Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i have invited my brother to a girls weekend away?

443 replies

NatMoz · 10/01/2024 15:18

It is both my mum's 70th and my aunty's 60th in March/April.

My brother had made 0 plans and his only idea was a Chinese. I said that I'll book a girls long weekend away (myself, mum and aunty) to make it memorable and he can be in charge of the inclusive family meal where everyone will be invited to celebrate which he agreed to.

So I've planned, booked, organised an itinerary for a long weekend European city break for the 3 of us for a girls weekend. My brother is now absolutely hounding me because he has decided he would also like to join in on the girls weekend. Telling me he doesn't mind carrying the bags and is there room for a little one. I explained it would spoil the dynamic of the trip and at 31 why would he want to spend a girls weekend with us anyway🤣. He is already going on holiday with my mum and dad for 10 days in June to Greece so it's not like he's missing out on going abroad and spending time with my parents! He lives at home so spends every day with them so again it's not like he lives on the other side of the world.

He explained he hasn't been on holiday with my aunty in 10 years. The last time he did, i organised that trip too!!! I did say if he felt so strongly about it, why has he not organised something prior to this point as there have been 10 years of opportunities.

I've now been told I'm banned from the family meal he is organising 🤷.

To clarify further, my husband, my dad nor my daughter (aged 2) will be attending this weekend away either. Just myself, mum and aunty.

Am i in the wrong here?

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 11/01/2024 08:52

plumberdrain · 11/01/2024 05:58

i presume you don’t ever read, listen or watch any news relating to the UK economy nor the housing market

@plumberdrain

i do yes, I’m well aware.

if he can’t afford to buy or rent on his own, why can’t he move into a house share? The answer isn’t to just live with patents indefinitely.

Seymour5 · 11/01/2024 08:51

We do women only trips, friends, daughter, daughter in law at least once a year. My 70 something birthday this year will be at our favourite spa. DH would hate it, and DS and other male partners are looking after their children, dogs etc. They do their own thing too sometimes.

We have family get togethers too, and odd events that random family and friends might join forces for. I’m with you OP, it’ll be a relaxing break for your mum and that’s whats important. As others have said, your brother needs to grow up.

HRTQueen · 11/01/2024 08:45

No I didn’t misread I mentioned my man child brother in previous post and mentioned married to or have men in their lives in post you quoted Getthethrowonthesofa

KimberleyClark · 11/01/2024 08:44

Bit odd to exclude your brother from a family trip.

Getthethrowonthesofa · 11/01/2024 08:42

HRTQueen · 11/01/2024 08:40

i know on MN many posters are married to or the men in their lives that between them enjoy all the same activities, that feel there is no separation in what the sexes like and the men are always considerate to their needs

but many of us have men in our lives that have separate interests, that enjoy separate times between the men and women which we enjoy to, men that are not interested in going to the ballet and as already demonstrated will often act like a man child

Sounds like a lovely weekend op. Being surrounded by men/boys for most of my work and home life I often crave female only company

I’m sorry I think you misread, it’s not her husband, it’s her brother, and it’s a family weekend away.

HRTQueen · 11/01/2024 08:40

i know on MN many posters are married to or the men in their lives that between them enjoy all the same activities, that feel there is no separation in what the sexes like and the men are always considerate to their needs

but many of us have men in our lives that have separate interests, that enjoy separate times between the men and women which we enjoy to, men that are not interested in going to the ballet and as already demonstrated will often act like a man child

Sounds like a lovely weekend op. Being surrounded by men/boys for most of my work and home life I often crave female only company

colourfulchinadolls · 11/01/2024 08:35

I'd imagine the mum would be grateful for a break from her 31 year old son who still lives with her 😂 you're not the arsehole OP.

Getthethrowonthesofa · 11/01/2024 08:28

I’d have assumed girls weekend away was with mates. This is a family weekend away so I can’t see why you don’t wish him there. How does it change the dynamic as he’s male?

HRTQueen · 11/01/2024 08:23

Oh dear op you have handed yourself on to a plate by using the word girls when you mean mature ladies 😬

of course it would change the dynamic, your brother is an adult who is quite capable of arranging his own trip

sounds like something my brother would do and sulk if he doesn’t get his own way 🙄

gannett · 11/01/2024 08:17

Consideringachange2023 · 10/01/2024 21:54

Why are so many people pretending they’ve never heard of a girls weekend???? WTAF on mn.

of course men change the dynamic? Women have their own bonds and rituals the same way men do. We’re allowed to say actually this is for women, because it’s what we’d prefer this time.

thats without the whole thing about the mum wanting a break from the men she lives with day in day out.

ignore your brother OP, its more than sufficient to say “sorry, it’s girls weekend this time but feel free to organise your own trip”. Enjoy!

I object to all-male bonds and rituals as well because they've mostly served to exclude women from supposedly "masculine" activities like sport, and to keep women out of professional/political power.

"No girls allowed" is the core of misogyny, it's based on the idea that men are just more suited to certain roles and activities because men and women are so different. Women should be in the home, not in the sports club or the board room. "No boys allowed" is the same illogic, flipped.

I do think all-women groups in professional contexts are vital, especially in male-dominated industries. But "girly weekends" that are based on "men like these things, women like those things" are just absurd.

Harry12345 · 11/01/2024 08:11

I’m not old fashioned, have male friends and cousins who I am close to but I understand the dynamic with a girls trip can be changed and it should be ok to spend time with specific people in your life without including everyone. My sil isn’t allowed to go away with her daughter or have spa days as the husband feels left out, I think that’s sad

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 11/01/2024 08:06

Suggest that you split the bill with your brother if he comes so the treat is from both of you…… 😉

or just tell him it’s all organised and he’s not invited. If he wants to provoke a massive row with your parents by excluding you from the family meal on their birthday, fire away.

5128gap · 11/01/2024 06:51

Muchof · 11/01/2024 05:34

@5128gap

I know you think you are being clever. But you aren’t and I am sure even you know the difference between a stag do and a 70 year old mothers birthday celebration.

You're right, I do! I was just teasing you because you were being a bit unnecessary over it, 'ive read it all now' about a perfectly normal everyday arrangement for women to go away without men. I thought you were being a bit silly so I was a bit silly back.

Zanatdy · 11/01/2024 06:32

Mikimoto · 10/01/2024 17:33

...and YOU say hello to Doris Day for us, the next time you see her.

You’re here all week I take it? 🙄

plumberdrain · 11/01/2024 05:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 10/01/2024 19:33

Op why is your brother still living with your parents at the age of 31?!

he needs to grow up

YANBU

i presume you don’t ever read, listen or watch any news relating to the UK economy nor the housing market

Muchof · 11/01/2024 05:34

5128gap · 10/01/2024 18:03

You might want to sit down for this one, but my DS excluded me, his sister, his auntie, his wife and his 80 year old nan from his stag do. Just for being female! And FOR NO OTHER REASON!!

@5128gap

I know you think you are being clever. But you aren’t and I am sure even you know the difference between a stag do and a 70 year old mothers birthday celebration.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/01/2024 01:48

maddening · 10/01/2024 23:07

And I would have left the decision to the mum and aunt whose birthday it is.

The mum already said she is looking forward to time away from men.

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/01/2024 00:35

it seems like the brother just wants a free holiday

yanbu op

saraclara · 10/01/2024 23:41

maddening · 10/01/2024 23:07

And I would have left the decision to the mum and aunt whose birthday it is.

The problem is that if they were put in a situation where they know he's asked and they have to decide, they'll capitulate, because they've been having to do that all their lives.

It's OP 's gift, she knows they're excited to escape their needy men, she's booked everything, so there's no need for them to decide anything.

But yep, if you're making the point that it's their choice to have a women only trip, your on the money.

Fullofxmascbeer · 10/01/2024 23:38

The time to have said that he wanted to come was at the time the idea was mooted.

Anyway it’s your present to your mum.

maddening · 10/01/2024 23:07

And I would have left the decision to the mum and aunt whose birthday it is.

maddening · 10/01/2024 23:06

If it were me and my brother I would have happily had him along- it is just a family trip imo

WandaWonder · 10/01/2024 22:39

Consideringachange2023 · 10/01/2024 21:54

Why are so many people pretending they’ve never heard of a girls weekend???? WTAF on mn.

of course men change the dynamic? Women have their own bonds and rituals the same way men do. We’re allowed to say actually this is for women, because it’s what we’d prefer this time.

thats without the whole thing about the mum wanting a break from the men she lives with day in day out.

ignore your brother OP, its more than sufficient to say “sorry, it’s girls weekend this time but feel free to organise your own trip”. Enjoy!

I can;t think of anything in my female life that I do normally or on holidays that I need to be in female only company for I could not think of anything worse than having to have a 'girlie' weekend I have been away to events with all male and all females and mix sexes and there is nothing wrong with that but a staged 'girlie' weekend is not necessary, I just get on with people because of who they are

I have no desire for spa days, talking of periods, makeup or martyring myself by hard done by men make me feel - if this is a girlie weekend then sounds boring

BUT like anything if an even is for someone like a birthday it is up to that person what they want so if a close friend wanted that themselves fine

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 22:29

gannett · 10/01/2024 18:56

I'm not offended, but it's striking that whenever people bring up examples of conversations they simply cannot have with a man in the room, it's usually to do with either birth or hating their husbands. Neither of which are relevant to me! So that's a reason that "girly weekends" and the like don't make sense to me.

I don't really talk about periods with friends at all tbh, though I wouldn't hesitate to make an offhand reference in front of men. If I had an actual health issue I'd want to talk to my GP, and I definitely wouldn't want to bring it up over cocktails with the girls.

When I'm out with female friends I have no preconceived ideas of what we are going to talk about.

Sometimes it's the same topics as we talk about when our husbands are there, sometimes it's not.

Sometimes we talk about them! Sometimes we may talk about something personal that we don't want the others' DHs to know about.

All I know is, both situations are enjoyable, but I like sometimes just going out with women

Consideringachange2023 · 10/01/2024 21:54

Why are so many people pretending they’ve never heard of a girls weekend???? WTAF on mn.

of course men change the dynamic? Women have their own bonds and rituals the same way men do. We’re allowed to say actually this is for women, because it’s what we’d prefer this time.

thats without the whole thing about the mum wanting a break from the men she lives with day in day out.

ignore your brother OP, its more than sufficient to say “sorry, it’s girls weekend this time but feel free to organise your own trip”. Enjoy!