Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:44

alittleprivacy · 10/01/2024 12:32

I was a massive reader and have a DS who reads a bit/games a lot. His vocabulary is off the charts to the point that his teachers tell me that it occasionally causes him problems being understood at school because other kids don't know the words he uses or the concepts that go with them. He gets As in English and has read at a high adult level since he was seven. He just rarely reads for fun. His general knowledge is insane. He recently spent a lot of time researching the relationship between adrenaline, dopamine and addiction. The legal ramifications of Steamboat Willie becoming public domain. The damage TikTok does to mental health. The dangers and benefits of AI. The stages of grief. He gives brilliant, insightful reviews of movies.

I wish he'd read more. Because I took such joy from reading. But that's a me issue, tbh. Not something he especially needs to do.

Edited

I‘m not sure I understand this? Surely he does read a lot, or where else would he be getting all this knowledge and vocabulary? And you say he doesn’t read much for fun…but since he seems to be independently seeking out all these topics and information, he must be garnering a huge amount of enjoyment from it?

He sounds like a voracious reader to me. Good for him.

UsernameChangerRanger · 10/01/2024 12:44

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

The assassin's creed and civilization franchises are probably good for this.

FourLeggedBuckers · 10/01/2024 12:43

There’s reading and there’s reading. If you’re reading a solid diet of mediocre (but often fun) kids fiction - Blyton for my generation, those bloody glittery fairy books or something similar, for this maybe - then you’re not going to be enhancing your vocabulary or learning much. That’s not to say that they’re not fun, or kids shouldn’t read them in moderation, of course.

But if you’re encouraging your kids to read an eclectic range of books - classics, modern fiction, non-fiction, even adult books where they’re not hugely age inappropriate - they’re going to be learning a lot more than through most games. There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

UsernameChangerRanger · 10/01/2024 12:41

I think reading fluency was often seen as the holy grail rather than comprehension and practical application which is transferable and more aligned with intelligence. If a child is reading but not understanding or interrogating the text and asking questions of it while they go through then yes I'd agree with you.

5128gap · 10/01/2024 12:40

Reading broadens the vocabulary and improves general literacy. It exercises the imagination as a reader is forced to create mental pictures rather than being presented with those pictures. It also allows for greater depth in conveying ideas than visual communication. If you think those things matter, then you'll value reading. I'm sure gaming and other media offer other benefits and skill development that are different, so i don't understand the comparison. Its a bit like asking if a walk in the park is as good as an apple.

MrsSlocombesCat · 10/01/2024 12:39

alittleprivacy · 10/01/2024 12:32

I was a massive reader and have a DS who reads a bit/games a lot. His vocabulary is off the charts to the point that his teachers tell me that it occasionally causes him problems being understood at school because other kids don't know the words he uses or the concepts that go with them. He gets As in English and has read at a high adult level since he was seven. He just rarely reads for fun. His general knowledge is insane. He recently spent a lot of time researching the relationship between adrenaline, dopamine and addiction. The legal ramifications of Steamboat Willie becoming public domain. The damage TikTok does to mental health. The dangers and benefits of AI. The stages of grief. He gives brilliant, insightful reviews of movies.

I wish he'd read more. Because I took such joy from reading. But that's a me issue, tbh. Not something he especially needs to do.

Edited

Is your son on the Autistic spectrum? He sounds a lot like my son.

burnoutbabe · 10/01/2024 12:38

I am 50

Ism a huge reader, when young and now, at least 50 books a year now, thought iota all light weight stuff -crime or jilly Cooper

It stands me in great stead doing a second degree (law) and professional exams -as I can read the textbooks and articles pretty quickly, so happy to do lots of wider reading.

I am also a huge gamer. What's that if not interactive stories! (Well the games I play) most games have a ton of reading in them -notes or conversations -so handy to skim fast and take in the relevant information.

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 12:38

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:35

@LightSwerve l take your point, but gaming is a gateway and certainly requires more problem solving skills than reading fiction does. Whilst it doesn't always translate and, as with books, it depends on the game, I would still consider it offers more than reading unless the child is honestly reading more factual content or high-level vocabulary.

Gaming has been shown to use few problem-solving skills, unlike say woodwork or craft or coding, and there is evidence it actually reduces problem-solving resilience because games are designed to be solved - life is not like that.

You may consider gaming to offer more, but the evidence just isn't there.

Reading is truly amazing.

TravelInHope · 10/01/2024 12:37

OP, your posts are very well written, concise and informative. Excellent grammar and legibility, a great communication skill. I wonder where that came from?

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:35

@LightSwerve l take your point, but gaming is a gateway and certainly requires more problem solving skills than reading fiction does. Whilst it doesn't always translate and, as with books, it depends on the game, I would still consider it offers more than reading unless the child is honestly reading more factual content or high-level vocabulary.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 10/01/2024 12:34

I strongly believe dc need a mix of activities and gaming / reading both offer escapism which is important. Academically, reading is essential but life isn’t all about being academic. Am obsession with gaming, or anything that prevents a dc engaging with every day life is an issue. My dc use a ps4 but can put it down no issue if I ask them to help when the shop gets delivered (for example). It’s also something they do with dh or together so rarely a solo activity in our house.

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:34

I‘m a gamer myself, as is my partner, so I understand what it entails and I’m no snob about it. But gaming and reading are vastly different things, and yes, reading IS a superior pursuit in terms of development and emotional maturity.

Gaming is largely passive - it’s repetitive, you’re channelled through a series of very tight narratives which are predetermined, and all the visuals and characterisation and voices are laid out before you. You receive it, you are not a part of creating it. The language and scripting is almost universally formulaic and poor (even in the best and most lauded games) compared to most decent novels, and the universe (even in the largest open world games) is small and constricted and one-note.

Novels and other forms of literature are the opposite of passive: they engage with you and communicate with you but asking you to engage your imagination, to create in your own head in your own way the universe that the writer has created in theirs. It requires understanding and empathy as characters evolve and grow. It provokes a vast range of all human emotions in a way that no game truly can.

Non-fiction can provide much deeper dives into human lives, knowledge, language and the human condition which can’t help but improve and inform our own. Anyone who avidly reads is almost by definition a different person, who conducts themselves differently and sees things different to the person they would have been if they had never read.

They are FUNDAMENTALLY different things, reading and gaming. I enjoy both, and there is room for both in an enjoyable life, but I only exalt one of them, because only one of them is deserving of it.

Oblomov23 · 10/01/2024 12:33

I agree. Not sure what being a voracious reader brings you. I've read a bit, eggs more in life does that bring me? More than other things? I think not.

Dh dislikes the fact that ds2 loves gaming, but he also does ok at school, plays in a football team, and is quite a happy chap. So what's the problem. What is it? We're all striving for here? To be happy and successful, what's your definition of success?

alittleprivacy · 10/01/2024 12:32

I was a massive reader and have a DS who reads a bit/games a lot. His vocabulary is off the charts to the point that his teachers tell me that it occasionally causes him problems being understood at school because other kids don't know the words he uses or the concepts that go with them. He gets As in English and has read at a high adult level since he was seven. He just rarely reads for fun. His general knowledge is insane. He recently spent a lot of time researching the relationship between adrenaline, dopamine and addiction. The legal ramifications of Steamboat Willie becoming public domain. The damage TikTok does to mental health. The dangers and benefits of AI. The stages of grief. He gives brilliant, insightful reviews of movies.

I wish he'd read more. Because I took such joy from reading. But that's a me issue, tbh. Not something he especially needs to do.

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 12:32

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:26

I would add that my parents certainly didn't regard my reading as any sign of intellectual superiority at the time, gaming didn't exist anyway, then, like it does now. It certainly didn't translate into my being great at school or anything.

But how much worse would you have done at school without the reading?

We each only get one life, so can't judge anything from our own life as there is no control to compare against.

But the data around reading is very robust - reading helps a lot. Gaming just doesn't do what reading does.

Thelootllama · 10/01/2024 12:30

DarkAcademia · 10/01/2024 12:12

Also my teen DD reads ACOTAR, and I'm QUITE sure there's little virtue in that! 😳

What's wrong with ACOTAR?! 😆just started the first book!

itsmyp4rty · 10/01/2024 12:30

Mine is a code writing whizz but has always had a huge love of reading. Being great at games is very different from writing code and many, many people love playing games but have absolutely no interest in all the coding that lies behind it.

For me there is no comparison between being a keen reader as a child and spending all day playing crossy road on an ipad.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:26

I would add that my parents certainly didn't regard my reading as any sign of intellectual superiority at the time, gaming didn't exist anyway, then, like it does now. It certainly didn't translate into my being great at school or anything.

OP posts:
LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 12:22

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:13

@Iwishiwasasilentnight oh, absolutely, I understand that, but what gaming does seem to do is enhance analytical skills. My husband wasn't a gamer (born too soon, as was I), but it seems to be that gamers in the modern world are more likely to be proficient in that area than those who lean far more towards reading.

The evidence from research is reading proficiency is a key component of both education and career success.

Gaming - very different to programming or coding - is very poor for developing problem solving or analytical skills as most games are written with finite options - many are seek and find for example - whereas real life involves problems of much greater complexity and problems that can't be solved requiring a total rethink.

Reading is known to increase emotional intelligence which is very helpful for future success, being able to understand and relate to a wide range of people is very valuable in modern society. Gaming has a first-person bias and is thought to negatively impact empathy in some people.

I'd favour reading any day.

dancinginthewind · 10/01/2024 12:20

I totally agree. I read voraciously as a child. My parents were very smug about this and I did develop some general knowledge but, as I mainly read things like the Trebizon stories on repeat, it is more limited than you'd expect. In retrospect, with limited social skills (going through diagnosis process now), I did this as it was safe. I basically hid in books. I listen to DS gaming and think he is developing good negotiation & teamwork skills with his friends as well as chatting to them about life in general. Yes, he might not want to come off his devices but nor did I want to put down my book, and I might have read it a dozen times before.
I also think reading left me with some unrealistic expectations. Books are wrapped up in 300 pages or so, life is not! How a character behaves in a book and how people respond to that behaviour is controlled by the author. Life is much more varied than that!

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 12:20

GasPanic · 10/01/2024 12:17

I think different skills.

There is a lot of predjudice against gaming from older generations who don't do it, but it can be very educational. Stuff like Minecraft is very creative and a lot of gaming involves problem solving skills and teamwork.

Kids are increasingly going to be creating and working in digital environments in the future, so neglecting gaming as a way of familiarising them with those environments is bad news. I think the right way to approach it is to encourage them in games that actually involve thinking and learning and creating and not just blasting aliens.

Reading is something essential to have, whether you are reading for the pleasure of it or reading to understand and learn information, so it needs to be encouraged, but not to the exclusion of other activities like sports and gaming.

To be fair, we have no idea what the future holds. Blasting aliens might turn out to be a skill that saves humanity!

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 12:18

Beamur · 10/01/2024 12:08

You're comparing apples and pears.
Reading develops many skills - vocabulary, language, expression, imagination. But gaming can do as well - fine motor skills, strategy, spacial awareness.
I think you have a point though that reading is generally better thought of as a more 'intellectual' pursuit. Does rather depend on what you read though!

I think the point is that some people think pears (reading) are inherently superior to apples (gaming) always and forever and in every way. There is a lot more to it than that (as you know).

Electio7899 · 10/01/2024 12:18

I’m not sure I agree about analysis' - it does depend what type of reading you’re doing, plenty of analytical thinking in fact based books.

GasPanic · 10/01/2024 12:17

I think different skills.

There is a lot of predjudice against gaming from older generations who don't do it, but it can be very educational. Stuff like Minecraft is very creative and a lot of gaming involves problem solving skills and teamwork.

Kids are increasingly going to be creating and working in digital environments in the future, so neglecting gaming as a way of familiarising them with those environments is bad news. I think the right way to approach it is to encourage them in games that actually involve thinking and learning and creating and not just blasting aliens.

Reading is something essential to have, whether you are reading for the pleasure of it or reading to understand and learn information, so it needs to be encouraged, but not to the exclusion of other activities like sports and gaming.

Electio7899 · 10/01/2024 12:16

Similar story here @Utterbunkum I agree up to a point that any obsession can get out of hand and be used to ignore harder stuff, but ideally, you want them to both read and game as it’s important socially now. I totally agree that there’s a lot of passive content consumption in gaming (as in reading).

Swipe left for the next trending thread