Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To reflect that ‘some chase ex for their salary not child contribution

212 replies

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:40

using ‘ ExDh’ as example as most common situation

Wondering genuinely …

If I was to work out how much extra having a child live in my house ( accounting for the cost of having an extra room for them )
would likely not come to around £500/ £700 a month, what I generally hear is paid in CMS.

Reflecting on the ‘ french private school’ related trending post…

I have seen many people chase and chase for exDH salary….when In reality there is no way that they are spending £700 a month on having a child ( the exDH £500 and £200 contribution of the other parent- due to the fact that the child costs is supposed to be shared , (accounting for them having child more frequently )

I wonder further about this, particularly when people live in a mortgaged property that is going up in price, yet the parent that has paid towards that housing will never have a claim on it …

When I stop and think the cost of my child’s room
their food
clothes
activities
holidays
savings
I just can’t see how it totals £500-700 every 30 days?

when you separate you may loose the ‘ bonus’ of another’s potentially greater salary… continually trying to access it, beyond what is realistic , seems unfair
AIBU

OP posts:
Stopthetankerimtryingtosleep · 12/01/2024 12:24

My nursery bill is over £600 per month for 2.5 days a week.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 12:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/01/2024 12:17

My view is that the non resident parent should pay in proportion with their income, not just a sum that covers their share.

So if I earn £20K and exDH earns £40K and the costs of my child are £1200 a month he should be contributing £800.

If you earn more you should contribute more.

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 12:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Yeah it’s a different matter when your rent is almost 50% of salary

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 09:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Beezknees · 12/01/2024 08:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

I would have no choice but to, as a single person earning £24k a year I could not afford anything else! Maybe a bedsit.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 12/01/2024 08:46

toomuchfaff · 11/01/2024 21:04

but the idea is that £700 Is the ex"s half contribution, when combined with your £700, surely you can manage 2 kids on £1400 a month?

the ex contribute but so does the resident parent...

I’m afraid I couldn’t. Unless you’re not counting heating, car insurance, their activities and hobbies.

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 08:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Probably not but I wouldn’t have 2 beds if I didn’t need them here in the south east. I stayed here despite high prices (from up north) so kids could be near their dad. I’ve waited 13yrs now still paying high rent and I’ve got 2.5 more years before I can go back north and buy a house, finally stop renting. So yes their dad should contribute to that. He’s only started paying maintenance in the last 2 months despite being a high earner. He’s living in a 5 bed house, he’s been able to excel in his career more than me by going overseas and earning double his salary. He’s only paying 50% of what he should as he thinks like the poster of this thread. How can she cost more than £300 a month? It really angers me how people expect one parent to pick up all the slack, financial and parenting. God if I moved on and handed over £300 for my kids and the rest for myself I’d be minted.

Some women are paying £1000 a month in childcare so they can work and their ex is paying £300 a month in child support as the childcare doesn’t come into it. It’s completely unfair and posts like this don’t help. My ex thinj he can be the good guy, buying expensive laptops and phones and that’s enough of a contribution as he doesn’t want to give money direct to me. Absolute joke.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

BlackeyedSusan · 12/01/2024 08:12

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 17:53

£500 to feed two people for 30 days…. Come off it

You don't have a teenage boy then?

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/01/2024 08:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 07:26

Genuinethought · 11/01/2024 18:07

older DC per child
£300 all in,
If that.
they have the elder hand me downs.
I save monthly for an annual holiday.
they have a hobbie each and some clothes new,
some brought online.
and that’s supporting them FULL TIME
not some of the week and some weekends.

And their portion of bills / rent / mortgage. Why are you not adding that to your total? If I didn’t have a child living with me I could get a room in a shared house, not pay £1350 on rent for 2 bedrooms. My bills would be significantly lower if I wasn’t paying for my daughters devices and the cost of a flat instead of a room. That’s why child maintenance does include this kind of stuff and not just the stuff you list

Zanatdy · 12/01/2024 07:23

It’s a contribution to the rent / mortgage / portion of bills. It’s not just their food and club costs. You are being unreasonable

Iamnotthe1 · 12/01/2024 07:17

YetMoreNewBeginnings
That one parent pays more than the other does not necessarily mean they are subsiding their ex. It means they are paying for a lifestyle proportionate to their income.

But this is only true if the payments are used purely for the child's expenses and if the other parent is also making their own reasonable contribution. Otherwise, there is subsidising happening.

If there is a NRP who is paying a tiny amount of maintenance, or none at all, it isn't said that he's just paying his proportion and that's fine. It's recognised that the RP is picking up the lion's share of the tab and, in effect, subsidising the costs that should be covered by the NRP. This thread proves it with it's 'deadbeat dad' and 'not a real man' and 'bare minimum' statements.

So when the opposite is true and the NRP's payments cover more than their share and the RP is paying a small percentage of the costs of raising their shared child (in effect, being subsidised), why don't we hear 'deadbeat mum' or 'a real woman wouldn't do this'?

Just as there are examples of the RP doing everything and the NRP gaming the system or being a lazy fucker and not pulling their weight, there are also examples of the opposite. That's what the OP was flagging and asking about.

Bean83ts · 12/01/2024 07:17

just thinking of some of our monthly costs and it hits that level

food: £100-150
share of housing costs to cover: £150 (which wouldn’t be near the real cost)
childcare (wraparound) £100 (way more in the holidays!)
piano lessons £75
football £80
cubs £10
a child’s day out or activity a month £100
clothes £30
school trips averaged £20
school diners £80
school shoes £20
otger stuff that come up I.e school pictures, kids parties, swimming, school fayres etc £20
minimum one holiday per year averaged per month £60

thats nearly £1000 a month

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/01/2024 07:00

Iamnotthe1 · 12/01/2024 06:54

But the purpose of child maintenance is to cover a proportion of the cost of raising the child. The mismatches within the ratios are because of the way it's calculated using an imperfect system. The fact that the amount changes when there's a change to the days with RP and NRP demonstrate this.

In a perfect world, the costs of raising a child should be split equally between the two parents who created that child. When it's not, one side of the balance is subsidising the other and, in that case, the payment (or lack of payment) is no longer 'for the child'.

Edited

The purpose of maintenance is for the child to have a lifestyle in proportion to their parents joint income. It is not for the NRP to pay a set half of the costs while the child is with the RP, which is the point I was correcting.

That one parent pays more than the other does not necessarily mean they are subsiding their ex. It means they are paying for a lifestyle proportionate to their income.

Should the child of a CEO and a binman live a lifestyle that is 50/50 based on the binman’s salary? Or a child of a professional footballer and a cleaner? Or a nurse and a banker?

Paying more toward your child than their other parent because you earn more is paying for your child’s lifestyle. Not subsiding your ex. And that attitude is why so many men get away with the “I’m not paying, she just uses is for her hair and nails” bullshit,

rb472 · 12/01/2024 06:57

@Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas
we look after them in the school holidays, we are happy to, they are lovely kids. He doesn’t earn hundreds of thousands, he chooses to pay roughly half of his salary. The kids want for nothing, he buys them new school shoes whenever needed (£100 usually!) and they have brand new iPads and phones. I don’t think they know what second hand clothing is.

I just wanted to add this perspective because it sounds like he is in the minority, but it does happen. He loves his kids very much and wants the best for them.

Iamnotthe1 · 12/01/2024 06:54

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/01/2024 06:43

And I was making the point that your statement was wrong.

There is no “matching” contribution. That’s my point. Parental financial contributions are not necessarily meant to be 50/50. The child’s lifestyle is meant to be a percentage contribution of their parents income. Some NRPs and RPs will pay 50/50, some will be 70/30 and some will be 20/80.

The sentence I quoted is perpetuating the myth that maintenance is to pay for half of the expenses if the child (as it literally said) when they are with the NRP and that is not correct.

But the purpose of child maintenance is to cover a proportion of the cost of raising the child. The mismatches within the ratios are because of the way it's calculated using an imperfect system. The fact that the amount changes when there's a change to the days with RP and NRP demonstrate this.

In a perfect world, the costs of raising a child should be split equally between the two parents who created that child. When it's not, one side of the balance is subsidising the other and, in that case, the payment (or lack of payment) is no longer 'for the child'.

YireosDodeAver · 12/01/2024 06:44

Yabu

How much a child costs to raise is flexibile and adjusted according to the affluence of the parents.

Of course families living on the breadline manage to nake ends meet on a tiny amount. Other families where one or more parent earns 6 figures will spend way more on each child.

When the parents split they are not divorcing their child, they remain their parent. The non resident parent absolutely should contribute in proportion to their income. The child has a right to live in a lifestyle/affluence bracket reflecting their parents affluence. The amount calculated by CMS is a pittance and a decent person who is the NRP and not a selfish arsehole should contribute much more. The money is for the child, not for the ex.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/01/2024 06:43

Iamnotthe1 · 12/01/2024 06:39

I was that poster and was explaining the purpose of the maintenance, not the calculation.

What does get said all the time on here, and even repeatedly in this thread, is the notion that the maintenance payment is what it costs to raise a child or what they have to raise a child on. It's not. Every poster here who has said, for example, 'my children cost more than £500 a month so that's not a high enough payment' is completely choosing to ignore:

  1. their own matching financial contribution,
  2. to adjust for the days with RP and NRP.

They respond from an emotional place with 'bare minimum' and 'what kind of man?' etc. but, when you look at this from a purely mathematical standpoint, there is a clear tipping point. Below it, the RP is covering more than their share of the child's costs and so easing the life of the NRP. Above it, the NRP is covering more than their share of the child's costs and so subsidising the life of the RP.
That's the point the OP was making.

And I was making the point that your statement was wrong.

There is no “matching” contribution. That’s my point. Parental financial contributions are not necessarily meant to be 50/50. The child’s lifestyle is meant to be a percentage contribution of their parents income. Some NRPs and RPs will pay 50/50, some will be 70/30 and some will be 20/80.

The sentence I quoted is perpetuating the myth that maintenance is to pay for half of the expenses if the child (as it literally said) when they are with the NRP and that is not correct.

Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas · 12/01/2024 06:40

rb472 · 12/01/2024 04:38

DP pays £2100 a month to ex for two DC. There are no childcare costs (both are in school and walk to school, 5 mins away) and they stay with us maybe 30% of the time, alternate weekends and most of holidays.

I fully agree that he should be paying his fair share, although for various reasons it does seem very generous to me. When my parents split, my dad paid nothing and we lived with mum 100%, it was really hard.

One thing that hasn't been mentioned on this thread, is that most NRPs also have to pay for extra space, we have a bedroom etc for 2 DSC here, which will have to increase to two bedrooms soon as they get older. So both parents are paying for extra bedrooms usually.

I feel for all posters getting ripped off, and I agree that raising a child is bloody expensive!

who looks after them in the school holidays? Or after they come home from school?
If he makes enough that he is asked to contribute £2100 he must be a very high earner. Does he not think his children should benefit from that? Would he want them to buy secondhand clothes while he makes hundreds of thousands?

Iamnotthe1 · 12/01/2024 06:39

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/01/2024 06:27

The point I made is that maintenance is not, as the poster said “supposed to be for half of the costs incurred for the days the RP has the child over the NRP”

That gets said all the time on here and is completely incorrect.

I was that poster and was explaining the purpose of the maintenance, not the calculation.

What does get said all the time on here, and even repeatedly in this thread, is the notion that the maintenance payment is what it costs to raise a child or what they have to raise a child on. It's not. Every poster here who has said, for example, 'my children cost more than £500 a month so that's not a high enough payment' is completely choosing to ignore:

  1. their own matching financial contribution,
  2. to adjust for the days with RP and NRP.

They respond from an emotional place with 'bare minimum' and 'what kind of man?' etc. but, when you look at this from a purely mathematical standpoint, there is a clear tipping point. Below it, the RP is covering more than their share of the child's costs and so easing the life of the NRP. Above it, the NRP is covering more than their share of the child's costs and so subsidising the life of the RP.
That's the point the OP was making.

RecycleMePlease · 12/01/2024 06:37

CMS is only paid if there is a disparity in the amount of time the child spends in the two different homes - ie. if there is a RP and an NRP.

Taking care of a child takes a) time and b) money.

50/50 care agrees with this, as then there is equal time and (in theory) equal money incurred therefore no maintenance due either way.

When one parent has 100% of the time burden, I think the fair thing would be for the other parent to have 100% of the financial burden personally, and that grade down as care becomes more shared.

And since it's not fair to put an extra time burden on the RP to calculate these costs (which are a case of how long is a piece of string), the % of the NRP's salary seems to me to be the imperfect, but probably best tool available for that.

Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas · 12/01/2024 06:35

I’d say the biggest expense is childcare or reduced working hours. If you have family that look after them it will make a big difference. If they broke down all these things the system would be too complicated and claims would need to be changed constantly. Of all the single mums I know non of them get £700 or any where near it. I’m sure all of them would rather have a had a dad for their kids who actually stuck around/wasn’t abusive/gave a shit.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/01/2024 06:30

But who pays for childcare in this scenario? To work full time you need childcare. Most parents who pay CMS don't also pay half of the childcare bill on top.

The reality for many is that tax payers pay the childcare bill in the form of benefits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread