Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you forgive your child if they went no contact?

135 replies

mrsxox · 10/01/2024 09:46

Ds was living at home with his father and I and 2 younger siblings, we were a loving family and all close.
He had a gf who would regularly come over and often stay over.
One day he announced he was moving out, had found a place with gf and would text the address when they had settled in.
We never got that text as instead he blocked us and we were left wondering what we'd done wrong for nearly 5 years.
He recently got back in touch with us, apologised for the long time no hear and explained that we hadn't actually done anything wrong but ex gf hadn't really liked our family so didn't want us in their lives but that they'd split up now.
Ds is now in regular contact with us and we meet up often as he's living close by.
He didn't see his siblings who live at home in the 5 years he went no contact and he hasn't mentioned anything other than it was what ex gf wanted and hadn't been his decision.

AIBU to think ex gf didn't do this he did, he had a choice and decided to cut us all out of his life at the wishes of ex gf but he still chose to do that and would never have seen us again if he was still in that relationship.
I love him dearly and I'm grateful to have him in our lives again, especially as we didn't expect to see him again but I feel like he's shown me his true colours and I can't unsee them.
Or maybe I should just accept he stood by his relationship and now that's not worked I get to have a son after all.
And if they get back together will we be cast aside again?

OP posts:
Pestopastaandcheese · 10/01/2024 13:47

'You are trying to make out she has done something to deserve it and that is unkind when she is reaching out for help.'

@PussInBin20
Where have you read on any of my replies that I have been nasty? And where have you read that I'm trying to make out the OP deserves it please?

I've said no such thing. I don't think such thing. As I said, we don't know the ins and outs. She's posted in Aibu and I have my opinion, which is the whole point of posting here.

Stop making scenarios up in your head to suit your narrative, it derails threads.

Sonolanona · 10/01/2024 13:17

We have just come out of a not dissimilar situation here.
My eldest met their partner 8 years ago.. all seemed fine. Eldest lives about 4 hours away but came home whenever the could. Then the partner moved in, they bought a place,married, and contact diminished dramatically. Partner was 'too anxious' to visit, didn't want us there (we are chilled and a happy family and my other children's partners actually both lived with us for a few years, we aren't scary!)
My daughter would make quick phonecalls on their way home from work, but cut off the second they got home.
Fast forward to just over a year ago, and the partner had had an affair and left.
Finally I was able to go there, talk freely, go be with my devastated child.

Gradually the picture emerged of just how controlling the ex was. Also vicious, and emotionally abusive. We are now just reaching the end of a horrible process (ex never worked, never contributed a penny, no kids (thank God) but gunned for everything they could take) of divorce. We are broke, paying them off, BUT we have our girl back. She was home for Xmas, we are off on holiday with all the siblings shortly, we talk every day.

SHE didn't realise what a bad situation she was in, she was just trying to keep her partner happy.

We are just busy helping her become whole again, and appreciating that she is BACK. No point holding on to resentment IMO (I don't resent my daughter at all I was deeply worried)

SadCelticBunny · 10/01/2024 13:10

Of course I would! And of course I did!!
My children and grandchildren can expect unconditional love from me at all times.

We can disagree about things I do and things that they do. However, my door and my heart are always open to them.

wasanneofcleves · 10/01/2024 12:58

Yes I would forgive me own child. It sounds like it was a very painful period for you which is very understandable but I couldn't imagine rejecting my child because I didn't agree with their behaviour when they were a young adult/teen.

ThisHumanBean · 10/01/2024 12:51

In that respect I think he's vulnerable to being taken advantage of because he is a pleaser.

OP why do you think he is a pleaser? What, in his early life, has shaped him and led him to want to please people? Why was it easier for him to go NC rather than move out and keep both relationships going but face conflict?

OldTinHat · 10/01/2024 12:50

DC2 started dating a woman in her early 20s when he was 17. He's 23 now and I haven't seen him in 4yrs or have any idea where he lives with her.

At the time, our whole family welcomed her. She was rather brusque, sometimes rude. My DM was flat out scared of her. But we involved her and invited her, after all, my DC had chosen her.

DC2 went NC with me first after a fabulous weekend we'd spent together. Then he went NC with his DB when DB asked him to go out for a drink. My DM next when he was on the phone and said things weren't easy, she suggested he took a break from GF. He hung up, sent her a vile text message and NC with her. DF has cancer, DC knows this, DF sent a happy birthday text to him. Nothing. His aunt has tried to reach out. Nothing.

So, if I were in your shoes OP, I would absolutely forgive your DC, hold them tight and not let go! Relationships are complicated and we don't know what goes on, but you have them back so carry on loving them unconditionally and try and vent your resentment on places like here. You're hurt, you're angry, but they're back.

ThisHumanBean · 10/01/2024 12:47

Did your DS explain why the GF did not like his family? Did you have any idea/warning on that? I find it odd that you do not mention any history on your relationship with her whislt she visited your home. Did you appprove of the relationship/ did you make her feel welcome?

And assuming he fell under her coercive control, as parents are you and tour DH willing to look at why he was vulnerable to this?

LaDamaDeElche · 10/01/2024 12:44

It must have been devastating for you, but ultimately most people want relationships with their children, apart from in very extreme circumstances. I imagine you're very hurt and it's probably going to take some time for you to forgive and trust him and fully process the last 5 years, and that's ok. I do agree with others on here, that it sounds like he was a victim of coercive control.

mrmagpie · 10/01/2024 12:43

mindutopia · 10/01/2024 12:33

In your situation, yes, it sounds like you had a good relationship prior to this and he got in way over his head at a young age when he was still developing and figuring out life and he made a bad decision, which he now regrets, and he's doing what he can to make amends. Yes, I would be proud of my child for admitting their mistake and trying to make it right.

I am NC with my mum, and while I don't have any interest in a relationship with her in the future, I do wonder really what she says to other people about me and our relationship. I do agree with you though that it's the choice of the people involved that the relationship didn't work out. It is because of your ds, not his ex, but it may be hard to get his head around that still.

I am NC with my mum in part because of her relationship with her partner (he is controlling and has isolated her, but he also poses a risk to my children). When I said we could no longer have a relationship with him because I needed to keep my dc safe, it set her into attack mode - because he is the most important thing in her world, and any threat to him is a threat to her and her sense of self and stability. But controlling partner or not, the reason we are NC is because of her and her behaviour, not her partners.

All that said though, I do have to say I think it's unlikely in a good, happy, healthy relationship for a child to go NC out of the blue, unless they've been sucked into a cult or fallen quickly into addiction or having a breakdown or something. I often think about what it would be like for my dc to choose one day to be NC with me, and I just can't ever imagine it happening. Because I know how difficult it is and the lengths I went to to save my relationship with my mum. I couldn't imagine my dc raising a concern with me or asking for help or reaching out the way I did and me not wanting to do everything I could do to heal that relationship.

It may be that you need to look at yourself and your family too. It was clearly running from something and yes, he accepts it wasn't the right thing to do now, at the time, it clearly felt like the answer. I think it's worth trying to understand that more, and that includes what you could have done differently. I'm a big believer in talking these things through. And also family is so important - and short of situations (like mine) where safety necessitates a relationship ending - I think most family pain and ruptures can be healed if everyone is committed to working through them.

Good post. I know my own mum has told people she has 'no idea' why I cut her off, which is completely untrue and totally ridiculous - she knows very well.

Which is why I'm always a bit wary of these kinds of posts to be honest. You never have the full picture.

He may well have been sucked into a coercive relationship, but it also sounds like the parents made almost no effort to contact him. Why? This is something I simply can't imagine happening with my own children.

StillShocking · 10/01/2024 12:39

Relationships are so complex. There is no black-and-white way of looking at this.

You are allowed to feel joy and relief that your beloved son is back in your life. You are also allowed to feel anger, confusion and resentment about what happened. These feelings are not mutually exclusive.

I hope you can work through this. It sounds astonishingly painful for you all.

Universalsnail · 10/01/2024 12:39

I would forgive this yes. I would explain how hurt I was and explain that we would have to rebuild trust.

upwardsonwards · 10/01/2024 12:35

mindutopia · 10/01/2024 12:33

In your situation, yes, it sounds like you had a good relationship prior to this and he got in way over his head at a young age when he was still developing and figuring out life and he made a bad decision, which he now regrets, and he's doing what he can to make amends. Yes, I would be proud of my child for admitting their mistake and trying to make it right.

I am NC with my mum, and while I don't have any interest in a relationship with her in the future, I do wonder really what she says to other people about me and our relationship. I do agree with you though that it's the choice of the people involved that the relationship didn't work out. It is because of your ds, not his ex, but it may be hard to get his head around that still.

I am NC with my mum in part because of her relationship with her partner (he is controlling and has isolated her, but he also poses a risk to my children). When I said we could no longer have a relationship with him because I needed to keep my dc safe, it set her into attack mode - because he is the most important thing in her world, and any threat to him is a threat to her and her sense of self and stability. But controlling partner or not, the reason we are NC is because of her and her behaviour, not her partners.

All that said though, I do have to say I think it's unlikely in a good, happy, healthy relationship for a child to go NC out of the blue, unless they've been sucked into a cult or fallen quickly into addiction or having a breakdown or something. I often think about what it would be like for my dc to choose one day to be NC with me, and I just can't ever imagine it happening. Because I know how difficult it is and the lengths I went to to save my relationship with my mum. I couldn't imagine my dc raising a concern with me or asking for help or reaching out the way I did and me not wanting to do everything I could do to heal that relationship.

It may be that you need to look at yourself and your family too. It was clearly running from something and yes, he accepts it wasn't the right thing to do now, at the time, it clearly felt like the answer. I think it's worth trying to understand that more, and that includes what you could have done differently. I'm a big believer in talking these things through. And also family is so important - and short of situations (like mine) where safety necessitates a relationship ending - I think most family pain and ruptures can be healed if everyone is committed to working through them.

This is a really helpful post and there is a lot worth considering in it @mrsxox

mindutopia · 10/01/2024 12:33

In your situation, yes, it sounds like you had a good relationship prior to this and he got in way over his head at a young age when he was still developing and figuring out life and he made a bad decision, which he now regrets, and he's doing what he can to make amends. Yes, I would be proud of my child for admitting their mistake and trying to make it right.

I am NC with my mum, and while I don't have any interest in a relationship with her in the future, I do wonder really what she says to other people about me and our relationship. I do agree with you though that it's the choice of the people involved that the relationship didn't work out. It is because of your ds, not his ex, but it may be hard to get his head around that still.

I am NC with my mum in part because of her relationship with her partner (he is controlling and has isolated her, but he also poses a risk to my children). When I said we could no longer have a relationship with him because I needed to keep my dc safe, it set her into attack mode - because he is the most important thing in her world, and any threat to him is a threat to her and her sense of self and stability. But controlling partner or not, the reason we are NC is because of her and her behaviour, not her partners.

All that said though, I do have to say I think it's unlikely in a good, happy, healthy relationship for a child to go NC out of the blue, unless they've been sucked into a cult or fallen quickly into addiction or having a breakdown or something. I often think about what it would be like for my dc to choose one day to be NC with me, and I just can't ever imagine it happening. Because I know how difficult it is and the lengths I went to to save my relationship with my mum. I couldn't imagine my dc raising a concern with me or asking for help or reaching out the way I did and me not wanting to do everything I could do to heal that relationship.

It may be that you need to look at yourself and your family too. It was clearly running from something and yes, he accepts it wasn't the right thing to do now, at the time, it clearly felt like the answer. I think it's worth trying to understand that more, and that includes what you could have done differently. I'm a big believer in talking these things through. And also family is so important - and short of situations (like mine) where safety necessitates a relationship ending - I think most family pain and ruptures can be healed if everyone is committed to working through them.

Hatty65 · 10/01/2024 12:26

I think there is a difference between forgiving and forgetting to be honest.

Yes, I could forgive. And I'd be very glad to have him back. But I don't think I could blindly trust that he'd never do this again and it couldn't be the same relationship. Once someone has shown you who they are it's difficult to throw caution to the winds again.

I would be welcoming and pleasant and leave it up to him to set the pace. I would also be protecting part of myself, I suspect, just waiting for him to do this again when he gets another girlfriend.

Ohnoooooooo · 10/01/2024 12:20

I think really you are just asking if it’s ok to tell him how hurt you were / are and the impact his actions had on your lives.
you can - but just follow up that you are glad he’s back as he’s very loved.

pikkumyy77 · 10/01/2024 12:12

If it wasn’t coercive control then what? What dies he say about thise lost years?

He must have very shallow emotions

  1. not to have missed you and his siblings.
  2. not to feel shame, concern, curiosity about those missing years. Are there no discussions about that time and what it meant to you? What happens if you bring it up? Is part of the problem that you no longer feel safe bringing it up so that, in a sense, he doesn’t feel like a full member of the family?
curbingthesugar · 10/01/2024 11:59

I'm extremely close to my parents and love them with all my heart, my mum is my best friend and my rock.
I couldn't possibly imagine not having them in my life.
I couldn't possibly hurt them by cutting them off through no fault of theirs and giving no explanation whatsoever.
Their pain would be in my thoughts day and night and not only could I not expect them to forgive me I couldn't forgive myself if I did that to them.

I suspect the relationship wasn't that close in the first place to be that disposable.

TommyNever · 10/01/2024 11:49

I've had similar resumption of contact by self-estranged relatives (but not offspring) after many years, and I can understand your mixed feelings.

My advice: Sure, enjoy their company again and make the most of occasional times together. But the fact that you were rejected for a long time without justifiable reason, should remind you that your value in their eyes, although positive again, is probably not very deep.

It's not a matter of "retaining hard feelings", it's a matter of adjusting to a role in which they are thankfully back again, but more marginal in your own emotional scheme of things.

mrmagpie · 10/01/2024 11:43

LenaLamont · 10/01/2024 10:18

What is your goal?

To enjoy a relationship with your son?
Or to hurt him like he hurt you?

This, really.

I'm NC with my parents for different (as far as I know, we are only hearing your version here) reasons and I can promise you it's not something anybody does lightly. It's a huge sacrifice on many levels and really impacts quite a lot of areas of life.

If he chose to do that, he had a reason. If that reason was the girlfriend then it's possible he was in a very unsafe place. I would support him and try and make sure he is now in a safe one with you. You are a parent and although he is an adult, I feel it's my job to protect and support my children forever.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 10/01/2024 11:39

I think he just really wanted a girlfriend and when he got one he desperately wanted to keep her and did anything to make her happy.
I do think he'd do the same in the future because he so desperately wants to be in a relationship.
In that respect I think he's vulnerable to being taken advantage of because he is a pleaser.

To be honest, I think this is an extreme form of all the men who outsource their family relationships to their wives or partners - expecting them to remember birthdays, buy presents, make plans etc. I take it to mean that their own immediate comfort means more to them than their families, and so they are content to let their partners manage these. I do think it is likely it will happen again if he has a partner who does not like you, but not because he is a pleaser, but because its just easier for him.

Dweetfidilove · 10/01/2024 11:34

I would be happy to have him back, but rug sweeping helps no one here.

He must be open to discussing what went wrong and if necessary, some counselling for him or the family, if there is a wider issue.

This has the potential to become a cycle where he disappears/ reappears etc, or leave a lot of unspoken resentment in the family.

I hope you can sort it out and get back to being a loving unit.

Littlecatonthefence · 10/01/2024 11:28

My brothers husband done the same in a similar scenario except it wasn't coercive control, he made the decision to go NC with his mum and dad and his brother.

It lasted 2 years then his marriage fell apart and he came crawling back, there was actually no discussion or accountability for his actions which in turn has led him to live a pretty mediocre life with plenty of bad decisions along the way that has effected his relationships.

Whilst i would welcome him back i think its actually important to discuss and find the root cause, perhaps get him some counselling in order to start being more resilient in life and tools to help him make better decisions

PussInBin20 · 10/01/2024 11:27

Pestopastaandcheese · 10/01/2024 11:20

@PussInBin20

I'm absolutely not trying to put a knife in. She posted in AIBU and I gave my opinion.

But resulting to 'I didn't expect to see him again' due to him being in an obviously controlling relationship, I am surprised.

So no, not sticking the knife in. I'm just surprised by the OPs blasé view on this but obviously we don't know the full story.

Exactly, WE don’t know the full story so we have to go on what the OP has written - except you have decided to read into things that aren’t there and are just being nasty. How do you know she has a blasé view? How do you know he was in an “obviously controlling relationship”? You don’t!

You are trying to make out she has done something to deserve it and that is unkind when she is reaching out for help.

So many horrible people on his site.

SuperFurryCat · 10/01/2024 11:26

I would forgive in those circumstances.
The alternative is to hold it against him or put a wall up to protect yourself and that will likely lead you back down the NC path. He’s returned to you, build on that. Look forwards not backwards would be my advice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread