Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
PSEnny · 10/01/2024 13:45

The skill you have is that you are literate. Literacy is a fundamental skill that is the bedrock for so much. Your husband will also be literate regardless of him not reading. Education in reading is to build literacy skills. Children who are not literate struggle.
I read huge amounts and studied English Lit. Am I more intelligent than someone who doesn’t read as much? Of course not. But there is a big difference in being literate and not reading than not having the ability to read or read well. This is why early literacy is so important. Without being literate you won’t have the choice.

TripleDaisySummer · 10/01/2024 13:44

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming.

Moderation with everything is probably key - but yes I do think there can be over emphasis on reading.

DD1 not a reader - always suspect dyslexia but never got anywhere - huge vocabulary according teachers. DH and I have good vocabulary and use it round our kids - we listen to radio, pod casts, you tube, tv - audio books, films and games - life in fact.

I suspect content is more important than medium in most cases.

You tube for us is actually fairly positive - professionals in niche areas finding things out and leaning from experience and others with experience to create things. Sometime gaming sparks interest in architecture or historical events. Educational apps have been useful as well - they can be variable but DD2 is enjoying some language ones at minute.

Electio7899 · 10/01/2024 13:43

So what are we really saying here? That if you are exclusively reading badly written repetitive pony stories, that’s as much of an issue as if you’re logging onto Roblox and playing someone’s shooting / dress up dolly type games?

not that controversial I’d have thought!

TeaToastIsAll · 10/01/2024 13:42

My autistic dc finds reading abit boring, he is good at it, has a wide vocabulary etc so I'm not concerned.
However, he absolutely loves gaming, it is his passion, and calms his mind & helps him get out any frustrations. Due to this he is great at problem solving, analysing, tactical play, building, creating etc. He goes into the finer details of the games. Acouple of his games are on the laptop so he types, has become a great typer as well as practising more complex spellings than he learns in school.
Some of his friends who are banned from screens struggle with the computer lesson at school, can't find letters/numbers on the keyboard etc.
Technology is part of the world we live in, and I think it is important children have at least some access to this. Dc is 7, and I think destined to become a game designer!

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 13:41

@MorningSunshineSparkles I think that's an important point l should have made clearer. It's the blanket belief that reading trumps gaming no matter what. As a pp mentioned upthread, there wasn't really anything much better about her in her room reading pony stories than if she had been a gamer, yet, regardless of CONTENT, it would still have been viewed as 'better'.
It depends on a lot of other factors, which aren't always taken into consideration when indicating that children should read rather than game in the generic terms I often see this stipulation being made.
Reading in and of itself is really not an indicator of exam success. There's a lot more to it than that, and favouring gaming over reading for no other reason than it's just 'better' doesn't get to the nub of the 'why' of it.

OP posts:
Goatymum · 10/01/2024 13:40

You sound like me! I’ve always been a bookworm, good at English, have a wide vocabulary and am a proficient proofreader but useless at maths and probably have dyscalculia as I get numbers mixed up etc.
i don’t think gaming per se is better than reading. It may be social and fun, prob good for hand/eye coordination (another thing I lack!), but reading gives you insight into other worlds, a great deal of general knowledge and is also a great pastime.
I am v social and never read instead of going out etc! I’ve also gamed and enjoyed it too (more in my 20s than now, I leave it to the kids these days).

Latewinter · 10/01/2024 13:39

I genuinely love both, but the cognitive effect of reading is quite different. No need to pit them against each other, but if you could only do one, I'd pick reading, for both me and kid.

There's different games as others have said. My son spending hours shooting critters on Super Animal Royale isn't the same experience as us playing Breath of the Wild or Tears of the Kingdom together, with him doing the reading, or exploring planets on No Man's Sky.

I believe in games as art. Some of my favourite games are up there with some of my favourite books for storytelling. I am amazed at some of the beautiful things my son builds and some of the logical puzzles he can solve on video games - he's much better than me at that and he's only nine.

I think the social aspect is oversold. Sure if they're playing together in person, but when a lot of people say that they mean online, and I'm not going to let my son have access to games with open text chat or voice chat till he's pretty much old enough to go out and see his friends anyway. It's as dangerous as having them on social media - worse in some ways.

Anonymouslyposting · 10/01/2024 13:36

I read absolutely voraciously as a child and teen. I also gamed extensively as a teen.

My view is that it depends so much on the game - if I sit on my iPad playing a match 3 style game is that equivalent to reading a good book? Absolutely not. However, there are games which have as good stories as books and which require good problem solving abilities. Similarly, there’s reading Tolstoy and there’s reading mills & boon. So I think both have their place - and it’s fine to do things just because they are fun, not everything has to be improving.

honeylulu · 10/01/2024 13:35

I'm not saying gaming has no value - I think it does refine skills in things like problem solving, reaction times and technology obviously. But reading definitely has different and distinct values that can't be easily replaced or refined by other means.

My kids are both bright and avid gamers, much less interested in reading especially the eldest. I was a real bookworm. My spelling, vocabulary and grammar are all excellent. <Waits for someone to point out multiple errors in my post!> My children are weak at v those skills in comparison. My eldest is now at uni and has struggled to get the hang of writing essays. He does sometimes ask me to proofread and I do end up amending sentence structures etc.

Youngest is being tutored for the 11+. Tutor says she's definitely bright enough but her spelling and vocabulary are below par and "she needs to read more".

It seems a shame as they'd both have those extra strings to their bows if they had got into the swing of reading for pleasure. I did try and encourage them but Minecraft was always more interesting!

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 13:32

Depends on what you read surely? If you’re sat there whizzing through encyclopaedia after encyclopaedia and retaining all that knowledge I’d say it was completely different to gaming. If you’re sat there reading fantasy or crime or other fiction then no, it’s no better than gaming.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/01/2024 13:31

IMO reading for pleasure will very likely enhance English language skills, help to increase their vocabulary and to absorb (painlessly!) good grammar and spelling.

FloorWipes · 10/01/2024 13:31

I suspect gaming will have a different sort of effect on dopamine pathways to reading.

takealettermsjones · 10/01/2024 13:26

The world needs both.

But there will always be those who sneer at what they perceive as less intellectual or lower class pursuits.

I can make slime with my kids, and talk about measurements, materials, reactions, etc. I can play Monopoly with them, and talk about value for money, borrowing and repaying, budgeting etc. I'm sure some of the people dragging their kids round a museum might think they're better educating their kids than I am, but the truth is that opportunities for education are everywhere and not just in the pursuits that Jacob Rees-Mogg would approve of.

(Go forth and game!)

Flockameanie · 10/01/2024 13:26

For example (video games' negative impact on brain development): https://www.nature.com/articles/mp2015193

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 13:25

@StaunchMomma not really a case of being the exception that disproves the rule, just using myself as an example to posit the question.

OP posts:
Flockameanie · 10/01/2024 13:22

I haven't RTWT, but I think one of the concerns about gaming is that it gives your brain a dopamine hit and that is why it can become addictive. It affects your brain in a different way to reading and in a way that isn't necessarily positive.

That isn't to say that gaming doesn't have its plusses, which this book-loving, old-culture consuming luddite is beginning to see in my DC who are beginning to get into it.

CouCouCachou · 10/01/2024 13:21

I’m not sure - reading is a very important part of developing language and writing skills. Is the same true of gaming?

StaunchMomma · 10/01/2024 13:20

You seem to be treating yourself as the case that disproves the rule but obviously you are just one person and there are always outliers in a data set.

Statistics show very clearly that children who read tend to perform much better at exam levels.

That said, there are many other factors at play, eg what the child reads (comics or actual books etc), the child's health, support system (financial as well as general), mental health, post code (unfortunately, but true), drive etc all affect their outcomes.

As a rule, and a rather firm one, readers do better in education than gamers, although plenty do both, but the skills sets are not equivalent

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 13:20

GasPanic · 10/01/2024 13:13

You learn a language primarily by speaking it with people and listening to it being spoken.

You can do that via real world interaction. Maybe via co-operative gaming on the net. Or by digital language applications, many of which are games in a way. Interactive learning through digital applications is far better at teaching people languages than reading books.

My guess is that a large proportion of non English speakers actually learn the majority of their English via the net and TV, not from books.

Tell that to the Japanese officials who design the Japanese school system! 😂

Doublebiscuit77 · 10/01/2024 13:20

I didn't vote. I think it depends on how you are defining 'better'. You seem to be basing it on earning potential and high IQ, and assuming that other people think reading is superior because it contributes to these two things. You are arguing it doesn't and is therefore purely for enjoyment's sake, as is gaming?

I think it depends on what you are gaming or reading! Reading can be a literary form of art, i know less about gaming but there's no reason to assume it can't be a form of art in its own right. The pleasures derived from art far extend pure enjoyment.

I'm glad reading has been part of my life - I'm not sure i could live in any way happily without it. It seems you feel the same, even if it hasn't turned us into a combination of Einstein and Bill Gates! And agree with some snobbery around gaming - i can tell DS1 is going to be an amazing gamer, and reader! Both opening up worlds for him, even if they're imaginary.

User1789 · 10/01/2024 13:19

There is a very, very, odd focus on reading in schools.

My son is in reception and is on target for his phonics. Yes, reading is important, but the ability to read/do phonics is places on a pedestal over and above things like numeracy (something he is really good at) and science, again something he has a fascination with and shows ability to understand concepts of.

And forget any focus on physical ability like his ability to swim, ride a bike and run 2k all before starting school. I don't think anybody has realised...

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 13:17

Absolutely, @dreamingbohemian , no need to choose between them. But the OP’s question was about gaming being just as good. And it’s really, really not!

Gilead · 10/01/2024 13:16

Reading helps analysis, critical thinking, and teaches us how to cope with things, death, illness, jealousy etc.

It is readers that challenge government and regimes; scientists and coders are rarely interested in anything other than their fields.
please note I said rarely.

kitsuneghost · 10/01/2024 13:14

In my experience (which obviously doesn't cover everyone before the 'ah but my kid') Gamers tend to be more logical and mathematic and readers tend to be more artistic.
I don't think one is better or worse than the other. Just uses and enhances a different skill set

Perhaps alternate evenings reading, gaming and excercise would be beneficial for everyone.

Ramalangadingdong · 10/01/2024 13:13

I suppose it depends on what kind of books you read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread