Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex husbands childcare offer

158 replies

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 15:00

What would you do if this was your ex partners offer of childcare for the following year?
I should add he has them every Sunday 7.30 - 4.30. The asterisk next to days marks them as a Sunday.
How would you respond?

Ex husbands childcare offer
OP posts:
sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:57

SD1978 · 11/01/2024 22:50

What's he done previously? Do you usually have them the whole school holidays or something similar to this? His girlfriend is willing to pick them up slightly earlier, and he has never had overnights? How is this different to every other year? Is it better or worse than what he has done previously?

Previous years he has done more. Normally he has 2 weeks in summer holidays, and sorts all Christmas and Easter, as I can't get those off work. Also until he moved in with his gf last year he used to have the kids after school once a week, but that stopped pretty much as soon as he moved because it was costing him too much in petrol and the kids were spending most of the time in the car.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 11/01/2024 22:50

What's he done previously? Do you usually have them the whole school holidays or something similar to this? His girlfriend is willing to pick them up slightly earlier, and he has never had overnights? How is this different to every other year? Is it better or worse than what he has done previously?

minou123 · 11/01/2024 22:49

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 22:16

No, no one can force anyone to be a decent parent.

But what it can do is to stop him chopping and changing and demanding his schedule takes priority. The court would want to know why no overnights for example (unless of course the OP agreed). I found it just gives a certainty that I never had previously. Without one if he refused to return them there is nothing the police will do.

I'm sorry to keep quoting you, but I'm not sure I'm understanding.

How would it stop him chopping and changing and demanding his schedule take priority?

I understand in your circumstances it gave you certainty because, presumably, the father of your children wants to see his children and you both needed set days as your ex wasn't taking into account your needs.

But sparkellie is in a different situation. If I understand it, her ex doesn't really want to look after the children.

He's willing to do every Sunday and he's only offering more dates as a way to 'help'.

He's only ever going to look after the children on his terms only - even if there was a CAO in place, he could and would completely ignore it and just send his silly list of dates as per usual.

That leaves sparkellie in exactly the same place she's in now.

sparkellie is in a no win situation
His attitude is very much "these are the dates im willing to have the children - take it ir leave"

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:47

caringcarer · 11/01/2024 22:44

OP, this is what I did and there was a tribunal and as well as the chair there was an accountant on the panel. I'd made a list of all his likely outgoings like rent, council tax, dentist, barber, food, pet food, gas, electric, water, etc and they asked him for proof of what he spent each mo the. He had to provide bank statements. When it was all added up it was well over what he declared to be earning. He was self employed and clearly getting some people to pay him cash. He was ordered to pay me about 1/3 more than he did previously and was told if he didn't pay it there would be penalties and I seem to recall having his driving licence/passport taken away as a last resort. He paid up.

That's really interesting thank you.
Is it likely that he would be able to say his gf pays though? As I'm pretty sure they won't look into her earnings, as they aren't relevant. I know the house is hers, though no idea if he is now on the mortgage or even if there is one!

OP posts:
caringcarer · 11/01/2024 22:44

RandomMess · 11/01/2024 16:15

Remember with CMS you can appeal if his declared income doesn't match his lifestyle.

What a shit he is.

OP, this is what I did and there was a tribunal and as well as the chair there was an accountant on the panel. I'd made a list of all his likely outgoings like rent, council tax, dentist, barber, food, pet food, gas, electric, water, etc and they asked him for proof of what he spent each mo the. He had to provide bank statements. When it was all added up it was well over what he declared to be earning. He was self employed and clearly getting some people to pay him cash. He was ordered to pay me about 1/3 more than he did previously and was told if he didn't pay it there would be penalties and I seem to recall having his driving licence/passport taken away as a last resort. He paid up.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:39

Codlingmoths · 11/01/2024 22:34

What would happen if you said ‘I will be at work those days so I can drop them off at 7 or not at all as I’ll have to have made other arrangements. Let me know by the weekend. (I’d go with dropping them as he sounds so unreliable)
I guess if he says no you can’t work but you can’t really work anyway with those hours, honestly I’d die in a ditch before I went along with hours that meant I couldnt work anyway, if I had to give up my job I may as well spend time with my children!

Apart from the fact that I don't drive, so dropping them off isn't doable, that's pretty much where I am. It seems ridiculous to have to give up my job for the sake of a few weeks though, as it works well during term time.
Long term it may not be workable when my eldest leaves school, but for now I want to work where I can. I don't want to be in an even worse position with no pension etc even I'm older.

OP posts:
Codlingmoths · 11/01/2024 22:35

Ah I see you don’t drive. I guess you say they are available until 7:30 when I have to make other arrangements, you could keep them overnight if you don’t want to collect them then.

Codlingmoths · 11/01/2024 22:34

What would happen if you said ‘I will be at work those days so I can drop them off at 7 or not at all as I’ll have to have made other arrangements. Let me know by the weekend. (I’d go with dropping them as he sounds so unreliable)
I guess if he says no you can’t work but you can’t really work anyway with those hours, honestly I’d die in a ditch before I went along with hours that meant I couldnt work anyway, if I had to give up my job I may as well spend time with my children!

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:34

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 11/01/2024 22:22

I think speaking to his parents might well be a good idea. Even if he doesn't reply to you/ take you seriously, he might be more inclined to listen to their opinion of the situation.

...And if they have the financial means, they might offer to help cover the costs of raising their grandchildren (and/or leave money to them in their wills, rather than their feckless son! play the long game, OP...).

If he claims not to be earning enough from his self-employment to pay a fair contribution towards the actual costs of feeding/ housing/ caring for his children, that would suggest that he's either setting his rates too low, or had a lot more spare time than you do. In which case he should be able to look after them 50% of the time. What happens if you visit him at home? Presumably he and his gf would then have to talk to you? I think it's time that you suggest one week on, one week off, and use that as a basis to start negotiations...

You said you work in retail. Are you able to 'buy' more annual leave? Or alter your job to part-time/ job-share? Or start looking for another job which allows you to work more in term-time? (so if he offered more money, you'd be able to earn enough to live off while they're at school?)

His parents are his parents, so me going to them complaining won't go down well,whatever they think of the way he is being. They are decent people, and their only concern in facilitating a relationship with their GC, so I am sure long term they will do what they can for the kids. However, being the ex wife I'm not high on their list of favourite people!
He lives 45min drive away, and I don't drive, so I'm unlikely to just rock up at his doorstep. Plus, again, it's unlikely to do me any favours.
One week on, one off wouldnt work for anyone, especially my eldest. And school would be very hard to facilitate living so far apart. Also, as I said earlier, I am fine with no overnights if its what the kids want, I don't want them to feel as though we are fighting to not have them.
Regarding work, I have about as good a balance as I think it's possible to get in retail, and it works fine outside of holidays. I'd be unlikely to find the hours I currently have and the same understanding from another employer.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 11/01/2024 22:27

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/01/2024 15:25

@sparkellie no, you can't force him to parent his own children and yes, it's incredibly disappointing. I'm sorry. I brought up my children alone and their dad refused to have then for longer than 2hrs at a time.

My way of coping was to try to get on with it. I accepted that I was the only parent, reduced my working hours (because my children were already sad about losing their dad and I wanted to be around more for them), and vowed to give them lovely lives no matter what it took.

I'm through that now and have time for myself again The kids have grown into wonderful young people and those years of doing it hard are in the past.

Thank goodness your DC had 1 decent and reliable patent.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:24

caringcarer · 11/01/2024 22:20

Are you sure he will I lay have to pay £200pcm for 2 DC if he has no overnights whatsoever. Go on to the CMS calculator. Put in exh does not want any overnights with his DC whatsoever as see how much you will be entitled to. By only having them from 11.30 he's making it very hard for you to get a job. How will you manage with so little money and only limited ability to get a job?

I have no idea what he would have to pay as I have no idea what he earns. He is self employed though, which makes it harder for csa to get an accurate assessment and therefore payment, and as tempting as it is,I can't really afford to end up with less.
I have a job, but yes, those hours make it pretty impossible for me to work in school holidays.

OP posts:
Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 11/01/2024 22:22

I think speaking to his parents might well be a good idea. Even if he doesn't reply to you/ take you seriously, he might be more inclined to listen to their opinion of the situation.

...And if they have the financial means, they might offer to help cover the costs of raising their grandchildren (and/or leave money to them in their wills, rather than their feckless son! play the long game, OP...).

If he claims not to be earning enough from his self-employment to pay a fair contribution towards the actual costs of feeding/ housing/ caring for his children, that would suggest that he's either setting his rates too low, or had a lot more spare time than you do. In which case he should be able to look after them 50% of the time. What happens if you visit him at home? Presumably he and his gf would then have to talk to you? I think it's time that you suggest one week on, one week off, and use that as a basis to start negotiations...

You said you work in retail. Are you able to 'buy' more annual leave? Or alter your job to part-time/ job-share? Or start looking for another job which allows you to work more in term-time? (so if he offered more money, you'd be able to earn enough to live off while they're at school?)

caringcarer · 11/01/2024 22:20

DontPutTheKidsThroughIt · 11/01/2024 15:12

Why does it always start at 11:30? Is that a good thing for your kids or does your ex just not like getting up early? Is there a reason he can’t do overnight care ever?
Do you work or are you a full time carer? If you work or would like to work I’m guessing the 11:30 starts are pretty useless.
Good thing on the child maintenance front is that it’s calculated on overnights so he’ll still owe you the full amount.

Are you sure he will I lay have to pay £200pcm for 2 DC if he has no overnights whatsoever. Go on to the CMS calculator. Put in exh does not want any overnights with his DC whatsoever as see how much you will be entitled to. By only having them from 11.30 he's making it very hard for you to get a job. How will you manage with so little money and only limited ability to get a job?

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 22:16

minou123 · 11/01/2024 21:48

What do you mean?

Lets say the CAO takes all sparkellie needs into account, and for example it states the dad should have the children on a Saturday and Sunday 8am to 5pm and on dagys x, y, z during the school holidays.
As the non resident/non main parent, the dad doesnt have to stick to it. He just doesn't show up or refuses to take them.
As far as I'm aware, nobody, not sparkellie nor any court can force him to stick to the CAO. There's no consequences for him.

No, no one can force anyone to be a decent parent.

But what it can do is to stop him chopping and changing and demanding his schedule takes priority. The court would want to know why no overnights for example (unless of course the OP agreed). I found it just gives a certainty that I never had previously. Without one if he refused to return them there is nothing the police will do.

LittleOwl153 · 11/01/2024 21:57

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 18:58

15yo doesn't have a social worker. Has autism, and learning disabilities, but it's never been necessary. Obviously that will change 16+. But having respite in place would still leave me with needing something for 11yo.

Could the 11yr old not then wait alone at home for dad's girlfriend at 9am, or go to a club or something?

minou123 · 11/01/2024 21:48

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 21:37

You can't no...but a CAO will ensure your needs are taken into account and he can't just demand you work around him.

What do you mean?

Lets say the CAO takes all sparkellie needs into account, and for example it states the dad should have the children on a Saturday and Sunday 8am to 5pm and on dagys x, y, z during the school holidays.
As the non resident/non main parent, the dad doesnt have to stick to it. He just doesn't show up or refuses to take them.
As far as I'm aware, nobody, not sparkellie nor any court can force him to stick to the CAO. There's no consequences for him.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 21:40

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 21:37

You can't no...but a CAO will ensure your needs are taken into account and he can't just demand you work around him.

I understand that that's the idea, I just think it will make him more likely to bail on arrangements, leaving me in the lurch last minute. At least if I go with what he says he will probably stick with it.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 21:37

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 20:47

But I can't make him have them if he doesn't want to, and I don't want to make them feel like they aren't wanted here either. I'm not going to fight him on who doesn't have the kids.

You can't no...but a CAO will ensure your needs are taken into account and he can't just demand you work around him.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 20:47

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 20:29

Just say no and apply for a Child Arrangement Order which will take your work into account.

But I can't make him have them if he doesn't want to, and I don't want to make them feel like they aren't wanted here either. I'm not going to fight him on who doesn't have the kids.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2024 20:29

Just say no and apply for a Child Arrangement Order which will take your work into account.

minou123 · 11/01/2024 20:12

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 17:26

Honestly I don't know.
He thinks anything he does is to help me which is why he resents it so much. As far as he's concerned I am the main carer so all is my responsibility.

Ah. I completely get why you used "childcare' in your Op.

I was like others thinking it's not childcare, he's the dad, it's parenting

But now you've explained it, you are completely right, he literally is just providing childcare.

in his head , his only responsibility is to supervise the children while you are working and only for the hours that suit him.

This isnt parenting, or being a father, or a dad, it's just a glorified babysitter.

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/01/2024 19:00

@Mmamadness while I agree that the father in question is pitiful, I can guarantee that your suggested approach won't work. It'll only create more stress for @sparkellie
People don't change unless they are highly motivated to do so and very well supported. They definitely don't change on the instructions of an ex-partner.

Having lived this, I can attest to the value of pouring energy into making it work despite the dad. It's hard to be the only parent and the only adult interested in yoir children's lives, never mind when they have complex needs, but adding to that load with a quest to improve the ex is self-defeating. He won't change. He isn't "winning"; it should never be reduced to a power struggle. He lost years ago by choosing to be a deadbeat dad.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 18:58

LittleOwl153 · 11/01/2024 18:53

Could you speak to his parents, show them what he has offered, explain that you need cover for work and ask if they will take them for some of the time? Would they talk to him and make him do more?

I would focus on sorting out the 15 yr old, speak to social services I assume he has a social worker? Tell them you need respite for hlf the holidays as Ex won't step up and you need to work. You might get a couple of weeks out of them. Or they might be able to provide a 'nanny' type situation for the 1-2hrs in the morning before the girlfiend can pick them up? I know things are ridiculously stretched but it has to be worth asking.

15yo doesn't have a social worker. Has autism, and learning disabilities, but it's never been necessary. Obviously that will change 16+. But having respite in place would still leave me with needing something for 11yo.

OP posts:
sparkellie · 11/01/2024 18:54

UggyPow · 11/01/2024 18:40

Might you be eligible for some funding for a PA through the short breaks team? Or whatever it is called in your area.
Would you qualify for carers allowance for your older child if you didn't work? Or worked less hours as it's different to UC they wouldn't be concerned with the bereavement payment. Might it work out better to reduce if so.
But you won't be eligible for carers if you get a pension or anything
But it could be worth looking at

I'm not sure.
Carers allowance isn't worth dropping the hours for, though it would make life a lot easier, you can only claim if you earn less than £139/week. It's less than 80/week.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 11/01/2024 18:53

Could you speak to his parents, show them what he has offered, explain that you need cover for work and ask if they will take them for some of the time? Would they talk to him and make him do more?

I would focus on sorting out the 15 yr old, speak to social services I assume he has a social worker? Tell them you need respite for hlf the holidays as Ex won't step up and you need to work. You might get a couple of weeks out of them. Or they might be able to provide a 'nanny' type situation for the 1-2hrs in the morning before the girlfiend can pick them up? I know things are ridiculously stretched but it has to be worth asking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread