Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

364 replies

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 22:44

This is eating me up inside as I can't talk about this with anyone else, please help me decide what to do. Last year I went to visit my in-laws with my dds, my dh didn't go due to work commitments. My in-laws are nice people but also small minded. They live abroad in a small town and I can have a basic conversation with them in thier language. One night Dd2 slept with me and dd1 (4) slept with my mil. I have always used a bed guard with my dds abroad and my in-laws know this very well. It's a stone floor. In the middle of the night, dd1 woke up and came to me because she had a bad dream. I comforted her and my mil took her back to bed. 1 hour later I heard a thud and dd1 screaming. I ran into the room to see dd1 on the floor, her chin split open dripping blood. She had not been put on the side of the bed where the bed guard was in place, but on the other side where my mil should have been sleeping. The cut was an inch wide. I panicked and told my fil to take us to the hospital while my ignorant mil got a wet tissue to dab at the wound. My fil didn't take us to the hospital but a tiny medical centre, which was a tiny room with a guy claiming he was a nurse. He put a plaster on and that's all. I only have a beginner level knowledge of the local language and I said she needs stitches but the guy said no need it's enough. My dd bled for around four days, I begged my in-laws to take her to a hospital but they would look a me with a blank stare like they didn't understand me. I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster. I said to please call a taxi and I would pay for it but they said there are no taxis in the area. There is a hospital 20 mins drive away. I felt so lost and helpless. I cried so much. Its healed but there is a noticible scar left which, given the size, will remain. I was never given an apology for what happened and was told 'its just thier mentality'.
This time when I visited my in-laws with my dh, my mil notice the scar and said my dd should have got stitches. I saw red in that moment and screamed why she didn't do anything at the time and take dd to the hospital like I had begged.
I know what happened wasn't intentional but it was neglect and I am expected to carry on like nothing happened. But I can't let it go, I never want to see my in-laws again or leave take my dds there to meet them, I never enjoyed going I only did it for my dh. Soon the yearly subject will come up of booking the plane tickets and i want to tell dh no this time. I get so much anxiety and stressed out at the thought of going back there. I'm civil with my inlaws but i hate them since that incident. What would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
silverbubbles · 11/01/2024 09:35

You know the responsibility for your daughter falls on your shoulders which is why you remain so angry about this. You were with her and you should have got her to hospital if that was what was required.

Southern Italy is hardly the Congo and you found out that a hospital was only 20 minutes away.

If this is really eating you up then get some counselling to get over the problem,

I don't think you should be simply blaming your inlaws or your dh. You need to accept the fact that you are the mother, you were with her and you could have done more.

Put this behind you and be thankful that it was just a minor accident. How would you have behaved if it had been more serious?

whatsappdoc · 11/01/2024 09:30

You screamed at mil a year later? Maybe she was agreeing that the 'nurse' didn't do enough. Maybe she felt guilty. I wouldn't want you in the house overreacting like that, your dh must have been really embarrassed. Must have been a lovely visit for all involved.

And two of my dds had 'dripping blood' chin injuries and only had steri-strips. Is it normal to have stitches?

Spaghettieis · 11/01/2024 09:28

Why are you only capable of holding a basic conversation when it’s been at least 5 years and Italian is one of the easiest languages? You need to put some work into learning it for your DDs’ sake.

If she’d needed stitches they would have done it or said so at the medical centre.

GreatGateauxsby · 11/01/2024 09:28

Sorry if it was asked and I missed it but What did your husband say about all this?

You spoke to him and so will have explained what happened and the injury.
Presumably you sent photos of her face?

Only asking as initially i assumed this was a big injury but based on how the thread has developed I'm wondering if your perception of it is more catastrophic/traumatic than the reality.
Being isolated / alone/ feeling out of control etc. can be really distressing and it sounds like there is more going on with the in laws

VimtoVimto · 11/01/2024 09:23

I was expecting the back of beyond not Italy.

Didn’t your travel insurance have a helpline you could call to advise you?

If you are a frequent visitor to an area especially with young children I’d advise you to familiarise yourself with the medical system and location of facilities in advance of going. I’d also advise learning the language especially if you want your children to grow up speaking both languages.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 09:23

lovescats3 · 11/01/2024 09:05

It's a hard no you are not agreeing to the children going there, your first responsibility is to your children's welfare not your husband's or his relatives wishes

It's a hard no that OP makes to decide they joint children don't get to see their grandparents!

A very hard no, I would divorce my DH if after the events detailed said I wasn't to take our children and I can assure you that the time the children were with me they would be visiting my parents,

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 09:23

Between now and your next visit, download a language app, practice with your dh, and your next visit will be very different.

I think you freaked out. It looks very foreign down here. Northern Italians think of the south as backward. It gets a bit less cash spent on it. Its definitely not flash, but it's just as functional, and often better than the uk in many ways.

Either don't come alone, or equip yourself with enough language to feel safe, competent, and independent. Your kids will thank you for making the effort.

It's not hard to find an overbearing, narcissistic Nonna. I think the stereotype enables them. It's possible that your MIL was happy with what the guarda medica said, and that was the end of it for her. She might be lovely, but quite innocently, with ways you find infuriating.

I'd also drive, if you can. There is no way you could get from our house to a hospital without a car, at any time of the day. No busses, no taxis. Wed ring an ambulance if it was an emergency and the car wasn't available.

The guarda medica are out of hours doctors, you probably wouldn't have got a different response at the hospital. Its the same doctors! Honestly, you need to learn the language to build a relationship with your in laws.

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 09:22

The problem here is the OP was in an emergency situation.

It wasn't an emergency.

pronounsbundlebundle · 11/01/2024 09:13

My goodness this thread! I've been to lots of places where there isn't internet or taxis and in some cases where both aren't available.

The problem here is the the OP was in an emergency situation. Had she known that her PIL were going to ignore her clear wishes then presumably she wouldn't have taken the same decisions and that's why she's thinking again about the situation.

FWIW OP I wouldn't visit without your DH again, ever.

I've been abroad with in laws and been ill and I assumed they'd take me to a medical centre on request - they didn't and questioned my medical need. Sometimes there are very nasty realisations in these situations. If you don't have your own car / can't drive in a situation like that it is very difficult. In my case I forced the issue and it wasn't an emergency, thankfully, but it's very easy to end up in a much more isolated situation than you expect if the people who should help you don't.

They should have done as you asked, however they did take your DD to a medical centre. Nevertheless, I would NEVER visit again without your DH, you are far too isolated without him there to translatte and advocate for you with his parents. You know they don't listen to your opinion now or respect your parental authority.

lovescats3 · 11/01/2024 09:11

I don't understand why your daughter slept in her grandmother's bed if there aren't enough beds you should go to a hotel or Airbnb

catelynjane · 11/01/2024 09:06

This is all very odd.

Your MIL didn't injure anyone - your 4yo fell out of bed as 4yo's are prone to do. It was an accident.

Your FIL then took you to get medical care in the middle of the night and you as the parent were unhappy but you still didn't find a way to get your injured child to the hospital over the next four days Confused

I have to say I agree with the PP saying you feel guilty and are unfairly taking it on your MIL

You're the parent - it's your responsibility to get the appropriate medical treatment for your child, and if you're going to go somewhere where you don't speak the language then you need to take a guide book.

lovescats3 · 11/01/2024 09:05

It's a hard no you are not agreeing to the children going there, your first responsibility is to your children's welfare not your husband's or his relatives wishes

diddl · 11/01/2024 09:02

I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster.

And what did/does your husband think of all this Op?

Tbh that's the point at which my husband would have organised for me to leave & had a hard think about his parents attitude to his wife & kids.

ChangeAgain2 · 11/01/2024 09:02

I think your being unreasonable. It was an accidents. It wasn't on purpose. They are at fault for not following your wishes and taking DC to the hospital as requested. They should have done what you wanted as the parent. However, I don't know what the medical provision is like in their area. It imagine they took DC to where thet would have gone if the got injured. You could have taken your child by taxi to the hospital if you wanted. Personally, I wouldn't want to go to visit the inlaws without my H in a country where I don't speak the language so maybe insist he comes as well.

I have a scar on my chin. I had an operation as a small child. It's not very visible. My mum massaged the scar every day with a tiny bit of olive oil. It was very red and raised and now its a fine line. Its worth a try. If it still looks bad you could consider having it corrected in the future.

Scarlettpixie · 11/01/2024 08:59

Your in-laws weren’t neglectful. Accidents happen. They took you to minor injuries twice. Presumably that is usual practice for this type of thing. If my DS had cut his chin, I would take to minor injuries here in the uk, not A&E. Pretty sure it is normal to do that here too. I cut my chin age 2 and had stitches. I still have a scar. It was stitched by a GP who was on call. We met him at the surgery and he didn’t use any anaesthetic. Gotta love the 70s! These things happen.

You sound very nasty about your MIL and the medical centre. So what if the room was small. Why doubt that he was a nurse? Your MIL comment about it should have been stitched likely means she thinks the nurse should have done it. I am sure she feel terrible regardless of how it comes across.

You could have got your husband to look up hospitals/transport and generally help with communication but even if you went to the hospital the outcome might have been the same, I suspect your in laws just felt that hospital was not the right setting. The travel insurance company would also have helped you if you had any.

i think you need to move on from this. If you cannot deal with the practicalities of being in rural italy then don’t go without your husband.

I don’t think you should deprive your children of some lovely memories of visiting rural italy and you can’t stop your husband taking them in any event.

Invest in some blow up beds for the children or stay in a hotel. Learn more of the language. Hire a car. Make a plan for any future emergencies. take out travel insurance.

ISSTIUTNG · 11/01/2024 08:52

OP it sounds like you're being a total drama llama tbh. You describe your MIL as injuring your dd. She didn't, you were all awkwardly crammed into single beds and she fell out. Unfortunate but only a minor fault if any at all of your MIL.

It sounds like the medical centre was the equivalent to a minor injuries unit here. I'd expect that the same medical treatment was offered to her as it would have been in ED and even stitches used if appropriate. It could be that the nearest true ED is absolutely miles away and generally only used for serious trauma/illness in such a rural area. It could also be that whatever word you were saying to mean hospital they were interpretting as the medical centre she was taken twice to. This may explain why your PIL perhaps didn't quite know what you wanted. Even if her head was bleeding slightly doesn't mean she needed stitches.

I'm a doctor and don't see much wrong with how MIL initially managed the wound. Your priority is to apply pressure to the wound to minimise bleeding and keep it as clean as possible. You're being really harsh on her tbh.

Tbh if she'd been bleeding significantly I think you'd be describing it much more dramatically than you have. A little bleeding into a dressing is fine. It's no easy thing suturing such a small child. It would have been distressing and painful for her and likely led to worse scarring

I can see why the situation was scary and frustrating for you but as pp have said take some responsibility. The buck stops with you ITO your child's health and safety. If you'd been that desperate for 4 whole days then you should have found a way to get her to a hospital. At the very least could you have called your husband and communicated how worried you are and asked him to act as more of an interpretor and help you

Do what you need to. Go no/low contact with PIL if it makes you feel better but you're a parent. It's your responsibility to be a bit less precious and ensure that from now on wherever you are in the world you know how to advocate for your child and stay calm in a crisis. It doesn't actually sound like any major harm was done so the most healthy thing you can do is probably just to let it go. Your anxieties will rub off on your children and that could be far more damaging than a small cut

Kittylala · 11/01/2024 08:48

The lack of control is horrendus. I know. My mother in europe got in a strop on the day and then accused me of hurting my daughter when her arm was limp. She wouldn't even take us to a medical centre. She ignored me. I had to call my dad home from work.

My daughter also split her head open. The wound was grey so it was deep. We spend 6 hours in A&E. It was a waste of time. We got home and she ripped the glue out. The scar is hardly noticeable and if it happens again - I'll stick a plaster on it.

I sympathise with you. Ignore the ignorents on here. Its a very vulnerable place to be when caring for children in a foreign country when you don't speak the language and especially when our parents won't help.

saraclara · 11/01/2024 08:47

The child was taken to the right place. As I said earlier, my own daughter had a similar inch long deep cut to her chin, and was treated at my local medical centre with steri strips.

Italy has these excellent local centres where her DD received the same care.

I can only assume that it was panic, lack of the language and being out of her usual country that has led OP to be so
suspicious of the care. But seriously, doubting that the nurse was really a nurse? Italy is a modern European country with good healthcare. A healthcare system that her in-laws know their way around.

@Almondmist you've had a tough time here, not all of which you deserve. But seriously, it sounds as though your DD had appropriate treatment, and like my daughter's, the scar will disappear. Forgive yourself and forgive your PILs.

Namechange2468109 · 11/01/2024 08:45

I’ve got two pretty big scars on my face from various childhood injuries (I was taken to hospital but they botched both of them for one reason or another!) I’ve lived to tell the tale.

I don’t love them, but I have had them so long that I don’t really notice them. They often lead to conversations and first date stories! Don’t worry she won’t hold it against you or granny

MerryMarigold · 11/01/2024 08:38

I think it's your lack of being j in control of the situation which is like a trauma for you. The likelihood is that it would have scarred anyway. DS2 had an accident in preschool, small but deep cut (a child whacked his cheekbone with a toy) and he went to hospital, but it still scarred. DD tore her chin on a rosebush (when with my Dad) and that scarred too. They are 15 now and both like their scars. I would not make this into something bigger or deeper than it needs to be. A close family with loving grandparents is worth so much more.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 11/01/2024 08:37

LookItsMeAgain · 11/01/2024 08:29

If this post does nothing else, let it be a lesson to never travel overseas (particularly in Europe) without a European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) though I'm not sure the UK is eligible to apply for these since leaving the EU, but I am open to being educated on that.
Also, don't leave home without taking out travel insurance and health insurance if you're going on holidays.

There’s now a thing called a GHIC. Does exactly the same thing, and also free.

SoupDragon · 11/01/2024 08:36

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:31

EHIC scheme does not apply to the UK any more. And yes, of course everyone should have travel insurance. That was not the issue here though, the OP doesn't mention anything about how the medical care was paid for.

EHICs are valid until they expire. They have been replaced by GHIC.

https://www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/healthcare-abroad/apply-for-a-free-uk-global-health-insurance-card-ghic/

nhs.uk

Applying for healthcare cover abroad (GHIC and EHIC)

Find out if you're eligible to apply for a new UK EHIC or UK Global Health Insurance Card (GHIC).

https://www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/healthcare-abroad/apply-for-a-free-uk-global-health-insurance-card-ghic/

Babyboomtastic · 11/01/2024 08:36

bobomomo · 11/01/2024 07:36

Fair enough that in the middle of the night it would have been hard to go without help from the in laws but the following morning you could have used Google Maps to locate the hospital and either located a cab or public transport - it's Italy not Timbuktu! Google translate is ok to get any phrases you need re transport.

Even then a quick google pulls up the General Timbuktu hospital in seconds (along with some pretty shocking reviews).

Honestly, they're are precious few places in the world where Google can't show you your nearest hospital very quickly. Getting there might be a bit more tricky, but the OP didn't even bother pulling up google maps and typing in 'hospital' for 4 days!

Though perhaps the right treatment was given?

angsty · 11/01/2024 08:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 11/01/2024 08:35

Spinninggyro · 10/01/2024 23:19

Some very harsh comments here. Ubers are not available world wide and it sounded like the accident was in the middle of the night. Reading the post properly would help.

Yes but she could have gone to the hospital the following day — she kept asking her PIL to do so.