Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
Devilsmommy · 10/01/2024 14:35

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:34

I‘m a gamer myself, as is my partner, so I understand what it entails and I’m no snob about it. But gaming and reading are vastly different things, and yes, reading IS a superior pursuit in terms of development and emotional maturity.

Gaming is largely passive - it’s repetitive, you’re channelled through a series of very tight narratives which are predetermined, and all the visuals and characterisation and voices are laid out before you. You receive it, you are not a part of creating it. The language and scripting is almost universally formulaic and poor (even in the best and most lauded games) compared to most decent novels, and the universe (even in the largest open world games) is small and constricted and one-note.

Novels and other forms of literature are the opposite of passive: they engage with you and communicate with you but asking you to engage your imagination, to create in your own head in your own way the universe that the writer has created in theirs. It requires understanding and empathy as characters evolve and grow. It provokes a vast range of all human emotions in a way that no game truly can.

Non-fiction can provide much deeper dives into human lives, knowledge, language and the human condition which can’t help but improve and inform our own. Anyone who avidly reads is almost by definition a different person, who conducts themselves differently and sees things different to the person they would have been if they had never read.

They are FUNDAMENTALLY different things, reading and gaming. I enjoy both, and there is room for both in an enjoyable life, but I only exalt one of them, because only one of them is deserving of it.

Edited

That's the most insightful thing I've ever read on here and I completely agree

Devilsmommy · 10/01/2024 14:33

DarkAcademia · 10/01/2024 12:12

Also my teen DD reads ACOTAR, and I'm QUITE sure there's little virtue in that! 😳

Brilliant books though😁

TeaToastIsAll · 10/01/2024 14:33

Oh and one game as an example... 🤔

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 14:32

user1497207191 · 10/01/2024 13:56

Surely it depends on what you read and how you read it?

If you're just "reading the words" and not really thinking about the plots, themes, characteristics, not researching the meanings of things you don't understand, then it is pretty pointless, especially if it's "mass produced" generic novels, like Mills & Boon or even some popular authors, where "reading a book" is little more than something to do to avoid boredom.

But if you're reading "properly", i.e. really buying into the book, checking for words you don't know, researching places/people featured in the book, reading a wide range of different genres, different authors, etc., identifying characteristics, comparing different characters, then it is a really enriching activity, especially if the book is descriptive of historic people, places, visions of the future, etc.

But even with the likes of Mills & Boon crap, there's still a "value" in very simple terms such as broadening your vocabulary, learning spellings and grammar, etc just by reading, it's bound to sink in and you can then benefit by using better English skills in everyday life.

I also think gaming is similar, i.e. it's what and how you "game" that determines whether it enriches you or not. Some games really give you new skills, not only physical with spatial awareness etc., but also mental, especially when there are tactics to employ to "pass" each level, move to new levels, etc., or where you have to "do tasks" to earn points etc. A basic shoot to kill war game is probably pretty limited as to learn skills, but there are lots of games where you really have to use strategy, i.e. the much maligned Farming Simulator where you have to plant crops, harvest them and transport them to earn money which you need to buy new seeds, new tractors, new fields, etc - it is more akin to a business simulation game and can actually teach business/finance. Compare something potentially useful like that to, say, Pacman where you just have to try to avoid being eaten - the "skills" you learn are so different. Likewise with building games like Minecraft which are incredibly educational.

Surely it depends on what you read and how you read it and how your brain works, more like?

For example I am a reasonable bright person and I have a good grade at A level English Literature, but I can honestly say that beyond being able to repeat the bullet points relating to key themes that I was taught by teachers I got nothing out of it other than a hatred of Shakespeare, hatred of the theatre and a vow to never ever ever read anything written earlier than circa Jane Austen!

Some people get huge amounts from "great literature" with flowery prose. Other people need messages to be simple and to the point to have an impact. Reading Shakespeare and getting nothing from it at all other than a hatred of Shakespeare does not benefit the reader, nor does it benefit people who want to encourage the reading of Shakespeare.

TeaToastIsAll · 10/01/2024 14:32

'if you can read well, you can comprehend history, geography, physics, chemistry, coding, etc. etc., better.'

you game, you can kill znardvaars when they invade from the plant Vorrrdzinger to attack the kralggiii.'

😂 coding?? Other way around perhaps, this thread gets more hilarious by the minute.

Consideringachange2023 · 10/01/2024 14:31

Gaming is definitely skill set. It uses a lot of cognitive function and also builds problem solving skills, resilience and as you say, is enjoyable!

Reading enhances our knowledge of the human experience though doesn’t it. Tells us stories of lives we would never consider otherwise, opens our eyes to concepts we’d never known about. Gaming does that to an extent but I don’t think it’s quite as useful at expanding the mind.

Its still a skill set though, my young DC is far better at 5 than me on most games

HideousKinky · 10/01/2024 14:31

Not sure if anyone has already made this point - but several studies have shown that those who have the habit of reading fiction appear to be better able to understand other people, empathise with them and see the world from their perspective. Reading activates a part of the brain that you use to navigate relationships with others and understand their motives, showing a link between reading and social skills

waterrat · 10/01/2024 14:30

Big tech really are winning if people start to think this is a reasonable argument.

waterrat · 10/01/2024 14:30

Don't agree. Reading broadens horizons, increases empathy by taking children into different worlds - and encourages imagination and grows knowledge.

I am not academic - have adhd - but was a voracious reader as a child and it is the thing that has got me through life. I understand so much abotu science/ history etc because of novels/ stories/ non fiction Ive read

Gaming is living in a world designed by money making IT Companies - we are being suckered to think kids spending hours online is not bad for them - of course in moderation it's fine but many children are not gaming in moderation.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 10/01/2024 14:30

@Utterbunkum I do agree with you, sorry if that wasn’t clear! I don’t know anyone who sits there and reads encyclopaedia after encyclopaedia. I was the one sat in my room with my head in a book ignoring the world going past. I actually failed to develop some important social skills because of it. As an adult I’m quite keen on gaming too. I’d rather DC gamed than read because of the social aspect of it but I don’t see either as better than the other.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 10/01/2024 14:29

*argh! You wouldn't think I was a copywriter, my editing is atrocious 😆😅😬

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 10/01/2024 14:28

My DD (who's 13 today, happy birthday!) is an incredibly intelligent girl, and a hugely prolific reader. She read 1984 by Orwell last year, and is reading To Kill A Mockingbird after a relative gave her the book as a Christmas present.

Her vocabulary, intelligence, and writing ability is streets ahead of her peers, and I'm pretty sure it's helped hugely by much she loves her books.

I think reading is a essential skill, and one that will help you in many aspects of life.

willWillSmithsmith · 10/01/2024 14:27

Iwishiwasasilentnight · 10/01/2024 12:04

Being a gamer is very different to creating IT content.

Tell that to Pewdie Pie.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:26

@Ladyj84 I did not say my love of reading prevented me getting good jobs. I said it did not result in me doing better than a lot of gamers do today.

OP posts:
Spinet · 10/01/2024 14:25

Reading for pleasure as a kid is shown to be linked to success later in life. https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/reading-engagement/understanding-reading-engagement/reading-for-pleasure-a-door-to-success

It might be that they haven't done the study on gaming yet, or maybe it's love of narrative rather than reading, or something else, but the current understanding is that yes it is much better than gaming in a learning sense.

I don't have anything against gaming but I don't think it should be lauded as an alternative to reading.

https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/reading-engagement/understanding-reading-engagement/reading-for-pleasure-a-door-to-success

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:23

Mikimoto · 10/01/2024 14:13

if you can read well, you can comprehend history, geography, physics, chemistry, coding, etc. etc., better.

if you game, you can kill znardvaars when they invade from the plant Vorrrdzinger to attack the kralggiii.

And yet I, a prolific reader, absolutely cannot comprehend physic, chemistry or coding...

OP posts:
TripleDaisySummer · 10/01/2024 14:23

user1497207191 · 10/01/2024 14:13

@Verbena17

I think at GCSE level, Shakespeare has ruined a love of reading for many kids.
I don’t believe Shakespeare needs teaching to kids except for if they choose English Literature in 6th form. I think at GCSE level, only an English language paper needs to be taught and have English Lit as an additional subject you can choose if you want, like you do for French, history etc.

I fully agree. Our son was a prolific reader until he went to secondary school but they managed to kill it stone dead for him even before the GCSE years and Shakespeare! He completely lost interested and wouldn't even read the set-books let alone anything extra for fun. It was such a shame as we'd really made an effort from a very early age, reading to him every night, teaching him to read long before he started primary school, buying loads of books that interested him, but, no, almost as soon as he started secondary, he just refused, same with poetry and all fiction really - he just doesn't "get" it. He's brilliant with non fiction though!!

At least he had learned the literacy skills and is excellent with functional English, i.e. grammar, spelling, essays, written arguments, etc., which enabled him to get highest grades possible in written GCSEs and A levels, i.e. Geography, History, Economics, etc. His lowest GCSE grades were English Language and English Literature!! Couldn't believe that even in the Eng Language paper there was still fiction comprehension, poetry and creative writing - virtually no "practical" real life English/Literacy at all!

School teaching/examinations of English has really lost it's way! When I was at school, we did comprehensions of things like a recipe or an appliance instruction book and did "real life" tasks such as writing letters, but now it all seems dominated with poetry and description writing/fiction with very low relevance to day to day real life literacy needs.

I'd agree with this.

Poetry at GCSE has been particular low point. Poetry I did at school had structure rhymes patterns as well as imagery - occasional fun but still making a point one - a lot of poetry DC have studied seems more like prose and it's often harder to spot usage of language in them somehow - pretty much made our kids hate all of it.

Their first primary school did Shakespeare and to my surprised did is is such as way to be age appropriate and fun for them - secondary school killed that interest - took taking them to the globe for they to see how great it could be - they were very surprised how much they enjoyed it. Even DS who used to like analysing texts and comparing and contrasting pre GCSE hated both English GCSE.

Ladyj84 · 10/01/2024 14:23

If I could have written this post it would have been me and I still love reading and it didn't stop me getting good jobs either. All my children live reading and this will never be discouraged there learning all the time totally different to a game

mogsjanuary · 10/01/2024 14:20

I think reading is a good thing, reading good quality fiction has been shown to improve theory of mind and reading is also great for learning, for relaxing and your mental health.

Gaming in moderation is probably fine as well and probably has some benefits, its not my cup of tea but if kids are doing a bit of gaming then reading a book before bed then that is probably fine. I suppose the issue with gaming and screens in general is that some kids seem to become dependent on them, or use them to the exclusion of everything else and you don't much hear of kids who have a melt down when they can't read their book but you hear it pretty frequently about video games and screens.

On balance reading is probably a better past time for anyone so I voted that yanbu!

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:14

@stayathomer I have never actually read Mills & Boon, romance isn't my thing, but I am sure I have read the equivalent in crime, lol.

OP posts:
Mikimoto · 10/01/2024 14:13

if you can read well, you can comprehend history, geography, physics, chemistry, coding, etc. etc., better.

if you game, you can kill znardvaars when they invade from the plant Vorrrdzinger to attack the kralggiii.

user1497207191 · 10/01/2024 14:13

@Verbena17

I think at GCSE level, Shakespeare has ruined a love of reading for many kids.
I don’t believe Shakespeare needs teaching to kids except for if they choose English Literature in 6th form. I think at GCSE level, only an English language paper needs to be taught and have English Lit as an additional subject you can choose if you want, like you do for French, history etc.

I fully agree. Our son was a prolific reader until he went to secondary school but they managed to kill it stone dead for him even before the GCSE years and Shakespeare! He completely lost interested and wouldn't even read the set-books let alone anything extra for fun. It was such a shame as we'd really made an effort from a very early age, reading to him every night, teaching him to read long before he started primary school, buying loads of books that interested him, but, no, almost as soon as he started secondary, he just refused, same with poetry and all fiction really - he just doesn't "get" it. He's brilliant with non fiction though!!

At least he had learned the literacy skills and is excellent with functional English, i.e. grammar, spelling, essays, written arguments, etc., which enabled him to get highest grades possible in written GCSEs and A levels, i.e. Geography, History, Economics, etc. His lowest GCSE grades were English Language and English Literature!! Couldn't believe that even in the Eng Language paper there was still fiction comprehension, poetry and creative writing - virtually no "practical" real life English/Literacy at all!

School teaching/examinations of English has really lost it's way! When I was at school, we did comprehensions of things like a recipe or an appliance instruction book and did "real life" tasks such as writing letters, but now it all seems dominated with poetry and description writing/fiction with very low relevance to day to day real life literacy needs.

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 14:12

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 14:03

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

They're not recruiting gamers who can't read.

They are recruiting readers who can't game.

Being a gamer doesn't mean you can't also read. Just because someone doesn't read for pleasure, that doesn't mean they aren't literate.

FWIW, I have a relative (now in his mid-70s) who is an extremely eminent scientist - the world's leading expert in his field, holds multiple professorships at elite universities worldwide, recipient of various prizes, pioneer of technologies that now save people's lives every day. He never reads a book, ever. He wasn't interested in books as a child and he isn't interested in them now. It obviously didn't stop him excelling academically, or from writing his thesis, research papers, textbooks etc.

stayathomer · 10/01/2024 14:09

‘Mills and book crap’- the authors that spent time researching tropes and plot and theme and thinking up different scenarios and planning and researching their setting and reading voraciously to improve their knowledge and language and characters would love that. 😉 See op, you’ll never escape people’s preconceived notions.

MrsSunshine2b · 10/01/2024 14:08

My husband and I both taught Primary for many years. There will be exceptions to every rule, but the children that read widely were, on the whole, better learners in every respect than those that gamed a lot.

Reading builds knowledge, empathy, concentration, visualisation skills, imagination, understanding of language, and logical reasoning. It won't increase your IQ, make you good at every subject or "cure" special educational needs. It just enables you to use the brain you already have to its best potential.

Gaming (and I'm about the generalise) is highly addictive, uses a sophisticated pattern of withdrawal and rewarding with dopamine to encourage children to ignore their cues to switch activities, and can quickly become an obsession. That's before we get onto the issue of children playing games inappropriate for their age and issues of online safety when children are left unmonitored with an internet connected gaming console.

Reading with your child and encouraging them to read is the best and most important thing a parent can do for their education.

A few caveats: Not all games and books are created equal. Compulsively reading every Wimpy Kid book ever written is not equivalent to reading a range of high quality literature. Spending hours on Fortnite is not the same as collaborative play and world building on Minecraft. Some games (like Times Tables Rockstars and Reading Eggs) are specifically designed for educational purposes, but I've never met anyone who describes themselves as "a gamer" and means they have the top score in TT Rockstars.