Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex husbands childcare offer

158 replies

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 15:00

What would you do if this was your ex partners offer of childcare for the following year?
I should add he has them every Sunday 7.30 - 4.30. The asterisk next to days marks them as a Sunday.
How would you respond?

Ex husbands childcare offer
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sparkellie · 13/01/2024 11:13

Codlingmoths · 13/01/2024 11:01

It’s pretty clear who is the obtuse one here. The dad will not have them overnight. The dad does not have them overnight. The dad is not going to have them overnight. Never has, has never suggested it, has never taken up a suggestion that doesn’t suit him, will never suggest it, he does not want his kids overnight and there is no way to force him.

also, he is not getting there until after he’s worked. It’s not the commute, it was the same when he was 15 minutes away. He works in the morning then agrees to have them. He only has them when it suits him. It only suits him some of the time that he is not working. He does not take leave to look after them. He does not have them overnights.

Is that helping? You can get all that yourself if you read the ops posts.

op, is there a reason you can’t drive? Is it possible you could pass your test & get a car? I only say as it would open up the possibility of dropping the kids at his, driving off and going to work.

Thanks. For the sake of 100% clarity - the 11yo has in the past stayed at his, but only if she has requested to, as he doesn't like to say no and look bad. And of the 5/6 times she has asked to stay he has bought her home at least half of those late evening as she has changed her mind and wanted to come home.
I did attempt to drive a few years ago,but was spectacularly bad at it, and it was just not doable cost wise.
Having funds at the moment to try again, I would consider trying to pass a test in an automatic, but would need availability for driving lessons which are 2hr slots here, and would basically mean I couldn't do anything else on my day off, as buses are few and far between.

OP posts:
Codlingmoths · 13/01/2024 11:01

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 13/01/2024 07:54

Are you being obtuse?

The assumption is that he's not getting to you until 11.30 because of the commute to get to you each morning, no? Eliminated if they stay over.

It’s pretty clear who is the obtuse one here. The dad will not have them overnight. The dad does not have them overnight. The dad is not going to have them overnight. Never has, has never suggested it, has never taken up a suggestion that doesn’t suit him, will never suggest it, he does not want his kids overnight and there is no way to force him.

also, he is not getting there until after he’s worked. It’s not the commute, it was the same when he was 15 minutes away. He works in the morning then agrees to have them. He only has them when it suits him. It only suits him some of the time that he is not working. He does not take leave to look after them. He does not have them overnights.

Is that helping? You can get all that yourself if you read the ops posts.

op, is there a reason you can’t drive? Is it possible you could pass your test & get a car? I only say as it would open up the possibility of dropping the kids at his, driving off and going to work.

sparkellie · 13/01/2024 08:53

No, he's not getting to me until 11.30 so he can work. It's a 45 minute drive from his house, not 2 hours. Less when he's coming from work, how much depends where he's been working.

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 13/01/2024 07:54

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 23:08

Just to say as well I'm not sure why you think them staying overnight would be the answer, given that his availability was 11.30-6 on those days?
I was just musing that potentially it would be easier for him, he hasn't suggested overnights!

Are you being obtuse?

The assumption is that he's not getting to you until 11.30 because of the commute to get to you each morning, no? Eliminated if they stay over.

Tbry24 · 13/01/2024 00:11

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 16:03

No. For about 3 months he had them on a Saturday morning and then Sundays, because I worked, but since I dropped the Saturday he now doesn't have them. Tbf if I drop Sundays the chances are at least the 15yo would choose to stay here instead of going to his.

Don’t tell anyone your work schedule so it does not get passed on to the ex. If you choose not to work a few hours of one day he has them (ie gf has them) that is nobody else’s business but yours.

The exs schedule is terrible btw, such useless ‘parents’ out there. But I was a lone parent and never had any ‘help’ with parenting responsibilities at all.

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 23:53

olympicsrock · 12/01/2024 23:36

You need to work on the kids staying overnight with your ex. Sorry . One could sleep in the living room if they don’t want to share. You NEED to work . They prefer to be at your house. All the driving isn’t practical . It might be good for them to spend more time with father and build a better relationship . The long drive is just not practical. They should go for a week at a time.

How do I work on that when he isn't? He won't even take a couple of days to have them let alone a week! I have suggested it in the past, but get told that he has to work 'if you want me to pay you 200 a month'.
He used to live 15mins away, and it was no different then.

OP posts:
olympicsrock · 12/01/2024 23:36

You need to work on the kids staying overnight with your ex. Sorry . One could sleep in the living room if they don’t want to share. You NEED to work . They prefer to be at your house. All the driving isn’t practical . It might be good for them to spend more time with father and build a better relationship . The long drive is just not practical. They should go for a week at a time.

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 23:10

Hankunamatata · 12/01/2024 23:07

Could ex have 15 yr old to stay over the weeks you need holiday care to work while 11 year old stays home?

He will only commit to having them the hours he has sent me, which are 11.30-6 on my work days. So I would imagine he isn't prepared to not work for a full week in order to have either of them.

OP posts:
sparkellie · 12/01/2024 23:08

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 19:12

I have to be fair and say he would probably rather have them overnight than have to do all the driving,

Yes, this is what would solve him going to and from your house twice a day, on consecutive days at times that affect your work

but they don't want to stay as he's never made them feel like it's their house.

He's not been there that long, and it's his gf's house, so it makes sense that they don't see it as their house... Why would they? It's where their dad has just moved too, and a strange place to them. Yes, he needs to make them feel welcome, but you aren't helping yourself with the "it's all down to him not me, and I won't make them" approach. It would help to explain that no "new house" will feel like theirs. No, they don't have a bedroom, but that doesn't mean they aren't wanted, the house was like that before the gf even met their dad, so now he lives there too, it's something you all need to work round together

They also only have 2 bedrooms, and at 11 and 15 of opposite sexes, sharing a room isn't an option

Ok, so one child has the spare room. The other can have their room. They can put a bed in the living room for the few days the DC are there. Or a divider in the spare room. You can all make a reason not too, or you can find a solution.

Just to say as well I'm not sure why you think them staying overnight would be the answer, given that his availability was 11.30-6 on those days?
I was just musing that potentially it would be easier for him, he hasn't suggested overnights!

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 12/01/2024 23:07

Could ex have 15 yr old to stay over the weeks you need holiday care to work while 11 year old stays home?

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 22:56

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 19:12

I have to be fair and say he would probably rather have them overnight than have to do all the driving,

Yes, this is what would solve him going to and from your house twice a day, on consecutive days at times that affect your work

but they don't want to stay as he's never made them feel like it's their house.

He's not been there that long, and it's his gf's house, so it makes sense that they don't see it as their house... Why would they? It's where their dad has just moved too, and a strange place to them. Yes, he needs to make them feel welcome, but you aren't helping yourself with the "it's all down to him not me, and I won't make them" approach. It would help to explain that no "new house" will feel like theirs. No, they don't have a bedroom, but that doesn't mean they aren't wanted, the house was like that before the gf even met their dad, so now he lives there too, it's something you all need to work round together

They also only have 2 bedrooms, and at 11 and 15 of opposite sexes, sharing a room isn't an option

Ok, so one child has the spare room. The other can have their room. They can put a bed in the living room for the few days the DC are there. Or a divider in the spare room. You can all make a reason not too, or you can find a solution.

He's been there almost a year. He has had plenty of time if he'd wanted to take them to spend there, he doesn't want to. So sticks with his 9hrs a week.
He could do many things to help them settle there - suggestions from me aren't welcome though. So it doesn't matter what you suggest to me, or what I think or suggest to him, he won't act on it.
I'm pretty sure he's not gonna move his furniture around to have them overnight on my say so!!
Yes, there are workable ways he could have them wanting to stay. The problem is he doesn't want to. And whatever you might think about it, I am not going to force them to stay if he doesn't want them there. That's only going to make them feel unheard by me, and I'm not prepared to sacrifice my relationship with them to try and force one with him, especially going into their teenage years. His relationship or otherwise with his kids is not my responsibility, and it's not my job to facilitate it. He is more than capable, just chooses not to. If he wanted them there he would be moving heaven and earth to make it work, as I would if it was the other way round, and plenty on nrp do. I'm not sure why your so hellbent on making me solve the problems he has created??
If it helps he was in his last house 4years and it was the same there, so it's nothing to do with it being his gfs house or how long he's lived there.

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 19:12

I have to be fair and say he would probably rather have them overnight than have to do all the driving,

Yes, this is what would solve him going to and from your house twice a day, on consecutive days at times that affect your work

but they don't want to stay as he's never made them feel like it's their house.

He's not been there that long, and it's his gf's house, so it makes sense that they don't see it as their house... Why would they? It's where their dad has just moved too, and a strange place to them. Yes, he needs to make them feel welcome, but you aren't helping yourself with the "it's all down to him not me, and I won't make them" approach. It would help to explain that no "new house" will feel like theirs. No, they don't have a bedroom, but that doesn't mean they aren't wanted, the house was like that before the gf even met their dad, so now he lives there too, it's something you all need to work round together

They also only have 2 bedrooms, and at 11 and 15 of opposite sexes, sharing a room isn't an option

Ok, so one child has the spare room. The other can have their room. They can put a bed in the living room for the few days the DC are there. Or a divider in the spare room. You can all make a reason not too, or you can find a solution.

sparkellie · 12/01/2024 11:25

Luddite26 · 12/01/2024 11:16

Sharing a bedroom is the biggest problem he could make an effort to divide it but he hasn't not great for an 11 and 15year old different sex siblings one with autism and LDs. Father not really making the effort he could it's a bit of a vague offer.

He hasn't offerer to have them overnight anyway!

OP posts:
sparkellie · 12/01/2024 11:24

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 10:53

OP, then gently, what are you expecting?

He would have them overnight, which would solve a lot of your problems, but the children don't want too, and you support that.

It's a bit like me saying I have a free nursery available, but my DC don't like it, so they can't go. And now I can't work. Well...I can work, it's just I choose not to use the help available, which is of course my choice, but I can't make that choice then complain I can't go to work.

If you have made the decision (albeit because the DC find his house unwelcoming) that they can't stay overnights, then you can't also complain that he's not there to-ing and fro-ing every day at the time you prefer, to accommodate your work. The overnight accommodates your work, and you won't allow that.

You need to work on their overnight stays, get to the bottom of why they feel unsure about staying, and how this can be rectified. This is what's causing the issue.

Also as I mentioned before he only has 1 spare room, so would only have one overnight anyway, meaning the travel wouldn't change. It's not up to me to ensure he has adequate housing to have them!

OP posts:
sparkellie · 12/01/2024 11:22

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 10:53

OP, then gently, what are you expecting?

He would have them overnight, which would solve a lot of your problems, but the children don't want too, and you support that.

It's a bit like me saying I have a free nursery available, but my DC don't like it, so they can't go. And now I can't work. Well...I can work, it's just I choose not to use the help available, which is of course my choice, but I can't make that choice then complain I can't go to work.

If you have made the decision (albeit because the DC find his house unwelcoming) that they can't stay overnights, then you can't also complain that he's not there to-ing and fro-ing every day at the time you prefer, to accommodate your work. The overnight accommodates your work, and you won't allow that.

You need to work on their overnight stays, get to the bottom of why they feel unsure about staying, and how this can be rectified. This is what's causing the issue.

I'm expecting him to be the one to make them want to stay. To spend time with them, not 9hrs a week, and regularly work at least some of that so his gf picks them up as he can't. For the days he's saying he will have them to be actual days not afternoons. Maybe for him to arrange some of his work around having them occasionally?
The only reason it's a long drive is because he moved so far away, and promised at the time that it wouldn't matter because he would be able to spend the money he was saving in rent/bills on petrol.
Or failing all of that pay a bit more maintenance?
But I appreciate it's probably not something he will ever do.

OP posts:
Luddite26 · 12/01/2024 11:16

Sharing a bedroom is the biggest problem he could make an effort to divide it but he hasn't not great for an 11 and 15year old different sex siblings one with autism and LDs. Father not really making the effort he could it's a bit of a vague offer.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 12/01/2024 10:53

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 23:15

I'm not going to do that.
He hasn't made them comfortable there, or encouraged them to spend more time there, I'm not going to be the parent that makes them stay somewhere they don't want to be. Plus he doesn't have enough rooms for them both to stay anyway.

OP, then gently, what are you expecting?

He would have them overnight, which would solve a lot of your problems, but the children don't want too, and you support that.

It's a bit like me saying I have a free nursery available, but my DC don't like it, so they can't go. And now I can't work. Well...I can work, it's just I choose not to use the help available, which is of course my choice, but I can't make that choice then complain I can't go to work.

If you have made the decision (albeit because the DC find his house unwelcoming) that they can't stay overnights, then you can't also complain that he's not there to-ing and fro-ing every day at the time you prefer, to accommodate your work. The overnight accommodates your work, and you won't allow that.

You need to work on their overnight stays, get to the bottom of why they feel unsure about staying, and how this can be rectified. This is what's causing the issue.

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/01/2024 07:39

Codlingmoths · 12/01/2024 01:29

You absolutely cannot insist a man has his kids, cao or not. These penalties just don’t in practice happen.

I've known CAOs to be enforced.

In reality in many cases enforcement is not sought but it absolutely can be.

Luddite26 · 12/01/2024 06:16

I feel and I think you know this you are just going to have to do your best with the situation and hopefully his parents may help out.
You can't afford not to work but aren't you entitled to any benefits as a carer for your eldest child or if you receive dla have you thought about employing somebody on the direct payments route which is something you need to look at going forward for when your eldest leaves school?
I can't imagine their being any respite care available with the state of social care ATM but you must start looking at moving forward that way.
I am sorry you lost your husband too you are having it tough right now.
Now is the time to sort out the next few years or at least get an idea of your options going forward until your child is 18 and then beyond. Are you claiming everything you are entitled to?

caringcarer · 12/01/2024 01:50

Also you can point to his earnings in previous years and they want to know why they are lower this year.

caringcarer · 12/01/2024 01:49

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 22:47

That's really interesting thank you.
Is it likely that he would be able to say his gf pays though? As I'm pretty sure they won't look into her earnings, as they aren't relevant. I know the house is hers, though no idea if he is now on the mortgage or even if there is one!

They would not let ok at his gf money but they expect him to pay half on all bills. He'd need to produce a set of accounts he'd submitted to HMRC, also bank statements.

Codlingmoths · 12/01/2024 01:29

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/01/2024 00:55

That's the point really - he doesn't get to call the shots if there is an order in place. He doesn't get to change dates because the OP has the law on her side and can just refuse. There's nothing he can do. If he chooses to ignore it he will be in breach and can ultimately be forced to pay compensation and/or do unpaid work as well as having to pay her legal costs. He can have assets seized or even be sent to prison.

My ex managed 3 months then disappeared. He hated that he had no control over us anymore. I could have had the order enforced but to be honest we were glad to be rid of him as there was dv.

It was the single best thing I did to take back control over my life. I'm not saying it's perfect by any means but it definitely helped me immensely.

You absolutely cannot insist a man has his kids, cao or not. These penalties just don’t in practice happen.

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/01/2024 00:55

minou123 · 11/01/2024 22:49

I'm sorry to keep quoting you, but I'm not sure I'm understanding.

How would it stop him chopping and changing and demanding his schedule take priority?

I understand in your circumstances it gave you certainty because, presumably, the father of your children wants to see his children and you both needed set days as your ex wasn't taking into account your needs.

But sparkellie is in a different situation. If I understand it, her ex doesn't really want to look after the children.

He's willing to do every Sunday and he's only offering more dates as a way to 'help'.

He's only ever going to look after the children on his terms only - even if there was a CAO in place, he could and would completely ignore it and just send his silly list of dates as per usual.

That leaves sparkellie in exactly the same place she's in now.

sparkellie is in a no win situation
His attitude is very much "these are the dates im willing to have the children - take it ir leave"

That's the point really - he doesn't get to call the shots if there is an order in place. He doesn't get to change dates because the OP has the law on her side and can just refuse. There's nothing he can do. If he chooses to ignore it he will be in breach and can ultimately be forced to pay compensation and/or do unpaid work as well as having to pay her legal costs. He can have assets seized or even be sent to prison.

My ex managed 3 months then disappeared. He hated that he had no control over us anymore. I could have had the order enforced but to be honest we were glad to be rid of him as there was dv.

It was the single best thing I did to take back control over my life. I'm not saying it's perfect by any means but it definitely helped me immensely.

sparkellie · 11/01/2024 23:15

Coka · 11/01/2024 23:02

I think you need to have a chat with the kids and explain that if they dont stay overnights some times then you are at risk if losing your job. Ex has offered to have them over nights so sounds like the reason they cant be there 50% of holidays is their refusal to stay over

I'm not going to do that.
He hasn't made them comfortable there, or encouraged them to spend more time there, I'm not going to be the parent that makes them stay somewhere they don't want to be. Plus he doesn't have enough rooms for them both to stay anyway.

OP posts:
Coka · 11/01/2024 23:02

I think you need to have a chat with the kids and explain that if they dont stay overnights some times then you are at risk if losing your job. Ex has offered to have them over nights so sounds like the reason they cant be there 50% of holidays is their refusal to stay over

Swipe left for the next trending thread