Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

364 replies

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 22:44

This is eating me up inside as I can't talk about this with anyone else, please help me decide what to do. Last year I went to visit my in-laws with my dds, my dh didn't go due to work commitments. My in-laws are nice people but also small minded. They live abroad in a small town and I can have a basic conversation with them in thier language. One night Dd2 slept with me and dd1 (4) slept with my mil. I have always used a bed guard with my dds abroad and my in-laws know this very well. It's a stone floor. In the middle of the night, dd1 woke up and came to me because she had a bad dream. I comforted her and my mil took her back to bed. 1 hour later I heard a thud and dd1 screaming. I ran into the room to see dd1 on the floor, her chin split open dripping blood. She had not been put on the side of the bed where the bed guard was in place, but on the other side where my mil should have been sleeping. The cut was an inch wide. I panicked and told my fil to take us to the hospital while my ignorant mil got a wet tissue to dab at the wound. My fil didn't take us to the hospital but a tiny medical centre, which was a tiny room with a guy claiming he was a nurse. He put a plaster on and that's all. I only have a beginner level knowledge of the local language and I said she needs stitches but the guy said no need it's enough. My dd bled for around four days, I begged my in-laws to take her to a hospital but they would look a me with a blank stare like they didn't understand me. I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster. I said to please call a taxi and I would pay for it but they said there are no taxis in the area. There is a hospital 20 mins drive away. I felt so lost and helpless. I cried so much. Its healed but there is a noticible scar left which, given the size, will remain. I was never given an apology for what happened and was told 'its just thier mentality'.
This time when I visited my in-laws with my dh, my mil notice the scar and said my dd should have got stitches. I saw red in that moment and screamed why she didn't do anything at the time and take dd to the hospital like I had begged.
I know what happened wasn't intentional but it was neglect and I am expected to carry on like nothing happened. But I can't let it go, I never want to see my in-laws again or leave take my dds there to meet them, I never enjoyed going I only did it for my dh. Soon the yearly subject will come up of booking the plane tickets and i want to tell dh no this time. I get so much anxiety and stressed out at the thought of going back there. I'm civil with my inlaws but i hate them since that incident. What would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 11/01/2024 10:40

What did your mil say when you started shouting at her?

And yanbu. I would refuse to go again too.

Zimunya · 11/01/2024 10:38

@Almondmist - some posters seem determined to misunderstand / misread what you have written - please ignore the haters. For what it's worth, I think you'd be quite justified in saying that you are not content taking your kids to your in-laws alone until they are older and less vulnerable. Small children are hard to look after and things go wrong quite quickly with them (as you have evidenced). Nothing against the in-laws - but say (firmly) to your DH, that given the lack of internet, the language problems, and the cultural differences, you don't feel safe going alone with young DCs. Nothing to stop DH taking them when he does actually have leave (presumably he speaks Italian?) Make it clear that when they are older you're happy to reconsider, but it is too risky when they are young.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 10:34

Araminta1003 · 11/01/2024 10:33

Refuse to ever go back there without your DH. What would they do in a proper emergency? That would be my concern. I would not be able to be around people who are unsafe with children and minimise health issues. I bet if one of them had fallen on their face like that they would have gone to hospital?

In a proper emergency they probably would've driven the 20 30 mins to hospital?

It wasn't an emergency, it was a cut chin!

Araminta1003 · 11/01/2024 10:33

Refuse to ever go back there without your DH. What would they do in a proper emergency? That would be my concern. I would not be able to be around people who are unsafe with children and minimise health issues. I bet if one of them had fallen on their face like that they would have gone to hospital?

teddycoat · 11/01/2024 10:31

Go further into rural areas of Europe

OP said the hospital was 20 mins away then corrected to 30 mins away. It cant be that rural if the hospital is only a half hour drive can it? I live in a city and my local hospital is a 45 minute drive away so further away than this allegedly isolated rural backwater that noone can get to.

Calamitousness · 11/01/2024 10:28

those that are saying Italian healthcare is superior. No. Yes it has some excellent hospitals that would rival our best tertiary providers and provide highest standards of care. But. Go further into rural areas of Europe. Spain/italy etc. and it’s not the same. There is a basic level of standard care in NHS which treat emergencies like this. There isn’t in Europe. The equipment is very old and not fit for purpose. I have had experience recently. I think those saying state of NHS are confusing waiting times for elective care and delay in emergency treatment with the actual care that is then provided. And again I’m not talking about chronic community care.

Sonora25 · 11/01/2024 10:27

@Toomanyemails you would contact the embassy because a small child hit her chin? Omg 😦

LIZS · 11/01/2024 10:27

If you had two singles you could have top and tailed the dds, and had one yourself. Agree you need t9 take some responsibility for the mishap and not getting hospital care. Surely you would roughly know where the hospital was, given it was not your first visit. However no don't visit them again.

Sonora25 · 11/01/2024 10:27

Some people are super hysterical about taxis on here. I grew up in rural Italy, you can find taxis everywhere now! Maybe not in every tiny town but if there is a hospital within 30mins you can find a taxi place too.
as others have said it’s not rural Afghanistan!!

Toomanyemails · 11/01/2024 10:25

Almondmist · 11/01/2024 00:02

Thank you for all your replies, it's helping me see things clearer. To answer some questions - There's very poor wifi signal out there so the translator wasn't working.
Apologies the hospital was 30 mins away not 20 mins.
I let dd sleep with mil because the room I was in had 2 single beds pushed together. To sleep in the middle would be extremely uncomfortable because of the seams so that's why I let dd sleep with mil, I would have preferred she slept with me.

Hey OP, I totally agree with your anger.
If you do go back, on a practical note there is a lot you can do to avoid feeling lost and helpless again, that must have been horrible. Can you research contacts and addresses for hospitals and other urgent care, as well as numbers for local taxis in advance? There may well not be taxi companies in such a rural area, but can your DH do research into what the options would be. You could also contact the embassy who should at least support you in accessing urgent care and getting any translation support, and/or your health insurance provider. Another option is to find Facebook groups for expats in Italy or the specific region you're in, join those, and post asking for help if you need it. And maybe invest in a portable WiFi for any trips if that would help. When you have an emergency abroad, it's awful, so it can be helpful to have these details listed in a document so you don't need to think.
I understand you wouldn't have done this the first time as you thought you could rely on in-laws. I really hope your DH talks to them about this and explains that your and his decisions on your children's care need to be listened to, otherwise you won't feel safe visiting their home. You could then base yourselves in a nearish town or city, maybe renting a car for the visit. But personally I wouldn't let your kids stay there again unless you can feel confident you could get them to urgent care if needed

angsty · 11/01/2024 10:16

be very cautions about how much direct contact mil has with your kids

Have your kids never had accidents while in your care? It was an accident and medical attention was then sought promptly and given.

angsty · 11/01/2024 10:13

In terms of getting medical care, you clearly speak English and many people all over the world also speak it too, even if it’s a basic amount.

Actually: In terms of getting medical care, if you are married to an Italian and spend holidays with your children in Italy, learn to speak Italian. Your DD is four, you must have been in a relationship with your Italian husband for at least five years.

Redmat · 11/01/2024 10:11

Your PIL accessed medical care for you. You went twice and were told the same thing by a proffessional. If you were unhappy it was entirely down to you to sort out a trip to the hospital.

angsty · 11/01/2024 10:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rachie1973 · 11/01/2024 10:10

All seems very hysterical to me.

Title is misleading. MIL didn’t ‘injure’ your child. Child had an accident.

She also received medical attention fairly promptly.

OP you seem a bit helpless, for want of a better word.

GlowSnowGlow · 11/01/2024 10:05

I definitely wouldn’t stay there again and be very cautions about how much direct contact mil has with your kids. I know accidents happen however she was negligent and totally in the wrong.

In terms of getting medical care, you clearly speak English and many people all over the world also speak it too, even if it’s a basic amount. I don’t really understand why you couldn’t get to the hospital. They do sound very controlling though and this wasn’t their decision to make.

Saharafordessert · 11/01/2024 10:02

Your DD had an accident, she wasn’t injured by mil unless you’re saying she deliberately pushed her out of bed!
You’re the parent and it sounds like you panicked and didn’t handle the situation very well. Understandable in the middle of the night but why couldn’t your DH call a taxi for you the next day from the UK?
I think you should apologise to mil.

Sonora25 · 11/01/2024 09:58

Calamitousness · 11/01/2024 09:35

@Almondmist
if the scar is very noticeable and badly healed ie. The edges of the wound are not well approximated then you can have scar revision done for a better aesthetic. Especially as your child is a girl and more likely to be bothered by it in future. Ask your gp to refer you to plastics at your local hospital.
unfortunately healthcare abroad is not of the same standard as home. Even in Europe. I needed emergency trauma surgery abroad in Spain but they didn’t recognise severity and current treatment and merely casted the limb which needed replacement joints and massive tendon and ligament repairs surgically. I had to go to ED as soon as plane landed.

This is a generalisation. I am an Italian who lives jn England and in many aspects Italian healthcare is better (not all but many). You have rose tinted views of the NHS.

ilovebreadsauce · 11/01/2024 09:55

unfortunately healthcare abroad is not of the same standard as home.

No it is much better, especially Italy!
What an utterly xenophobic post about those Johnny-foreigner clinicians!

Katiesaidthat · 11/01/2024 09:48

You were taken to the health centre, you were unhappy with the situation/result/attitude. In the morning in bright sunlight you could have implemented actions to take your child to a hospital. You didn´t. Even paying a neigbour/shopkeeper/anyone to take you to the hospital! Google translate is your friend. It´s Italy, not Afghanistan.
My grandpa was a royal marine, his favourite saying was "use your effing initiative!".
You feel guilty and also angry at your husband, but you are transferring to your mother in law. She didn´t injure the child, I though you were going to say she manhandled her, and it is nothing of the sort!
What is done is done, the scar will fade in time and if not happy take her to a consultant re plastic surgery if needed.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 11/01/2024 09:46

Alloftheskies · 11/01/2024 00:08

Some people on this thread have no idea what rural means.
You think you can get Google everywhere?
There are places in the UK even where your only hope would be someone's landline...
Factor in not speaking the language... how on earth are you going to get a taxi? How are you going to find a taxi number? How are you going to communicate and pay etc etc... if the people you thought you could trust that you are staying with aren't helping you you'd be up shit creek

I wouldn't call 30 minutes from a hospital rural, at least not the kind of rural thats isolated. Rural isolation here means you're a 4 hour flight via light plane from emergency help. There aren't land lines, phone and internet require satellite, long range radio is the only other form or communication.

Given what a few people have said on here regarding medical treatment for facial wounds it sounds like the treatment given could well have been the correct treatment. I can't speak for Italy, but where i am if the treating doctor or nurse thought the injury required a higher level of care they would have said that the child needed to go to hospital. MILs remark was certainly not a kind one and FIL should have taken OP and her DD to hospital as she is the parent and its not their place to make those decisions. But maybe no one has to beat themselves up over this one as OPs daughter got the same level of care as other children wirh similar injuries.

stealtheatingtunnocks · 11/01/2024 09:41

whatsappdoc · 11/01/2024 09:30

You screamed at mil a year later? Maybe she was agreeing that the 'nurse' didn't do enough. Maybe she felt guilty. I wouldn't want you in the house overreacting like that, your dh must have been really embarrassed. Must have been a lovely visit for all involved.

And two of my dds had 'dripping blood' chin injuries and only had steri-strips. Is it normal to have stitches?

Not if they can avoid it - kids heal fast and if the wound can be held together without stiches they will.

my son’s chin injury was a long flap, the muscle came right off and I know I don’t want to see the inside of my kids face again. The plastic surgeon was amazing, and what he predicted is exactly what happened - in time the scar faded and moved down off his chin.

We are very lucky to have the NHS but I wouldn’t assume they’d stitch kids if they can avoid it. it hurts, increases infection risk and often needs an anesthetic

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 11/01/2024 09:40

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

From what you have said it is:

My DD had an accident, I thought it was important to go to a hospital, PIL didn't. I didn't do anything about it for 4 days.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 09:39

Calamitousness · 11/01/2024 09:35

@Almondmist
if the scar is very noticeable and badly healed ie. The edges of the wound are not well approximated then you can have scar revision done for a better aesthetic. Especially as your child is a girl and more likely to be bothered by it in future. Ask your gp to refer you to plastics at your local hospital.
unfortunately healthcare abroad is not of the same standard as home. Even in Europe. I needed emergency trauma surgery abroad in Spain but they didn’t recognise severity and current treatment and merely casted the limb which needed replacement joints and massive tendon and ligament repairs surgically. I had to go to ED as soon as plane landed.

Healthcare in Italy is far superior to the UK, have you used NHS services recently?

Headlines today key NHS targets missed for seven years.

Calamitousness · 11/01/2024 09:35

@Almondmist
if the scar is very noticeable and badly healed ie. The edges of the wound are not well approximated then you can have scar revision done for a better aesthetic. Especially as your child is a girl and more likely to be bothered by it in future. Ask your gp to refer you to plastics at your local hospital.
unfortunately healthcare abroad is not of the same standard as home. Even in Europe. I needed emergency trauma surgery abroad in Spain but they didn’t recognise severity and current treatment and merely casted the limb which needed replacement joints and massive tendon and ligament repairs surgically. I had to go to ED as soon as plane landed.