Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is BU? Neighbour's heat pump

115 replies

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 19:52

Help to resolve a dispute between DH and I.
Neighbours have installed a heat pump on the side of their house close to our boundary. It is very noisy! DH is not happy with the noise level, he has researched and regulations state should be no more than 42 dbs from our side. He's measured it as 60 dbs and 58 just outside our bedroom. He has sent an email to neighbour asking him to check it out, but no reply.

Relevant back story: We have lived in our house for 17 years, with no close neighbours (woodland). Couple of years ago the land was sold and developed. DH and I had different opinions on this- he thought having a house there was a good thing for security, I was really upset at the destruction of the trees.

Things got worse when they "accidentally" tore down our hedge (outside our fence but inside our boundary). There was then a boundary dispute, we had to pay for a land survey to resolve. Eventually "resolved" but boundary still not completely adhered when they erected fence.

So things were a bit awkward, then we had months of noisy building/ builders. Neighbours finally moved in and I was happy to let it all go for the sake of good relations. Have spoken to them briefly and all OK.

Now DH is complaining about the noise of the heat pump, where it doesn't really bother me that much and I would rather leave it. Especially as we have dogs that occasionally bark, and I'm sure we make noise of our own at times. I really don't want to be on bad terms with them- the reason we left our previous house was that our neighbours were horrible

Who's BU- DH or me? I think DH is being a bit petty, he thinks he is right to complain and that they are taking the piss! It was his idea to ask MN....

(Sorry about the essay, trying not to drip feed!!)

OP posts:
5thCommandment · 10/01/2024 23:42

Piffpaffpoff · 10/01/2024 19:55

It's almost 50% louder than it should be - I'd be speaking to the noise officer at your local council (if there is such a person) asap

EHO - environmental health officer. There are policies on this, they will need to move it or install something to reduce the noise (box it in?!)

SequentialAnalyst · 10/01/2024 23:34

Diyextension · 10/01/2024 23:29

I think you will.

how are you going to heat your house when you cant buy gas boilers anymore ?

I don't know about @Nanny0gg's residence, but my flat is all electricGrin

Diyextension · 10/01/2024 23:29

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 22:21

No, we won't

Many houses are not suitable for them

I think you will.

how are you going to heat your house when you cant buy gas boilers anymore ?

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 23:18

Thank you @mumummymeister , really useful information! I'll pass it on to DH

OP posts:
RadiantRainbow · 10/01/2024 23:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mummymeister · 10/01/2024 23:05

DH is not happy with the noise level, he has researched and regulations state should be no more than 42 dbs from our side....

Quite a lot wrong with this statement so will just give you the actual legal facts so you can take things forward. I am an ex EHO who dealt with statutory noise nuisance for over 20 years and was also a member of the institute of acoustics when I was working.

The issue here is, does it constitute a statutory noise nuisance. first off there are no set levels and no set times of day. None. 42 dB(A) so what if the background is 90 you wouldnt hear it.

For noise to be a nuisance depends on lots of variables - tonal characteristics, frequency, duration, level, audibility, back ground levels etc. The law isnt prescriptive and case law which goes back almost 100 years defines statutory noise nuisance as "that which is a nuisance or annoyance to the man on the Clapham omnibus" (sic)

There are two ways to take action for SNN. one is through the local authority. start off by keeping a diary of the noise - when you can hear when you cant, where in the building you can hear it, how audible is it (do you have to turn up your radio or TV) does it interfere with speech, does it affect the quiet enjoyment of your property. Does it have any tonal characteristics (thump whirr thump etc) keep this for several weeks. then speak to your local EHO and ask them to do a noise assessment. either someone will come around with a noise meter and take readings including background ones with the noise off or they will basically just come and listen. if they agree its a SNN they will serve notice under S79 - 84 of the Environmental protection act 1990 requiring action to be taken. this could be attenuation (baffling, mounting on rubber etc) or could be relocation who knows. If the EHO does not agree with you that its a SNN then you can take your own action. used to be called a S99 under the Public health act 1936 but same provision is in the EPA. again you keep records and you take to the magistrates court. I would suggest you employ your own acoustician to do the report. In all of this bear in mind - all complaints are logged and you have to declare them if you try to sell up within 5 years which may adversely affect your ability to sell. falling out with your neighbours is fucking miserable. there will be constant tit for tats between you, you will really hate living in your home. so before you do any of this, suggest mediation, try and find a solution because once you open that pandoras box that is legal action it is horrible.

Hippobot · 10/01/2024 22:58

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 20:09

OK, so it is just me being a wuss for an easy life! (Not unheard of!) Just we've been so long without close neighbours (2 houses have actually been built in the gap!) that the thought of falling out with next door makes me feel stressed

@ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs the thought of falling out with neighbours may make you feel stressed but there is plenty research that shows that long term exposure to noise levels above 50db in someone's home environment causes so much stress that it actually reduces life expectancy and causes diseases. If your husband is already bothered by this noise then it is likely already affecting his physical and mental health. A temporary stress for you in surely better than your husband feeling stressed all the time in his own home because of noise pollution. There are laws about the placement of these pumps for good reason! Also, if you don't address this through the appropriate channels you may have difficulty selling your home if/when you decide to do that. Your neighbours sound like CF already with the hedge/boundary nonsense. I wouldn't be trying to appease them when they couldn't give 2 hoots about your property and rights.

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 22:56

Blinkingbonkers · 10/01/2024 22:23

Where in the Country are you that the Council ignores the destruction of bat habitats?!…. Our council would’ve had the culprits at the police station sharpish…to be honest they’re a little ott on the subject but better that than the opposite I suppose!!! If your other neighbour had to seek permission to prune are you in a conservation area? If so they would have needed pp to remove the trees and if they did so without then they should have been prosecuted. Something very very wrong at your council if these are the circs!

We (and several other neighbours) officially objected to the planning on various grounds. I mentioned the lack of bat/ badger surveys, and they redacted those paragraphs on the public page! Don't know why... Got in touch with bat and badger conservation societies, but the trees were gone, so but pointless. Police useless at prosecuting, Animal Welfare Officer didn't know he was one, and suggested the local animal charity...
They had planning to cut down some trees, some were deemed healthy, but no-one seemed to care when we (and other neighbours) pointed out they had taken them all (very quickly, in just a few days). Have to say, have lost a lot of faith in the council after this whole thing. I can guarantee you, if those bats had moved into our attic you can bet they would have become protected again.....

OP posts:
Newbalancebeam · 10/01/2024 22:49

Their right to have a heat pump doesn’t trump your right to have peace and quiet. Don’t worry about upsetting them. They didn’t worry about upsetting you!

Blinkingbonkers · 10/01/2024 22:25

Vast majority of UK homes are not suitable for air pumps - really only work in ultra modern houses or complete retrofitted refurbs.

Blinkingbonkers · 10/01/2024 22:23

Where in the Country are you that the Council ignores the destruction of bat habitats?!…. Our council would’ve had the culprits at the police station sharpish…to be honest they’re a little ott on the subject but better that than the opposite I suppose!!! If your other neighbour had to seek permission to prune are you in a conservation area? If so they would have needed pp to remove the trees and if they did so without then they should have been prosecuted. Something very very wrong at your council if these are the circs!

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 22:21

aveline161 · 10/01/2024 22:16

I think you (he) will need to get over it. Everyone is acting like heat pumps are a lifestyle choice; eventually we will all have them and where are they supposed to put the thing- the middle of the lawn? Against the neighbours fence on the other side? They’re not deliberately making it noisy to annoy you, it is what it is and what they’ve destroying trees at least they’re somewhat offsetting by not using additional fossil fuels?

No, we won't

Many houses are not suitable for them

Lovetosleep1 · 10/01/2024 22:20

@TheJanuaryPinks you must be joking right?! I love trees, they're beautiful.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 22:20

TheJanuaryPinks · 10/01/2024 20:26

You were upset at “destruction of the trees”? 😂

What is wrong with you?

Ancient woodland?

I'd have been devastated

aveline161 · 10/01/2024 22:16

I think you (he) will need to get over it. Everyone is acting like heat pumps are a lifestyle choice; eventually we will all have them and where are they supposed to put the thing- the middle of the lawn? Against the neighbours fence on the other side? They’re not deliberately making it noisy to annoy you, it is what it is and what they’ve destroying trees at least they’re somewhat offsetting by not using additional fossil fuels?

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 22:07

Agree with your DH too, but also, of course you were upset at the destruction of the trees and wildlife! Ignore the poster laughing at you, hell of a lot weirder to not give a shit about that than it is to be upset about it.

Happyhappyday · 10/01/2024 21:50

What brand is the heat pump? Mitsubishi? We live in an area where they are very common (we have 2). One of ours was noisy but it was due to a bent fan blade and also due to the platform it was installed on. Once those two things were fixed, it was not at all noisy so they should be able to deal with it. That said, I think there are just a couple of really reputable heat pump manufacturers (Mitsubishi and Daikin) and a lot of others that are pretty sub standard, so if they have one of those, maybe it'll just be noisier.

Abitofalark · 10/01/2024 21:45

Your husband is right to want to do something about it, though I understand your own hesitation or reluctance to get into something with neighbours. As far as the council goes, remember they work for you, so do not hesitate to ask them to deal with an issue, however many other issues have arisen that fall to their responsibility.

I've experienced something a bit similar thing here when neighbours got planning permission to convert the garage, which is just the other side of the boundary fence, into a habitable room. Next thing I knew they've installed a shower room in it and I hear this humming noise from an extractor fan on the back wall. This is when I'm in my sitting room. I hear it through the double glazing, not loud but still annoying. I am dreading that the next thing will be a heat pump as they get everything new as it comes out.

2024afreshhope · 10/01/2024 21:44

My brother’s house was quite noisy from the noise of a neighbouring pub’s fans.

He built some baffles to deflect the noise - quite a cheap effective solution. But a bit hit and miss as to whether they’d work. Fortunately they do.

It may be that the fans need to be mounted on absorbant/rubber feet? It may be that they are unbalanced/have loose internal components/are faulty?

Measuring of sound levels, certainly in terms of legality/officially a nuisance is quite technical. Whilst diy meters will give a guide in terms of enforcement you’d need calibrated devices and technical help. Your council should be able to help.

TheShoulder · 10/01/2024 21:35

60dB??! That would drive me insane!

60dB about the same as normal conversation. 40dB is more like a whisper.

Anyone who thinks “normal conversation” levels doesn’t sound too bad, try whispering “whirwhirwhirwhir” next to someone then try it in your normal speaking voice to see how annoying it is 😂

I’m with your DH!

LauderSyme · 10/01/2024 21:34

Let's be charitable and say @TheJanuaryPinks has been cast adrift away from their roots in the natural world. But I like the "actual psychopath" response better!

There must be tons of charities whose purpose completely baffles Pinks. My mind is boggling at such a sad level of ignorance.

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 21:31

1CocklodgerHouse · 10/01/2024 21:29

Sorry didn’t word my question right, I meant was the noise level measured inside or outside the house. But if your house is 3m from the boundary I guess it was measured outside

Yeah, DH measured in our garden and just outside our bedroom window

OP posts:
TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 10/01/2024 21:30

Local authority should intervene to require a noise assessment by an acoustic consultant. They will specify an enclosure to contain the noise. Its a standard planning requirement for air conditioners but as usual the Tories have "cut red tape" for ASHPs without thinking of the consequences.

1CocklodgerHouse · 10/01/2024 21:29

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 10/01/2024 21:27

It's on the outside of their house, at ground level, about 1.5m from our boundary. Our house is about 3m from the boundary, our bedroom upstairs on that side

Sorry didn’t word my question right, I meant was the noise level measured inside or outside the house. But if your house is 3m from the boundary I guess it was measured outside

Fireyflies · 10/01/2024 21:29

Is there a fence between your house and the heat pump? If not, could you put one up? It might bounce the sound away from your house a bit.
We recently installed double glazing in my house and have been amazed how much less noise we hear from the street, if that's an option for you?
But you might want to try calling the council environmental health team and asking their advice. They may come and measure the nose, which would help you and them know whether there's further action could be taken.