Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I should have been godmother?

233 replies

ProbablyLate · 10/01/2024 16:05

I’m usually 100% on board with it being the parents’ right to choose who are their children’s godparents but I’m curious whether people think my BIL and SIL have been weird about this.

They asked DH to be DN’s godfather a couple of months ago (he’s BILs brother). I would have loved to also be asked but didn’t think too much of not being.

Anyway, at the christening on Sunday it turns out the godparents are DH’s other brother and his wife, DH, and one of BILs school friends.

SIL is an only child at DH only has the two brothers so of all DN’s aunts/uncles I’m the only one not to have been asked.

Me and DH have been together slightly longer than other BIL and SIL, both sets of us are married, live a similar distance away, and see one another a similar amount.

I would have said I got on well with both BIL and SILs so this has thrown me a bit!

On the day FIL was a bit 🤔about it but MIL cut him off with a “I’m sure Probably understands it’s their choice” (admittedly that probably wasn’t the moment to discuss it)

So AIBU to think I should have been asked to be godmother here?

OP posts:
LadyEloise1 · 10/01/2024 19:00

ProbablyLate · 10/01/2024 16:15

I haven’t mentioned it at all, even to DH, because I do appreciate it’s the parents’ decision. However, I also think it’s a bit of an unusual thing to do without mentioning it as I think it was always going to be obvious at the event that I was “left out”

If you hadn't mentioned it at all did your fil just bring it up on the day when his wife then said "I'm sure Probably understands." ?

5128gap · 10/01/2024 18:49

housethatbuiltme · 10/01/2024 17:58

That is absoloutly no part of it... there is zero legality in child care or adoption in it.

Which is why I clearly said 'MY understanding of the role' and that 'other people will have a different understanding of it' Had I been labouring under the misapprehension that was the legal position I'd have said so.

Maddy70 · 10/01/2024 18:48

You're "supposed" to have 3 godparents 2 male and 1 female for a boy and 2 female for a girl

No idea why you are peeved tbh

chopinwaltz26 · 10/01/2024 18:45

Abject apologies, but I forgot to mention that, in the CofE, godparents are normally christened and confirmed in that religion.

DeeIee · 10/01/2024 18:44

You are being ridiculous. And the fact that you think you should have been asked just because you are married to your DH is crazy. It's about the person, the relationship, the closeness, not who you're married to. My DH was asked both times for his niece and nephew, I wasn't asked for either and it literally didn't even remotely enter my head until seeing your post. I'm talking over 10 years ago for both. They asked their close friends, DB, people who you would expect. Not just people for the sake of it.

tachetastic · 10/01/2024 18:44

FlamingoQueen · 10/01/2024 18:41

They may be thinking that you’ll be first in line for the next baby!

I was also thinking this, but then it would have been better to have just BIL/SIL and two friends this time, and the OP/DH and two other friends next time.

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/01/2024 18:44

shoulda, woulda, coulda - etc

It's only a 'title' - I enjoy being 'Auntie' Thing, for some dc, it gives them a sense that someone else cares too.

bathsinkdoorandwindow · 10/01/2024 18:43

I agree there is no "should" about it, however I can see your point that it was a shock to see the other SIL included on the day and to feel left out.

You haven't mentioned it to anybody and I feel you're responding to comments here and generally taking it with good grace.

I think that's the right thing to do (the only thing to do, really).

There could be many reasons why this is what they've chosen, you may find out you may not. But it sounds like you all generally have a good relationship so I wouldn't dwell on it or let it upset you. X

Mittens1717 · 10/01/2024 18:43

DisforDarkChocolate · 10/01/2024 16:16

I've never been asked and I'll be honest it does hurt, it's also not my decision so I focus on that. I've never been a bridesmaid either. Perhaps I'm just horrible?

You're not horrible, I've never been asked either and yes it does hurt 😔

chopinwaltz26 · 10/01/2024 18:43

I do not think that Godparents are the same as Guardians.
Godparents are supposed to provide guidance and advice. Guardians are supposed to be who looks after a child or children, should anything happen to their parents
I am one of 3. We all had different godparents, but our guardians were one of my maternal aunts and her husband, neither of whom was a godparent to any of us.
My SIL explained godparents in a really good way to my godson. Chopin is a "special" aunt. He is now 23 and the last time I saw him, which was at Christmas, I got massive kisses and loads of adult chat :-)

FlamingoQueen · 10/01/2024 18:41

They may be thinking that you’ll be first in line for the next baby!

plumberdrain · 10/01/2024 18:41

ISSTIUTNG · 10/01/2024 18:37

Well my overall point and contribution to the thread was that you will never be good enough for some people no matter how hard you try. Blood should be thicker than water but that will only be the case if all parties see it this way. Otherwise they can be just as insignificant to you as you are to them. The choice is ultimately your's, that's my point

i have read and re read your description of your relationship with your sister and i’m completely baffled why you’d ever think or want to be involved with her family. There is nothing, nothing, to suggest you would have been 😐 @ISSTIUTNG

Changethetoner · 10/01/2024 18:41

We had no family or friends that were Christians, so when we had our baby baptized they didn't get any godparents. The Priest tried to force/encourage us to nominate people from the church, but as we didn't know them that well, we declined. It caused a bit of a stir, but we genuinely had no-one to ask to do it. So DH and I signed the paperwork ourselves.

Maray1967 · 10/01/2024 18:39

chopinwaltz26 · 10/01/2024 17:44

Godparents do not go in pairs.
I am godmother to the eldest child of my brother and the eldest child of my sister. There was no question of my other half being involved.
By the same token, my brother is godfather to our sister's son, no question of my SIL being involved.
When choosing godparents, you choose 1 person, not a married (or otherwise) couple.

Edited

My DH and I are godparents to both of two siblings and the parents are our DCs’ godparents.

I was brought up by an active churchgoer who had no godparents for me or DB.

I don’t think there are fixed rules.

I think OP is right to be hurt - this is a very strange choice and does look very awkward. If I was OP, though, I would raise it with DH - just to ask whether he knows why SIL was chosen and I was left out.

ISSTIUTNG · 10/01/2024 18:37

Mrsttcno1 · 10/01/2024 18:32

Haven’t you sort of proved my point there then? You and her have never gotten along, you dislike her, she dislikes you… so of course when she had a baby, you weren’t on the visit list.

I’m not saying that’s your fault, but you didn’t have a good close relationship with her beforehand, so you were unreasonable to think you would have a good close relationship with the baby.

Again, your relationships with babies are just an extension of your relationships with their parents. Not close to the parents = not going to be close to the baby.

Well my overall point and contribution to the thread was that you will never be good enough for some people no matter how hard you try. Blood should be thicker than water but that will only be the case if all parties see it this way. Otherwise they can be just as insignificant to you as you are to them. The choice is ultimately your's, that's my point

LuluBlakey1 · 10/01/2024 18:37

ProbablyLate · 10/01/2024 16:15

I haven’t mentioned it at all, even to DH, because I do appreciate it’s the parents’ decision. However, I also think it’s a bit of an unusual thing to do without mentioning it as I think it was always going to be obvious at the event that I was “left out”

You weren't 'left out'. You have no right to be a godparent- the child's parents have a free choice and, for whatever reason, did not want to choose you.
Possibly:
BIL's old friend is someone he very much wanted to have a role in his child's life. My best friend has 2 D Sis and 2 D Brothers but she asked me and another friend to be godparents to each of her two DC
They don't like you as much as the other 3 they chose.
They are saving you for their next DC.
They might be going to ask you if you would be a guardian if something ever happened to both of them.

Their choice. No 'should' about it.

redxlondon · 10/01/2024 18:36

You haven’t mentioned anything about your relationship to the parents. My godchildren are the children of my best friends. A family relationship gives you no automatic right. Really odd tbh that you’ve made it all about the family dynamic and not personal friendships.

ek20 · 10/01/2024 18:34

So as well as being involved in the spiritual upbringing of the child it's also common that the godparents would be considered the people to take care of the child if the parents died. Could that be it? Are they more financially stable than you? Or have/don't have children of their own? Maybe it was deliberate that only one couple were involved to prevent any future squabbles.

sunandfog · 10/01/2024 18:33

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

sunandfog · 10/01/2024 18:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Mrsttcno1 · 10/01/2024 18:32

ISSTIUTNG · 10/01/2024 18:28

The kindof relationship was that we did all the running around and visitting my IL's, mostly whilst being smirked at and looked down on by my self-indulgent little princess of a SIL who's 6 years younger than me. I tolerated her being a total bitch to me for years before any baby arrived. I could tell that SIL and PIL can't stand me for nothing other than superficial reasons. Her PIL are 100% preoccupied with their princess daughter and couldn't give a shit about anything affecting myself and my husband. If we ever did anything to remotely upset SIL we were even more austracised for it whether the SIL was in the wrong or not because PIL seem determined to eternally lick her arse and call it ice cream

There was a serious event in the family and it could easily have meant that my dh and I lost our child through no fault of our own. My IL's significantly contributed to this and yet when it all came to light the only thing they all cared about was how it was affecting them.

It's hard to believe for people who actually have nice families but some are just scum who are never actually going to care about you no matter what you do

Edited

Haven’t you sort of proved my point there then? You and her have never gotten along, you dislike her, she dislikes you… so of course when she had a baby, you weren’t on the visit list.

I’m not saying that’s your fault, but you didn’t have a good close relationship with her beforehand, so you were unreasonable to think you would have a good close relationship with the baby.

Again, your relationships with babies are just an extension of your relationships with their parents. Not close to the parents = not going to be close to the baby.

SerafinasGoose · 10/01/2024 18:31

On the day FIL was a bit 🤔about it but MIL cut him off with a “I’m sure Probably understands it’s their choice” (admittedly that probably wasn’t the moment to discuss it)

Ouch. That is pointed, OP; particularly given it was said in your hearing which does tend to suggest you were intended to hear.

Of course people have their own reasons for their choices, but leaving out one person in the circumstances you describe is a glaring omission and this also looks pointed. FiL, at least, has clearly picked up on this enough to comment on it.

Despite the inevitable comments upthread that your expectations are too great, that no one has the 'right' to be asked, etc., it is natural to be hurt by this. It does convey the message, whether intentionally or otherwise, that you are valued less than the other family members. It also really, really stings when you discover (or suspect) that others value you less than you do them.

Of course you can say nothing, as you'd (probably rightly) be accused of making it all about you. If this is a passive-aggressive snub, then the frustrating thing about passive aggression is that if you push back in response to it, you are the one who ends looking like a troublemaker.

I suggest you say nothing and do nothing, just file this information away for future reference. It's not worth causing a family schism over this, but I think I'd start taking very gradual steps back and spending my time instead with family and friends whom I know truly value my presence.

🌹

ISSTIUTNG · 10/01/2024 18:28

Mrsttcno1 · 10/01/2024 18:11

There is 2 sides I agree, but there’s also often a backstory.

What kind of relationship did you have with them pre-pregnancy, how often did you see each other, all go out together, make plans together, speak to each other? How many times did you go round to see her when she was pregnant? How many times did you make plans with just her? How many times did you call and check in with her/them throughout the pregnancy?

If the answer to any of those is never/none/not much… of course you wouldn’t be on the invite list when baby is here.

I’m not saying that is the case for you, but there does seem to be this idea people have that regardless of the relationship you have with the mum & dad, everyone should be given equal and free access to any baby born “because they’re family”. If you didn’t have a close relationship pre-pregnancy and you didn’t have a close relationship during pregnancy, you can’t expect a close relationship after pregnancy. A woman (and both parents to be honest) never forgets the people that were there for HER. Take my BIL & SIL for example, I haven’t got a relationship with them currently, we don’t meet up, they don’t come round despite over the years us having repeatedly asked and made effort, they have maybe asked once how pregnancy is going. Me giving birth doesn’t suddenly mean I will then welcome them into my home constantly.

Your relationship with the child is an extension of your relationship with mum/dad, if you don’t really have a relationship with mum/dad, you will not have one with baby.

The kindof relationship was that we did all the running around and visitting my IL's, mostly whilst being smirked at and looked down on by my self-indulgent little princess of a SIL who's 6 years younger than me. I tolerated her being a total bitch to me for years before any baby arrived. I could tell that SIL and PIL can't stand me for nothing other than superficial reasons. Her PIL are 100% preoccupied with their princess daughter and couldn't give a shit about anything affecting myself and my husband. If we ever did anything to remotely upset SIL we were even more austracised for it whether the SIL was in the wrong or not because PIL seem determined to eternally lick her arse and call it ice cream

There was a serious event in the family and it could easily have meant that my dh and I lost our child through no fault of our own. My IL's significantly contributed to this and yet when it all came to light the only thing they all cared about was how it was affecting them.

It's hard to believe for people who actually have nice families but some are just scum who are never actually going to care about you no matter what you do

Rewis · 10/01/2024 18:25

In general I don't think couples need to be asked to be godparents. But I can totally understand why you're hurt in this case. But no need to dwell on it. Just consentrate on being an aunty and don't do any of the mental load of present buying etc. So make sure that's your husbands responsibility.

Wexone · 10/01/2024 18:21

ISSTIUTNG · 10/01/2024 18:13

Families can be right funny buggars and there's very little you can do about it. It took a lot of years of heartbreak and ultimately a very significant event for me to finally realise my IL's were never going to really care for me/dh/dh or put our needs first no matter what I do. This was actually very liberating as I pay them no mind now. I'll breathe the same air as them and that seems to work for us all

Well done. I think the same as you however for my parents its harder and hurts them so much. For example my mother sat the other side of the room in the hairdressers while my brothers mother in law sat the other side ( she didn't realise till leaving she was there ) and listened to everyone cooing over photos, how big he is getting, what food he is eating milestones he has reached etc that he knows nothing about. My fathers work collegues able to tell him about photos put up on FB etc that we are not part of but everyone else is. We live in a small town to make it worse. They are now actually contemplating moving, from a place they have lived in for over 20 years because of it