Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I ask them to pay? play date dilemma, need advice!

293 replies

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 14:33

My daughter attends a sensory group (she has ADHD and sensory issues once a week). out of this group have come some lovely friendships between the mums, one in particular. We sometimes meet for a play out with the group and yesterday was one of these days and we met at my house. Her son was very hyped up with my daughter and they were playing nicely if a little on the boisterous side (which I more than understand as both have significant sensory needs)
Anyway, I’d asked them both several times to stop running around so fast, and then directly asked her son to stop gently while holding quite a heavy sensory ball that he always carries. I was worried he’d hurt himself or bang into my 1.5 year old who was toddling around. My friend was trying to catch up on work emails at the time so was aware but distracted. .
next thing I know, there is a bang and a smash and we run upstairs to see that the window has been cracked by the ball being thrown at it. It’s a huge crack and will 100% need replaced as looks like it can shatter at any time.
cue hysterics from all kids, me trying to calm everyone down and mainly just checking no one was hurt which luckily they weren’t. My friend left shortly afterwards saying she was sorry, this often happens in their home so she knows how annoying it is and she can send me the number of their glazier.
sure enough she sent me
the number last night with a “sorry about today, here is X number they are really
good. See you at the group next week, remember it’s dress up day xx”
I guess I was hoping / assuming she’d offer to pay but she hasn’t. I’m now in awkward position as my default is to just leave it and avoid confrontation but I really really can’t afford a glazier cost of what I’m estimating to be around £200-250 as it’s a slightly awkward shaped double glazed window.
Is it reasonable to ask Her to pay for it? Go halves? or do I just suck it up and stick it on my credit card and accept it’s part of play dates? We don’t have any other play dates so I don’t really know what’s the norm for breakages in someone else’s house ☹️thank you in advance

OP posts:
Newbalancebeam · 11/01/2024 17:46

She pays. If she doesn’t, don’t be shy about calling her out. And telling everyone at the group not to invite her son round due to the damage he’ll cause and the bills they’ll be left with.

beachlover24 · 11/01/2024 17:33

I’d definitely end up just paying it cos I’d be too awkward.

Gnomegnomegnome · 11/01/2024 17:33

Agree with others, ask if it would be best for the glazier to invoice her directly.

Rosiiee · 11/01/2024 17:31

You can’t afford it but maybe she can’t afford it either?

RobinEllacotStrike · 11/01/2024 17:30

children unsupervised playing with a ball - its hardly surprising somethig was broken.

The main problem is you can't be 100% sure who broke the window.

I think you need to cover the cost.

AlltheFs · 11/01/2024 17:29

I think as you didn’t actually see it happen I’d be expecting to go 50/50 - but she is definitely a CF to not offer immediately it happened.

She’s not a keeper regardless!

SnowflakeSparkles · 11/01/2024 17:22

Honestly? If my son (I highly suspect ADHD and sensory issues so I can certainly relate) broke something in someone else's house that was expensive to repair, I would physically struggle to pay for it.

But for that reason, I would not let him be boisterous and if he really couldn't stop I was ask if I could take him outside or just leave.

Because this scenario is my worst nightmare!

snackatack · 11/01/2024 17:20

porridgeisbae · 11/01/2024 17:09

'Please could you possibly send me some money towards the cost of getting the window replaced? As it was broken by {son's name.} I wouldn't ask, but I live on a very tight budget and can't afford it.'

This is a good suggestion - and seems fairer than the 'assume the other person is totally responsible' brigade.

snackatack · 11/01/2024 17:19

I know hindsight is a great thing - but - You should have taken the ball off them when they were running around with it - 'sorry you might cause damage with that' remove item...

I'd be angling for half the costs - they egged each other on for sure

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 11/01/2024 17:11

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 14:34

Sorry that first sentence reads oddly 😂my daughter attends a group once a week, she has additional needs all the time!

It did make me 😁though!

porridgeisbae · 11/01/2024 17:09

'Please could you possibly send me some money towards the cost of getting the window replaced? As it was broken by {son's name.} I wouldn't ask, but I live on a very tight budget and can't afford it.'

porridgeisbae · 11/01/2024 17:07

@Amislytherin Definitely ask them OP. Those saying you should just take the hit obviously aren't on the same budget.

howlismoving · 11/01/2024 16:53

I don't think you should send passive aggressive messages like the ones suggested. You should just be straight up with your friend and ask her if you think it's fair for her to pay or at least pay halves considering it was her child who broke your window. She should be understanding and if she isn't then she's not a good person!

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 16:43

mewkins · 11/01/2024 15:50

I'd make the assumption that she knows it will need replacing, has sent you the glazier details and so is expecting to pay. So I'd get the quote (from the contact she's given you or someone else) and then say ' the cost of replacing the window is xxxx, please could you transfer the money to cover this. Here are my bank details: '

This is the way to handle it.

And let the chips fall where they may.

You are not going to feel comfortable with this woman again, no matter what you decide to do. I'm guessing you're never going to invite the child over to your house again either.

So you might as well be very straightforward about your request for the cost of replacing the window.

She is going to go through friends fast if she thinks it's OK to let her child run wild in other people's homes while she sits back and gets on with her paid work.

Her fellow parents are not unpaid babysitters.

Denimdenimdenim · 11/01/2024 16:22

Mum always said "you break, you buy".

I would be asking for at least some of the cost, if not all. How awkward for you.

wronginalltherightways · 11/01/2024 16:19

Sorry, but neither of you were supervising the children properly, so you were clearly happy to take chances of something happening in/to your home. They both have special needs. You know that. So they need 'special' supervising.

You knew her son had form for playing in a way that you thought was inappropriate. You had already spoken to him about it. And yet you still left him alone, unsupervised in your home.

I think you're going to have to suck it up and pay for the damage.

If you're unhappy about it, stop having playdates with him in your home or supervise him properly if you do.

astarsheis · 11/01/2024 16:16

I have to go against flow here and say YABU. Similar thing happened in my house with TV screen getting smashed. I let them play Wii with controllers attached to their wrist but son's friend still went to close. They were 9 year olds too. We didn't charge friend's parents for new TV. Accidents happen when kids are at play.

Bookworm20 · 11/01/2024 16:13

She has already admitted it happens alot in her home! To the point she has the number for a glazier to hand.
Of course she should pay. her son has form for chucking stuff through windows it seems.
I'd defintiely send the text @TillyTrifle suggested and go from there.

Of course on playdates you expect there may be some accidental stuff, like a vase or ornament accidently knocked over, or a toy broken, but you don't expect the child to lob stuff through your windows.
And as it happens alot apparently, it doesn't sound accidental.
If he has additional needs and can not understand about not throwing heavy objects at windows, she should of at least warned you!

LumpyandBumps · 11/01/2024 16:11

If both children were playing boisterously then it seems quite harsh to blame just one, even if he was the one who actually caused the damage.
I think it’s fair to split the cost. It would have been better if she had offered this.
Personally I would not be trying to demand that she pays the full amount, by getting the invoice sent direct, etc. There is no realistic way of enforcing it.
Unless it was an enormous window or you live in a very expensive area I wouldn’t expect to pay £200 to have a glazed panel replaced. I had a normal sized window panel replaced fairly recently and it was £115 ( East Anglia).

itsmylife7 · 11/01/2024 16:02

The ball he never let's go of, where was it when you went upstairs?

wasn't one of the first questions " who done that "

LondonBusGirl · 11/01/2024 16:01

SlightlyJaded · 11/01/2024 15:19

OP I think half is fair. Be honest with her as well. So

‘Thanks for the glazier’s number. I’ll let you know once they’ve been round to do the quote and how much it is. To be honest, I feel very uncomfortable about asking you to cover costs - I was hoping you'd offer - because even the fact that it was your DS aside, I just can't afford it. Having said that, it was an accident and it happened on my watch, so how about we go halves? That feels fair to me."

Edited

I think this is the best suggested message, the others are a bit too confrontational.

Other mum said this happens in her house often, her son apologised for throwing the ball so there is no doubt he was responsible.

Ultimately it was of course an accident so I don't think demanding the full amount would be fair when both children were playing together, even if it was hers that threw the missile!!, but she should have offered a contribution towards the costs from the start and I think half is fair.

I'm guessing she's definitely trying to avoid paying as surely the first thing out of most parents' mouth after this happened would be an offer to cover at least some of the cost!

DiaNaranja · 11/01/2024 16:00

I don't think she has any intention to pay if I'm honest op. If it were me I would have apologised profusely straight away and made sure the other parent knew I was going to 100% foot the bill, and organise to get it fixed, as I wouldn't feel comfortable leaving, knowing I'd left them with any extra hassle and cost due to my child. She obviously doesn't see it that way, as was happy to leave you to organise it being fixed, with no hint of covering any of the cost. This is after her son has apologised (i.e admitted fault) so it's not as if anyone was left unsure who did it. I'd probably message along the lines of...

"I hope Henry is okay after what happened yesterday with his ball and the window... has he said how it happened? Emma said he just threw it, and it hit the window? I know we are lucky none of the kids were hurt, as it could have been so much worse, but I'm still shook up and upset about it. I was hoping the window could have been repaired, but having looked again today, the whole window is going to need to be replaced, as the pane is completely smashed. I don't have the money to do this at the moment, and I'm feeling really stressed about it to be honest."

See what she responds to that. If that doesn't provoke her into offering something towards fixing it, I'm not sure anything will.

MeridianB · 11/01/2024 15:58

Sorry, OP, I think they should have been shadowed, given the circs. And because of that the bill should be halved rather than her paying it all.

But... I do think your 'friend' was taking the mickey by sitting there responding to work emails while her son was running around your house with a heavy object - especially as she says he keeps breaking windows at home! So she has really let you down here, then made it 10 times worse by not offering to pay.

For these reasons you really shouldn't feel bad about asking for half. And if you really don't want to lose her as a friend then just only see her and her DS outside your house.

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 15:51

amusedbush · 11/01/2024 15:50

You've missed another part of OP's posts. They weren't left upstairs unsupervised, they were playing downstairs and jumped the stair gate moments after OP spoke to them.

No, I saw that. They were unsupervised and had been told to calm down multiple times - someone should have followed them, not just let them run off.

amusedbush · 11/01/2024 15:50

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 15:44

I missed the update - I still think it should be 50/50 as both the adults chose to leave two children with additional needs unsupervised upstairs.

You've missed another part of OP's posts. They weren't left upstairs unsupervised, they were playing downstairs and jumped the stair gate moments after OP spoke to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread