Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i have invited my brother to a girls weekend away?

443 replies

NatMoz · 10/01/2024 15:18

It is both my mum's 70th and my aunty's 60th in March/April.

My brother had made 0 plans and his only idea was a Chinese. I said that I'll book a girls long weekend away (myself, mum and aunty) to make it memorable and he can be in charge of the inclusive family meal where everyone will be invited to celebrate which he agreed to.

So I've planned, booked, organised an itinerary for a long weekend European city break for the 3 of us for a girls weekend. My brother is now absolutely hounding me because he has decided he would also like to join in on the girls weekend. Telling me he doesn't mind carrying the bags and is there room for a little one. I explained it would spoil the dynamic of the trip and at 31 why would he want to spend a girls weekend with us anyway🤣. He is already going on holiday with my mum and dad for 10 days in June to Greece so it's not like he's missing out on going abroad and spending time with my parents! He lives at home so spends every day with them so again it's not like he lives on the other side of the world.

He explained he hasn't been on holiday with my aunty in 10 years. The last time he did, i organised that trip too!!! I did say if he felt so strongly about it, why has he not organised something prior to this point as there have been 10 years of opportunities.

I've now been told I'm banned from the family meal he is organising 🤷.

To clarify further, my husband, my dad nor my daughter (aged 2) will be attending this weekend away either. Just myself, mum and aunty.

Am i in the wrong here?

OP posts:
feellikeanalien · 10/01/2024 18:17

Sorry I meant that it is a treat for both her mum and her aunt from the OP.

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 18:17

@PrawnLiberationFront Only that's not true is it? Maybe have a look on google..might take you a few seconds to find your'e wrong!

When did the concept of gender begin?

The ancient world had no basis of understanding gender as it has been understood in the humanities and social sciences for the past few decades. The term gender had been associated with grammar for most of history and only started to move towards it being a malleable cultural construct in the 1950s and 1960s.
------
Women fought long and hard and suffered for the rights we have now. PROTECTING OUR SEX IS THE BEST GIFT WE CAN GIVE TO OUR DAUGHTERS!

NoTouch · 10/01/2024 18:17

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 16:52

I can't stand dividing activities by gender without good reason, and in my experience almost always results in one or more people who'd actually vastly prefer the activities/atmosphere/company of the other group but are denied it because of their genitals for some reason.

It is nothing to do with male sex wanting to attend female informal social meet ups or vice versa whether that is a hen/stag do, girls/lads night out or whatever. It is about the people attending not wanting them there in the context, even if that context is just a good old female chin wag, it is absolutely reasonable.

Feel free not to attend if you can't stand them 🙄

plumberdrain · 10/01/2024 18:16

feellikeanalien · 10/01/2024 18:13

OP I think if you had said that you were taking your mum and your aunt away as a joint birthday treat and that your brother, who is 31, lives at home and expects his mum to do all his washing and cooking is now insisting on coming you would have had quite different replies. I think suggesting that because he is male it would change the dynamic rather than because he is a lazy entitled manchild would change the dynamic has resulted in the many of the replies you have received.

but it’s not even a joint treat. The OP very much gave the impression it was

when actually she is paying for her aunt and mother and no one else is contributing ie it is the Op’s present to her mother

Anjea · 10/01/2024 18:14

How stupid. No wonder he's put out.

feellikeanalien · 10/01/2024 18:13

OP I think if you had said that you were taking your mum and your aunt away as a joint birthday treat and that your brother, who is 31, lives at home and expects his mum to do all his washing and cooking is now insisting on coming you would have had quite different replies. I think suggesting that because he is male it would change the dynamic rather than because he is a lazy entitled manchild would change the dynamic has resulted in the many of the replies you have received.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 18:13

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 18:03

That's not research, it's an opinion piece.

And as I said, that's a self-perpetuating cycle, and I'm not convinced it serves anyone or anything except reinforcing ignorance division and isolation.

You can state you think it is perpetuating isolation and ignorance, but I think having women only chats/days promotes cross-generational learning and information sharing about important parts in a woman's life. Chatting about marriage/menstruation/birth /babies/menopause etc is important for helping us feel less isolated. Some of these conversations we wouldn't have with men in the vicinity.
And vice versa

There is many many opportunities for both genders to be together. Vast majority of experiences is both men and women. Work, Christmas parties birthdays etc. virtually every human interaction for an occasion you will spend with your family and friends which includes your husband, dad, sons etc. there will maybe be a once a year girls weekend away where it's the only time where you can share similar experiences. How is this a problem?

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 18:12

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 18:10

@PrawnLiberationFront

Anti trans nonsense? What the actual fuck is wrong with you? I am Female, I have never had a gender.

I'm not ashamed to be female, nor do I want to see it being eradicated to appease men!

Gender is a new concept, women/female is the correct term.

Women strong and proud!

Gender is not a new concept at all, the word has been in use since the 13th century.

Sorry to puncture your victim complex but no one is suggesting eradicating females.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 18:12

There are often posts on here where women say that they go out and meet a friend but she insists on bringing her partner.

And they complain that that isn't the idea and it totally changes the dynamic.

Are they being Unreasonable?

And the usual answer is an overwhelming Yes

TimetoPour · 10/01/2024 18:11

FFS. YANBU. You have booked, organised and paid for a weekend for you, your mother and aunt. It is your gift to them.

Tell your brother he can come if he gives you half the money to make it a gift from
you both. I guarantee the CF will change his mind when he realises he can’t piggy back on your kindness.

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 18:10

@PrawnLiberationFront

Anti trans nonsense? What the actual fuck is wrong with you? I am Female, I have never had a gender.

I'm not ashamed to be female, nor do I want to see it being eradicated to appease men!

Gender is a new concept, women/female is the correct term.

Women strong and proud!

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 18:07

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 18:02

They're not 'working men's clubs'

And Men's Sheds is new and growing

FannyFarting · 10/01/2024 18:07

It will be blissful for your aunt and mum, no waiting on the blokes hand and foot. It’s a well earned break for them I’m sure.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 18:06

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 17:57

Now that you have added the comma in the position you have, it does indeed change the entire meaning of your sentence.

Had that comma been in place initially I wouldn't have commented the way I did.

Why don't you thoroughly proof-read your posts - or at least take responsibility for your lack of punctuation?

Wow, I think you're unnecessarily critical.
I think my meaning is clear without the comma, but ja, sorry, I should have put a comma there.
I'm typing, cooking and cleaning and don't proofread as well as I should have, although I don't think it warrants such a snide comment.

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 18:05

Muchof · 10/01/2024 17:56

And in this family, the brother is interested in joining in the activities planned but apparently he is forbidden to join his mother's 70th birthday and aunt's 60th birthday trip, by his sister, because he is male and no other reason. I really have read it all. It takes sibling rivalry to a whole new level.

And his mother and his aunt are perfectly happy with that

Pineapplewaves · 10/01/2024 18:05

Would your Mum and Auntie like him to go?

If so, tell him which flights and hotel you have booked and tell him he'll need book his own flight and hotel as you can't afford to pay for him too. See if he still wants to go then.........

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 18:04

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 18:03

@PrawnLiberationFront Actual it is SEX, gender is a murky, grey area. it means nothing. (anyone can claim any sort of gender)

I do not have a gender, I have a sex.. Female. Many women fought for this right and I will continue to support that.

Oh don't bring your anti-trans nonsense in here. Everyone knows what gender means in this context.

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 18:03

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 17:57

https://www.thegazelle.org/issue/242/male-only-mental-health-spaces

You can disagree, but it doesn't mean there are loads of things most women would rather not discuss in front of men and vice versa.

That's not research, it's an opinion piece.

And as I said, that's a self-perpetuating cycle, and I'm not convinced it serves anyone or anything except reinforcing ignorance division and isolation.

5128gap · 10/01/2024 18:03

Muchof · 10/01/2024 17:56

And in this family, the brother is interested in joining in the activities planned but apparently he is forbidden to join his mother's 70th birthday and aunt's 60th birthday trip, by his sister, because he is male and no other reason. I really have read it all. It takes sibling rivalry to a whole new level.

You might want to sit down for this one, but my DS excluded me, his sister, his auntie, his wife and his 80 year old nan from his stag do. Just for being female! And FOR NO OTHER REASON!!

dorry678 · 10/01/2024 18:03

@PrawnLiberationFront Actual it is SEX, gender is a murky, grey area. it means nothing. (anyone can claim any sort of gender)

I do not have a gender, I have a sex.. Female. Many women fought for this right and I will continue to support that.

Ohhbaby · 10/01/2024 18:02

Nanny0gg · 10/01/2024 17:52

Men's Sheds
Freemasons (mostly still segregated although there are women's ones)
Round Table
There's another one that begins with P that I can't remember
And loads of small local ones all over the country

You're right, but they are rapidly closing .
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/death-of-the-working-men-s-club-889632.html

Death of the working men's club

They used to guarantee a cheap pint and a good night out but, as more close every month, a bastion of British life is now under threat

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/death-of-the-working-men-s-club-889632.html

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 18:01

planetarynoodle · 10/01/2024 17:59

This at the end of the day.

Also your brother could just identify as a female for the weekend if you're that sexist about it.

Perhaps he could identify as "not an arsehole" and allow the women to enjoy their break.

FannyFarting · 10/01/2024 18:01

Your brothers being an arse. A special girls weekend is for women! There’s a larger family celebration for everyone.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/01/2024 18:00

PrawnLiberationFront · 10/01/2024 17:55

Gender is a perfectly acceptable and widely understood synonym for sex in this context.

In your opinion.

This merging of "gender" (a social construct) and "sex" (a biological reality) causes so much trouble. Euphemisms are ridiculous, sometimes.

Had the brother been of the same sex as OP and her mum and aunt, then he would have been her sister, and very possibly sharing in the trip.

But he isn't. He's the opposite SEX. His "gender" is immaterial.

phoenixrosehere · 10/01/2024 18:00

Dragonflyhelper · 10/01/2024 17:43

The OP planned, booked and PAID for this trip which her mum and aunt sound thrilled about.

Let's leave it at that, it's HER gift and as far as I'm concerned she gets to call the shots.

So many people on here are hand wringing about nothing. It's a just a weekend! Her brother is free to also plan and pay for another trip for them if he so desires.

Agree.

Some posters seemed to be ignoring or brushing over the fact that he AGREED to all of this beforehand and only after everything is bought and paid for, has a problem. His idea for the mother who still cooks and does his laundry was a Chinese takeaway if that’s what OP means by Chinese.

Unless I missed it, I didn’t see anywhere that he was saying he would pay his way to go so he likely also expects OP to shell out for him too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread