Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

364 replies

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 22:44

This is eating me up inside as I can't talk about this with anyone else, please help me decide what to do. Last year I went to visit my in-laws with my dds, my dh didn't go due to work commitments. My in-laws are nice people but also small minded. They live abroad in a small town and I can have a basic conversation with them in thier language. One night Dd2 slept with me and dd1 (4) slept with my mil. I have always used a bed guard with my dds abroad and my in-laws know this very well. It's a stone floor. In the middle of the night, dd1 woke up and came to me because she had a bad dream. I comforted her and my mil took her back to bed. 1 hour later I heard a thud and dd1 screaming. I ran into the room to see dd1 on the floor, her chin split open dripping blood. She had not been put on the side of the bed where the bed guard was in place, but on the other side where my mil should have been sleeping. The cut was an inch wide. I panicked and told my fil to take us to the hospital while my ignorant mil got a wet tissue to dab at the wound. My fil didn't take us to the hospital but a tiny medical centre, which was a tiny room with a guy claiming he was a nurse. He put a plaster on and that's all. I only have a beginner level knowledge of the local language and I said she needs stitches but the guy said no need it's enough. My dd bled for around four days, I begged my in-laws to take her to a hospital but they would look a me with a blank stare like they didn't understand me. I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster. I said to please call a taxi and I would pay for it but they said there are no taxis in the area. There is a hospital 20 mins drive away. I felt so lost and helpless. I cried so much. Its healed but there is a noticible scar left which, given the size, will remain. I was never given an apology for what happened and was told 'its just thier mentality'.
This time when I visited my in-laws with my dh, my mil notice the scar and said my dd should have got stitches. I saw red in that moment and screamed why she didn't do anything at the time and take dd to the hospital like I had begged.
I know what happened wasn't intentional but it was neglect and I am expected to carry on like nothing happened. But I can't let it go, I never want to see my in-laws again or leave take my dds there to meet them, I never enjoyed going I only did it for my dh. Soon the yearly subject will come up of booking the plane tickets and i want to tell dh no this time. I get so much anxiety and stressed out at the thought of going back there. I'm civil with my inlaws but i hate them since that incident. What would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
teddycoat · 11/01/2024 08:33

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 08:21

Airport transfers are a separate business to local taxis. For example, our nearest airport is in Bari, three hours away. Are you suggesting the op called a taxi for a six hour round trip? Besides, airport transfer taxis will not do non aiport runs. They're a completely different business, and can't be just called up in that way. Airport transfers are prebooked, have different insurance, and licensing.

I am suggesting that I don't buy this idea that there are "no taxis" to take her to the hospital but there suddenly are taxis to take her to the airport. That makes no sense at all. She said the hospital was 30 mins away so it cant be "that" rural if a major hospital is half an hour away by car. How did she get to the medical centre? why couldn't she have got a taxi from the medical centre (on the second visit) to the hospital if she was so concerned? why does she think the nurse at the medical centre was "claiming" to be a medic? does she think he was actually a cleaner pretending to be a nurse? If she was so concerned about scarring, then why didnt she take her daughter to a doctor as soon as she returned to the UK? - she wasn't visiting for 6 months so she could have easily done this when she got back.

As I said, so many holes in this story that don't add up.

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:31

EHIC scheme does not apply to the UK any more. And yes, of course everyone should have travel insurance. That was not the issue here though, the OP doesn't mention anything about how the medical care was paid for.

Namerequired · 11/01/2024 08:29

I wouldn’t go without your oh again, but would go as long as he did. Yes they did wrong but I don’t think it was intentional. They just thought you were overreacting over a cut. The fact their ‘nurse’ just put a plaster on was probably enough for them to believe that’s all that was needed.
If they are lovely and love you all then I wouldn’t cut them out for this. Do you feel safe with your oh there? The other alternative is oh taking the kids without you and surely that’s worse?

LookItsMeAgain · 11/01/2024 08:29

If this post does nothing else, let it be a lesson to never travel overseas (particularly in Europe) without a European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) though I'm not sure the UK is eligible to apply for these since leaving the EU, but I am open to being educated on that.
Also, don't leave home without taking out travel insurance and health insurance if you're going on holidays.

Didimum · 11/01/2024 08:28

I don’t think your in laws did the right thing here, but also yes, I agree you could/should have gotten her to hospital instead. Though yes, they should also have facilitated that.

How do you know the person at the medical centre only claimed to be a nurse? Is that just an assumption? Based on what? My daughter suffered what sounds like a near identical injury on her chin when falling over and landing on a doorstep. We did take her to hospital and we were told that at that age stitches or glue would make the scar worse and was also more prone to infection.

The scar looked pretty awful for a long time, but now is essentially unnoticeable.

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 08:25

msbevvy · 11/01/2024 07:13

My late MIL's second husband was Italian. They left England to live in rural Tuscany.
She was always full of praise for these "Medical centres" where they did all sorts of tests and treatments that would normally involve a trip to the hospital in the UK.

The guarda medica are fantastic. No queues, no appointments, open in the evening, and staffed well enough to be able to take time, and be thorough.

C8H10N4O2 · 11/01/2024 08:22

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:02

I find the OP quite xenophobic in their attitude. Why was taking the child to a medical centre (twice) not good enough for her? Is it because it was in Italy? Why call the MIL "ignorant" for using a tissue to stem the bleeding? Why question whether the staff at the medical centre was really a nurse, would you do that about someone who claimed to be a nurse in a GP's office in the UK? And if you really thought you needed a hospital after being told by the nurse that you didn't (he presumably knew what the hospital would or would not do) why didn't you find a way to go there yourself in the four days, you are the child's parent and you also had recourse to your DH on the phone. You say it is a small town, not a rural area. They must be some form of transportation. I holiday in a rural area in a less developed country than Italy and there are plenty of taxis (and I make sure I have a taxi number at all times, if my car is not with me).

And we don't know the tone in which the MIL later said that she thought the child had needed stitches, maybe it was with regret "oh, in fact looking back I think she should have had stitches". She presumably feels guilty about the accident.

Quite. Italy is a modern country with professional and regulated set of qualifications for Doctors, Nurses and other HCPs. If the local walk in centre staff tells you they are a nurse then why do you disbelieve them?

The fact that the local walk in centre wasn't big and glitzy enough for you is your problem - you were taking a minor injury not a potential stroke. It was the logical place for quick treatment of a minor injury.

Having had a season ticket to A&E when my DC were small, and happening to live near a hospital with a world leading plastics unit, I recall how reluctant the plastics people were to stitch the faces of young children. It can result in worse scarring as adults if injuries are borderline. The little plaster things were the norm at that age and long term effective.

If you don't like your in laws, work on better Italian and stay in an AirBnB where you have total control. Make sure you keep numbers for local healthcare and transport when you go but don't be at all surprised if when the local walk in centre says "no stitches" a trip to the hospital produces the same answer after a longer wait.

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 08:21

teddycoat · 11/01/2024 06:59

Fine, so how did OP get to the airport for the return flight then?

Airport transfers are a separate business to local taxis. For example, our nearest airport is in Bari, three hours away. Are you suggesting the op called a taxi for a six hour round trip? Besides, airport transfer taxis will not do non aiport runs. They're a completely different business, and can't be just called up in that way. Airport transfers are prebooked, have different insurance, and licensing.

Forbreadalone · 11/01/2024 08:21

Is it possible that a lot of your anger is in fact at yourself for being in a position where you weren’t in control?

Paddleboarder · 11/01/2024 08:20

It was a horrible situation for you both and I would also feel very upset. But I suppose your Mil and Fil trusted the local medical centre to provide the right treatment or advice. You probably could have communicated your concerns to the staff with Google translate. But it's in the past now. Just to add, both of my children have had accidents where stitches were required and provided by the NHS. They both have scars though, but they are older and bigger now and the scars aren't really noticeable unless you are looking for them.

butterpuffed · 11/01/2024 08:20

Surely the medical centre would have said if they didn't have the provision to help and would recommend you should take your DD to a hospital ?

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 08:19

fairymary87 · 11/01/2024 08:14

Don't go again, and advocate for your child

Agreed IP shouldn't go, she hates her ILs. But her DH should go and take the children regularly.

What a joy for the DCs to visit rural southern Italy, the different culture, learn to speak Italian so they can chat with grandparents, it's a beautiful place and they're lucky they can visit.

greasypolemonkeyman · 11/01/2024 08:18

ReadtheReviews · 11/01/2024 00:01

I barely get signal om my phone in the UK countryside.
I've also stayed with relatives at their mercy of where to go because I didn't have a hire car. Taxis not a thing there. Ubers not around. Expect op was tied by politeness to not go to neighbours who may have been far away, elderly, not spoken any English etc etc.
The pile on is not deserved.
I wouldn't go OP. Let dh take them if he wants. The anxiety will be high for you but not as high as being around them yourself.

When it comes to the safety of my children I'm certainly not "tied by politeness" . I do whatever I can to ensure their safety and make sure they get the medical treatment they need regardless of "manners"

greasypolemonkeyman · 11/01/2024 08:16

Surely your DH would have told you the hologram was only 20 minutes away? Didn't you have a smart phone with maps? Disney you notice where you were going from the airport?

I'm sorry but this is ALL of your fault for your daughter being injured and ultimately it's your fault for not getting her to the hospital. I've been in a very similar situation with one of my Dc, injured in a country where we didn't speak the language, while staying in a villa in the countryside. But I took him to the hospital and he got 8 stitches in his foot despite me never having been to that country before and not speaking a single word of the language. And this was 9 years ago!

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:16

Also, if you are married to an Italian and regularly travel to Italy, learn to speak some Italian for goodness sake. Why haven't you?

fairymary87 · 11/01/2024 08:14

Don't go again, and advocate for your child

Wolfpa · 11/01/2024 08:05

Your title is a little unfair here, your MIL didn’t injure your daughter. Your daughter fell out of bed.

These things happen and you will never know if the stitches will have made the scar better or worse.

it sounds as if your MIL is upset that they didn’t make a different choice at the time which is why she is mentioning it.

are you going to stop your daughter from seeing yourself when you make a bad decision?

life is too short , just let it go

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:02

I find the OP quite xenophobic in their attitude. Why was taking the child to a medical centre (twice) not good enough for her? Is it because it was in Italy? Why call the MIL "ignorant" for using a tissue to stem the bleeding? Why question whether the staff at the medical centre was really a nurse, would you do that about someone who claimed to be a nurse in a GP's office in the UK? And if you really thought you needed a hospital after being told by the nurse that you didn't (he presumably knew what the hospital would or would not do) why didn't you find a way to go there yourself in the four days, you are the child's parent and you also had recourse to your DH on the phone. You say it is a small town, not a rural area. They must be some form of transportation. I holiday in a rural area in a less developed country than Italy and there are plenty of taxis (and I make sure I have a taxi number at all times, if my car is not with me).

And we don't know the tone in which the MIL later said that she thought the child had needed stitches, maybe it was with regret "oh, in fact looking back I think she should have had stitches". She presumably feels guilty about the accident.

LookItsMeAgain · 11/01/2024 08:02

Accidents happen. I would strongly urge you to learn Italian or any other European language as most Europeans can speak their own language and at least one other (even to the level of asking where the hospital is and can I have the bill please).
Also, you mention that your DD may have a scar for the rest of her life because of this incident, and I think that isn't necessarily true. You could investigate getting some cosmetic surgery to remove the scar, because I believe that every time you look at your DD, you see the same accident happening again and again and again and you can't get past it.
I'm not suggesting that you resume visits to your DH's parents but I do think you need to accept even a portion of culpability because during the 3 or 4 days after the accident happened, you didn't approach any taxi drivers or by the sounds of it anyone to ask for their help for your daughter, you didn't even phone your DH from the town/village and hand your phone to another person so that they could converse in Italian and understand what you needed. You also didn't even phone 112 from a landline which is the emergency number for ambulance/fire/police.
I don't want to pile on as I can genuinely understand how distressed you were at the time but it's not just MiL who injured your DD, it was FiL and it was to a degree you as well.
Why didn't you bring your DD to your GP or to hospital in the UK on your return? There were plenty of opportunities to improve this situation but I would strongly urge you to not cut these in-laws off but to definitely stay elsewhere when you do visit.
I don't know who your inlaws are but I can only imagine that they are eating themselves up at the possibility that they have permanently scarred their granddaughter.
Everyone makes mistakes.

girlgonenorth · 11/01/2024 07:55

My daughter got a deep cut on her chin at about that age, we went to hospital and she gad stitches, she’s 22 now and still has a scar

Dancerprancer19 · 11/01/2024 07:46

The wrong side of the bed thing is a really easy mistake to make and not something to be angry about in and of itself but the subsequent treat is appalling. I wouldn’t ever see them again either.

barkymcbark · 11/01/2024 07:44

What's down is done so no point milling over it. It does sound like they handled it badly, there's no way I'd have refused a mother wanting to go to a hospital with their child, no matter how silly I thought it was.

But you do have choices.

You can choose to never see them again, your dh goes alone to see them.

You could go but stay in a hotel, in a more populated area and your mil and fil stay there too

Invite them to stay with you this year

Go low contact and speak to them over the phone / FaceTime.

I get that it must have been scary in a place with no taxi and limited language. You're getting a hard time here which I don't think is entirely justified

PriOn1 · 11/01/2024 07:44

Biazarre that your MIL would comment that your daughter should have had stitches without being incredibly apologetic. Did she admit their part in not getting them?

For what it’s worth, your daughter’s face will grow and the scar won’t. Good advice from a PP on watching out/checking with a dentist on jaw alignment.

As other have said though, I wouldn’t be taking your children back there without DH and some means of transport you can use. This time there is no serious harm done, but next time you might not be so lucky.

If you have no choice, is it possible to find out the emergency number so you are prepared? Most times if you ring it, there will be someone with at least some English who can help, even in the middle of nowhere.

Catza · 11/01/2024 07:37

LittleGreenDragons · 11/01/2024 00:46

To be fair OP hasn't stated how many times they have visited each other. I was basing my assumption on two visits a year so 8 visits in total with 6 months forgetting time in between each visit. A four yr old won't remember so yes, a stranger.

OP spoke on the phone to DH. He could have googled hospital, taxi firm and texted her phrases to use. Or demand his parents take his child. So many options really.

My grandparents lived abroad and I saw them twice a year until the age of 11. I absolutely remembered them and had a very close relationship with my grandmother. Still have memories of falling asleep on my grandmother’s lap at the age of 3 (I know I was 3 because I remember being picked up at the airport. We took a train after I turned 4).

bobomomo · 11/01/2024 07:36

Fair enough that in the middle of the night it would have been hard to go without help from the in laws but the following morning you could have used Google Maps to locate the hospital and either located a cab or public transport - it's Italy not Timbuktu! Google translate is ok to get any phrases you need re transport.