Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argh, look at this awful text from a date!

564 replies

londonisnotme · 10/01/2024 21:00

AIBU to think it's just bloody awful?

'Hi L! How are you? Sorry I haven't replied , busy few days in the office. Listen, I really enjoyed our time together but I think your caring roles are a different world to mine. It just doesn't seem right for me to, and I thought you needed to know. You ARE beautiful (yes you are!) , but I can't get past this. I needed you to know so you knew why sometimes it won't work , but I'm sure there's a very nice guy out there just for you 😌'

I go from thinking it's cringe, to patronising. To maybe making for of me?!

For context, went on a few dates. Kissed and asked to have sex. I did. I wanted to. Wasn't very good but we move

He's then text this. Whilst I'm on a date with someone else Saturday night Grin

I still haven't deleted the text so me and a few friends can have a laugh.

OP posts:
SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 11/01/2024 14:05

@ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea

You are missing the point . Totally .

No I'm not. I agree it's patronising but I was specifically responding to the person who said it wasn't "better" than being ghosted and I was explaining why I think that being ghosted is worse behaviour.

@FourLeggedBuckers

You don’t get to decide that I have an issue with this text for spurious reasons of your own fabrication.

What you are talking about is my opinion, and yes I do get to decide my own opinion! LOL.

ClawedButler · 11/01/2024 13:24

Well yeah, it beats being ghosted but dear god the level of cringe is off the chart.

I think this is yet another perfect occasion to use the infamous response from a Mumsnetter: "Thanks for your opinion, random man"

butterpuffed · 11/01/2024 13:18

He said sorry for not replying , OP said she hadn't texted him. Who knows 🤐
They're both better off without each other .

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 11/01/2024 13:04

AlwaysGinPlease · 11/01/2024 10:24

@NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision

Nobody likes a smart arse 😂

You are NOT nobody (no you aren't!) ❤

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 11/01/2024 13:01

SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 11/01/2024 12:23

And raise your standards - this really isn’t “better” than being ghosted, it’s just a different variety of shit.

This is nonsense. The OP and everyone else spouting these lines seem overly riled about the fact a man does not want to date a parent carer. This is his choice.

If you are a parent carer you may not like it as it is too close to home, any more than if you are divorced parent, being told by a man that he does not want to date a divorcee with children or if you are unfit and hate exercise, being told that a man wants to date a very active person he can go running with. This is life though.

Being ghosted is very rude for three main reasons. One is that it is just plain discourteous to end contact with someone you have been engaging with on an intimate level whatever stage it has got to. The second is - this is the important one - is that a ghoster knows it is likely to cause a lot of mental angst in the ghostee - because human nature hates uncertainty and the mind will mentally gnaw obsessively on what the reason was for the sudden change from interested dater to radio silence. The third is that it is cowardly and dishonest.

So actually being told directly (however badly worded and however patronising) that someone does not what to date you for compatibility reasons and roughly what those reasons are, is "better" than being ghosted because it is politer actually to make the position clear, it provides certainty to the recipient and avoids the mental picking apart anguish and it is honest and direct.

Of course it is "shit" to be rejected ESPECIALLY for something about yourself that you can't change. The more so where it is worded badly in a patronising way. But that unfortunately is part of dating and life. Rejection for trivial or important reasons that matter to other people that may not matter to you is how the world turns.

Top tip: if you are ever in this situation yourself, the simple answer is to say as a reason there's no chemistry for you. It's a reason, it's simple and understandable, it's not as offensive as the real reason and you can't argue with it.

You are missing the point . Totally .

It's the bit where he tells OP she is beautiful (oh yes she is 🙄) and that she will find someone who is right for her one day. It's massively patronising and so unnecessary. It reads as if he sees himself as being so superior to her.

OP - I would reply along the lines of

'No worries - as explained I'm not actually looking for a relationship ATM anyway x '

I've added the kiss as it's the way most people text and makes your reply look more off-the-cuff-not-bothered. If you wouldn't normally sign off with a 'x' then don't use it .

Pomodori · 11/01/2024 12:59

YANBU, because my casual dating friends get pathetic texts like this from time to time. We all get to have a good laugh 😄

"How are you?" - Why do people start what is essentially a "I don't like you" text, with this?! It's not like they're actually interested in how you are or would even want a reply.

"Sorry I haven't replied" - No you're not, lol.

"Busy few days" - Why do people use this excuse, when we all know they're constantly on their phone, crushing candies, looking at social media, researching The Roman Empire, swiping on Tinder 🙃

"Listen," - Oh yeah, women love being told what to do. We'll all hang on your every word from now on.

"I really enjoyed our time together" - Superfluous platitude, thanks for the food, drinks and shags you mean.

"but I think your caring roles are a different world to mine" - Just couldn't imagine caring for anyone or anything, the mere concept is soooo out there and foreign 🙄

"I thought you needed to know" - Aww, how thoughtful, because all women do is stare at their phones desperately waiting for the thoughts of men. We're able to rest now you've let us know.

"You ARE beautiful" - Because a women's only worth is in how they look and can only be validated by a man.

"but I can't get past this" - Contrived melodrama!

"I needed you to know so you knew why sometimes it won't work" - Thank you for letting a woman fulfill your needs, by educating us with your deep knowledge.

"I'm sure there's a very nice guy out there just for you" - Another weird superfluous platitude, predicting the future.

I swear it's like people only have a few old, boring cliches to choose from, no originality. I'm only surprised that he didn't add "we can be friends if you like" at the very end, because he's so "very nice"!

AliceOlive · 11/01/2024 12:49

londonisnotme · 11/01/2024 12:35

I think it's fair enough. I wasn't hurt or offended. Although he could've just said something more generic.

My ex was a Doctor. Awful to date. Nice man, profession not so nice and you will suffer for it alongside them for a long time

I see your point but think it could really hurt someone who is already struggling.

PeggyPoggleshaw · 11/01/2024 12:44

SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 11/01/2024 12:23

And raise your standards - this really isn’t “better” than being ghosted, it’s just a different variety of shit.

This is nonsense. The OP and everyone else spouting these lines seem overly riled about the fact a man does not want to date a parent carer. This is his choice.

If you are a parent carer you may not like it as it is too close to home, any more than if you are divorced parent, being told by a man that he does not want to date a divorcee with children or if you are unfit and hate exercise, being told that a man wants to date a very active person he can go running with. This is life though.

Being ghosted is very rude for three main reasons. One is that it is just plain discourteous to end contact with someone you have been engaging with on an intimate level whatever stage it has got to. The second is - this is the important one - is that a ghoster knows it is likely to cause a lot of mental angst in the ghostee - because human nature hates uncertainty and the mind will mentally gnaw obsessively on what the reason was for the sudden change from interested dater to radio silence. The third is that it is cowardly and dishonest.

So actually being told directly (however badly worded and however patronising) that someone does not what to date you for compatibility reasons and roughly what those reasons are, is "better" than being ghosted because it is politer actually to make the position clear, it provides certainty to the recipient and avoids the mental picking apart anguish and it is honest and direct.

Of course it is "shit" to be rejected ESPECIALLY for something about yourself that you can't change. The more so where it is worded badly in a patronising way. But that unfortunately is part of dating and life. Rejection for trivial or important reasons that matter to other people that may not matter to you is how the world turns.

Top tip: if you are ever in this situation yourself, the simple answer is to say as a reason there's no chemistry for you. It's a reason, it's simple and understandable, it's not as offensive as the real reason and you can't argue with it.

Brilliantly put. 👏

londonisnotme · 11/01/2024 12:35

AliceOlive · 11/01/2024 12:33

I think mentioning someone’s occupation is really, really off. Bringing up their disabled child is ten times worse.

Imagine telling a man his role as an auto mechanic is not compatible for you. It’s really not nice no matter how true.

I think it's fair enough. I wasn't hurt or offended. Although he could've just said something more generic.

My ex was a Doctor. Awful to date. Nice man, profession not so nice and you will suffer for it alongside them for a long time

OP posts:
AliceOlive · 11/01/2024 12:33

I think mentioning someone’s occupation is really, really off. Bringing up their disabled child is ten times worse.

Imagine telling a man his role as an auto mechanic is not compatible for you. It’s really not nice no matter how true.

londonisnotme · 11/01/2024 12:33

Heather37231 · 11/01/2024 12:32

I read it in a squeaky James Blunt voice!

Ooo ironic, he reminded me a bit of James Blunt! Surface level he was a catch, but had a stranger vibe to him after that

Then again he loves running and does every week or so running competitions Grin could never see myself personally being one of those families holding everyone up in their cars as they rode their tandem bike along

He was very good looking though (hence the sex)

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 11/01/2024 12:33

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/01/2024 12:00

Well this thread certainly explains why there are so many people on mumsnet who have sleepwalked into relationships with manipulative and misogynistic men.

Red flags - please learn to spot them and read between the lines. And raise your standards - this really isn’t “better” than being ghosted, it’s just a different variety of shit.

It’s not about whether he wants to be in a relationship with the OP, or not, it’s about how he thinks about and communicates with women. Read that text again and ask yourself if there is any respect for the OP in what he’s said. He talks to her like she’s an insecure little child who needs his reassurance that she’s valid. That is not ok.

And I’d say sharing this text online is a worthwhile act if it influences just one person in how they interpret male behaviour and communication.

Brava, @FourLeggedBuckers.

The implicit message 'Be Kind' reverberates long and loudly through this thread. Put up with the patrony, infantalizing and negging, OP, because 'he's only trying to be polite'. Predictably OP's derisive reaction is SO mean; naturally far worse than the patrony, infantalizing and negging which prompted it in the first place. Boils my blood, TBH, that we're still in a place in 2024 in which women are encouraged to return men's flagrant disrespect with nothing but respect, and if you can't do that, say nothing.

Just look at where that's getting us in the current climate.

I heard and internalized all the messages in my younger years of 'you must be polite', and 'let him down gently'. I followed the last piece of advice and it earned me nearly a year of stalking, culminating in an attempt made on my life. Go, me.

And so much for patriarchal indoctrination. It's not intended to benefit women and we get no brownie points whatsoever for being kind, nice and polite. In fact, it will usually be used against us to our detriment. When will some of us ever learn?

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/01/2024 12:32

I’d like to know if any of the women who would be happy to receive this message in these circumstances would write the same text themselves to a man.

Would a woman really write the “you ARE handsome (yes you are!)” line to a man?

And if you wouldn’t say it to a man, why would you be happy to have a man say it to you?

Heather37231 · 11/01/2024 12:32

I read it in a squeaky James Blunt voice!

londonisnotme · 11/01/2024 12:30

This is nonsense. The OP and everyone else spouting these lines seem overly riled about the fact a man does not want to date a parent carer. This is his choice.

No. As I said, it's perfectly valid and absolutely fine not to want to date someone with caring commitments I probably wouldn't want to if I wasn't a carer etc

What's not fine is the 'Listen' and the 'You're beautiful (yes you are!)'

His reasoning from that text is fine!

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 11/01/2024 12:29

Just to be clear, @SirQuintusAureliusMaximus I’m not a parent carer and, as I’ve made clear repeatedly on this thread, that isn’t what I have an issue with. You don’t get to decide that I have an issue with this text for spurious reasons of your own fabrication. I’ve been very clear that my issue is with how men - some men - think about and talk to women.

You may think being ghosted is the biggest sin possible in these circumstances - I vehemently disagree. I would take ghosting over this shit any day.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 11/01/2024 12:26

NeverStopTwinkling · 11/01/2024 11:55

This! If my friend showed me this to laugh at I'd tell them they were being weird and nasty.

TBH, nobody knows this chap from Adam, so it's not nasty in that sense, as if he's being outed or anything is it? It's to illustrate a discussion point really.

Heather37231 · 11/01/2024 12:24

I think that there is still an outdated idea amongst men that any woman who has sex with them must have fallen in love with them and think it’s a big deal. They can’t really cope with women who genuinely do just see casual sex as casual sex. Total double standards of course.

SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 11/01/2024 12:23

And raise your standards - this really isn’t “better” than being ghosted, it’s just a different variety of shit.

This is nonsense. The OP and everyone else spouting these lines seem overly riled about the fact a man does not want to date a parent carer. This is his choice.

If you are a parent carer you may not like it as it is too close to home, any more than if you are divorced parent, being told by a man that he does not want to date a divorcee with children or if you are unfit and hate exercise, being told that a man wants to date a very active person he can go running with. This is life though.

Being ghosted is very rude for three main reasons. One is that it is just plain discourteous to end contact with someone you have been engaging with on an intimate level whatever stage it has got to. The second is - this is the important one - is that a ghoster knows it is likely to cause a lot of mental angst in the ghostee - because human nature hates uncertainty and the mind will mentally gnaw obsessively on what the reason was for the sudden change from interested dater to radio silence. The third is that it is cowardly and dishonest.

So actually being told directly (however badly worded and however patronising) that someone does not what to date you for compatibility reasons and roughly what those reasons are, is "better" than being ghosted because it is politer actually to make the position clear, it provides certainty to the recipient and avoids the mental picking apart anguish and it is honest and direct.

Of course it is "shit" to be rejected ESPECIALLY for something about yourself that you can't change. The more so where it is worded badly in a patronising way. But that unfortunately is part of dating and life. Rejection for trivial or important reasons that matter to other people that may not matter to you is how the world turns.

Top tip: if you are ever in this situation yourself, the simple answer is to say as a reason there's no chemistry for you. It's a reason, it's simple and understandable, it's not as offensive as the real reason and you can't argue with it.

MrsSunshine2b · 11/01/2024 12:23

I don't see anything wrong with this, he's realised it won't work and is being upfront and honest about that.

Lightermoon · 11/01/2024 12:19

I know what a parent carer is. I am one. Child with sen. Either he doesn’t like that you don’t work. Or he doesn’t see your life fitting into his. He tried to be polite. It backfired didn’t it.

Badburyrings · 11/01/2024 12:15

I am sure you are not too bothered but anyone who starts a sentence with "Listen" needs to be chucked right back.. ugh

porridgeisbae · 11/01/2024 12:14

If he thought that you weren't compatible then he shouldn'tve bumped and dumped you.

I'd like to be called beautiful sometimes though. Smile

FourLeggedBuckers · 11/01/2024 12:10

babysensoryclass · 11/01/2024 12:05

I wonder what op wrote before

Obviously I don’t know what the OP wrote in any previous communication, but unless you’re suggesting she’s lying, she didn’t say, do or write anything to provoke the “you ARE beautiful (yes you are!)” comment, or the tone of the message.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 11/01/2024 12:07

This would be ok with me if not for the fact that you'd had sex.