Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate next doors cat with an absolute passion

105 replies

PostWar9 · 10/01/2024 15:23

Next door have this nightmare cat which I think is a nasty little creature. Constantly destroying my garden, going to toilet in it, hissing at us. It’s got to the point now where whenever it comes into the garden I specifically let the dog out to chase it to get it out and I’d never normally do that. Dog stays inside most of the year. A lot of cats are filled with love and you can see as friends or companions but this one is just not nice at all. AIBU to hate this cat?

OP posts:
Bellyblueboy · 10/01/2024 18:21

Please don’t send your dog out to attack the cat.

I once overhead a neighbour joking about allowing his dog to kill my cat. I hate than man with a passion - and got my revenge when he need access via my garden. I said no and explained I couldnt risk removing the fence even temporarily when he had a dangerous dog! Then further explained when he looked confused. He back pedalled furiously - but I wouldn’t change my position!

SunnieShine · 10/01/2024 18:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KeeeeeepDancing · 10/01/2024 18:13

I think the root of the conflict seems to be that you think your garden is yours. And the cat thinks your garden is its garden.
Hence it is defending its territory. You have to show it who is boss. By shooing it out of the garden yourself. Yes to a supersoaker, ready filled with water. Won't hurt the cat but it will get the message.

OldTinHat · 10/01/2024 18:08

I also hate my neighbour's cat with a passion. It shits on the flat roof under a bedroom window and if I open the windows the whole house stinks. My flat roof is literally a litter tray.

I've sat in the window armed with water pistols, shouted, put anti cat pellets all over but no, the bastardy cat still shits in one half under the window and sun bathes at the other end.

treeinthedistance · 10/01/2024 17:50

What do you mean by 'destroying' the garden? If it's causing damage then might be worth a chat with the owner?

On the subject of wildlife... of course I understand that we don't want rats, etc and potentially harmful creatures right on top of us, but it does bug me when people are surprised to see foxes, rodents and the like in their garden. We're constantly eroding their habitat, where do we expect them to go? Animals don't understand the concept of our human boundaries, and why should they? The world isn't just for us.

Butterandtoast · 10/01/2024 17:48

puncheur · 10/01/2024 17:34

Foxes are native wild animals, domestic cats are not. And if you don't want a fox in your garden you're perfectly within your rights to shoot it. Shooting domestic cats is a bit more problematic as they count as property so you could, in theory, be charged with criminal damage. However feral cats are on the DEFRA open licence so as long as you have a valid reason (e.g. protection of wildlife) and they don't have a collar you can get away with claiming it was a feral.

Yes, because lots of people shoot animals in their gardens in the UK

Very relatable post 👌

puncheur · 10/01/2024 17:39

AInightingale · 10/01/2024 17:32

They do get a bad press - justifiably in the case of birds, but the mouse and rat problem would be considerably worse without outdoor cats. We had a nightmare couple of years during the 'Covid summers' due to a neighbour ground-feeding birds incl. pigeons, and my cat was catching about 5-6 mice in the gardens a day.

The mice and voles they kill are not a "problem". Rats and house mice can be, but the mouse species that live outdoors (wood mice, yellow-necked mice, harvest mice and dormice) are not pests, and in the case of the dormouse are endangered. Voles are generally not pests either (and again, in the case of the water vole, are endangered).

puncheur · 10/01/2024 17:34

VolvoFan · 10/01/2024 17:14

Would you feel the same way if a fox wandered into your garden?

Foxes are native wild animals, domestic cats are not. And if you don't want a fox in your garden you're perfectly within your rights to shoot it. Shooting domestic cats is a bit more problematic as they count as property so you could, in theory, be charged with criminal damage. However feral cats are on the DEFRA open licence so as long as you have a valid reason (e.g. protection of wildlife) and they don't have a collar you can get away with claiming it was a feral.

AInightingale · 10/01/2024 17:32

They do get a bad press - justifiably in the case of birds, but the mouse and rat problem would be considerably worse without outdoor cats. We had a nightmare couple of years during the 'Covid summers' due to a neighbour ground-feeding birds incl. pigeons, and my cat was catching about 5-6 mice in the gardens a day.

ginasevern · 10/01/2024 17:28

beezlebubnicky · 10/01/2024 16:19

I'll get flamed for this - but this is why cats should be indoors or out in a catio/harness trained for outdoors. Most countries do this and the cats are fine, if they have enough enrichment, facilities and toys they are extremely happy and they live longer on average.

I've never understood why we are so hell bent in this country on letting our cats shit in other people's gardens, annoy neighbours, indiscriminately kill wildlife, be exposed to pathogens, poisons and so on.

I've never understood why humans are allowed to pour a gazillion ton of sewage, plastic and noxious waste into the rivers and oceans. Or why they are allowed to hunt other creatures to extinction, destroy their habitats and indiscriminately kill for fun or profit.

pinksunglasses · 10/01/2024 17:27

I get really bad vibes from people who can hate animals like this. Setting your dog on a cat for just being…a cat, is pretty unhinged.

Katastrophic · 10/01/2024 17:26

Does no one else think it’s a bit weird to have a dog that doesn’t go for any walks anymore? Is it disabled? Elderly dogs still need exercise and usually enjoy going out for short walks.

DewHopper · 10/01/2024 17:23

Horribly cruel to set your dog on a cat. What a scummy thing to do.

ExtraOnions · 10/01/2024 17:22

VolvoFan · 10/01/2024 17:14

Would you feel the same way if a fox wandered into your garden?

It would have a job .. I live in a terrace with a high back wall, so unless it can fly.

It’s such a weak argument from cat owner “foxes can do that as well”.. it’s a lot more difficult for a fox to get into a garden than a cat..

AInightingale · 10/01/2024 17:21

The best way to keep neighbours' cats out of your garden is to get your own cat, preferably a tom as they seem more territorial. Obviously you have to really want to own and look after it for the long haul, I'm not suggesting it just for guardcat reasons. Your own cat will pick a specific toilet spot and stick to it probably. My parents were keen gardeners and our pet cat never had much impact on their plants etc.

BassoContinuo · 10/01/2024 17:17

VolvoFan · 10/01/2024 17:14

Would you feel the same way if a fox wandered into your garden?

People don’t keep pet foxes, though, so it’s not really comparable. (I’d say the same about feral cats, actually, although would be inwardly cursing whoever allowed them to originally get that way)

Why should someone’s desire to have a pet impact on their neighbours?

BreatheAndFocus · 10/01/2024 17:15

I’ve had many cats over the years but I hate the ones local to me simply because of the disgusting crapping all over my front path, my lawn and my garden. What if I let my dog crap all over my neighbours front garden as I walked past? They’d be rightly pissed off, but they let their cat crap all over mine.

Much as I love cats, I think urban cats (ie cats in areas of housing) should have to have an indoor or outdoor litter tray. And yes, they can be trained to use it. I think lots of people get cats because they think they’re an easy pet - and then they do f**k all to look after them.

OP, you need to break the habit of the cat crapping in your garden. They return to the same place by habit. Also, find it’s point of entry and put something to deter it, eg a piece of trellis, rubber spikes, children’s windmills, etc.

VolvoFan · 10/01/2024 17:14

ExtraOnions · 10/01/2024 16:59

Cat owners seem to generally believe that, once thier cat is out the house, they become absent of any responsibility around cats behaviour.
Cat shouod be allowed to wander, shit, kill whatever birds it wants .. as “that’s what cats do”, it would be “cruel” to make it stop in.
So those of us don’t like cats, or don’t want cats on our property have no choice other than to suck it up.
The persons right to own a cat, clearly outweighs my rights not to have one on my property .. for some inexplicable reason.

Would you feel the same way if a fox wandered into your garden?

Mothership4two · 10/01/2024 17:04

My neighbour swore that their ultrasonic pest repeller kept her NDN's cats out of her garden. It certainly has worked stoppping another neighbour's dog that used to come into our front garden most mornings to do an early morning surprise poo for us.

I'm a cat lover, but would also suggest a water pistol for when you want to go out and enjoy your garden when its there.

Retas · 10/01/2024 17:04

Solar cat deterrents can be bought online. It detects movement then makes a frequency humans don't hear. Haven't had the local cat shit in my garden since. I was picking up its crap everyday, had tried orange peel but its effect didn't last long.

VolvoFan · 10/01/2024 17:02

Cats will be cats. I have two that are indoor only. My neighbours have cats that come into our garden, poop everywhere and annoy our two watching them from the kitchen window or French doors. I think it's a bit cruel to set your dog on them. A spray of water will suffice.

ExtraOnions · 10/01/2024 16:59

Cat owners seem to generally believe that, once thier cat is out the house, they become absent of any responsibility around cats behaviour.
Cat shouod be allowed to wander, shit, kill whatever birds it wants .. as “that’s what cats do”, it would be “cruel” to make it stop in.
So those of us don’t like cats, or don’t want cats on our property have no choice other than to suck it up.
The persons right to own a cat, clearly outweighs my rights not to have one on my property .. for some inexplicable reason.

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 16:55

TeenLifeMum · 10/01/2024 16:40

@ManateeFair yep, a bill to the neighbour would be laughed at. Totally legal for a cat to roam free in this country (whether we agree or not), no normal person would agree to pay.

Have you tried a water pistol by the back door?

Yes, I know it would - I was joking, to make the point that it's bloody unfair that this is how it is.

If I had a cat that was straying into a neighbour's garden and causing a nuisance, I honestly would make alterations to my own fence, rather than expecting the neighbour to alter theirs, because it would have been my choice to get a cat and I'd feel bad for being a terrible neighbour otherwise. My sister actually did do this when she had cats, because they were being a proper pest to her neighbour and she felt bad about it (admittedly my sister had four cats and all four of them were very bold and inquisitive, so I think they did generate more feline mayhem than most).

billybear · 10/01/2024 16:54

i have side strip open plan garden local cat messed everywhere, i ment business. put mesh down round where it dug and went to loo. cheap herbal tea bags from aldi, sprayed them with orbis oil. it really did put it off,

Peanutsnanna · 10/01/2024 16:54

Water pistol. I adore cats.💕