Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's never a bad time for a sugar tax

155 replies

Time2Rise · 11/01/2024 07:55

I just heard a(nother) politician on the radio say now is not the right time for a sugar tax, due to the cost of living crisis. At the same time, he was expressing outrage at the high rates of tooth decay in children and pledging tooth-brushing lessons in primary schools. Surely a cost of living crisis is a perfectly reasonable time for a sugar tax? When families are struggling financially, it's irresponsible to appease them with cheap sugary treats that damage their children's health.

OP posts:
DelilahsHaven · 11/01/2024 09:55

I disagree for several reasons.

Mainly because any attempt to reduce access to things via tax affects poorer people more, its just not fair.

Plus, it is ineffective, just look at alcohol and tobacco. My mum was a smoker for sixty years. It was her biggest weekly expense in the end. She eventually gave up reluctantly when she broke her hip and physically couldn't get outside to smoke for several weeks. Yes, she could have tried harder etc, but she enjoyed smoking and was very addicted.

My child suffers with severe ADHD and sweeteners upset his stomach, which makes his ability to regulate significantly worse than consuming sugar. We don't buy pop, juice or cordial, but it is not easy to avoid at social occasions, as things with sweetener are much more widely available.

Sweeteners upset my stomach. I primarily drink unsweetened tea, but again the move to some places selling only no added sugar or diet drinks, social occasions can now leave me without a good option, especially if im driving and would benefit from a bit of caffiene.

People with diabetes need sugar at times.

It's actually relatively easy to avoid obviously sweet stuff, such as sweets and pop, but it is harder when it is hidden in savoury foods eg pizza, tomatoey foods etc. I don't want sweeteners in my food.

Theunamedcat · 11/01/2024 09:53

WE NEED DENTISTS
Not taxes

And food does need to be regulated the shear amount of shit that goes into food is ridiculous everything is sweeter even bread it never used to be this sweet I have gluten free bread its FULL of suger I can't make a savory sandwich it tastes vile far too sweet sweetners taste sweeter than suger so when they replace suger it just becomes inedible

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/01/2024 09:51

Portion sizes is another issue contributing to obesity surely? We get gousto boxes and what you get from them is what a normal portion size should be, yet a lot of others who get them complain the portion sizes are too small, still hungry etc whereas we are always full after our dinner.

to me it’s a combination of factors and not just sugar or whatever else they want to tax

Theunamedcat · 11/01/2024 09:49

CroccyWoccy · 11/01/2024 09:33

I appreciate this is an issue for adults (I can't get an NHS dentist for love nor money) but children have free access to NHS dentistry.

No they don't in practice in theory they do but you have to find one with with space and some will only take on children if a fee paying adult joins the practice at the same time

OceanicBoundlessness · 11/01/2024 09:48

It's a simplistic solution to a complex problem and I don't think it will make a difference.

Better education must be part of the approach but that must also mean looking again at what we're told is a healthy diet.

OceanicBoundlessness · 11/01/2024 09:44

Crisps are one of the worst things for teeth. Also raisins that people feed their toddlers thinking it's a better option.

I thought we already had a sugar tax? The removal of sugar and replacing it with sweeteners has not been a good thing.

Deadringer · 11/01/2024 09:43

When families are struggling financially, it's irresponsible to appease them with sweet sugary treats which damage their children's health.
Would you ever fuck off.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/01/2024 09:42

I don’t agree with this mainly because those of us who do make good choices are being taxed because of the ones that don’t and then there are those that have no choice. When I was growing up it was everything in moderation, we could have coke but one glass, we could have sweets and crisps etc but in moderation and I’ve carried this on through my adult life and on to my kids, we are all within healthy weight ranges (I have put weight on but mine is actually due to the contraception I am on). I hate Diet Coke or Coke Zero and anything with that horrid artificial taste

Tabithasettles · 11/01/2024 09:41

Befop · 11/01/2024 09:39

Anyone remember the fruit and veg vouchers given out during Labours government?

Those were such a blessing. I have fond memories of them arriving in the post and getting the kids dressed to go fill up a basket with whatever fruit they wanted. They called them 'fwoot tickets' 😂

Adorable. 😊

Tabithasettles · 11/01/2024 09:41

MistressoftheDarkSide · 11/01/2024 09:38

The whole approach to the ills of modern life is so stupid.

Preach individual responsibility all you like but the fact is that almost everything we do / rely on to live has a cumulatively negative effect on our health both physical and mental, the environment etc etc.

Because of greed and capitalism and the reliance on consumers to keep buying all the stuff we are simultaneously told we shouldn't because it's bad in every way, we live in a time of complete cognitive dissonance.

The answer is always to bilk more money out of the consumer rather than address the sources and reasons for their "poor choices" and frame it as concern fir health and well- being.

Consumers buy what is offered to them, and the competitive market spends billions on figuring out how to get them / us addicted to products, services and leisure pursuits in order to maximise profits.

Capitalusm runs on creating innovative solutions to problems - and then when a market is saturated actually inventing problems to convince us we need the newly minted solutions.

Will a sugar tax really improve children's dental health, or is it a cynical ploy to extract extra profit for the government and the corporations who work in lockstep behind the scenes to make sure every penny that can be is extracted from the consumer?

This approach is akin to offering a child an ice cream and then slapping them upside the head on the tenth time and telling them off for enjoying it. It's abusive on an insidious level.

"Here is a complex challenging world full of lovely things and technology and things which are difficult to exist without - now we are going to simultaneously blame you for being a good consumer and make you pay, pay, pay."

It's in every facet of our lives because money. It always boils down to money.

A proper dental programme would be a better answer that could encourage education but it wouldn't be as profitable as a sugar tax. They don't care about our health, safety or welk- being - they care about profit.

Well said.

Befop · 11/01/2024 09:39

Anyone remember the fruit and veg vouchers given out during Labours government?

Those were such a blessing. I have fond memories of them arriving in the post and getting the kids dressed to go fill up a basket with whatever fruit they wanted. They called them 'fwoot tickets' 😂

LifeIsALemon · 11/01/2024 09:38

You are assuming that we can all become registered with an NHS Dentist. When we first moved here absolutely no dentists in the area were taking on NHS patients of any age.

We managed it eventually but currently, the same issue is happening again. Several dentists in our area will no longer take on ANY patients under NHS. Mine does but he has a constant waiting list and every time you go the waiting room is packed.

I know I'm far from the only person who has had issues finding a dentist for them or their kids.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 11/01/2024 09:38

The whole approach to the ills of modern life is so stupid.

Preach individual responsibility all you like but the fact is that almost everything we do / rely on to live has a cumulatively negative effect on our health both physical and mental, the environment etc etc.

Because of greed and capitalism and the reliance on consumers to keep buying all the stuff we are simultaneously told we shouldn't because it's bad in every way, we live in a time of complete cognitive dissonance.

The answer is always to bilk more money out of the consumer rather than address the sources and reasons for their "poor choices" and frame it as concern fir health and well- being.

Consumers buy what is offered to them, and the competitive market spends billions on figuring out how to get them / us addicted to products, services and leisure pursuits in order to maximise profits.

Capitalusm runs on creating innovative solutions to problems - and then when a market is saturated actually inventing problems to convince us we need the newly minted solutions.

Will a sugar tax really improve children's dental health, or is it a cynical ploy to extract extra profit for the government and the corporations who work in lockstep behind the scenes to make sure every penny that can be is extracted from the consumer?

This approach is akin to offering a child an ice cream and then slapping them upside the head on the tenth time and telling them off for enjoying it. It's abusive on an insidious level.

"Here is a complex challenging world full of lovely things and technology and things which are difficult to exist without - now we are going to simultaneously blame you for being a good consumer and make you pay, pay, pay."

It's in every facet of our lives because money. It always boils down to money.

A proper dental programme would be a better answer that could encourage education but it wouldn't be as profitable as a sugar tax. They don't care about our health, safety or welk- being - they care about profit.

crackofdoom · 11/01/2024 09:38

I would be in favour of a sugar tax if the revenues went to sorting out our dental crisis.

Tabithasettles · 11/01/2024 09:38

Bubbles254 · 11/01/2024 09:21

I think what is needed is more subsidies for the production of whole foods (fresh fruit and veg) funded by more taxation of ultra processed food (including those with added sugar and artificial sweeteners). It will never happen though, the large scale food manufacturers lobby is much more powerful than that of smaller farmers and independent producers. We will all ultimately pay though for this through the increase in preventative illnesses and healthcare costs.

I’ve just noticed we said pretty much the same thing. Sorry. I didn’t read your thread but good to know I’m not the only one thinking this.

Tabithasettles · 11/01/2024 09:35

I agree with you in principle OP but the trouble is that manufacturers of ultra processed foods then just switch to sweeteners. It solves the teeth issue but doesn’t solve the UPF issue.

Massive taxes on food producers of anything that is classed as UPF might help. At the moment UPF is manufacturers use edible substances that aren’t actually ‘food’ because they are cheaper. Maximum profit for them, cheap edible substances for us, very cleverly marketed to us with little to no nutritional benefit to us, leaving us craving more food, overeating and gaining weight and increasing our risk of cancer.

If we make UPF more expensive to produce, less people will produce it. We could also subsidise fresh fruit and veg with the taxes made from the UPF manufacturers.

More information available to people about the health issues associated with a UPF heavy diet and the need for more fresh fruit, veg and fibre.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 11/01/2024 09:34

As a grown adult I'm getting rather pissed off with them pushing what I can & can't eat on me. If I want to eat a kg of sugar I will. Making things higher in price won't stop people buying them it just means it will stretch their budget & given a choice over a pack of biscuits that will get eaten vs a pack of apples that have a day out to school every day and come sit back in rhe fruit bowl I know what most people would pick

Vegetus · 11/01/2024 09:33

AndThatWasNY · 11/01/2024 08:16

Interesting. Do you think drugs should be legalised? My anti nanny state friend doesn't which makes no sense to me!

Decriminalise all of them. legalise some of them! Things like weed, certain party drugs and psychedelics like mushrooms there's no good reason to have these as banned compounds all it does is create a criminal drug trade for substances which aren't overly harmful.

CroccyWoccy · 11/01/2024 09:33

LifeIsALemon · 11/01/2024 09:28

A better way to help prevent dental
Issues is to make sure NHS Dental treatment is actually accessible to people.

It's an expensive thing that's often first to be ditched as you don't see the benefits. We waited until unbearable toothache set in before we walked into a dentist when we have no money and no NHS provision. Then we panicked, crossed our fingers and hoped we could access emergency NHS dental care somewhere as we couldn't afford private.

These days my teeth are still awful because of it and I'm missing several.

I appreciate this is an issue for adults (I can't get an NHS dentist for love nor money) but children have free access to NHS dentistry.

LifeIsALemon · 11/01/2024 09:28

A better way to help prevent dental
Issues is to make sure NHS Dental treatment is actually accessible to people.

It's an expensive thing that's often first to be ditched as you don't see the benefits. We waited until unbearable toothache set in before we walked into a dentist when we have no money and no NHS provision. Then we panicked, crossed our fingers and hoped we could access emergency NHS dental care somewhere as we couldn't afford private.

These days my teeth are still awful because of it and I'm missing several.

ElevenSeven · 11/01/2024 09:28

@Bubbles254 and taxing these hasn’t resolved their problems either; precisely my point.

C1N1C · 11/01/2024 09:25

WandaWonder · 11/01/2024 08:59

Do people really not know about healthy eating?

Sure people eat whatever they want healthy or not but is there really anyone who is not aware a salad is healthier than a pizza?

People know they just ignore it

Isn't this their choice then? By imposing a tax, you are forcing the (typically, poorer) members of society to give it up, not the richer. That forces sugar into becoming a luxury item, rationing it.

Don't get me wrong, I think it was useful, and extremely effective with cigarettes, but sugar isn't the same. Sugar can be managed.

Imagine if 'recreational WiFi' was taxed... You could use it strictly at work for sending emails etc, but you'd have to pay a pound more per hour for WhatsApp, Facebook, David Attenborough documentaries on YouTube (whatever takes your fancy). People are addicted these days, but regulation should be self-imposed.

Befop · 11/01/2024 09:21

But it's still a valid example

Befop · 11/01/2024 09:21

Meadowfinch · 11/01/2024 09:15

@Befop I said Baby Belling, not Babybel 😀

Anyway Babybels are just individual portions of cheese that are £12.50 a kg and a proportion of that is wax. Stupid expensive.

Buy a larger lump of mild cheddar at £7 a kg and cut it up.

I'm dyslexic 😂😂