Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is X unreasonable expecting me to use child benefit to buy DDs clothes?

142 replies

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 13:40

Who is being unreasonable here?
DH and I have split up and he gets keys to his new house on Friday.
We’ve just started talking about how to divide paying for DD’s things.
We will share custody, and since we split up, I have been the one to take her on holiday as he doesn’t like going on holiday. He will probably never take her on holiday except to visit relatives to sit in their house eating their food. (minimal costs)
towards DDs holidays. DH wants me to use the child benefit to buy DDs clothes instead. Am I being unreasonable to think that he should pay for half of her clothes and allow me to use the child benefit for her cultural education, as outlined above?

OP posts:
MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 11/01/2024 16:51

CB is not for holidays, cultural or otherwise. Its for providing items your child NEEDS and a holiday is not that.

CB is for clothes or food or other necessities. Not museum visits.

Gymnoob · 11/01/2024 16:41

To be fair to op there have been many threads on here talking about cultural capital. Ie. Things you can do for your child to replicate experiences those more well off get through private education ie. Art galleries, ski trips, museums etc.

So it is a thing. A MN things maybe. But certainly a real thing.

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · 11/01/2024 16:40

It doesn’t sound like 50/50 would be in DD best interests?

WithACatLikeTread · 11/01/2024 16:38

Riseandshinee · 11/01/2024 16:35

I’d be surprised if child benefit covered the cost of clothes for her anyway

Depends where you shop.

SingsongSu · 11/01/2024 16:36

Very difficult to take your ex DH’s personality into account when we don’t know him.
Museums are free to visit as are many cultural experiences you want your DC to be exposed to which I think is a great idea btw.
But holidays are not a priority if you can’t afford them. I also agree with PPs that you should share the CB payment as you’re 50/50 custody.
If he’s happy for you to keep it for clothes then that is a reasonable compromise.

Riseandshinee · 11/01/2024 16:35

I’d be surprised if child benefit covered the cost of clothes for her anyway

hanschristmassolo · 11/01/2024 16:35

I don't think you can argue a week on the beach in Benidorm is cultural education 😂

Ponderingwindow · 11/01/2024 16:29

He needs to pay for the clothing for his house. That is house maintenance is calculated, that the parent is covering all the costs associated with the days that parent has responsibility.

even if you do the actual shopping, he needs to pay for the clothes.

would child benefit cover all the clothing your child needs at both houses for a year, including uniforms?

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 16:27

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:34

How would that be moral. I won’t know what he’s spending it on and he won’t spend it on clothes or activities or books. He will probably spend it on crisps so how is that morally right?

You need to take him to court and force him to provide clothes at the very least for his child, to be kept at his house, her other home, if he does not do this.

Do not buy clothes or other stuff that she needs and send her with a suitcase.

You are going to need to step back and gather evidence that he is not providing adequate parental care for her while he is supposed to be parenting her. You are going to have to bite your tongue really hard, and sit on your hands instead of packing a suitcase.

Your child needs to understand that her fathers house is her home, not a hotel she visits.

If it is not her home - and a home is not a place you bring a suitcase to, and pack your atuff when you leave - then you need to take him back to court and get the 50-50 arrangement and its financial element thrown out.

Play a relatively long game here. Try to hold your anxiety about your child at bay while you force him to step up.

Let your child go to her father's wearing only the clothes on her back. If she comes back in the same clothes, having only worn them for the time she's spent there, take note. Do the same for the next sessions with her father. Take note again.

Then tackle him about the lack of clothes, by text or email. Insist he provide clothes, etc, for her at his house and at his expense, since his house is her other home, equal to yours in that regard. If he still won't, then inform him by text or email that you have been forced to send her with everything she needs, and start packing suitcases for her.

Then take him to court.

Honeychickpea · 11/01/2024 16:18

Katypp · 11/01/2024 13:59

Sorry, how on earth did you come up with that theory based on this post? I think you are projecting just a little.

Just a little? Rather a lot.

pinkdelight · 11/01/2024 16:12

You value holidays. He doesn't. You disapprove of what he values. That's irrelevant. The CB should be split and you can't control what he spends it on for her.

Jux · 11/01/2024 16:07

There's nothing wrong with buying clothes from charity shops, or etsy or ebay or amazon. Mostlly they're cheap and not the quality of say, M&S, but you have to cut your coat according to your cloth.

Yes, you want to minimise the upheaval that splitting up has for dd, but you can't shield her from everything, and if you can't afford clothes AND holidays then you either buy cheaper clothes and have cheaper or fewer holidays, or you get into debt. That's your call.

SmallestInTheClass · 11/01/2024 16:03

Clothes seems like a more appropriate use to me.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 11/01/2024 16:01

YABU, you pay for your DD when she’s at your house and he pays for her when she’s at his. You want her to go on holiday that’s on you to pay for, you’ll still need to ensure she has adequate clothes at your own home just as he needs to make sure there is at his. Poor child shouldn’t be carting a suitcase back and forth.

Jux · 11/01/2024 15:59

Keeping a roof over a child's head, keeping them warm at home, keeping them fed and clothed are the priorities.

Then luxuries like holidays, cultural experiences and fun.

As said above, if you have 50/50 custody then child support should be split equally. If there's a massive disparity in incomes and important outgoings (to ensure the first lot) then you will have to negotiate that.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 11/01/2024 15:54

I think if you're going to have to provide clothing, enrichment, and everything else, then he shouldn't have 50/50 care.

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:37

I do see your point, but I know him, and I know that she won’t have those things looked after properly so I am just trying to do my best for my child, having known him for a very long time I know that I’m going to have to continue to do those things if I want her to be okay.

OP posts:
Beezknees · 11/01/2024 15:37

I don't allocate child benefit to specific things. It all goes in one pot.

If you have 50/50 custody he should be paying half of her clothing costs.

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:36

I can afford to go on holiday myself, but I don’t see why I should pay for all of DD’s holidays. I’m not talking about lying in the Sun. I’m talking about going to cities, visiting museums, et cetera which is what my child likes to do. Is there any need to be so judgemental or petty?

OP posts:
BassoContinuo · 11/01/2024 15:35

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:34

How would that be moral. I won’t know what he’s spending it on and he won’t spend it on clothes or activities or books. He will probably spend it on crisps so how is that morally right?

Why should you know what he’s spending it on? Once it’s in his control, it’s his decision.

He has no business asking you what you’re spending it on either.

Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:34

How would that be moral. I won’t know what he’s spending it on and he won’t spend it on clothes or activities or books. He will probably spend it on crisps so how is that morally right?

OP posts:
Flowerpower333 · 11/01/2024 15:33

Its not savings its education

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 11/01/2024 15:30

Is it a 50/50 split? If so, the cb really ought to be split, morally, regardless of your ex's personality.

Jingleballs2 · 11/01/2024 15:30

Cultural education 🤣 if you want a holiday, pay for it out of your money

mathanxiety · 11/01/2024 15:27

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 11/01/2024 15:20

He should be paying for clothes at his house. A certain amount of ebb and flow between houses, favourite hoodies goings everywhere etc is to be expected, but it's not on you to provide every stitch she wears. At 50/50 she should just be able to rock up at whichever house with no luggage and have everything she needs there.
Otherwise 50/50 sounds more like a wheeze to avoid maintenance payments and clothes probably the thin end of the wedge.

This ^