Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i have invited my brother to a girls weekend away?

443 replies

NatMoz · 10/01/2024 15:18

It is both my mum's 70th and my aunty's 60th in March/April.

My brother had made 0 plans and his only idea was a Chinese. I said that I'll book a girls long weekend away (myself, mum and aunty) to make it memorable and he can be in charge of the inclusive family meal where everyone will be invited to celebrate which he agreed to.

So I've planned, booked, organised an itinerary for a long weekend European city break for the 3 of us for a girls weekend. My brother is now absolutely hounding me because he has decided he would also like to join in on the girls weekend. Telling me he doesn't mind carrying the bags and is there room for a little one. I explained it would spoil the dynamic of the trip and at 31 why would he want to spend a girls weekend with us anyway🤣. He is already going on holiday with my mum and dad for 10 days in June to Greece so it's not like he's missing out on going abroad and spending time with my parents! He lives at home so spends every day with them so again it's not like he lives on the other side of the world.

He explained he hasn't been on holiday with my aunty in 10 years. The last time he did, i organised that trip too!!! I did say if he felt so strongly about it, why has he not organised something prior to this point as there have been 10 years of opportunities.

I've now been told I'm banned from the family meal he is organising 🤷.

To clarify further, my husband, my dad nor my daughter (aged 2) will be attending this weekend away either. Just myself, mum and aunty.

Am i in the wrong here?

OP posts:
planetarynoodle · 10/01/2024 17:59

MahShinyShoes · 10/01/2024 15:32

What do your Mum & Aunt want?

Why are you making it about squabbling siblings?

This at the end of the day.

Also your brother could just identify as a female for the weekend if you're that sexist about it.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 17:57

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:53

Reread my reply. I'm saying what you're saying .
I'm saying "to say girls only trips are dumb, is ridiculous".
Read my posts

Now that you have added the comma in the position you have, it does indeed change the entire meaning of your sentence.

Had that comma been in place initially I wouldn't have commented the way I did.

Why don't you thoroughly proof-read your posts - or at least take responsibility for your lack of punctuation?

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:57

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:39

Interesting, can you cite any of that research?

I'm pretty sure there are still men's clubs in the UK.

Also girls have been allowed to join the Scouts for decades now. Have you ever considered this idea that men "need" to be in men-only groups and can't possibly be themselves or express themselves in mixed company is a self-perpetuating cycle? Certainly the younger generations seem more able to cope, my sons include many more women in their circle of friends than was normal when I was young and honestly I think it's an improvement, they're far more emotionally intelligent and far less sexist than men of my generation. Imagine feeling like you can't be yourself in front of half the human race.

https://www.thegazelle.org/issue/242/male-only-mental-health-spaces

You can disagree, but it doesn't mean there are loads of things most women would rather not discuss in front of men and vice versa.

Silence Or Silenced: The Need For Male Only Mental Health Spaces On Campus

Men’s mental health issues are overlooked across the globe and NYUAD is no exception to this norm. Here’s what we can...

https://www.thegazelle.org/issue/242/male-only-mental-health-spaces

Muchof · 10/01/2024 17:56

JadziaD · 10/01/2024 15:54

Oh for pity's sake, no, of course not. I'm just telling you how it tends to go down in MY family. And that we sometimes do thinks split by sex because in OUR family, there's a slightly different dynamic and group of activities if it's just women vs if it's a mixed group. And it's no big deal. And other times we split things by interest. And sometimes by age. And sometimes we all do things together.

And in this family, the brother is interested in joining in the activities planned but apparently he is forbidden to join his mother's 70th birthday and aunt's 60th birthday trip, by his sister, because he is male and no other reason. I really have read it all. It takes sibling rivalry to a whole new level.

Dweetfidilove · 10/01/2024 17:55

What manner of madness is this, where women are not allowed to spend a weekend together, sans men, if they are so inclined 🤔.

If you wish to not have gender segregated activities, carry on.

If you wish to have gender segregated activities, carry on.

Not everything has to include everyone in everything. In my family we have women only, men only, adults only, nuclear family only and all together. No one suffers from FOMO, so everyone gets on just fine 🤷🏽‍♀️.

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:55

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 17:54

I can't stand dividing activities by gender without good reason

Nobody is dividing anything by gender @PrawnLiberationFront . The "division" is by sex.

And not wanting someone of the opposite sex tagging along is a "good reason".

Gender is a perfectly acceptable and widely understood synonym for sex in this context.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:55

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:39

Interesting, can you cite any of that research?

I'm pretty sure there are still men's clubs in the UK.

Also girls have been allowed to join the Scouts for decades now. Have you ever considered this idea that men "need" to be in men-only groups and can't possibly be themselves or express themselves in mixed company is a self-perpetuating cycle? Certainly the younger generations seem more able to cope, my sons include many more women in their circle of friends than was normal when I was young and honestly I think it's an improvement, they're far more emotionally intelligent and far less sexist than men of my generation. Imagine feeling like you can't be yourself in front of half the human race.

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-09269-1
Mine have higher rates of suicide in the UK.
Meant 'oldest' men's club have closed.

Engaging male students with mental health support: a qualitative focus group study - BMC Public Health

Background Males are less likely to seek help for mental health difficulties compared to females. Despite considerable interest, a paucity of evidence-based solutions exists to address this. Concerns about students’ mental health has led to the United...

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-020-09269-1

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 17:54

I can't stand dividing activities by gender without good reason

Nobody is dividing anything by gender @PrawnLiberationFront . The "division" is by sex.

And not wanting someone of the opposite sex tagging along is a "good reason".

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:54

Tempnamechng · 10/01/2024 17:02

I agree with @SouthEastCoast. It isn't like a group of 18 - 20s girls on the pull, it's a specific family group, which your brother is part of. Excluding him because of his sex seems off.

She's excluded her father, her uncle and her husband and daughter.

Because her mother, her aunt and the OP want to go away together!!

Purpleafro8 · 10/01/2024 17:54

Tosieposie · 10/01/2024 15:24

It's just fucking weird.

Why would the dynamic be ruined because hes a man?

Are you doing nails and hair and throwing pink glitter around 24/7? 🤔 🙄

Just let him attend the trip.

Because men and women are different.

fromhellsheartistabatthee · 10/01/2024 17:53

Can't understand anyone being so desperate to be included in a group where he's not really wanted. Is he a bit needy?

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:53

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 17:37

But is iS Dumb and ridiculous - the minute there is a man there it ceases to be a girls trip.

Why shouldn't women want to spend time with other women? Or men, with other men?

Why does everything have to be "gender-neutral" to make it "fair"?

Men and women are different .

They are equal, but different, and anyone who can't see that is either wilfully determined to negate those differences, or just too thick to see it.

Reread my reply. I'm saying what you're saying .
I'm saying "to say girls only trips are dumb, is ridiculous".
Read my posts

NightisdarkandfullofterrorsGOT · 10/01/2024 17:52

Women need time without men around it’s just a fact.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:52

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:39

Interesting, can you cite any of that research?

I'm pretty sure there are still men's clubs in the UK.

Also girls have been allowed to join the Scouts for decades now. Have you ever considered this idea that men "need" to be in men-only groups and can't possibly be themselves or express themselves in mixed company is a self-perpetuating cycle? Certainly the younger generations seem more able to cope, my sons include many more women in their circle of friends than was normal when I was young and honestly I think it's an improvement, they're far more emotionally intelligent and far less sexist than men of my generation. Imagine feeling like you can't be yourself in front of half the human race.

Men's Sheds
Freemasons (mostly still segregated although there are women's ones)
Round Table
There's another one that begins with P that I can't remember
And loads of small local ones all over the country

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 17:51

I think he just wants a free holiday!

Girls holiday is just fine. There's a separate celebration later for everyone. That's just how it is.

Of course your mum wants to be away from her son, her husband, it's a carefree weekend!

5128gap · 10/01/2024 17:50

Gnomegnomegnome · 10/01/2024 17:33

What makes it a ‘girls weekend’? Simply no boys allowed? Pink handcuffs? Face masks and manicures?

No, it's more about spending time in the company of people who don't sneer at what they imagine women's interests to be. If i was in an all female group I'd be very surprised if anyone there implied women only got together for manicures.

OneMorePlant · 10/01/2024 17:48

Tempnamechng · 10/01/2024 17:02

I agree with @SouthEastCoast. It isn't like a group of 18 - 20s girls on the pull, it's a specific family group, which your brother is part of. Excluding him because of his sex seems off.

I can't believe how ageist this is...

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:47

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:46

If I want to go out/away with my female friends and not our husbands I will!

And they are at liberty to do the same.

We are not surgically attached.

Who on earth said you were. This has nothing to do with partners having their own friends.

Gymnopedie · 10/01/2024 17:47

Also to the person who keeps harping on about whether my mum has specifically said she doesn't want my brother there...she has said she is looking forward to a weekend away from all the hopeless men in her life!

What would be absolutely brilliant is if being away from the men and seeing a different perspective gave her the courage to start making some changes at home and refusing to be their maid, cook, washerwoman and all the other things. A far fetched hope perhaps but it could happen.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:46

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 16:52

I can't stand dividing activities by gender without good reason, and in my experience almost always results in one or more people who'd actually vastly prefer the activities/atmosphere/company of the other group but are denied it because of their genitals for some reason.

If I want to go out/away with my female friends and not our husbands I will!

And they are at liberty to do the same.

We are not surgically attached.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:46

gannett · 10/01/2024 16:57

Men and women don't behave that differently, though personally I'm not friends with any men who'd expect the holiday to revolve around him nor any women who'd cater to that.

99% of interests, pastimes and activities are gender-neutral, or is everyone stuck in the days when women who played sport were seen as masculine, and men who liked fashion got homophobic abuse even if they weren't gay?

A lot of posters saying "the dynamic would change" but I'd be interested to read their explanations of exactly how? I've been the only woman in male social groups plenty of times, and just as much have also been in groups which are all-female except for one man. Not deliberately, just how things worked out. And the dynamic was absolutely fine.

Really? If we hold a barbie with all my friends, male and female, we definitely have different conversations than on the odd chance that it's just the girls.
Sometimes we chat about menstruation, birth experiences/trauma, tips for stretch marks, cellulite. Heck I don't know, sometimes we chat about shared experiences between women, which I think is really important. Sometimes it's nice and reassuring to hear that yeah it's normal for your breasts to change when nursing, vaginal dryness after birth etc.
All of these which I wouldn't be comfortable discussing in front of my best friends husband.
I think this 'gender-segregation is weird' thing is actually contributing towards the aloneness we feel and the info that does not get carried over. I've chatted to so many younger women who said 'oh I never knew this was common' or 'no -one told me these tips' 'i thought it was just me'.

And in a similar fashion men can chat, joke, reassure each other in a different way when it's just men.

Fantaandcola · 10/01/2024 17:44

Men do change the dynamic. One of my closest friends is a guy, I actually spent a recent Christmas with him (and his family) but despite that when I organise a birthday activity for my next birthday it’s probably going to be girls only therefore I won’t be inviting him and other men I’m close to. And it’s no reflection on who he is as a person, I just sometimes prefer girls only.

In OPs case it’s super clear that the brother shouldn’t be involved also for the fact he is so entitled. My brothers would never demand to go anywhere that me and my female cousins and Aunty etc had planned. Particularly if I had paid for it. They wouldn’t ask let alone demand because they’d be smart enough to know , in the absence of an invite, where they’re not wanted 😂

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:44

FaiIureToLunch · 10/01/2024 16:48

Don’t be a dick, it’s his mum and she might not be here for her 80th - my mum didn’t make it

Oh ~FFS!

I HATE these sorts of responses.

My mum didn't make her 60th. Is it a competition?

My daughters took me out for my 60th.

And I did something different with my son.

And we did something with all the family.

I had a lovely time.

And btw, he lives with her and she looks after him, so I bet it's more to do with him and his dad not having the housekeeper at their beck and call.

Dragonflyhelper · 10/01/2024 17:43

The OP planned, booked and PAID for this trip which her mum and aunt sound thrilled about.

Let's leave it at that, it's HER gift and as far as I'm concerned she gets to call the shots.

So many people on here are hand wringing about nothing. It's a just a weekend! Her brother is free to also plan and pay for another trip for them if he so desires.

Gymnopedie · 10/01/2024 17:43

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:35

Are they inviting your brother to that?

The OP has answered that. Yes, and they already have done.