Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that kids being great readers isn't so much better than being gamers?

213 replies

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 11:59

I write this as a prolific reader. It was the family joke that I could be found with a book at all times. I loved reading, it was my greatest pleasure. I read from a young age.

But I wasn't a clever child. In every other respect, I was average, apart from maths, at which I was an unmitigated dunce (still am). This was later diagnosed as dyscalculia, unheard of in my childhood. A bit of a digression, but I think my maths teacher at secondary school, who was also the dyslexia assessor, knew something was off. He offended my mum once by asking her how I did in English and being surprised when she told him, 'very well, it's her best subject'.

To cut a long story short, my only skill (reading quickly and easily) has been of very little practical use. I got a degree in Eng Lit as a mature student, which did little to get me out of the minimum wage earning potential.

I find it interesting the importance people place on reading as an activity over gaming. My reading was just as antisocial (more so, since you can't chat with your mates whilst doing it) and the young gamers I know seem to be far more analytical and have higher earning potential than I ever did. My husband barely picked up a book. He is an IT whizz with a very high IQ. My nephew is not dissimilar.

I still love reading. And I do think kids who don't are missing out, but I suspect that's because my life has been so enhanced by it from an enjoyment perspective. But kids who game probably feel the same. I don't think reading is quite the superior form of entertainment some think it is.

OP posts:
11NigelTufnel · 10/01/2024 18:56

I think people place the greatest value on what they did as a kid. My parents didn't have TV, so though I watched too much. I think my kids watch far too much garbage on youtube and should try watching some proper telly or a film instead. I'm sure if they have kids, they will think the same about whatever comes next.

GasPanic · 10/01/2024 18:50

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 18:42

Interesting. It's certainly not been my experience, but as @Spinet said, happy to be proved wrong. It could, again, be a difference in terms of types of reading, certainly many more STEM oriented folk I have known are not huge readers of fiction, some even (a small amount) are somewhat scathing about fiction. Non- fiction, yes, I would concede.
Which comes back to an important point that has been made throughout this thread. The blanket assumption that reading is automatically 'better' regardless of quality remains a blanket assumption.

I am STEM and don't read much.

STEM is generally about finding solutions to problems and in todays commercial environment as quickly and efficiently (low cost) as possible.

What I do think I am good at is finding relevant information quickly and then making use of it, and that is far more useful than having a lot of knowledge. To me anyway.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 18:45

@HarpyRampant that's great! And amazing on being a novelist, well done!

OP posts:
Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 18:44

@horseyhorsey17 why? I think it's provoked an interesting and thought inducing discussion.

OP posts:
Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 18:42

FourLeggedBuckers · 10/01/2024 17:32

It’s certainly been my experience that high earners in STEM fields are also prolific readers. It’s not universally the case, for sure, but the vast majority in the fields / companies / institutions I’ve worked with have been.

Being a STEM graduate also doesn’t mean you’re into gaming. A lot of gamers do STEM subjects, but a lot of STEM graduates are not necessarily gamers - whether or not they’re also into reading.

I also think people are missing the point that a lot of the high earners in coding / software engineering roles will also be, or have been, prolific readers as well as gamers. Most intelligent high achievers do seek information and stimulation from lots of sources.

Interesting. It's certainly not been my experience, but as @Spinet said, happy to be proved wrong. It could, again, be a difference in terms of types of reading, certainly many more STEM oriented folk I have known are not huge readers of fiction, some even (a small amount) are somewhat scathing about fiction. Non- fiction, yes, I would concede.
Which comes back to an important point that has been made throughout this thread. The blanket assumption that reading is automatically 'better' regardless of quality remains a blanket assumption.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 10/01/2024 18:37

Zodfa · 10/01/2024 15:52

I am going to guess that people who read a lot of fiction probably understand other people better and likely have better social lives as a result. I think studies have shown reading is correlated with empathy.

Prolific gamers, on the other hand, tend not to be the most socially able people in my experience...

There's more to life than money.

Nobody who shuts themselves in a room all day is likely to have a good social life, whether or not they spend their time reading or gaming.

Lastnightschips · 10/01/2024 18:23

I read so much, I couldn’t get enough of it. I do have really good general knowledge. However, I’m pretty sure I read partly because there was naff all on TV (born in early 70s) and the gaming industry was in its infancy. I did like being by myself. But would I have read so much if I’d had technology at my fingertips - probably not. Two of my DC were avid readers but we lost them to tech once they got their phones in year 7.

horseyhorsey17 · 10/01/2024 17:47

HarpyRampant · 10/01/2024 16:32

I don’t entirely disagree, with caveats, and I say this as a voracious reader who has made a career out of it (novelist who also has an academic post in a combined Eng Lit and Creative Writing department).

My capacity for reading has to a large extent made me who I am — my parents struggled with literacy and thought reading was ‘lazy’, so I found the library for myself, it almost certainly pushed up my school grades across the board, and got me my four degrees on scholarships, when no one in my family had ever stayed in school past 14 (and strongly discouraged me for doing so).

However, reading was pure escapism for me. My childhood was difficult, we were very poor, and I suspect that if gaming had existed, and we’d had the resources, tech, privacy etc for me to be able to do it, it’s perfectly possible it might have become the thing I escaped to instead of books. The TV in my house had two channels and was seldom free for use by the children.

The thing that reading had for me, which gaming doesn’t, is the sheer amount of knowledge I’d absorbed without noticing, by the time I was 12 , without any idea I was ‘improving my mind’ — things like the basics of Greek mythology, the Bible, smatterings of other countries’ history, geography, languages, wildlife, norms of other time periods, folktales and legends, children’s abridged versions of adult classics (an anthology about horses had an extract from Anna Karenina!), the Brontës (via an Antonia Forest novel about children inventing an imaginary world in their Christmas holidays) falconry (Forest again), the life and work of Shakespeare (Forest again!)

Reading showed me a bigger world.

I loved Antonia Forest's books and still think about them. Are they still in publication?

horseyhorsey17 · 10/01/2024 17:46

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 10/01/2024 16:03

I think you are understating the benefits of reading and very much overstating the benefits of gaming. I honestly have nothing against gaming. Dh and ds are keen gamers and talk about it quite a lot with each other, which is nice. I've done a bit in the past too.

Some games involve and element of actual rl history or culture. Most don't. If you were comparing a 10yo who was a voracious reader to one who spends hours on Fortnite, it's not hard to see who's going to get more benefits in terms of vocabulary, language skills etc.

Plus reading requires sustained concentration in a different way from gaming. The speed, colour and instant gratification of gaming almost certainly make books and non-screen-based school work less appealing and harder to concentrate on. Much like adults saying they find it hard to concentrate on books because they are too used to scrolling and short, attention-grabbing snippets of information.

Yeah, I agree, I think this whole thread is highly disingenuous tbh.

FourLeggedBuckers · 10/01/2024 17:41

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2024 13:00

There are exceptions to every rule, of course - some games are far more beneficial than others. But few give you in the insights into history, other cultures, philosophy(…) and build vocabulary and critical thinking in the way that reading can.

Perhaps, but for example, my son has learned a lot about East Asian cultures and history through gaming. He's learned virtually nothing about them in school (he's secondary age), and if I asked him to read a book about Japanese history he'd probably not be keen. He sometimes plays games with Japanese or Korean language on and has learned a few phrases, his dream is to travel there when he's older.

Gaming is partly why youth culture today has such an Asian influence, which personally I think is a great thing

That’s great about your son. Asian culture has had an increasing impact on western youth culture since the widespread availability of many kinds of Asian media, not just gaming. Manga was the thing in my youth.

Children are inspired by many types of media - a well research book set in an Asian culture might be a fairer comparison for the games that inspired your son. Such books have certainly sparked similar passions in others.

I would, however, have a lot of concerns about children learning history from games. Whilst there are some exceptions, most games really aren’t that accurate and have some serious limitations, just as historical fiction varies in quality. If you want to learn history, you’re going to end up reading, sooner or later.

FourLeggedBuckers · 10/01/2024 17:32

Spinet · 10/01/2024 15:50

there are more high achievers in STEM fields who weren't prolific readers than there are prolific readers with low STEM skills in high earning posts.

I don't believe this is true. I think most high achievers in STEM fields and non STEM fields will have been prolific readers. But I'm open to having that proved wrong.

It’s certainly been my experience that high earners in STEM fields are also prolific readers. It’s not universally the case, for sure, but the vast majority in the fields / companies / institutions I’ve worked with have been.

Being a STEM graduate also doesn’t mean you’re into gaming. A lot of gamers do STEM subjects, but a lot of STEM graduates are not necessarily gamers - whether or not they’re also into reading.

I also think people are missing the point that a lot of the high earners in coding / software engineering roles will also be, or have been, prolific readers as well as gamers. Most intelligent high achievers do seek information and stimulation from lots of sources.

HarpyRampant · 10/01/2024 16:32

I don’t entirely disagree, with caveats, and I say this as a voracious reader who has made a career out of it (novelist who also has an academic post in a combined Eng Lit and Creative Writing department).

My capacity for reading has to a large extent made me who I am — my parents struggled with literacy and thought reading was ‘lazy’, so I found the library for myself, it almost certainly pushed up my school grades across the board, and got me my four degrees on scholarships, when no one in my family had ever stayed in school past 14 (and strongly discouraged me for doing so).

However, reading was pure escapism for me. My childhood was difficult, we were very poor, and I suspect that if gaming had existed, and we’d had the resources, tech, privacy etc for me to be able to do it, it’s perfectly possible it might have become the thing I escaped to instead of books. The TV in my house had two channels and was seldom free for use by the children.

The thing that reading had for me, which gaming doesn’t, is the sheer amount of knowledge I’d absorbed without noticing, by the time I was 12 , without any idea I was ‘improving my mind’ — things like the basics of Greek mythology, the Bible, smatterings of other countries’ history, geography, languages, wildlife, norms of other time periods, folktales and legends, children’s abridged versions of adult classics (an anthology about horses had an extract from Anna Karenina!), the Brontës (via an Antonia Forest novel about children inventing an imaginary world in their Christmas holidays) falconry (Forest again), the life and work of Shakespeare (Forest again!)

Reading showed me a bigger world.

Ramalangadingdong · 10/01/2024 16:10
  • voracious, not contractors.

if my phone is going to correct me it could at least use words that are closer to my intended meaning.

Ramalangadingdong · 10/01/2024 16:08

The fact that so many gamers earn far more than the contractors readers among us says far more about a capitalist society than it does about the incredible value of reading.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 10/01/2024 16:03

I think you are understating the benefits of reading and very much overstating the benefits of gaming. I honestly have nothing against gaming. Dh and ds are keen gamers and talk about it quite a lot with each other, which is nice. I've done a bit in the past too.

Some games involve and element of actual rl history or culture. Most don't. If you were comparing a 10yo who was a voracious reader to one who spends hours on Fortnite, it's not hard to see who's going to get more benefits in terms of vocabulary, language skills etc.

Plus reading requires sustained concentration in a different way from gaming. The speed, colour and instant gratification of gaming almost certainly make books and non-screen-based school work less appealing and harder to concentrate on. Much like adults saying they find it hard to concentrate on books because they are too used to scrolling and short, attention-grabbing snippets of information.

Zodfa · 10/01/2024 15:52

I am going to guess that people who read a lot of fiction probably understand other people better and likely have better social lives as a result. I think studies have shown reading is correlated with empathy.

Prolific gamers, on the other hand, tend not to be the most socially able people in my experience...

There's more to life than money.

Spinet · 10/01/2024 15:50

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 15:42

@TheAlchemistElixa no, but it does have a bearing. Those graduating in the STEM fields are more likely to be higher earners than those with arts degrees.
A few years ago, there was a lot of talk about 'Mickey Mouse' degrees, and English Literature was counted as one of those degrees less likely to have real world value. At the time, there was quite a bit of rudeness about Eng Lit being the type of degree to result in a lifetime of saying 'do you want fries with that?' and whilst not absolutely true, it isn't far off.
This isn't to say, by the way, that I don't think the arts are important. I absolutely do. I just recognise that if you have STEM abilities, your earning potential is higher, and there are more high achievers in STEM fields who weren't prolific readers than there are prolific readers with low STEM skills in high earning posts.

there are more high achievers in STEM fields who weren't prolific readers than there are prolific readers with low STEM skills in high earning posts.

I don't believe this is true. I think most high achievers in STEM fields and non STEM fields will have been prolific readers. But I'm open to having that proved wrong.

Aquamarinemermaid · 10/01/2024 15:49

But the OP isn’t suggesting illiteracy as a way forward!

AnneValentine · 10/01/2024 15:45

the ability to read is absolutely key in every single subject.

Utterbunkum · 10/01/2024 15:42

@TheAlchemistElixa no, but it does have a bearing. Those graduating in the STEM fields are more likely to be higher earners than those with arts degrees.
A few years ago, there was a lot of talk about 'Mickey Mouse' degrees, and English Literature was counted as one of those degrees less likely to have real world value. At the time, there was quite a bit of rudeness about Eng Lit being the type of degree to result in a lifetime of saying 'do you want fries with that?' and whilst not absolutely true, it isn't far off.
This isn't to say, by the way, that I don't think the arts are important. I absolutely do. I just recognise that if you have STEM abilities, your earning potential is higher, and there are more high achievers in STEM fields who weren't prolific readers than there are prolific readers with low STEM skills in high earning posts.

OP posts:
alittleprivacy · 10/01/2024 15:42

MrsSlocombesCat · 10/01/2024 12:39

Is your son on the Autistic spectrum? He sounds a lot like my son.

I don't think so. He's just very interested in the subjects he's passionate about. I can definitely see that he has traits in common with ASD but then he's very different in other ways.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 15:36

BetrayedAuntie · 10/01/2024 15:03

Being an avid reader has been proven to increase vocabulary exponentially

Yet if you watch author YouTube videos and master class courses, one of the important things they say from the get-go…..keep it simple. Don’t just write words for the sake of it. And it’s true. Not every book has to be a literary work of art and full of description.

Who cares if anyone knows 7 words for ‘lovely’. And with the internet, if someone needs a different word, they have a google and get one. Nobody is saying it’s bad to have a good vocabulary but at the same time, it’s not bad if you don’t.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 15:32

horseyhorsey17 · 10/01/2024 14:06

It's completely different. Reading enriches you culturally and intellectually, gaming doesn't.

I'm not anti-gaming as such, it's a fun pastime if that's what you're into, and yes it can be a career path for a tiny handful of people (as can anything really), I just don't think hours spent completing the latest Zelda gives you much of a cultural or intellectual insight into anything.

But surely the same can be said for reading…..I could read 100 books and not be remotely more intellectual or cultural. Books have the potential to be many things for many people but don’t think people only read for those two things.

It may be they want to escape, read a story and move on.

alittleprivacy · 10/01/2024 15:29

TheAlchemistElixa · 10/01/2024 12:44

I‘m not sure I understand this? Surely he does read a lot, or where else would he be getting all this knowledge and vocabulary? And you say he doesn’t read much for fun…but since he seems to be independently seeking out all these topics and information, he must be garnering a huge amount of enjoyment from it?

He sounds like a voracious reader to me. Good for him.

His vocabulary initially came from me. Now it, and a lot of his general knowledge, comes from online documentaries and analysis. He would be very unlikely to have read a book about the legal ramifications of a character that entered the public domain a week ago. But internet analysis was available immediately.

Spinet · 10/01/2024 15:26

AnonnyMouseDave · 10/01/2024 15:02

When were the people in the studies born, and is it possible that the result for people born in 2015 will be completely different compared to 1970?

It possible of course. But the studies show scores on cognitive tests not the income of adults born in 1970. As with everything you have to define what success means along with everything else. Here's more. https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/reading-for-pleasure-early-in-childhood-linked-to-better-cognitive-performance-and-mental-wellbeing.

I don't think it should be either reading or gaming but it is false - based on current evidence - to say that reading for pleasure and gaming for pleasure are even of the same value. Currently we think reading is better.

I don't want to denigrate gaming because I think it has loads of benefits and is fun. But reading is really important too.

Reading for pleasure early in childhood linked to better cognitive performance and mental wellbeing in adolescence

Children who begin reading for pleasure early in life tend to perform better at cognitive tests and have better mental health when they enter adolescence, a

https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/reading-for-pleasure-early-in-childhood-linked-to-better-cognitive-performance-and-mental-wellbeing

Swipe left for the next trending thread