Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I should have been godmother?

233 replies

ProbablyLate · 10/01/2024 16:05

I’m usually 100% on board with it being the parents’ right to choose who are their children’s godparents but I’m curious whether people think my BIL and SIL have been weird about this.

They asked DH to be DN’s godfather a couple of months ago (he’s BILs brother). I would have loved to also be asked but didn’t think too much of not being.

Anyway, at the christening on Sunday it turns out the godparents are DH’s other brother and his wife, DH, and one of BILs school friends.

SIL is an only child at DH only has the two brothers so of all DN’s aunts/uncles I’m the only one not to have been asked.

Me and DH have been together slightly longer than other BIL and SIL, both sets of us are married, live a similar distance away, and see one another a similar amount.

I would have said I got on well with both BIL and SILs so this has thrown me a bit!

On the day FIL was a bit 🤔about it but MIL cut him off with a “I’m sure Probably understands it’s their choice” (admittedly that probably wasn’t the moment to discuss it)

So AIBU to think I should have been asked to be godmother here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moreorlessmentallystable · 19/01/2024 12:05

Could have written this post. Never been asked to be part of anyone's wedding or to be godparent for my nieces/nephews. Me and my husband are the longest relationship in the family. He has been usher twice, best man once, and godparent and I am just there feeling undeserving every time 😂

Pogue4Life · 19/01/2024 10:05

@ProbablyLate i totally understand where you’re coming from.
I’ve been though similar. Was best friends, with someone I worked with, for well over 10 years.
When she had her first baby she asked school friend and family to be god parents (fair enough, she had known them longer) although she was asked to be my child’s god mother.
I spoke at her wedding, helped organise her surprise birthday party and we saw each other regularly (by this point we weren’t working together anymore) we sent the kids presents at birthdays etc.
She then ended up getting pregnant with twins, was really excited for her. She asked someone that she had worked with for 2 years at this point to be godmother to BOTH children. I was devastated when she told me. We still see each other but our relationship is nowhere near what it was.
She knew I’d never been asked to be a godparent to anyone’s child.

Martha645 · 14/01/2024 07:52

@JoanneParish

I 100% agree with you. My husband was not annoyed or upset but his mother (and her family) were upset. None of them had even met the best man or the bridesmaids (the bride’s sisters).

JoanneParish · 14/01/2024 05:57

I don’t know if there is a “should” in matters of godparents/bridal parties/etc… YANBU to be hurt or miffed, but YWBU if you made a big deal of it or raised it with the parents.
I would reevaluate the relationship and ensure you are matching their energy level. I’m not saying cut them off or do anything drastic, I’m just saying that they have clearly identified their chosen people and I wouldn’t be going above and beyond in future.

Side story: my friend and her sister used to be super close, almost to the point of codependent. Best friends, maid of honor, daily phone calls, etc. Older sister got married, had baby and despite younger sister being asked to help (cook/clean/babysit) weekly, older sister chose married brother and wife to be godparents and told younger sister that it’s because she wanted married godparents and younger sister was single. Second child came, godparents were married school friend and husband (ironically nasty divorce now). Third child, single sister was asked and declined. Single sister is now married with kids and sees older sister once a year and there is almost no relationship.

My point is that parents can ask who they like, but they have zero control over how others feel about their choices.

Martha645 · 14/01/2024 03:47

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 06:14

You expected them to follow what you did. And when they didn’t, you concluded they were “weird”

Nope. What is weird is thinking that someone is weird for not replicating your decision

Just adding that when their only child was born they gave him the same name as my son. So now the grandparents have 2 grandchildren named “Bobby Smith”

Folks are weird……..

Beenthroughit · 12/01/2024 19:12

Traditionally a boy has 2 godfathers has one godmother
A girl has 2 godmothers and 1 godfather
This isn't set in stone and it's possible to have more but pretty u usual, there's have to be a reason for it, you can have fewer too, my children have one of each

SerafinasGoose · 12/01/2024 13:05

MadMadaMim · 12/01/2024 00:23

Read your comments. It's very clear why.

You made the whole thing about you. Repeatedly.

I don't think she has. She thought nothing of it until it became very evident that she alone had been pointedly left out (and an even more pointed reference to it made on the day by her in-laws).

Of course, making an issue of this at this stage would be 'making it all about you'. This would be inadvisable.

But it's certainly one to file away for future reference.

Enko · 12/01/2024 11:00

@Spirallingdownwards. I didn't miss the joke I wasn't specifically quoting you.

I do find it worrisome when people are adamant x has been said when it is open to interpretation.

@plumberdrain. Personally I would argue the key part is "in some countries" not even mentioning what countries. However I think we are of the same agreement "this is not a current practice and Wikipedia is not claiming this happens right now in ANY country"

On a side note the Wikipedia entry is actually interesting.

AlleycatMarie · 12/01/2024 10:23

Is this a nephew or niece? And what is the gender of the school friend? I think traditionally, you only ask one godmother for a boy and more godfathers/ one godfather for a girl and more godmothers. Are they very traditional?

T1Dmama · 12/01/2024 10:10

I understand @ProbablyLate … It’s not the fact you weren’t asked that bothers you, it’s the fact you were the only one not to be asked!!
I wouldn’t mention it to anyone else, but I would mention it to DH!!….. if he’s anything like my ex there was probably a discussion had between him and his brother about God parents and they’d probably said they were having SIL this time and you next… and he said oh great then just never told you!!
My ex would be on the phone to his mother for ages… I’d ask ‘How’s your mum?… what did she say?’….
He’d always reply that she’d said ‘nothing much!’

Then further down the line I’d find out some major news had been revealed like his niece was pregnant!!….In fact once I got a message from his mother saying his niece had given birth to a baby girl and called it Ruby and blubbering on about some nonsense…. I responded about what a surprise that was to me as no one had even told me she was pregnant !! 😂😂

Mention it in a ‘just passing’ comment to your husband and see if he suddenly reveals some big discussion about it!

Also you haven’t said … do you have children? Does the other SIL have children?

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 09:14

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 09:05

I appreciate it.

I should know better really, I'm practising too with an A level in Theology and generations of clergy family! I'm usually pretty good on rules and conventions and understandings of C of E.

Bit cross with myself for having made an assumption without checking but you live and learn.

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 09:05

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 08:36

Alright, I'll stand corrected.

I appreciate it.

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 09:04

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 08:27

how do you know all this?

Partly because I’m a practising Anglican; partly because we moved house between DC1 and DC2 so one was baptised by a very strict priest and one by a very relaxed one; and partly because I went to a university with a big theology department and although I didn’t study it myself I consequently have a lot of friends who are priests Smile.

yeahwhatev · 12/01/2024 08:48

In the end we didn’t christen our twins partly because of this family politics - just couldn’t be bothered with it! I think it’s significant your sIL is an only child. So all the godparents are her husbands siblings - she probably just wanted at least one person from ‘her side’ so it was a friend. The husband probably felt he was doing the right thing by asking all his siblings. I don’t think that automatically includes their wives too. Maybe he’s not that close to you and hoped you’d just understand that all the spots couldn’t be taken up by his side of the family!!

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 08:36

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:14

Yes, because pragmatic priests will often use their judgment to make exceptions (some even turn a blind eye to unbaptised godparents) but that doesn’t change the canon law and it doesn’t make it ‘convention’.

Alright, I'll stand corrected.

Nanaof1 · 12/01/2024 08:33

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 07:13

There’s no ‘these days’ about it. Conventions vary between denominations. Church of England is a minimum of three, two of whom are the same sex as the child. In the Catholic Church only one godparent is the norm, sometimes two.

On this side of the pond, when mine were small, Catholic churches and Protestant religions that encouraged having Godparents usually had two, most often a married couple. I would imagine that has changed with the changes in circumstances.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 08:27

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:14

Yes, because pragmatic priests will often use their judgment to make exceptions (some even turn a blind eye to unbaptised godparents) but that doesn’t change the canon law and it doesn’t make it ‘convention’.

how do you know all this?

Nanaof1 · 12/01/2024 08:23

Lizzieregina · 10/01/2024 16:11

Definitely a bit odd to exclude you in that circumstance. Also that’s a lot of godparents for one child!

In my day, Godparents (2) were chosen and accepted the role that, if anything ever happened to both parents, the Godmother and Godfather would raise their child. I read above that it is different for the CoE, so that may be the reason for their choices.

It's mostly a ceremonial role, unless the parent's feel/hope the Godparents should/will give lavish gifts on birthdays and holidays (something else I've seen over the years, along with a few other expectations). I know, even in my day it was supposed to be religious instruction and guidance but honestly, I didn't see GP's doing that at all. The parents did that role. If your church expects that and the GP's follow that path, that is really nice, and you should have been included.

OP--It's not that big of a deal, unless they start expecting your DH (and by extension you) to take care of the child when they want some time off. Then, since you aren't Godmother, you can feel free to refuse. So, it can be a good thing. (Remembering another thread in here with Nephews and DH's)😉

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:14

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 08:11

If you look on the C of E website under guides to life events it says "should", not must. Which is a deliberate softening to me.

Yes, because pragmatic priests will often use their judgment to make exceptions (some even turn a blind eye to unbaptised godparents) but that doesn’t change the canon law and it doesn’t make it ‘convention’.

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 08:11

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:06

Can I refer you to my reply to@plumberdrain for the relevant section of the Canons of the C of E. Pragmatic priests will often use their judgment to make exceptions but that doesn’t change the canon law.

If you look on the C of E website under guides to life events it says "should", not must. Which is a deliberate softening to me.

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 08:11

shout out to my rule breaking priest!

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:06

DappledThings · 12/01/2024 07:57

That's not a C of E rule at all. It's a convention. Only requirement is that the godparents are baptised themselves.

Can I refer you to my reply to@plumberdrain for the relevant section of the Canons of the C of E. Pragmatic priests will often use their judgment to make exceptions but that doesn’t change the canon law.

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 08:05

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:59

where is this “rule” (that my priest was unaware of!) published?

Um, the Canon Law of the Church of England, so you can drop your sarky inverted commas. There’s no way your priest wasn’t aware of it. Likely they have decided not to apply the letter of the law in their parish. Don’t worry, it doesn’t make your child any less baptised.

Someone else has already posted a screen grab upthread. The relevant section is B23:

”1. For every child to be baptized there shall be not fewer than three godparents, of whom at least two shall be of the same sex as the child and of whom at least one shall be of the opposite sex; save that, when three cannot conveniently be had, one godfather and godmother shall suffice. Parents may be godparents for their own children provided that the child have at least one other godparent.”

Do feel free to take a look for yourself: https://www.churchofengland.org/about/leadership-and-governance/legal-services/canons-church-england/section-b

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:59

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 07:54

Then she was baptised by a priest who wasn’t too bothered about the rules! Some are stricter than others.

where is this “rule” (that my priest was unaware of!) published?

plumberdrain · 12/01/2024 07:58

MotherOfHouseplants · 12/01/2024 07:54

Then she was baptised by a priest who wasn’t too bothered about the rules! Some are stricter than others.

well yes, of course she was baptised by a priest. it was c of e. So the rules you state are most certainly not a universal fact