Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL injured my dd and would not take her to hospital

364 replies

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 22:44

This is eating me up inside as I can't talk about this with anyone else, please help me decide what to do. Last year I went to visit my in-laws with my dds, my dh didn't go due to work commitments. My in-laws are nice people but also small minded. They live abroad in a small town and I can have a basic conversation with them in thier language. One night Dd2 slept with me and dd1 (4) slept with my mil. I have always used a bed guard with my dds abroad and my in-laws know this very well. It's a stone floor. In the middle of the night, dd1 woke up and came to me because she had a bad dream. I comforted her and my mil took her back to bed. 1 hour later I heard a thud and dd1 screaming. I ran into the room to see dd1 on the floor, her chin split open dripping blood. She had not been put on the side of the bed where the bed guard was in place, but on the other side where my mil should have been sleeping. The cut was an inch wide. I panicked and told my fil to take us to the hospital while my ignorant mil got a wet tissue to dab at the wound. My fil didn't take us to the hospital but a tiny medical centre, which was a tiny room with a guy claiming he was a nurse. He put a plaster on and that's all. I only have a beginner level knowledge of the local language and I said she needs stitches but the guy said no need it's enough. My dd bled for around four days, I begged my in-laws to take her to a hospital but they would look a me with a blank stare like they didn't understand me. I called my dh on the phone to translate to them but my fil refused and took her again to the same medical centre who only changed the plaster. I said to please call a taxi and I would pay for it but they said there are no taxis in the area. There is a hospital 20 mins drive away. I felt so lost and helpless. I cried so much. Its healed but there is a noticible scar left which, given the size, will remain. I was never given an apology for what happened and was told 'its just thier mentality'.
This time when I visited my in-laws with my dh, my mil notice the scar and said my dd should have got stitches. I saw red in that moment and screamed why she didn't do anything at the time and take dd to the hospital like I had begged.
I know what happened wasn't intentional but it was neglect and I am expected to carry on like nothing happened. But I can't let it go, I never want to see my in-laws again or leave take my dds there to meet them, I never enjoyed going I only did it for my dh. Soon the yearly subject will come up of booking the plane tickets and i want to tell dh no this time. I get so much anxiety and stressed out at the thought of going back there. I'm civil with my inlaws but i hate them since that incident. What would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 11/01/2024 07:00

Almondmist · 11/01/2024 00:02

Thank you for all your replies, it's helping me see things clearer. To answer some questions - There's very poor wifi signal out there so the translator wasn't working.
Apologies the hospital was 30 mins away not 20 mins.
I let dd sleep with mil because the room I was in had 2 single beds pushed together. To sleep in the middle would be extremely uncomfortable because of the seams so that's why I let dd sleep with mil, I would have preferred she slept with me.

I’m pretty certain a 2 year old and a 4 year old could share a single bed and you have the other one.

Ohnoooooooo · 11/01/2024 06:59

i am wondering if the taxi issue is a red herring - if the child saw medical help twice - even if she had of been taken to a hospital it might not have meant she was given stitches?

MamaGhina · 11/01/2024 06:59

The title of the OP “MIL injured my DD” is completely misleading. You allowed them to cosleep. You accepted the risks. Your MIL didn’t push her out.

She was bleeding for FOUR DAYS and you accepted a plaster? You need to accept some of the responsibility here. You could have got up the next day, seen it was still bleeding and found a way to treatment.

teddycoat · 11/01/2024 06:59

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 06:58

As someone who lives in southern Italy, let me tell you.. THERE ARE NO TAXIS. It sounds like ops inlaws went to the guarda medica, who are fully qualified doctors and act as a rural alternative to a&e. In my experience they are amazing! If that same incident happened where we live, there's no way without a car you'd be going anywhere. Here, it's a long walk to the nearest neighbours, and our nearest shop is a half hour drive. Not everywhere is like the uk. It doesn't make it a backward country, just one with a different population density. You all sound incredibly entitled to think you can "just ring an uber".

Fine, so how did OP get to the airport for the return flight then?

Umph · 11/01/2024 06:59

I think YAB a bit U to say that MIL injured DD. It was an accident. Perhaps a slight lapse in judgement but I think given that it was the middle of the night, this is somewhat understandable.

Soontobe60 · 11/01/2024 06:58

Owlsoutsidethewindow · 10/01/2024 23:02

Would you be comfortable sharing what country this was? I'm just wondering what the health care provision is like

Both of my DDs have split open their chins in accidents. Both times I have taken them to A+E. Both times they just had steri-strips applied. This is in the UK.
Just because a country may be small, it doesn’t mean their health care is any worse that that of a big country.

FigTreeInEurope · 11/01/2024 06:58

As someone who lives in southern Italy, let me tell you.. THERE ARE NO TAXIS. It sounds like ops inlaws went to the guarda medica, who are fully qualified doctors and act as a rural alternative to a&e. In my experience they are amazing! If that same incident happened where we live, there's no way without a car you'd be going anywhere. Here, it's a long walk to the nearest neighbours, and our nearest shop is a half hour drive. Not everywhere is like the uk. It doesn't make it a backward country, just one with a different population density. You all sound incredibly entitled to think you can "just ring an uber".

2024GarlicCloves · 11/01/2024 06:57

Is anyone else wildly impressed that a small Italian town has an all-night medical centre? Here in my small English town, you'd have to get the 20 miles to our nearest hospital (and there are no taxis).

If you made it, you'd be waiting for hours in A&E instead of having the wound fixed up locally and being back in bed!

JudyWater · 11/01/2024 06:56

It was an accident, your mother in law didn't injure your daughter, the title of your thread suggests otherwise. I completely understand it's stressful when kids are hurt but you do need to equip yourself with a bit more resilience than crying and begging for days. Now you know the logistical challenges of the region, have you ensured you have means to take your kids to a doctor if they are ill or injured again whilst visiting?

Sonora25 · 11/01/2024 06:55

bevelino · 10/01/2024 22:59

People all over the world manage to get their children to hospital in an emergency. It doesn’t matter if you don’t speak the language, you find a way.

I really don’t get this at all. Stop blaming your MIL, you are the parent, you had a phone, I am sure you would have a found a way to get YOUR DC to a hospital. You had a few days.

On a side note I hope your DC have dual citizenship or are insured when you travel to Italy.

i think you are rightly or wrongly blaming your in-laws for everything but I wouldn’t cut them off over a minor incident. They are rural people from a different culture and your DH should have also helped translate or send an ambulance/taxi to the house. I know he wasn’t there but sounds like you were in touch.

teddycoat · 11/01/2024 06:54

One thing that makes no sense at all- if you can get a taxi from the airport to their house when you first arrived, then surely within a 4 day time period you can order a taxi to pick you up to take you to the hospital? Yes, your in laws seemed to play it down but why didnt YOU arrange this?- you could have rung your DH and asked him to order a taxi for you if you didnt speak the language.

Taxis must go out to your in laws house otherwise you wouldnt have been able to physically get there in the first place. You seem so angry with them but appear to have no taken any responsibility yourself for your own daughter. I get the language barrier- my in laws don't speak English but ultimately, your daughter is your responsibility, not theirs so it was up to you to take action if you were so concerned.

How did you get to the airport for the return flight if you couldn't get a taxi???? There are so many holes in this account that something is very, very off here

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 06:53

Alloftheskies · 11/01/2024 00:08

Some people on this thread have no idea what rural means.
You think you can get Google everywhere?
There are places in the UK even where your only hope would be someone's landline...
Factor in not speaking the language... how on earth are you going to get a taxi? How are you going to find a taxi number? How are you going to communicate and pay etc etc... if the people you thought you could trust that you are staying with aren't helping you you'd be up shit creek

She could ring her husband and ask him to sort.

Kwam31 · 11/01/2024 06:53

Why didn't you ask your DH in those 4 days of hysteria to speak to his dad?
Can you not drive? You could have found a way in 4 days to get her to a hospital.

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 06:51

ReadtheReviews · 11/01/2024 00:01

I barely get signal om my phone in the UK countryside.
I've also stayed with relatives at their mercy of where to go because I didn't have a hire car. Taxis not a thing there. Ubers not around. Expect op was tied by politeness to not go to neighbours who may have been far away, elderly, not spoken any English etc etc.
The pile on is not deserved.
I wouldn't go OP. Let dh take them if he wants. The anxiety will be high for you but not as high as being around them yourself.

OP hasn't mentioned having no phone signal. Indeed, she rang her husband.

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 06:49

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 23:37

I agree with many of you who said I should have found a way to take her to the hospital, I think I was in shock in disbelief but thats no excuse. I am also to blame and my dd deserved better than me.
I only found out the hospital was 20 mins away after I spoke to an airport worker on the flight back home

In shock for 4 days because your child cut their chin? Come off it. Take some responsibility for not doing anything to sort yourself out.

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 06:47

Almondmist · 10/01/2024 23:34

Thank you all for your honest responses, I'll try to answer as many questions as I can. The fall happened at 3am and my in-laws live in southern Italy, deep in the countryside. There are no ubers available here. I went alone with dh as it was summer holidays and he couldn't get time off work. Both my parents passed away before my dds were born so I wanted my dds to be close to the only grandparents they had. My in-laws have always been kind to me but I never knew how neglectful they were till last year.

My God, take some responsibility. Why were you incapable of ringing a taxi (not Uber) in 4 days?

PinkPlantCase · 11/01/2024 06:47

I think it’s a bit of a stretch to say anyone was neglectful tbh.

Not taking a child with a broken bone to hospital - neglect

Taking a child who cut their chin in an accident to a medical center - not neglect

However I can see why you would feel angry about the bed guard and PILs are in the wrong for not listening to you. Even if culturally they would not usually use a hospital for something like this to say no to a mother who wants to take their child to hospital is wrong.

I think they need a firm word from your DH.

kisstheblarney · 11/01/2024 06:45

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/01/2024 06:36

to those saying that OP should have taken her DD to the hospital. Walked, told their in-laws that she would drive (with their own car), told her DH to organise her a hire car etc. I agree in theory. And it probably seems so easy to most of us. But it clearly was not in this case.

there is clearly a major culture gap and some language issues. We do not know if there were stores (or hotels) OP could have called and if they would have helped a foreign woman.

we also don’t know if there were safety issues to consider. There are so many places in this world where a person - especially a woman - walking along the street is exposed to considerable danger. Having bad reception won’t have helped. I would be incredibly afraid of getting lost (I have an awful sense of direction) and potentially endangering my child…

And that is only the question of whether taking the DD to a hospital was objectively possible.

There is also the issue of whether it was subjectively possible for the OP in that situation. It seems to me like OP felt isolated and was emotionally vulnerable. When two people who should care about your child clearly state that a doctor isn’t necessary? Make you feel as if you’re the crazy one? Refuse to engage with you?

That has an impact. And it seems like OP didn’t have the tools to defend herself (mentally).

=> there were clearly various barriers between OP getting her DD the necessary medical care.

and her in-laws were responsible for erecting most of them and /or intentionally refused to help OP overcome these obstacles. The comment her MIL made during this visit clearly illustrates that she understood the concept but that her in-laws simply did not want to help. Why?? To exert their own power? To distress OP?

we will probably never know. But I definitely hope that OP and her DD will never visit them again. Especially not without her husband present / the child’s father.

They were in southern Italy.....

They went to a medical centre

They were seen by a doctor

DoorPath · 11/01/2024 06:45

Spinninggyro · 10/01/2024 23:19

Some very harsh comments here. Ubers are not available world wide and it sounded like the accident was in the middle of the night. Reading the post properly would help.

Nobody has mentioned Ubers. Just normal taxis. Remember them? OP could easily have Googled for a taxi number and ordered one for herself, using Google translate for help with language.

GRex · 11/01/2024 06:44

A small scar isn't an issue and might have happened even with stitches. If you felt your child needed a hospital though then you should have gone. It is your child, in your care, and your responsibility to take her to hospital. Middle of nowhere places can be hard; particularly parts of Asia and Africa, it's slow but it's always achievable. But you couldn't manage a bus in Italy? What is wrong with you, seriously? You have children, grow up and be more self sufficient.

By all means skip visiting the in laws if you want, but you'll need to let your DH take them if he wants to. Maybe rent a place next time so you have your own space, and get a car and a map if you really can't manage buses.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/01/2024 06:43

Flyhigher · 11/01/2024 05:30

It all sounds very strange. Why not let the four year old snuggle with you in a single bed. Or top to toe with dc1.

Also must have been someone that spoke English.

Also must have been someone that spoke English

someone somewhere? Sure.

Someone OP knew (of) and would also manage to contact?
Not necessarily. There are so many places - especially remote and rural - where you won’t get far with English.

MariaVT65 · 11/01/2024 06:43

Yeah actually re-reading your title, I think your perspective is way off. Your MIL didn’t injure your DD. She fell out of bed and it was an accident.

Isthisisthis · 11/01/2024 06:42

Yes you should have taken her yourself but I understand that’s not easy when someone else is telling you they won’t take you and you don’t speak the language.

If I were you, I wouldn’t go without DH again.

ilovebreadsauce · 11/01/2024 06:39

They took her to a MEDICAL centre in a country with one of the best healthcare systems in the world.The centre would have given her the most appropriate treatment or referred her yo the hospital had that been necessary.
I think you owe your MIL an apology

BreatheAndFocus · 11/01/2024 06:38

I can understand you’re upset, OP, but hopefully the scar will fade over time. My DD had a massive and awful gash on her forehead with chunks of skin missing and it was wide and zigzaggy. This has hugely improved now and you wouldn’t notice it unless I’d told you and you’d looked at her very closely.

Note - they didn’t put a single stitch in my DD’s forehead. They said they would leave scars. Instead they ‘glued’ the wound shut and put a couple of sutures on.

Also - obvious to me but maybe I’m old! You should always take an Italian phrasebook. They’re £5 or so and have excellent basic sections about getting a taxi, going to the doctors, being injured, etc. That and a pocket Italian dictionary would have been very helpful.