Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
anotherside · 10/01/2024 15:21

Firstly, I think books still open minds in a way that games do not (at least yet). And beyond that, much of our education system, at least up to the age of 16/18, is still strongly built around reading comprehension and the ability to write effectively.

Going further, there are probably very, very few teenagers who are stick with their heads in books from the moment they get home from school until bedtime + weekends. They will invariably also be engaging in some gaming/socialising/music/100 other hobbies.

Many gamers on the other do get to addicted to the point of not having time for anything else. So I don’t think that gaming is inherently bad - in fact it’s a great hobby. But the addicting nature of it can be quite negative as it may hinder the development of other interests and skills.

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 15:15

PonkyPonky · 10/01/2024 14:46

I’m a strong believer in reading being important for young people and too much gaming being bad for you but…. Anecdotally, DH is a high earner and has never read a book in his life. I have read thousands of books and have a low paid career. Though mostly my earning potential was impacted by having children, I still wouldn’t be on as much as DH. So it’s definitely not the b-all and end-all but I still think it’s a better use of a child’s time than gaming. They do pick up grammar and vocabulary better from reading which are useful skills in almost any job.

High earnings aren’t an indicator of anything at all other than high earnings. They don’t accurately indicate or reflect intelligence, or skill, or talent, or enjoyment of life, or emotional maturity, or social skills. Or anything much at all. So I’m not sure that’s much of an argument.

Ddifficultday · 10/01/2024 15:13

Gaming has been shown to improve IQ similar to learning an instrument - and it's linked to a higher IQ in the beginning.

I don't know why gaming gets a bad rep

ManchesterLu · 10/01/2024 15:11

There's nothing to say reading is good and gaming is bad, or vice versa. Both can be good, but nothing is good if you do it ALL the time. The trouble with gaming isn't the activity in itself, but the addictiveness of it, plus the danger of not always knowing who you're talking to online (but obviously that can be managed by only speaking to friends). There's no doubt that gaming with friends is a way to socialise, though I'd argue it's not as beneficial as in-person contact. A huge amount of communication is via body language, which just isn't there when gaming.

Being plugged into a gaming headset is completely different, in my opinion, to reading - as you're taking yourself out of your surroundings. When I'm gaming I won't speak to anyone, but when I'm reading, I have an awareness of what's going on around me.

As far as I know, there are no long term negative effects of reading, but plenty from excessive gaming.

It's all about moderation and balance, it's not black and white.

TripleDaisySummer · 10/01/2024 15:08

Aquamarinemermaid · 10/01/2024 14:55

This is a brilliant thread. We actually sound very similar OP, and I am married to a man who doesn’t read and never has but earns far more than me and always will.

I have no real contribution other than to thank you as it’s been so interesting!

DH not a reader now - but he was in childhood well much more than now and often non-fiction.

MIL didn't approve of all the reading and wanted him out playing outside in fresh air and she has stories of him thwarting her by smuggling a book out and later finding out he'd spent time outside reading.

I do think literacy is an important skill and if you can get kids to practice vital skills on their own and have fun doing so - it's a huge win but beyond a certain level and stage - probably stage my older two are with good vocabulary decent exam results behind them if they start reading less and less and spend time doing other thing it's much less an issue.

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 15:06

I was always a voracious reader, while my brother hated reading and loved film/gaming.

I became an academic, he makes an insane amount of money working in the gaming industry.

We're both happy! We're just different.

That's why I fundamentally agree with you OP. Not everyone loves to read for pleasure and that's ok. Some people don't like reading OR gaming, they want to do sport or be outside all day, that's ok too.

BingoMarieHeeler · 10/01/2024 15:05

gaming and telly (we always have the subtitles on) has really helped DSs’ reading. Well, I believe so. They’re great readers and do reading AND gaming for fun!

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 15:04

@LightSwerve they don't employ prolific readers who are only functionally numerate either. Reading is only one of many skills GCHQ require. I can guarantee you they'll employ a gamer with high mathematical skills over a prolific reader with low numeracy skills. They won't employ anybody who can't read at all, obviously, so a bit of a non-point, there.
GCHQ doesn't employ average to poor academics at all, except possibly to clean the loos.

OP posts:
BetrayedAuntie · 10/01/2024 15:03

Being an avid reader has been proven to increase vocabulary exponentially

Onthebusallday · 10/01/2024 15:03

There are huge amounts of snobbery and classism surrounding children reading.

My MIL, who constantly talks down to me and amuses me greatly with her completely incorrect assumptions me, is always banging on about my child ' must read more' because it's ' wonderful' - like I'm so common that I couldn't possible have an imagination conducive with reading .

I work in H.E. and know the degree courses that are based around gaming ..cloud management, game design, information security etc that lead to very lucrative careers.

If you find money and the security it brings is a bit uncouth though, you can stick to a relatively worthless English Literature degree.

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 15:02

Spinet · 10/01/2024 14:45

No. It's been shown that reading for pleasure is an indicator of later success. It hasn't been shown that gaming is. So if it's a choice between one or the other (and I'm not sure why it should be), reading is currently known to be the better choice.

When were the people in the studies born, and is it possible that the result for people born in 2015 will be completely different compared to 1970?

lazyarse123 · 10/01/2024 15:00

I don't know much about gaming (yes I live under a rock) but I think reading for pleasure and knowledge is never wasted.
In my experience, I am mid sixties, you can tell among my friends the ones who read and the ones who don't. I'm not being snobby but the non readers have a much lower level of knowledge than the readers.

Aquamarinemermaid · 10/01/2024 14:55

This is a brilliant thread. We actually sound very similar OP, and I am married to a man who doesn’t read and never has but earns far more than me and always will.

I have no real contribution other than to thank you as it’s been so interesting!

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:54

@Spinet I suppose I am viewing it from the perspective of someone who is only functionally numerate (at best) so probably need to look at statistical analysis of barely numerate gamers versus barely numerate readers. But I take your point

OP posts:
SeanMean · 10/01/2024 14:53

@LightSwerve
Excellent post, I totally agree.

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 14:53

waterrat · 10/01/2024 14:30

Don't agree. Reading broadens horizons, increases empathy by taking children into different worlds - and encourages imagination and grows knowledge.

I am not academic - have adhd - but was a voracious reader as a child and it is the thing that has got me through life. I understand so much abotu science/ history etc because of novels/ stories/ non fiction Ive read

Gaming is living in a world designed by money making IT Companies - we are being suckered to think kids spending hours online is not bad for them - of course in moderation it's fine but many children are not gaming in moderation.

Do you honestly believe that 12 hours in a bedroom alone reading trashy novels is inherently better than spending 12 hours on a headset co-operating with 5 close friends on a creative and challenging minecraft project? I don't.

Obviously obsessions are unhealthy and variety is (part of) the spice of life.

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 14:50

LightSwerve · 10/01/2024 14:03

There's a reason places like GCHQ and technology companies recruit heavily among gamers.

They're not recruiting gamers who can't read.

They are recruiting readers who can't game.

What does the fact that GCHQ requires literacy, and the fact that gaming skills are not relevant to every single job at GCHQ, got to do with anything?

TripleDaisySummer · 10/01/2024 14:49

Having struggled with reading - turned out I was dyslexia - I became an avid reader quite late in primary school but am one even now - I did find my families and village primary school view of me was very fixed they had low expectations. Secondary school was great - they tested us and sets went on that and I did really well.

When my older two really struggled and were slow readers - we put a lot of work into support with them at home - number of people who told us to stop or it wasn't worth bothering they'd never be "bright" - one at Uni and other doing well at A-level.

RL people knowing my qualifications hearing I'm dyslexia suddenly deciding this means I can't read.

It all leads me to wonder if all the research finding good readers at young ages do better in school is a self fulling prophesy.

I can see in past with less variety of media - that such a correlations would happen but now I wonder if our association with reading meaning academically good is more self fulling prophesy - we tell non readers they aren't as good academically and they do less well.

Though I wouldn't stop trying to get kids to enjoy reading especially not in favour of gaming.

PonkyPonky · 10/01/2024 14:46

I’m a strong believer in reading being important for young people and too much gaming being bad for you but…. Anecdotally, DH is a high earner and has never read a book in his life. I have read thousands of books and have a low paid career. Though mostly my earning potential was impacted by having children, I still wouldn’t be on as much as DH. So it’s definitely not the b-all and end-all but I still think it’s a better use of a child’s time than gaming. They do pick up grammar and vocabulary better from reading which are useful skills in almost any job.

Allfur · 10/01/2024 14:46

I thought gaming gave you a dopamine hit which books don't, making it more addictive?

Spinet · 10/01/2024 14:45

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:39

@ForeverDelayedEpiphany but you said at the start your daughter was highly intelligent. For those of us that really aren't, either reading or gaming for pleasure doesn't necessarily alter that. The point I am making is that for average children of average ability, reading is not necessarily a superior pastime than gaming.

No. It's been shown that reading for pleasure is an indicator of later success. It hasn't been shown that gaming is. So if it's a choice between one or the other (and I'm not sure why it should be), reading is currently known to be the better choice.

YouJustDoYou · 10/01/2024 14:44

What a weird way to see things. Reading builds a child's vocab, opens their minds to new worlds, often helps with their mental health...I mean, seriously.

TeaToastIsAll · 10/01/2024 14:42

'Gaming is largely passive - it’s repetitive, you’re channelled through a series of very tight narratives which are predetermined, and all the visuals and characterisation and voices are laid out before you. You receive it, you are not a part of creating it. The language and scripting is almost universally formulaic and poor (even in the best and most lauded games) compared to most decent novels, and the universe (even in the largest open world games) is small and constricted and one-note.'

'Novels and other forms of literature are the opposite of passive: they engage with you and communicate with you but asking you to engage your imagination..'

I actually disagree with this. My dc uses his imagination when he is designing and building anything he wants and choosing how he wants it to look by the finer detail. I don't think it is fair to say you don't engage your imagination in games, and that it is all laid out for you. This is true of some games but not them all. It is the same with books, they don't all prompt you to use your imagination. There is a balance with both.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 14:39

@ForeverDelayedEpiphany but you said at the start your daughter was highly intelligent. For those of us that really aren't, either reading or gaming for pleasure doesn't necessarily alter that. The point I am making is that for average children of average ability, reading is not necessarily a superior pastime than gaming.

OP posts:
GaterGame · 10/01/2024 14:39

waterrat · 10/01/2024 14:30

Don't agree. Reading broadens horizons, increases empathy by taking children into different worlds - and encourages imagination and grows knowledge.

I am not academic - have adhd - but was a voracious reader as a child and it is the thing that has got me through life. I understand so much abotu science/ history etc because of novels/ stories/ non fiction Ive read

Gaming is living in a world designed by money making IT Companies - we are being suckered to think kids spending hours online is not bad for them - of course in moderation it's fine but many children are not gaming in moderation.

You do realise that book publishers are also money making companies?

Swipe left for the next trending thread