Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
Rnaom · 10/01/2024 14:07

One thing I've noticed about reading so much with my kid (four now, been reading daily since birth) is the exposure to new words that wouldn't naturally come across his path. I have a fairly wide vocabulary, yet there are words that pop up in books that he wouldn't normally be exposed to until much later, if at all. As such he has a fantastic vocabulary, really advanced for his age, and absolutely loves learning new words, trying to read signs, sounding out letters, it's lovely.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 10/01/2024 14:07

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:05

@ForeverDelayedEpiphany I am truly sorry for your loss.

Thank you for your kind words. ❤️

Oh, I do like gaming very much too, and will happily spend an hour with my DS on his Switch playing Mario Kart. I find it relaxes me and isn't as difficult to get into as reading is now for me.😊

RosesAndHellebores · 10/01/2024 14:07

It's all about balance. My DC were reading pre school. They also loved pokemon (which I thought taught them numbers, cypes/categories and numbers through strength Quotients. They had a love of music and played instruments. Most importantly they had access to a variety of books as well as school stories and Harry Potter.

Both took firsts in their first degrees at Oxford or Cambridge (both Liberal arts and language based). One now teaches English, the other is an academic and has had his first book published.

Interestingly both love language. Only last night dd informed me she had studied 8 languages and had mastered three: English, Music and BSL (her French is pretty fluent) as well as Spanish, Latin, Arabic and German.

horseyhorsey17 · 10/01/2024 14:06

It's completely different. Reading enriches you culturally and intellectually, gaming doesn't.

I'm not anti-gaming as such, it's a fun pastime if that's what you're into, and yes it can be a career path for a tiny handful of people (as can anything really), I just don't think hours spent completing the latest Zelda gives you much of a cultural or intellectual insight into anything.

GaterGame · 10/01/2024 14:06

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 14:03

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

They're not recruiting gamers who can't read.

They are recruiting readers who can't game.

How many gamers who can't read do you think there are?

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:05

@ForeverDelayedEpiphany I am truly sorry for your loss.

OP posts:
ruby1957 · 10/01/2024 14:05

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

This comment alone fills me with apprehension - I worked in IT from the 1970s and know about coding and analysis at the machine level. There needs to be logical thinking and analytical ability and being able to understand what the user wants from the system and how rigorously to test it. I would trust a reader over a 'gamer'.

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 14:04

I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is

Agreed. I speak as an avid reader - I learnt to read at a very young age and was reading at an adult reading level by the time I was 8 or 9. My degree is in English literature and I now have a book reviews blog. But ultimately reading is entertainment. A hobby. Reading for pleasure isn't a morally or intellectually superior leisure activity to watching a TV drama or playing Red Dead Redemption or chatting with friends or playing football or anything else.

Just because someone doesn't read books, that doesn't mean they aren't engaging with stories and consuming information.

I also find it odd that among the objections that Mumsnetters have to kids spending a couple of hours gaming is that 'You can't tear them away from it' and 'It's solitary so they aren't engaging with others'. OK, fine, but that would also have applied to me as a child when I spent hours reading. I had to be dragged to the dinner table and then told off for trying to read during the meal, and when I was reading for hours I certainly wasn't taking part in conversation. We all have things that we find super-absorbing, whether it's reading or gaming or binge-watching Succession or doing bloody jigsaw puzzles, and I don't think one is any better than the other.

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 14:03

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

They're not recruiting gamers who can't read.

They are recruiting readers who can't game.

TripleDaisySummer · 10/01/2024 14:03

The skill you have is that you are literate. Literacy is a fundamental skill that is the bedrock for so much.

Is anyone saying literacy isn't important - I though OP was talking about more reading for pleasure.

I did when kids were young try very hard to encourage a love of books or comics or anything that meant they were practising reading skills but once they hit a certain level does it matter as much? DS an avid reader, once he got past slow start, trailed off in teen years with his reading - less gaming more actual coding with him - still did well in GCSE.

I also looked for fun way to practise maths skills - though those were harder to find - an online site they did - math-factor -was great though and they've done really well with maths since - though also did real world activities as well.

Most of DH spare time is spent making things - models to paintings to clothes or watching TV - he'll read magazines but only occasional book - he still capable of reading for work - which is a university lecturer so yes well educated and has to read to keep us with new advances in field.

GreenTurtle75 · 10/01/2024 14:02

Thelootllama · 10/01/2024 12:30

What's wrong with ACOTAR?! 😆just started the first book!

I love ACOTAR. @DarkAcademia Have you read them, too? If not, I'd read along, as the series does become more adult as it progresses, so DD may have questions (particularly if she's early teens). Great tackling of mental health and relationships, though.

On the main point, I think the ideal would be for people to consider kids being great readers as good as them being great gamers.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 10/01/2024 14:02

Sorry for the random typos - thanks, autocorrect! 😅😆

Yalta · 10/01/2024 14:02

Neither myself or husband or dc have ever read a book unless forced to.

Ds didnt master reading English until he was 12 years old.
His writing is like that of a 4year old (he is early 20s and English grammar is something that I don’t think he will ever understand

However he did teach himself Spanish and is now learning Mandorin
His writing is so neat when he forms the characters that you wouldn’t believe it was the same person writing the same words in English

He is by far the most intelligent person I know of his age yet without that English GCSE the only employment open to him are minimum wage jobs.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 10/01/2024 14:01

Reading has always been my passion, as has language and English. So much so, that i decided from a very early age that writing was my future career.

And hence why I became an editor and journalist on a trade magazine, then moved onto copywriting. Reading prolifically as a child helped me hugely with a means to escape, build vocabulary and expand my knowledge.

I'm pretty sure that I also have the dyslexic equivalent of maths (sorry, I can't remember its name). I think if I'd had Bern good at maths, it coulf possibly have opened doors to a more financially rewarding career or job. After a head injury and post concussion syndrome 9.years ago, i lost my ability to see in my mind's eye, and during my acute recovery period after the initial injury, I have aphasia for a while, which was extremely difficult to work with. As you can imagine, not being able to read or write properly when trying to make a living as a writer is pretty devastating and scary.

I have regained my ability to read, thank goodness, but haven't been able to use my mind's eye ever since the accident. I've just about come to terms with it in some ways, but the loss of my imagination while I read isn't something I'll ever truly be at peace with. I miss it. 😢

snowdrop098 · 10/01/2024 14:00

Not that long ago, the novel was seen as an immoral art form. I love reading, very similar to you, have an Eng Lit Degree. But I don't think it's particularly edifying. Just fun.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:00

@BitchBrigade thank you. That's sort of what I was getting at, although even I would say there is a difference between reading and watching Jeremy Kyle.
My point is that you do find more prolific gamers in the fields you have referenced than you find prolific readers, so reading (depending on factors, as others have mentioned, such as what you are reading) isn't necessarily automatically 'better than'.
What I am getting at is that there's a blanket view of this that I am not convinced is accurate.

OP posts:
Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 13:59

I completely agree @Utterbunkum .

I learnt to read from a very early age and did well at school because of it I guess however, in my teen years, I was devouring books nightly ….at age 12/13 until 2am, then being knackered all day because of it!

I think at GCSE level, Shakespeare has ruined a love of reading for many kids.
I don’t believe Shakespeare needs teaching to kids except for if they choose English Literature in 6th form. I think at GCSE level, only an English language paper needs to be taught and have English Lit as an additional subject you can choose if you want, like you do for French, history etc.

Once you can read, unless you want to read for pleasure, like any other hobby, it’s a choice. At a certain point in my life, I would have a handful of books on the go but not actually read past chapter 1 of any of them - my brain needed something else (Netflix) more visual for a quick fix than slogging my way through a book.

Currently I’m writing my first novel (slowly) because I want to share my writing and ideas creatively and I’m really glad to be back in a world of books again.

Its all relative.
Gaming can be brilliant for so many young people and adults. My autisic son uses gaming to relax learn and design. My older parents love to use YouTube to learn stuff and love the ease of the internet.

Nothing has to be set in stone. Don’t worry that people think you have to read!

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 10/01/2024 13:56

My nephew is an absolute sponge for information. Will tell you the history of a particular jet engine on a type of plane, or will tell you about all sorts of military history. Some of it will have been picked up from some books, but most of it is picked up off the random things he watches on You Tube. If he's not watching that, he's gaming with his mates. He does occasionally read a book, but not too often.

When I was his age, we lived in the middle of nowhere and I had no friends nearby and was an only child. We didn't have a car, and public transport was practically non-existent, so the only socialising I did was at school. I had a computer to play games, but this was pre-internet, so it was just me playing on my own. Other than that I read books. As OP says, it was a very isolating existence really.

When I compare to my nephew, his general knowledge outside of school work is so much greater than mine was and his social skills are better than mine were at that age. He's much more confident in talking to people and putting his arguments across in a discussion. Even his own mum has said she wishes she had been half as confident as he is when she was his age.

I don't think gaming is anywhere near as bad as people make it out to be. Sure you've got to be careful what they're playing and who they're talking to, and making sure they are engaging in the real world, but there are huge benefits to this new wider open world for kids.

user1497207191 · 10/01/2024 13:56

Surely it depends on what you read and how you read it?

If you're just "reading the words" and not really thinking about the plots, themes, characteristics, not researching the meanings of things you don't understand, then it is pretty pointless, especially if it's "mass produced" generic novels, like Mills & Boon or even some popular authors, where "reading a book" is little more than something to do to avoid boredom.

But if you're reading "properly", i.e. really buying into the book, checking for words you don't know, researching places/people featured in the book, reading a wide range of different genres, different authors, etc., identifying characteristics, comparing different characters, then it is a really enriching activity, especially if the book is descriptive of historic people, places, visions of the future, etc.

But even with the likes of Mills & Boon crap, there's still a "value" in very simple terms such as broadening your vocabulary, learning spellings and grammar, etc just by reading, it's bound to sink in and you can then benefit by using better English skills in everyday life.

I also think gaming is similar, i.e. it's what and how you "game" that determines whether it enriches you or not. Some games really give you new skills, not only physical with spatial awareness etc., but also mental, especially when there are tactics to employ to "pass" each level, move to new levels, etc., or where you have to "do tasks" to earn points etc. A basic shoot to kill war game is probably pretty limited as to learn skills, but there are lots of games where you really have to use strategy, i.e. the much maligned Farming Simulator where you have to plant crops, harvest them and transport them to earn money which you need to buy new seeds, new tractors, new fields, etc - it is more akin to a business simulation game and can actually teach business/finance. Compare something potentially useful like that to, say, Pacman where you just have to try to avoid being eaten - the "skills" you learn are so different. Likewise with building games like Minecraft which are incredibly educational.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 13:52

@PSEnny this isn't about literacy at the basic level of being able to read. Nobody, certainly not me, denies the importance of that. This is about the generic notion that reading automatically trumps gaming as a pastime for kids, not the notion that gaming trumps illiteracy.

OP posts:
stormy4319trevor · 10/01/2024 13:52

Reading is said to have health benefits such as lowering heart rate and be generally a calming activity.

BitchBrigade · 10/01/2024 13:52

A lot of people here failing to realise that what is being got at here isn't that Gaming teaches kids coding and IT skills.

Gaming is the gateway to an interest in coding and computer hardware. PC gaming isn't just "Stick CD in and turn into zombie". Consoles open up the world of PC gaming which is much better from a technical aspect. For some games, especially the newer ones, you need high spec PC hardware builds (so kids research and learn about computer tech and hardware) and take some level of general IT knowledge to make changes, install drivers etc on the system itself.

Then there is graphic design and implementing that content into games. Some of the visuals alone are enough to inspire children into the arts SEPARATELY to IT based roles in graphic design and art creation for games. The amount of coding that goes into not only that, but coding a whole video game into a cinematic masterpiece would likely blow your mind.

THEN there are the beautifully crafted storylines. Mysteries, crime, drama, romance, grief, loss, fantasy, absolutely unbelievable creative writing opportunity for children inspired by them, all backed up with stunning cinematics and a cast and crew of voice and physical actors (mocap etc). I would rather my children immerse themselves in most of the stories told in video games than watch Sharon dive senselessly into another shitty affair because soap writers want desperately to to normalize extremely toxic ideals such as incest and affairs (not that this isn't shown in video games and there are problematic themes, they are generally just written much better than scummy soap storylines are). And you aren't just sitting there melting your brain. You are controlling the character and thinking things through even in the most basic of games. some of them have extremely complex puzzles, mathematics, require critical thinking and problem solving. It's not all violent GTA (and Red Dead Redemption - which actually have extremely well written stories behind them) or "mindless" Minecraft (who have a WHOLE educational package). There are millions of games out there that are educational that Mumsnetters know nothing about through pure ignorance because they want to keep crying about "video game bad".

HUGE swathes of the people I work with in IT, Software development, coding jobs from the bottom right up to management are "Gamers" and got into their jobs because of their "mindless gaming" while their parents screeched about how amazing the high brown storytelling in Eastenders and Jeremy Kyle was. They are also paid more than our nurses and even some of our Doctors, and that's at entry level.

Go figure.

QueenOfMOHO · 10/01/2024 13:51

I agree with you to a point OP. One of my DC studied English Lit, got a first, but beyond their own enjoyment and a career in teaching (which wasn't for them). What use is it?
In the end they did a conversion masters into IT and now make a very decent salary as a software engineer. It's not their passion, but a fantastic knowledge of myth and legend doesn't pay bills.
Another DC never picked up a book in his life (beyond the beginners guide to python), parents evenings were always fraught as he just wasn't interested in English at all. His teacher kept telling him he would struggle to get a good job. He also went into software engineering and I suspect he is now earning double his teachers salary. He is 22.
I read, but I find the internet far more entertaining.

Latewinter · 10/01/2024 13:46

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 13:32

Depends on what you read surely? If you’re sat there whizzing through encyclopaedia after encyclopaedia and retaining all that knowledge I’d say it was completely different to gaming. If you’re sat there reading fantasy or crime or other fiction then no, it’s no better than gaming.

It is. It works your brain harder, and has fewer negative side effects. Also, piss off with the genre snobbery!