Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I ask them to pay? play date dilemma, need advice!

293 replies

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 14:33

My daughter attends a sensory group (she has ADHD and sensory issues once a week). out of this group have come some lovely friendships between the mums, one in particular. We sometimes meet for a play out with the group and yesterday was one of these days and we met at my house. Her son was very hyped up with my daughter and they were playing nicely if a little on the boisterous side (which I more than understand as both have significant sensory needs)
Anyway, I’d asked them both several times to stop running around so fast, and then directly asked her son to stop gently while holding quite a heavy sensory ball that he always carries. I was worried he’d hurt himself or bang into my 1.5 year old who was toddling around. My friend was trying to catch up on work emails at the time so was aware but distracted. .
next thing I know, there is a bang and a smash and we run upstairs to see that the window has been cracked by the ball being thrown at it. It’s a huge crack and will 100% need replaced as looks like it can shatter at any time.
cue hysterics from all kids, me trying to calm everyone down and mainly just checking no one was hurt which luckily they weren’t. My friend left shortly afterwards saying she was sorry, this often happens in their home so she knows how annoying it is and she can send me the number of their glazier.
sure enough she sent me
the number last night with a “sorry about today, here is X number they are really
good. See you at the group next week, remember it’s dress up day xx”
I guess I was hoping / assuming she’d offer to pay but she hasn’t. I’m now in awkward position as my default is to just leave it and avoid confrontation but I really really can’t afford a glazier cost of what I’m estimating to be around £200-250 as it’s a slightly awkward shaped double glazed window.
Is it reasonable to ask Her to pay for it? Go halves? or do I just suck it up and stick it on my credit card and accept it’s part of play dates? We don’t have any other play dates so I don’t really know what’s the norm for breakages in someone else’s house ☹️thank you in advance

OP posts:
mrstreacle · 11/01/2024 15:17

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 15:12

I don't think you can ask her to pay the full cost as neither of you know what actually happened.

I would ask her for 50% and see it as a lesson learned about leaving toddlers unsupervised.

In later posts it says that the children are not toddlers, they are 8 1/2 and the friend's child apologised for throwing the ball so it seems very clearcut to me

blankittyblank · 11/01/2024 15:16

GlitteryDirt · 11/01/2024 15:04

thanks for the glazier’s number - have you already been in touch with them or shall I get the ball rolling? I’ll let you know once they’ve been round to do the quote and how much it is. Probably easiest if they invoice you direct rather than faffing around with me paying and then you reimbursing me but I’ll discuss that when they come round and see what they say.’

That's so passive agreesive! If you really want to persue her paying then you need to talk to her about it.

Something like

Hey I feel a bit awkward about this but how do you feel about paying for part or all of the cost of replacing the window?...As I believe it was your child.

I agree - far too passive aggressive, please don't send this! I would also be more humble and upfront - something like that above answer is way better

Bournetilly · 11/01/2024 15:15

If your set on asking her to pay then I think you should ask her to go halves not pay the full amount. You don’t know for sure what happened and although her son threw the ball he was being boisterous with your daughter, which probably led to the window getting smashed. I think if you ask her to pay the full amount you risk losing her as a friend, I think she will understand you asking her to go halves. Tell her you are struggling to afford it as money is tight.

workshy46 · 11/01/2024 15:14

At worst she should pay half. If you could afford it I probably would leave it but seeing as you can't you must say it to her

A friends son did 500 pounds damage in my house, older but i never asked for the money as I could afford it and her son denied it

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 15:12

I don't think you can ask her to pay the full cost as neither of you know what actually happened.

I would ask her for 50% and see it as a lesson learned about leaving toddlers unsupervised.

Sunnydays0101 · 11/01/2024 15:10

Would you phone your insurance company to see what the legalities around thus. Maybe it’s possible for her to claim through her own insurance?

Hippobot · 11/01/2024 15:10

Would you have offered to pay if it was at her house and the same thing happened? Why were they upstairs unsupervised at such a young age? I would have taken the ball from him when you had assessed it was unsafe to be running about with. I think you knew what you should do regarding the ball but didn't do it and didn't ask the boy's mother to take it from him so I think, in this case, it's your own fault the window got broken as you say the mother of the boy was distracted, therefore it was up to you to keep an eye on them both and prevent this from happening. In future, don't allow that to happen and I think you'll need to pay for it. It was your house and you were the one watching them and saw the situation was unsafe but didn't follow through with preventative action.

pushbaum · 11/01/2024 15:09

I think it's better that you offer her the chance to go halves, her son might have broken it but if she was checking work emails and as it was your house you should have been a bit more 'on' it. You could say you've checked your home insurance and unfortunately it won't cover the cost of the broken window.

forrestgreen · 11/01/2024 15:09

I like the message you've got but not about her choosing whether you pay and she reimburses you.

Hi, thanks for the glaziers number, it was so sweet of x to apologise for breaking the number bless him. Have you spoken to the glazier about them invoicing you direct or shall I mention it to them?

Tbh if she loosing contact with you then you're not counted as a friend. It should have been the first thing out of her mouth.

willingtolearn · 11/01/2024 15:08

Interesting - https://www.claims.co.uk/knowledge-base/child-law/child-accidents-compensation-liability

In England and Wales, parents or carers are not automatically liable for the personal injury, loss or damage that the child has caused. However, if a parent was negligent in, for instance, allowing the child’s actions that caused harm or injury, or for failing to prevent the incident – the parent could be held liable.
So if the child was accompanied by a responsible adult at the time of the incident, it may be possible to take legal action against the adult. However, it will have to be shown that the adult acted negligently.

Accidents caused by Children: Has your Child caused an Accident? - claims.co.uk ™

In England and Wales parents or carers are not liable for the damage that their children cause. However, there are exceptions to this idea and compensatory claims could be enforced.

https://www.claims.co.uk/knowledge-base/child-law/child-accidents-compensation-liability

gamerchick · 11/01/2024 15:08

When I took any of my SN kids to peoples houses, I was shadowing them. You don't leave them unsupervised while you check emails Hmm especially since it's a regular occurrence at home. No matter how old they are.

Since it can't be proved who did it I'd absolutely ask to go halves and no more playdates at home.

Snowpaw · 11/01/2024 15:08

I'd just be honest and say I am struggling to cover this unexpected expense and given it was X that threw the ball at the window I think going halves on the cost would be fair. See what she says.

Sunnydays0101 · 11/01/2024 15:08

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 15:02

I’m very keen not to lose a friend over this ☹️I don’t have many. I’m just struggling to afford an unexpected expense and will need to put in on my credit card.

I am a believer in saying upfront what you want/mean, etc but in this awkward situation, I’d consider being a little passive aggressive and messaging your friend to say that the glazier has quoted you xx, thank goodness for credit card as you couldn’t afford to pay otherwise. We’ll have to do things differently next time.

See what she comes back with to that. But at the same time, she could take offence but you’d be certain of her character then. Or bite the bullet and use one of the other suggested responses.

Ohnoooooooo · 11/01/2024 15:07

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 15:02

I’m very keen not to lose a friend over this ☹️I don’t have many. I’m just struggling to afford an unexpected expense and will need to put in on my credit card.

She is not really a friend I am sorry if she is happy to put all of this on you

sensationalsally · 11/01/2024 15:06

Same thing happened to me years ago. Friend didn't offer to pay. I was a bit pissed off tbh as she was much better off than I was at the time, but I sucked it up. After all, the kids were playing together at the time and these things happen. I still haven't forgotten though!

willingtolearn · 11/01/2024 15:05

Whilst morally I agree she should contribute, I suspect that legally any accident that occurs in your home is your responsibility.

Moier · 11/01/2024 15:05

Both children ASD. Both hyper.. Both playing.
Both parents to pay half each.

GlitteryDirt · 11/01/2024 15:04

thanks for the glazier’s number - have you already been in touch with them or shall I get the ball rolling? I’ll let you know once they’ve been round to do the quote and how much it is. Probably easiest if they invoice you direct rather than faffing around with me paying and then you reimbursing me but I’ll discuss that when they come round and see what they say.’

That's so passive agreesive! If you really want to persue her paying then you need to talk to her about it.

Something like

Hey I feel a bit awkward about this but how do you feel about paying for part or all of the cost of replacing the window?...As I believe it was your child.

CactusMactus · 11/01/2024 15:04

Seeing as the glazier has not replied, could you text her "hey, no word from glazer... how much was it last time you needed a window replacing? I'm quite stressed out by how much it might be..."

Christmasgrinch234 · 11/01/2024 15:04

I was in the unsupervised camp until I saw the ages. At 8.5 the boy, even with ADHD should know not to throw heavy objects especially at windows. That’s not an accident. Kids being a bit excited/running around is how accidents happen but throwing a heavy object isn’t an accident.

Nevermind31 · 11/01/2024 15:03

Just ask her if she will settle the invoice directly, or whether she has third party liability insurance?

Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 15:02

I’m very keen not to lose a friend over this ☹️I don’t have many. I’m just struggling to afford an unexpected expense and will need to put in on my credit card.

OP posts:
Amislytherin · 11/01/2024 15:01

We were in the kitchen / sitting room (one room) and play date was there with them in between there and my kids
bedroom next door (it’s a very small flat). Must have been less than 30 seconds between them leaving the kitchen and climbing up the stairs to my room where the window was broken).

OP posts:
TokyoSushi · 11/01/2024 15:00

I think if she doesn't pay the full amount then she should definitely at least go halves, she should have offered already!

Sunnydays0101 · 11/01/2024 14:59

Whatever about social norms ……..who pays for what if something is broken by your child in another home that costs a lot ☹️….

Incidences like this is part of what home insurance is for. Chances are if you ask for your friend to pay/contribute to this, it may well be the end of the friendship or a cooling off of it. You need to decide first what is more important in this situation - your daughter’s ongoing friendship with her friend or your friend paying for the glass replacement. That’s what it’s down to really, unfortunately.