Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

364 replies

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 22:44

This is eating me up inside as I can't talk about this with anyone else, please help me decide what to do. Last year I went to visit my in-laws with my dds, my dh didn't go due to work commitments. My in-laws are nice people but also small minded. They live abroad in a small town and I can have a basic conversation with them in thier language. One night Dd2 slept with me and dd1 (4) slept with my mil. I have always used a bed guard with my dds abroad and my in-laws know this very well. It's a stone floor. In the middle of the night, dd1 woke up and came to me because she had a bad dream. I comforted her and my mil took her back to bed. 1 hour later I heard a thud and dd1 screaming. I ran into the room to see dd1 on the floor, her chin split open dripping blood. She had not been put on the side of the bed where the bed guard was in place, but on the other side where my mil should have been sleeping. The cut was an inch wide. I panicked and told my fil to take us to the hospital while my ignorant mil got a wet tissue to dab at the wound. My fil didn't take us to the hospital but a tiny medical centre, which was a tiny room with a guy claiming he was a nurse. He put a plaster on and that's all. I only have a beginner level knowledge of the local language and I said she needs stitches but the guy said no need it's enough. My dd bled for around four days, I begged my in-laws to take her to a hospital but they would look a me with a blank stare like they didn't understand me. I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster. I said to please call a taxi and I would pay for it but they said there are no taxis in the area. There is a hospital 20 mins drive away. I felt so lost and helpless. I cried so much. Its healed but there is a noticible scar left which, given the size, will remain. I was never given an apology for what happened and was told 'its just thier mentality'.
This time when I visited my in-laws with my dh, my mil notice the scar and said my dd should have got stitches. I saw red in that moment and screamed why she didn't do anything at the time and take dd to the hospital like I had begged.
I know what happened wasn't intentional but it was neglect and I am expected to carry on like nothing happened. But I can't let it go, I never want to see my in-laws again or leave take my dds there to meet them, I never enjoyed going I only did it for my dh. Soon the yearly subject will come up of booking the plane tickets and i want to tell dh no this time. I get so much anxiety and stressed out at the thought of going back there. I'm civil with my inlaws but i hate them since that incident. What would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
Trixiefirecracker · 11/01/2024 07:31

Why didn’t you get her checked out as soon as you were home? Also, Italy is not that backwards! You could have got yourself to a hospital easily enough, what would you have done if on holiday by yourselves?

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 07:28

Pacificisolated · 11/01/2024 07:26

It sounds terrible OP, I wouldn’t hesitate to refuse any more solo visits. Your DH must be there to help you or it is not safe for you to go.

Not safe?

Ladyj84 · 11/01/2024 07:28

Well the way I see it your the mother and didn't look after your child, sorry but it's your responsibility to have them in a safe place to sleep not someonelse and ive been abroad with our 3 and on 2 occasions needed a hospital, didn't speak the language and managed to arrange a taxi no problem. Stop taking your anger out on what was essentially an accident and what should have been your responsibility.

Pacificisolated · 11/01/2024 07:26

It sounds terrible OP, I wouldn’t hesitate to refuse any more solo visits. Your DH must be there to help you or it is not safe for you to go.

dottycat123 · 11/01/2024 07:26

Italy is generally considered to have a high quality provision of health care available with well qualified staff ( even if you are paying some contribution)Perhaps the HCP who saw DD didn't make it clear due to language issues why they felt the cut didn't need anything else doing.
As a few others have mentioned if stitches can be avoided in a 4 year old they should be. The local anaesthetic injections are painful and stitches certainly don't guarantee no scar. Most small facial cuts are held together with medical glue and steristrips.
It wouldn't have been significantly bleeding for four days though it sounds like it was oozing.
When one of my ds was 14 he fell off his bike and cut his chin open, I work in the local A&E. Ds refused to have it stitched and was considered to be competent to make this decision, it was glued. The scar gradually became less visible and now 12 years later cannot be seen. Remember faces grow but the scar won't.
I think you are letting your upset cloud your judgement a bit and would suggest you plan any future visits carefully. Take a good first aid kit, you can buy steristrips and get health insurance when abroad even if you are with family in Europe.

Lighrbulbmo · 11/01/2024 07:21

it might, probably would. Have scared anyway,
You explained this like you asked (begged) permission to go to the hospital. You should have just called a taxi.

However, mil and fil do not share your parental views and concerns and for that reason I could not trust them again.
They are your dh parents which complicates things, he needs to manage family relations to keep the peace if that is your wish.
YANU to hold a lifetime grudge against them though.
As a child, I’m 51 now, with a still visible scar on my face that happened under similar circumstances and I don’t think it’s anyone’s fault. It was an accident. Falling out for it is not worth it. You can work on being assertive around your in-laws in stead. No no no it’s your way not theirs in future.

AnotherCountryMummy · 11/01/2024 07:18

We can all learn a lesson here: if travelling to a rural destination, do some research - if anybody needed emergency medical attention, do I know the emergency phone number, do I know where the nearest hospital is, do a have a taxi number saved on my phone or an idea of transport, can I say that I need a hospital in the local language?

I'm genuinely not trying to be patronising; I will now be doing this before I go abroad in the future.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 07:17

RachelGreensHair · 11/01/2024 07:14

You are all a bunch of witches. No wonder OP hasn't come back.

Maybe she's been sleeping from midnight until now?

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 07:16

RachelGreensHair · 11/01/2024 07:14

You are all a bunch of witches. No wonder OP hasn't come back.

Much as it's common for posters to disappear when a thread doesn't go their way, she last posted at midnight and it's now 7am. I don't think we can say she's been run out of town just yet Grin

Sodndashitall · 11/01/2024 07:16

If it is any comfort I doubt A&E would have done better scar wise. If you want to avoid scars you need plastic surgeon rather than A&E who will.just patch up as best they can but have limited skill in scars free repairs.
It may be in this country A&E is not the same as UK and in any case minor injuries unit here would be perfectly appropriate. Overall there seems to be lack of communication here as I don't understand why they didn't explain to you what options you had. I also can't get my head around 4 days of bleeding profusely and doing nothing.futher ?
It all.seems rather odd and like you have a broken relationship with them

Longma · 11/01/2024 07:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 07:15

msbevvy · 11/01/2024 07:13

My late MIL's second husband was Italian. They left England to live in rural Tuscany.
She was always full of praise for these "Medical centres" where they did all sorts of tests and treatments that would normally involve a trip to the hospital in the UK.

Exactly!

Bloody wish the UK followed suit!

Not sure what OP thinks a hospital would've five differently, just because we have hospitals in the UK, does not mean they are better equipped than an Italian Medical Centre.

RachelGreensHair · 11/01/2024 07:14

You are all a bunch of witches. No wonder OP hasn't come back.

msbevvy · 11/01/2024 07:13

My late MIL's second husband was Italian. They left England to live in rural Tuscany.
She was always full of praise for these "Medical centres" where they did all sorts of tests and treatments that would normally involve a trip to the hospital in the UK.

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 07:13

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/01/2024 06:36

to those saying that OP should have taken her DD to the hospital. Walked, told their in-laws that she would drive (with their own car), told her DH to organise her a hire car etc. I agree in theory. And it probably seems so easy to most of us. But it clearly was not in this case.

there is clearly a major culture gap and some language issues. We do not know if there were stores (or hotels) OP could have called and if they would have helped a foreign woman.

we also don’t know if there were safety issues to consider. There are so many places in this world where a person - especially a woman - walking along the street is exposed to considerable danger. Having bad reception won’t have helped. I would be incredibly afraid of getting lost (I have an awful sense of direction) and potentially endangering my child…

And that is only the question of whether taking the DD to a hospital was objectively possible.

There is also the issue of whether it was subjectively possible for the OP in that situation. It seems to me like OP felt isolated and was emotionally vulnerable. When two people who should care about your child clearly state that a doctor isn’t necessary? Make you feel as if you’re the crazy one? Refuse to engage with you?

That has an impact. And it seems like OP didn’t have the tools to defend herself (mentally).

=> there were clearly various barriers between OP getting her DD the necessary medical care.

and her in-laws were responsible for erecting most of them and /or intentionally refused to help OP overcome these obstacles. The comment her MIL made during this visit clearly illustrates that she understood the concept but that her in-laws simply did not want to help. Why?? To exert their own power? To distress OP?

we will probably never know. But I definitely hope that OP and her DD will never visit them again. Especially not without her husband present / the child’s father.

if they would have helped a foreign woman

Lord have mercy, she was in Italy, a modern European country!

AnotherCountryMummy · 11/01/2024 07:12

OP, I think you need to move on. You're clearly very cut up about this, but its not entirely your MILs fault.

You chose to let DD sleep in MILs bed. You didn't demand at the medical centre that she was taken to hospital - I'm sure they could have called you a cab. You didn't look at Google maps for public transport options, ask a local shop, a neighbour, phone your DH to do it for you etc etc. I don't believe there was no WiFi or phone signal at all - if you're only 30 mins from a hospital then you're not that far from civilisation.

It's a shitty thing to happen, but both your PIL and you could have done things differently. But you didn't - people make mistakes. Try and move past it.

ChittaChatta · 11/01/2024 07:11

Greydogs123 · 10/01/2024 22:54

It literally explains in the op why she couldn’t get her dd to hospital!
OP in your shoes I would not visit, leave it all up to your Dh to organise. You probably can’t stop him taking your dd if he wants to, but you can make it clear that he must be very vigilant with her care and not leave alone with in laws.

^^ this and I'd be making it clear to DH that I didn't trust his parents to take appropriate care of the children

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 07:11

@PumpkinsAndCoconuts I don't think PPs are being harsh to OP, I think she's extremely unkind about her ILs and acting like they're vile people. See my post below, she's full of vitriol and innuendo, like the guy "said he was a nurse", where did she think she was if not in a medical centre, the local bar and in fact the guy was really a bar tender? Also, what's the problem with a small room?

Honestly!

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 07:09

Umph · 11/01/2024 06:59

I think YAB a bit U to say that MIL injured DD. It was an accident. Perhaps a slight lapse in judgement but I think given that it was the middle of the night, this is somewhat understandable.

Was it a lapse in judgement? Do 4 year olds usually have bed guards? Genuine question, we've never used them, I thought they were for much younger kids who would typically be in a cot. I would've thought by 4 they just go in a normal bed, I don't blame MIL for thinking the same. Different if it was a one year old or something.

Quitelikeacatslife · 11/01/2024 07:09

Look your child is ok, can't change the little scar or what happened in the past. You are traumatised by it but would do things differently if it happened again.
Of course you can go there again, just stay in control as a mother, and be direct with them. Maybe hire a car so you can go where you need to. Probably I would only go when your DH can go too.
If you let DC go without you that's much worse

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 07:08

TBH your whole post is full of vitriol for people you say are kind to you!

Your title is not true, your child had an accident

You describe your in laws as small minded

You never liked visiting them

They took you to a medical centre, it was a small room? So what?

The guy "claimed" he was a nurse? What are you suggesting your ILs did? Took you in southern Italy to some sort of witch doctor?

You hate them

You begged and pleaded ... really?

The hospital moved from 20 minutes to 30 minutes and this remote rural area was known to the airport worker you relayed the story too?

Very dramatic "I can't talk to anyone else about this", why not? Not got friends you can discuss this with? You discussed it with your DH.

Everything seems very dramatic and over the top for a cut on the chin. As I said previously let your DH go and you stay home, although I'll hazard a guess you won't want to do that either. You won't trust them to look after your DCs.

Takoneko · 11/01/2024 07:07

The child was taken to a medical centre. Twice.

We are talking about Italy, not a developing country with no healthcare infrastructure. They are healthier and live significantly longer than we do in the UK and their healthcare system is in better shape than ours is right now. The nurse at the centre would have been fully qualified and would have sent them to the hospital if that’s what was needed. The ILs didn’t take her to a local herbalist… they took her to see a medical professional.

Yes, OP could have been more proactive in finding a way to get her to the hospital if she really wanted but there’s nothing to say they would have done anything different to the medical centre. OP, I think you need to forgive your ILs and yourself on this. Your daughter was not neglected. You sought medical treatment and there is no reason to think there would have been a different outcome if she’d gone to the hospital.

2024GarlicCloves · 11/01/2024 07:07

Ohnoooooooo · 11/01/2024 06:59

i am wondering if the taxi issue is a red herring - if the child saw medical help twice - even if she had of been taken to a hospital it might not have meant she was given stitches?

Yes - OP was so sure she knew what treatment was needed, despite the doctor's disagreement, that she spent the next four days not managing to travel 20 miles to get a second opinion Confused

ColleenDonaghy · 11/01/2024 07:06

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 06:45

They were in southern Italy.....

They went to a medical centre

They were seen by a doctor

Exactly. One of DC's friends had a very nasty fall at school with a large cut on their face. A&E referred them to plastics and said it would need to be closed in surgery to prevent scarring. Plastics took a look and said it was actually healing just fine and that the best thing to do was to just keep changing the dressing and let the body do its thing.

OP insists it needed to be stitched, but it seems the only person with medical training involved disagreed.

I would've thought a clinic is the right place to go for minor injuries like this.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/01/2024 07:03

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 06:45

They were in southern Italy.....

They went to a medical centre

They were seen by a doctor

Hm, good point (I somehow missed that part).
southern Italy happens to be an area I am very familiar with (especially the countryside, that’s where my mother’s family is from).

I do still maintain my point that many users are being a bit too harsh on OP.
but yeah, OP could have walked to the next bus stop (there usually are some, even though timetables etc are sort of crappy) and taken her DD to a hospital.