust funds.

Bainbridgemews · 11/01/2024 19:47

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 19:29

Thank you for all your replies.
sorry for those of you that haven’t had what you are legally entitled to, that is rough.
I set out to understand if people
still want more than half of what I experience as enough to raise a child I feel I have my answer so will leave the post now .

And yet you appeared not to really consider any posts that didn't agree with you.

What about childcare for before school-age? That's about £60 a day at the cheap end. In other places £100+. Per child.

Once they're at school, wrap-around care could be £15 a day, again per child.

£100 a month per child for a few extra curriculars is pretty standard. Many posters have said they spend far more.

So even when you cut those costs on half, you're spending a hell of a lot on children before you take into account the extra housing, food, clothing, transport and activity costs. And of course the biggest killer, lost earnings.

Your argument is based on bad maths. I'm happily married btw, none of this matters to me, but I'm not ignorant as to what RP are up against.

OnlyFannys · 11/01/2024 19:45

around £500/ £700 a month, what I generally hear is paid in CMS. 😂😂😂😂😂

Sorry but hilarious that you think that is standard. Many of us get fuck all because ex is "self employed" and knows how to hide their income from cms. Average salary is 35k in uk so most will be around 200 per month, the higher earning pay more yes but even then it doesn't make a dent on childcare let alone providing food, clothes etc. Also the NRP isn't up at the crack of dawn to sort out packed lunch or doing school runs if they don't have them during the week so they are hardly hard done by. And if the resident parent sacrificed their earning potential for the NRP to end up with a huge salary it's the least they can do to provide a proportionally tiny amount of their salary to give the child a better quality of life where they spend the majority of their life.

Nonamesleft1 · 11/01/2024 19:43

it’s generally shit, and basically comes down to 1 household can’t be split into 2.

unless both of you earn enough to support yourselves, it can’t work.

1 house, 1 household income, does not support two separated families, pay two mortgages, two heating bills etc.

as I said, unless both of you earn enough to support yourselves, then there will be no “fair” option. Someone will have to go without somewhere along the line.

Swipe left for the next trending thread