Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 10/01/2024 13:13

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 13:02

That’s fantastic, but now imagine how much MORE he could gain from picking up some books on those areas of interest. He could even learn the whole language! No amount of gaming can do that.

Games, like movies, can be great catalysts for finding a passion or new subject of interest. But they are only ever a jumping off platform. Reading must carry someone the rest of the way.

You learn a language primarily by speaking it with people and listening to it being spoken.

You can do that via real world interaction. Maybe via co-operative gaming on the net. Or by digital language applications, many of which are games in a way. Interactive learning through digital applications is far better at teaching people languages than reading books.

My guess is that a large proportion of non English speakers actually learn the majority of their English via the net and TV, not from books.

JoanOgden · 10/01/2024 13:13

As others have said, so much depends on the type of books and games in question. Similarly with television - flicking through crappy gameshows won't teach you much, but watching Succession with your full attention is a much more educational and enriching experience than reading crappy crime or romance novels.

Carouselfish · 10/01/2024 13:12

Agree that my English Lit post grad is pretty useless though!

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 13:11

Most of the more complex strategies I can think of in all the games I play actually rely more on me thinking how the game designer planned it, knowing the tricks and tools and games logic that is so common across so many games platforms.

And you don't think that's a skill?
Real world strategising isn't done in a vacuum, with infinite options. In real world work situations you usually only have a limited set of options, constrained by your own capabilities, the rules set out in your industry/institution, and the potential responses of competitors.
Or take problem-solving in your own life. It's usually about figuring out what options you might have, there's usually not that many, and trying to get the most out of what you choose.

Not all games are useful, of course, but some of them do encourage this kind of structured thinking. Reading encourages it too but in different ways. They're both great! No reason to choose between them.

Carouselfish · 10/01/2024 13:11

Well, after reading a book for ages, my 8 year old is peaceful and friendly and normal. Spends the same amount of time playing a computer game and she's an irritable, moody crosspatch.
When I read Interview with the Vampire for the first time when I was 15 it opened my eyes to a lot of other interests, the 18th Century, classical music, poetry, philosophy. I read more, listened to more, studied for the fun of it. Reading only gives you words, it requires you to employ your imagination to picture scenes - computer games hand it to you on a plate, you zone out, reacting to stimuli but not really imagining things. Plus the improved vocabulary, better communication skills in general. Playing computer games seems to make communication worse!

stayathomer · 10/01/2024 13:11

Iwishiwasasilentnight

Being a gamer is very different to creating IT content.
This. I have one son that looks up YouTube tutorials and creates game from Scratch (the program!) and another that screams ‘Teammates. TEAMMATES!!’ at people on fortnite that do him wrong😅 And from someone just out the other side of my children’s screen addiction where one couldn’t sleep easily, was blinking tons and had black circles and another had concentration issues, I’ll say yes screens are great but not for huge amounts of time at a time- get them out, get them helping you or chatting or reading, do board games or walks or send them to gps to help them or get them to sit with a pet or SOMETHING!! Then they can get back to screens!

LuluBlakey1 · 10/01/2024 13:10

JassyRadlett · 10/01/2024 12:10

From an educational point of view, being a competent reader - able to read relatively quickly and comprehend accurately, having access to a firstly wide vocab - must make accessing the non-English parts of the curriculum so much easier. My son's secondary invests a lot of time on reading as an investment in GCSEs and A levels - not just in being able to do the exams but in being able to do the reading required to access the curriculum for most subjects.

But then I think reading isn't just about entertainment, it can be about being able to engage with more complex ideas and arguments, be able to challenge your own perspectives by being exposed to different ideas and worldviews, and overall be open to and able to consume more long form and complex content. I feel like these are quite fragile skills - I know in recent years I've spent less and less time reading books, long articles etc and I've made a conscious decision this year to increase my long-form reading.

All of this ^. Also, reading helps to develop empathy and sympathy for others, it exposes children to a wide range of situations they will hopefully never experience and helps them imagine what that might be like, challenges their feelings and thoughts, it gives them opportunities to experience things they might go on and choose to do- travel, ways of living, what they might like to do in the future. It takes them inside minds, thought-processes, reveals concepts that are important but, in a book, safe for the reader- ideas like how people can be manipulative, aggression and it's effects, anger, grief, sadness, risk-taking, the choices we make and how to make good ones, tolerance of difference, kindness vs unkindness, different life-chances, the impact of addiction etc.

That's also why English Lit is important in schools and why teachers and parents should take every opportunity to discuss reading (not necessarily fiction) with children- whatever subject they teach or what interest they have in reading.

The skills of a good reader are vast- analysis, interpretation, good judgement, understanding structure , understanding how language works- written and verbal- and the impact it has, making good choices, understanding people and motivations, they are usually emotionally intelligent and astute, can see thought-out routes through issues, are independent thinkers, have good critical thinking skills.

It's a habit for life. You are never alone with a book- whatever genre or form it is in now.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 10/01/2024 13:04

I agree with TheAlchemistElixa on the different values of reading & gaming.

However, in our modern world, I see both as life skills together with basic maths, riding a bike and swimming.

spanishviola · 10/01/2024 13:03

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:34

I‘m a gamer myself, as is my partner, so I understand what it entails and I’m no snob about it. But gaming and reading are vastly different things, and yes, reading IS a superior pursuit in terms of development and emotional maturity.

Gaming is largely passive - it’s repetitive, you’re channelled through a series of very tight narratives which are predetermined, and all the visuals and characterisation and voices are laid out before you. You receive it, you are not a part of creating it. The language and scripting is almost universally formulaic and poor (even in the best and most lauded games) compared to most decent novels, and the universe (even in the largest open world games) is small and constricted and one-note.

Novels and other forms of literature are the opposite of passive: they engage with you and communicate with you but asking you to engage your imagination, to create in your own head in your own way the universe that the writer has created in theirs. It requires understanding and empathy as characters evolve and grow. It provokes a vast range of all human emotions in a way that no game truly can.

Non-fiction can provide much deeper dives into human lives, knowledge, language and the human condition which can’t help but improve and inform our own. Anyone who avidly reads is almost by definition a different person, who conducts themselves differently and sees things different to the person they would have been if they had never read.

They are FUNDAMENTALLY different things, reading and gaming. I enjoy both, and there is room for both in an enjoyable life, but I only exalt one of them, because only one of them is deserving of it.

Edited

I came here to say this but you’ve said it much better than I could have done.

UsernameChangerRanger · 10/01/2024 13:03

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:47

I play those games, and while they go to lengths to make historical information available to the gamer who chooses to access it, I bet the percentage of those that do is very low. And the information given is very piecemeal, factoidy, and deeply lacking in the wider historical and social context that you would find in any half-decent book on the matter. They are definitely not, in that sense, “good for this”.

Probably. They were just games that came to mind relating to your post.

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 13:02

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 13:00

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

Perhaps, but for example, my son has learned a lot about East Asian cultures and history through gaming. He's learned virtually nothing about them in school (he's secondary age), and if I asked him to read a book about Japanese history he'd probably not be keen. He sometimes plays games with Japanese or Korean language on and has learned a few phrases, his dream is to travel there when he's older.

Gaming is partly why youth culture today has such an Asian influence, which personally I think is a great thing

That’s fantastic, but now imagine how much MORE he could gain from picking up some books on those areas of interest. He could even learn the whole language! No amount of gaming can do that.

Games, like movies, can be great catalysts for finding a passion or new subject of interest. But they are only ever a jumping off platform. Reading must carry someone the rest of the way.

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 13:01

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:34

I‘m a gamer myself, as is my partner, so I understand what it entails and I’m no snob about it. But gaming and reading are vastly different things, and yes, reading IS a superior pursuit in terms of development and emotional maturity.

Gaming is largely passive - it’s repetitive, you’re channelled through a series of very tight narratives which are predetermined, and all the visuals and characterisation and voices are laid out before you. You receive it, you are not a part of creating it. The language and scripting is almost universally formulaic and poor (even in the best and most lauded games) compared to most decent novels, and the universe (even in the largest open world games) is small and constricted and one-note.

Novels and other forms of literature are the opposite of passive: they engage with you and communicate with you but asking you to engage your imagination, to create in your own head in your own way the universe that the writer has created in theirs. It requires understanding and empathy as characters evolve and grow. It provokes a vast range of all human emotions in a way that no game truly can.

Non-fiction can provide much deeper dives into human lives, knowledge, language and the human condition which can’t help but improve and inform our own. Anyone who avidly reads is almost by definition a different person, who conducts themselves differently and sees things different to the person they would have been if they had never read.

They are FUNDAMENTALLY different things, reading and gaming. I enjoy both, and there is room for both in an enjoyable life, but I only exalt one of them, because only one of them is deserving of it.

Edited

Re-write that post only assuming that we are comparing the worst teen literature (misleading and poorly written, playing into stereotypes) to a group of intelligent teens co-operating on a massive minecraft project virtually,

Rnaom · 10/01/2024 13:00

Both have their place, however kids who don't get into reading very young are less likely to pick it up later, and of course reading is much more advantageous when it comes to school and later education than gaming is. So I'd always rather prioritise reading from day one, gaming can be picked up later if the child is interested in that, but reading sets a foundation for life that isn't easily replicated by gaming. And reading isn't just about enjoying books for fun, it helps with literacy, comprehension etc.

As a manager I could often tell who had been brought up reading by the standard of CV we'd get through the door.

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 13:00

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

Perhaps, but for example, my son has learned a lot about East Asian cultures and history through gaming. He's learned virtually nothing about them in school (he's secondary age), and if I asked him to read a book about Japanese history he'd probably not be keen. He sometimes plays games with Japanese or Korean language on and has learned a few phrases, his dream is to travel there when he's older.

Gaming is partly why youth culture today has such an Asian influence, which personally I think is a great thing

SoIRejoined · 10/01/2024 12:59

YABU (but I accidentally clicked Yanbu). Being a good reader puts you at a huge advantage, and reading is strongly associated with academic success. The fact you have a degree means you are more highly educated than most people, even if you struggle with maths.

If you are stuck in minimum wage jobs there are probably other issues holding you back.

I agree gaming isn't all bad and does develop some skills but it's nowhere near as important as reading. The reading age of many GCSE exams is 12, which means quite a few children can't pass even if they are ok at eg maths.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:58

Some of you have mentioned the type of reading, and I would agree, there. It's not that I don't value it, it's that I don't think fluency in it is the greatest indicator.

I can turn a phrase well, I will grant you, and, back in the day I could certainly analyse text with the best of them. I got a degree in it. But my problem solving ability is generally pretty dire (something almost every teacher of mine in subjects which required it, referenced).
@LightSwerve mentioned woodworking, etc, and I wholly agree with that, but craft was another area I was shite at. My analytical ability only seems to exist for literature. It's probably totally a 'me' quirk, but it doesn't seem to translate anywhere else. I suspect it does in genuinely bright kids, and I think that might be a key point. Gaming probably doesn't work for the gaming equivalent of me, but may well be a launch point for those more able to access the skills they gain in other areas. Interesting.

OP posts:
TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:55

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 12:50

Gaming - very different to programming or coding - is very poor for developing problem solving or analytical skills as most games are written with finite options - many are seek and find for example - whereas real life involves problems of much greater complexity and problems that can't be solved requiring a total rethink.

This might have been true once but games today are incredibly complex, if you look at some of the massive open-world games for example, you might have a certain goal but countless ways to approach it, lots of different factors to weigh against each other. They very explicitly require problem-solving and strategising, thinking ahead several steps.

Then there are the character builds, for the game my son and I play, there are several dozen characters you can play, each having about 10 different elements that need to be levelled up in very different ways, so you need to strategise how to balance all these tasks and then figure out which ones to use in which situations. That's just the background to the actual game.

So it depends what kind of games you play I guess, but my son has absolutely learned all sorts of analytical and strategy skills.

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

There’s some truth in this, but it’s not as powerful a tool for analytical thinking as you’re making out, in my opinion. Most of the more complex strategies I can think of in all the games I play actually rely more on me thinking how the game designer planned it, knowing the tricks and tools and games logic that is so common across so many games platforms. And of course I can never truly strategise because they are only so many pre-determined options built into the game. It’s essentially a fancy Tetris, in that’s sense: some skill and strategy required, but only so many options within the confines of the world created.

much better to have children develop analytical skills outside in the real world (books not much good for this either, though understand human character, frailty, emotions and motivation through reading history and fiction is incredibly useful for real strategy and analytics in the real world, since human behaviour is at the heart of it) or learning physics or maths through books or real world application in non-human contexts.

Gaming is great, but it’s not quite capable of what reading (or of course real world experience) can give you.

HoldMeCloserTonyDancer · 10/01/2024 12:55

I’m old school. Gaming won’t help you to read and write. What games are on the “canon” of the greatest of all time? We get so many of our references from literature. I think it’s a travesty not to read. To be ignorant of books is to miss out on so much x

MuffinCoffee · 10/01/2024 12:53

I think reading is a skill for everyone and is so important. In most professions you need to read and comprehend information to be able to perform well or interact well. Agree this is sadly changing into videos etc. But those who quickly read and understand will have an advantage.
Many times even the most professional people don't have best communication skills and the ones who have the best communication skills seem to be the one who read a lot. I can't generalise this ofc but this is based on my experience.

LaDamaDeElche · 10/01/2024 12:52

It totally depends on the person. My DD has ADHD and too much screen time/gaming has a marked effect on her symptoms, behaviour and mood, which reading doesn't. The draw of the dopamine fix from mobiles and games consoles can be incredibly addictive and can completely overtake all other activities in life. I'd say very few people experience that with reading in relation to screens and gaming.

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 12:50

Gaming - very different to programming or coding - is very poor for developing problem solving or analytical skills as most games are written with finite options - many are seek and find for example - whereas real life involves problems of much greater complexity and problems that can't be solved requiring a total rethink.

This might have been true once but games today are incredibly complex, if you look at some of the massive open-world games for example, you might have a certain goal but countless ways to approach it, lots of different factors to weigh against each other. They very explicitly require problem-solving and strategising, thinking ahead several steps.

Then there are the character builds, for the game my son and I play, there are several dozen characters you can play, each having about 10 different elements that need to be levelled up in very different ways, so you need to strategise how to balance all these tasks and then figure out which ones to use in which situations. That's just the background to the actual game.

So it depends what kind of games you play I guess, but my son has absolutely learned all sorts of analytical and strategy skills.

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

burnoutbabe · 10/01/2024 12:49

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:45

@burnoutbabe I did have a gaming period in my 30s and enjoyed it for all the reason you list. I can't do it now, as I always did struggle with 3D sickness and enhanced graphics made it worse. 10 minutes on a friend's PS4 and I had to lie down...

Certain games make me feel sick now -it's the "head Bob" effect, luckily you can turn it off in games it appears in - dishonoured I am looking at you!

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:47

UsernameChangerRanger · 10/01/2024 12:44

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

The assassin's creed and civilization franchises are probably good for this.

I play those games, and while they go to lengths to make historical information available to the gamer who chooses to access it, I bet the percentage of those that do is very low. And the information given is very piecemeal, factoidy, and deeply lacking in the wider historical and social context that you would find in any half-decent book on the matter. They are definitely not, in that sense, “good for this”.

FourLeggedBuckers · 10/01/2024 12:47

UsernameChangerRanger · 10/01/2024 12:44

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

The assassin's creed and civilization franchises are probably good for this.

I don’t think either of those are marketed at children though?

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 12:45

@burnoutbabe I did have a gaming period in my 30s and enjoyed it for all the reason you list. I can't do it now, as I always did struggle with 3D sickness and enhanced graphics made it worse. 10 minutes on a friend's PS4 and I had to lie down...

OP posts: